Preview

Amir And Hassan's Relationship

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1064 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Amir And Hassan's Relationship
Since ancient times the notion of friendship being a method for self gain has lurked in the shadows. Though never out rightly stated it is one which trumps the subconscious mind of each person and has even been pondered upon by great minds such as that of Aristotle, who believed certain friendships occurred simply as a means of utility. This raises the question of whether friendships are truly mutual and not driven by the needs and desires of a person.

It's simply impossible for one person to have all the resources and connections they require to fulfil their desires, so they connect themselves with those who do so that they may acquire such resources and connections. Whether they genuinely like the person becomes irrelevant as they are simply
…show more content…
Hassan considers Amir his very best friend and would do anything for him, Amir too was aware of this and knew Hassan wouldn't deny him anything if he really asked. However Amir himself wasn't clear as to what their relationship was and himself said “ the curious thing was I never thought of Hassan and me as friends either”. He further shows his true feelings for Hassan by putting Hassan down at every opportunity he got and by never thinking of him as a friend or companion but rather thinking of him as a servant, as he did when Hassan offered a suggestion on Amir's self written story. Amir was unwilling to share with Hassan and often lied in the process to make sure he didn't have to share with Hassan, as he did when Baba invited Hassan to Ghargha …show more content…
He further theorised that all friendships take place on the account of need. The idea that friendships occur through need has been expressed in many places other than the notebooks of philosophers. The Vatican saying 23 talks about how friendships take their beginnings from utility.

If one was to randomly ask any person about their past friendships, each of them would share multiple bad experiences which occurred due to the fact that someone who they thought was their friend was actually just using them to obtain what it was that they desire. If one were to take a deep look at any of their presently existing friendships they'd see how nearly all of their friendships are based on the principle of mutual utility and how they to initiate in friendships

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    Amir and Hassan had a very complicated relationship in which both boys felt at times they had been close like brothers and at other times it was just more of a servant-master relationship. Their relationship can be one way at times and another way at other times. Sometimes Amir didn't see Hassan as a friend because friends stand up for each other and support each other and help each other in times of trouble and come to each other's defense when needed, and Amir did not do any of those things for Hassan. Amir feels guilty for the choices he made in the situations that were brought towards him but obviously he didn't feel guilty enough because he never tried hard enough to fix things. A huge theme throughout the entire book in which Amir attempts…

    • 310 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    After Amir wins the competition, Hassan goes to retrieve his kite, when he then gets into a brawl with Assef and his two other boys. When Amir goes to find Hassan, he sees how he is getting abused by Assef and decides not to do anything about. He thought to himself, “I could step into that alley, stand up for Hassan- the way he’d stood up for me all those times in the past- and accept whatever would happen to me. Or I could run” (Hosseini 77). In the end, Amir decided to run because he was a coward and only thought of the best for himself, not Hassan. Readers uncover irony within this section of the novel. In order for Hassan not to be raped, he had to give Assef Amir’s kite, which Hassan knew would help boost Amir and Baba’s relationship. So Hassan, being a great friend, sacrifices himself, just so that Baba can be proud of Amir for once. After the rape, Amir and Hassan become distant from one another. When the two are face-to-face, Amir wishes Hassan would punish him. For instance, he pelts Hassan with the pomegranates, because he wants Hassan to hit him back. Punishment, Amir feels, would at least begin to make up for the way he wronged Hassan. Hassan, however, will not retaliate, and that became the greatest torment for Amir. Since Amir is still filled with the guilt of leaving Hassan to be raped in the alleyway, he decided he has to put an end to this. Seeing Hassan everyday was a constant reminder of his wronged actions. So, Amir went into Hassan’s living quarters, lifted his “mattress and planted [his] new watch and a handful of Afghani bills under it”, which made Baba believe Hassan stole all those items (Hosseini 104). Baba begs for Ali and Hassan to stay with them, but Ali makes the final decision that it would be best if they…

    • 561 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    When friendships are dissolved, the consequences can be devastating. In Aristotle’s Nicomachean Ethics - VIII – IX he explains how humans learn from one another, and that humans are innately social animals (Aristotle, Nicomachean Ethics - VIII – IX, 148-149). Friendships are required in life learn about values. Without friends, humans would not be able to learn such values from each other, nor will they be able to confide in each other. Having friends in life allow for the mutual growth of both parties. Rebecca Traister writes in her article “What Women Find in Friends That They May Not Get from Love” her experiences with her friend Sara. Traister says, “In each other, we found respite, recognition, a shared eagerness to relax, take stock and talk about it all.” (Sara Traister, “What Women Find in Friends That They May Not Get from Love, 1), going on to say this relationship was mutual where they benefited from each other’s company. As they both grew together over time, much like Aristotle suggests is the value of friendship. Humans life are not fulfilled unless friends are there to support each other. As Traister says, “For many women, friends are our primary partner through life” (Sara Traister, “What Women Find in Friends That They May Not Get from Love, 5). In Traister’s case, the friendship she shares with Sara is a friendship of virtue.…

    • 1192 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In Aristotle's Nicomachean Ethics, he states that there are three types of friendships that can be obtained- the friendship of pleasure, the friendship of utility and the friendship of good. The friendship of pleasure is a relationship based on the simple enjoyment of being around a particular person; the friendship of utility is a relationship based on convenience. In other words, this friendship has no real meaning behind it, other than this person is around this person frequently, so they might as well be friends. Lastly, the third category of friendship is that based on good. Friendship of good is the pure delight of one person and everything about that person. Good is the best form of friendship because it is the most virtuous. This…

    • 337 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The relationship between Hassan and Amir is something that is complex, yet so simple. The two boys grew up together and will always be connected by the fact that they drank out of the same wet nurse, but the events that happen will forever plague their relationship. To Amir, Hassan was a friend who he had conflicted feelings for. One part of him was always remembering their past while the other was telling Amir that he was a worthless hazara. This inner battle constantly kept Amir from getting too close to Hassan. On the other hand, to Hassan, Amir was everything. Amir was the one who kept him happy, read to him everyday, and was always there when times got tough. Hassan would do anything for Amir, even if it pained him. From the beginning…

    • 846 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    A true friendship should pose a likeliness to a codependency in nature, all parties benefit from it. If human beings went through life in solitude, our lives would be bleak. Friendship can be shown in many forms, friendship can be sharing your last bit of food, not judging someone for the strange things they do, comforting someone through a rough time, or just being there for the person whenever. Friendship is having someone to share everything with, the good and bad included.…

    • 210 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Aristotle states that utility friendships are the ones with the most complaints (1162b5). To me, this is one of the most important topics Aristotle has stated so far. I had a friendship in high school which I can now define as a utility friendship. We both used each other just for the fact that we could benefit off of one another. She gave me rides places and I gave her someone who she could vent to about all of her problems in life.…

    • 804 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Aristotle and Friendship

    • 566 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Friendship based on mutual utility is the kind of friendship that tends to be short-lived, coincidental, easily formed, and is easily dissolved when the abilities or needs of both people change. There is no affectionate feeling in this friendship. The individuals involved in this type of friendship are only interested in what they can do for themselves or they can gain from each other. For example, one person might pay another to teach them how to surf, one benefits from learning while the other benefits financially. This kind of friendship only lasts as long as the utility.…

    • 566 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    However, the definition that suits the idea of friendship the best is the acquisition of wisdom being the primary motivator. I for one agree with this notion and we shall explore this further. Socrates explains…

    • 2042 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    African American

    • 618 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Friendship is a virtue or at least involves virtue. Friendship is always a special thing but people tend to forget about how much its value is. Friendship is not just necessary, but also noble.Friendship consists of goodwill between two people. You can only have a few friends being that its take some precious time to build a real friendship. Aristotle’s speaks about how there are three kinds of friendship. The first is friends of utility, where both people receive some benefit from each other. Aristotle believed that this is the type of friendship that is for the old. Aristotle argued that they “are at such a time of life pursue not what is pleasant but what is beneficial.” The second is friends of pleasure, where both people are attracted to each other, good looks, or other their pleasant qualities all together . aristotles says this friendship is for the young. Aristotle argues that the young because “...quickly become friends and quickly stop...” and “...love and stop loving quickly...” The third is friends of excellence, where both people admire the other’s excellence and help one another strive for excellence. Aristotle says this about friends of excellence “...complete sort of friendship between people who are good and alike in virtue...”friends of virtue or excellence is hard to come by especially in the world we live in today because it is so much individualism. According to Aristotle the first two friendships are accidental, because in these case friends are only thinking about their own utility and pleasure, not are going to change over a period of time. If a friendship is based on excellence it will be a long lasting relationship, because excellence is a quality. This kind of friendship is the one everyone wants to have and it overlooks the other two friendships. This kind of friendship though is hard to find and takes a lot of time to progress but it is worth it. It is nothing like having a real and true friend. Friends who want the same thing will…

    • 618 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Friendships should be chosen carefully or it can cause more pain than anything else. The “Friendship in an Age of Economics” speaks of how we value friendship. It says, “We benefit from our close friendships, but they are not a matter of calculable gain and loss. While we draw pleasure from them, they are not a matter solely of consuming pleasure.”…

    • 555 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    “Friends encourage good habits, chase away depression, help you overcome diseases and cause satisfaction, pleasure and happiness” (The Huffington Post UK). It has been scientifically proven that you need friends in your life. Nothing can show a person’s loyalty than being the greatest friend possible. There are certain people that others need in their life to be able to live a great life. John Steinbeck, the author of, Of Mice and Men, shows that a healthy friendship is the most important commodity you can have in your life.…

    • 584 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    They are accidental in the sense that in these particular cases, the friends are motivated by their own utility and pleasure, and are not essential to the natures of the other parties. I believe that these kinds of friendship are short lived because a person’s needs and pleasures alter over the span of their life. It is the friendship based on goodness that is the best friendship to achieve and it is the most enduring of all three sorts of friendships. Aristotle gives reasoning in support of this in Book eight “Accordingly the friendship of such men lasts so long as they remain good; and goodness is an enduring quality” (Book VIII, 1156b, 10-15). I think such friendships are very rare, take more time to develop in comparison to the other two friendships of utility, and pleasure, but it is the most rewarding to a good man.…

    • 588 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The significance of friendship and in addition its significance to individuals is something exceptionally subjective. In any case, as a rule, we can say that among all the diverse connections that exist between individuals, fellowship offers the most extensive variety of connections. A few individuals might want to confine the intending to something obscure called "true fellowship", and which might be depicted as far as sayings alike "a friend in need is friend without a doubt. " In my mind friendship is something all the more significantly more normal, broad, and helpful than the such restricted brands of perfect friendship. In my opinion, friendship speaks to a common relationship of preferring, and association.…

    • 1449 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In this world we need to know and to make a difference between a good friend and a bad friend. In this world we see the friends are useful, helpful, and happiness. Per person point of view; for example, people are like to make friends, and some their do not like to make a friend who are solitary of the people.…

    • 325 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays