This past weekend I saw the movie Brother Bear, it's a new Disney movie and rated G. I have some trouble with the historical accuracy of the film and will be discussing that at great length. Sure it's a children's movie, but does that mean it's ok to disregard historical accuracy? Perhaps the fact that it's designed for children makes it even more important to keep it historically correct, after all children take things very literally. Why shouldn't they be shown facts? There were many historical inconsistencies that bothered me throughout the film. My main thoughts while watching this were 1) where is this 2) when is this 3) how much of this is accurate.
So lets start with where. That's not a hard one to figure out, my evidence: the wildlife, the weather, the people, and their culture. The moose in the film have extremely Canadian accents, so perhaps it's Canada. There was an Orca in the ocean, they are well known for being Alaskan animals. So possibly it's Alaska, for sure it's very northern. There were countless icebergs, that supports the idea of the far north. The people seem to be based on Inuits (native to the general area of Alaska), and they used kayaks, which are not found south of Canada. (The Spokane Indians used canoes.) Therefore I believe I'm correct in stating that, this all took place in either Alaska or Canada, after all they are connected.
That brings me to when, which is much more difficult to place. Possibly because the fine folks at Disney didn't actually know, or care which time period they were animating. The main problems as I see it are: the climate, the wildlife, and development of the land.
We have woolly mammoths; woolly mammoths were found during the ice age. Although, I would assume that it wasn't the ice age based on everything else. First of all there wasn't that much ice, or more importantly, the ice was extremely inconsistent. There would be snow and glaciers, and then there would be sunshine and meadows of flowers. People don't normally associate glaciers with meadows and flowers.
Then there is the whole question of the surrounding wildlife considered with the implications of the ice age. Bears existed then; I've seen them in museums. They just didn't look like these bears; these bears appeared to be the same as the ones currently found in the wilderness. The bears, when compared in scale to everything around them, including the humans, are not bears that would have lived in that time. And the bears that were here during the ice age would not be foraging for berries and fishing for salmon. Bears in that time would have been much too large to live on berries, it would have been like cats trying to live on ants. There are other animals to consider as well, were there moose, rabbits, salmon, geese, or chipmunks in the ice age? If so, I'm sure they didn't look the same.
Then there was an extremely disorienting scene that seemed to take place in a sort of fire pit. I would say volcano, except that the ground wasn't entirely molten. It was bright red and spewed steam occasionally, it really didn't seem to me to be the sort of thing that you could find at that point in the earths development. If that kind of turbulence were to have happened, it would have been over long before humans came about. There is the possibility that it was part of the "ring of fire", but I would think that would be in the form of a volcano, not a valley of partially volcanic red steaming earth. Also depending on where in the earth's growth, this takes place the continental drift must be considered. Below is a visual reference for the "ring of fire".
"Pacific Basin, on the bottom of the seabed, laid a dramatic series of volcanic arcs and oceanic trenches. The zone - the 'Ring of Fire' - notorious for frequent earthquakes and volcanic eruptions, coincides with the edges of one of the world's main tectonic plates. Earth's hot, pliable interior. Alaska's Aleutian Islands are growing as the Pacific plate hits the North American plate. The deep Aleutian Trench has been created at the subduction zone with a maximum depth of 25,194"
The term totem is misused throughout the movie. What they're referring to, as a totem appears to be a fetish, a carved stone bead or pendant. I was of the opinion that a totem was related to a totem poll, which is a large carved log, positioned in the ground vertically. I can't imagine how they could confuse the two.
Also the symbol of the bear is not in anyway identified as love. Often love or something similar is recognized as a deer, swan, or even a wolf in the sense of familial love. Bears are generally identified with the totem of dreaming, spiritual sleep, regeneration (as in hibernation), or strength.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
Pleistocene Epoch of the Cenozoic Era|Many species of Pleistocene conifers, mosses, flowering plants, insects, mollusks, birds, mammals, and others survive to this day. This period was also known for many large mammals such as mammoths and their cousins the mastodons[->0], long horned bison, saber-toothed cats, giant ground sloths, and many other large mammals including humans.|2.6 million to 11,700 years ago|…
- 747 Words
- 3 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
According to the article “Myths of the North in the Canadian Ethos”, Grant shows that Canadians believe that the northern Canada as a symbol of identity and is able to show their unique culture. Grant also states that, “Most Canadians believe that the north has somehow imparted a unique quality to the character of the nation”(Grant 1990:15). This reveals that the North is the important part of Canada and this also emphasizes our identity. Although the landscapes shown in the film is not exclusively found in Canada, it is the best part of the Canada for Canadian citizens to understand more about our culture deeply through the natural environments.…
- 713 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The last film Disney himself worked on was 'Winnie the pooh and the blustery day'.The company of Disney today is split into many different divisions with the one probably most influenced by Walt Disney himself is the Walt Disney animation studios. This division is located in Burbank California. From 1966 until 1984 there was a severe decline in the popularity of Disney films. It wasn’t until Michael Eisner took over the restructuring the Disney returned into prominence an eventually led what now is called Disney Renaissance in1989.The Disney Renaissance is easily identifiable by many of the most cherished films such as 'Beauty in the Beast','Little Mermaid and The Lion Ling'. These films will go on to create legacy of excellence in Walt Disney studios to live up to. They achieved status in the industry rarely seen in animation studios and set the new bar to the excellence in story, animation and overall production design. The films during the Disney Renaissance acquired many awards from different institutions including many best picture…
- 404 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Disney Movies are mostly entertaining, and they are all their for the fun of watching. Disney is not a historian, so, therefore, they don’t have to worry about being accurate, responsible, but they do have to be respectful to the historian who did the research. Disney is not accurate, responsible, and they are respectful towards the movie. Disney is not accurate because they have to make the movie appropriate to watch. The movie didn’t get her in the True Relation.…
- 422 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
We all grew up hoping to be the princesses who met the dreamy prince and lived ‘happily ever after’ like in a fairy tale. People debate over whether or not Disney fairytales are beneficial for children. Like Arielle Schussler the author of the piece “A case against fairytales”,I am against fairy tales. In this essay I will argue on why kids should not be taught Disney or original fairy tales.…
- 667 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The Inuit are the people who originally lived in the Artic. Perharps the best known Inuit way of life was one found in the Canadian Artic. It involved the people spending winters in temporary snowhouses communities out on the sea while hunting seals and whales as well as other species. They used all parts of the animals hunted for food, to make tools, build shelter and made clothing which were both warm and ideall suited for the climate and the activities of the people.Over time they developed a distinctive and complex adaptation to this region and these…
- 2991 Words
- 12 Pages
Powerful Essays -
The Columbian mammoth weighed 11 tons, during the last ice age, it was known for traveling through North America. New studies show that the Columbian mammoth might be from the same species as the Eurasian steppe mammoth. This new study shows that these two mammoths were both once the Eurasian steppe mammoth instead of being ancestors. The steppe mammoth had more adaptations to living in the cold weather. Mammoths first started roaming this earth about 3 million years ago. When mammoths reached Eurasia at first, they were known as the warm-climate kind of elephant species that still lived in the forest.…
- 345 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
The plots of the stories of Bear’s Busy Year and Clifford the Big Red Dog have many similarities and differences that distinguish them as both unique, and one in the same. The books we selected were Bear’s Busy Year by Marcia Leonard and Clifford the Big Red Dog by Norman Bridwell. The unnamed protagonist from Bear’s Busy Year is indeed a very busy little bear. He is always busy, all year. He likes to play outside, no matter the weather. Our other book, Clifford the Big Red Dog, is about Clifford, an abnormally large red dog, who is owned by Emily Elizabeth, who has a first name for a last name, for reasons which remain unexplained.…
- 626 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
≈11000 BC – The final glacier of the last ice age retreated from Wisconsin, leaving behind lakes and rivers as well as tundra suitable for large animals such as the wooly mammoth, mastodons, bison, and muskox.…
- 721 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
In this research paper you will learn more about “the descendants of the ancient Thule culture,” (Netsilik, N.D) the Eskimo clan Netsilik. The indigenous culture that is the Netsilik, reside “North of Hudson Bay, especially from Committee Bay in the east to Victoria Strait in the west, north to Bellot Strait, and south to Garry Lake” (Netsilik, N.D), just above the Arctic circle. They call themselves the Netsilik or “people of the seal” because of their unusual diet. “The winter months for the Netsilik people starts in September and last right up until June, during these months the temperatures can range anywhere from 30-50 degrees below 0” (Young, 1970). During the 2-3 months of warmer weather, “the summer tundra remains wet, since permafrost…
- 914 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Some people choose to believe that the ice age started off with the flood. “The Flood was a tremendous tectonic and volcanic event.” ("The Ice Age and the Genesis Flood." N.p., n.d.…
- 936 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
“If you can dream it, you can do it.”-Walt Disney. This quote pretty much sums up how Walt Disney lived, although he didn't have the greatest experience in education he still kept moving on and pursuing his dream. By living by this quote Walt Disney became the large figure he was in the 1920s. Walt Disney was an important figure in 1920s American History because he didn’t let things hold him back.…
- 492 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Sanne Kramer Ms. Watkins American Literature 5th 13 October, 2014 Comparing Time in the Prince and the Pauper Twain’s first attempt at the historical fiction genre was The Prince and The Pauper whose intended audience was children. This novel has been set in 1547 at the end of King Henry VIII’s rule and the beginning of King Edward VI’s rule. While historically accurate, Twain uses authorial license in The Prince and the Pauper such as the Kings duties, becoming king, social hierarchy and the causes of crime and the types of crime committed in both the novel and in 1547. Many scholars believe that Mark Twain was influenced by modern and humanistic ideas to write this novel. This has also been shown in one of his letters to…
- 1152 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
The mammoths lived 10,000 years ago the mammoths walk the earth. The animal is extinct because of the Ice age.No the mammoth do’s not have any characteristics.…
- 116 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
When I was a little kid, I used to spend hours looking the colored illustrations of an old book my father had. I wondered why the brown and long haired elephant that I saw in the book was different from the others elephants I had seen. Sometime after that, I learned that the strange looking animal was a mammoth. Mammoth, like mastodon, were prehistoric animals related to modern elephants. Although very similar in appearance, there was an amount of differences between mastodon and mammoth.…
- 432 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays