Arguments For Independence Dbq

During 1775 and 1776, the American colonies and people were debating over declaring independence against Britain. At the time, The colonies and Britain were in unstable relations, with Massachusetts already having fought battles with Britain in Lexington and Concord. This unstable relationship brought the idea of independence in the colonies. The reasons for independence were that it didn’t make sense for Britain to rule a colony that is larger than their own country, and America will regret not fighting for independence due to Britain not respecting their freedoms, so they should fight for independence now. The reasons against independence were that America will not receive any help from any country, like France, and Britain was the reason why America was so prosperous before the taxes. With these reasons, going against independence seems like the better choice for the colonies.

The arguments for independence are
This side made the better argument because it discussed the consequences of fighting a war against Great Britain. The consequences that were said was that America would lose all its current allies and it would very unlikely that they receive any help from France against the war. The arguments for independence, such as Britain disrespecting the freedom of the colonies or Britain not being allowed to govern a whole continent, doesn’t say if they will affect the colonies’ prosperity in the long run. The arguments for independence only discuss why Britain shouldn’t be controlling the colonies meanwhile the arguments against independence discuss why declaring independence and war against Britain will damage the colonies and why the colonies could benefit by staying a colony of Britain. The arguments against independence are better because they actually discuss the cons to fighting Britain while for independence doesn’t discuss the pros to fighting