Preview

Arthur Leff's Unspeakable Ethics, Unnatural Law

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
532 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Arthur Leff's Unspeakable Ethics, Unnatural Law
PRINCIPLES & LAWS
Yale Law Professor Arthur Leff expressed the bewilderment of an agnostic culture that yearns for enduring values, in a brilliant lecture delivered at Duke University in 1979 (summarized for this book). The published lecture titled: “Unspeakable Ethics, Unnatural Law” is frequently quoted in law review articles, but it is little known outside the world of legal scholarship. The heart of the problem, according to Professor Leff, is that any normative statement implies the existence of an authoritative evaluator. But with God out of the picture [in today’s secular society], every human becomes a “godlet” with as much authority to set standards as any other godlet or combination of godlets. For example, if a human moralist says,
…show more content…
To a (mono) theist like Aquinas, the reality of a moral law was not in question. The question was how much of that law we could know from natural reason (or academic philosophy), and how much we could know only from Scripture or the Church. This two level system of reason and revelation, made it possible for Aquinas to fuse the pre-Christian philosophy of Aristotle with the revelation-based doctrines of the Church. …

The assertion of rights cannot for long be separated from the imposition of duties, however. If we give X a right to do as she wants, and she wants to get an abortion, we must soon face the question of protecting her from Y, who wants to protect the rights of unborn child. If majority opinion in the legislature favors some restrictions upon abortion, and there is no specific language in the Constitution on the subject, then “pro-choice” forces have to invoke something very much like a natural law duty to get their way. “Thou shalt not interfere with a woman’s right to choose abortion; indeed, thou must help to pay for abortions through tax money; more than that, thou shalt not legislate that the woman contemplating abortion must be fully informed about the potential adoptive parents who desperately want to provide a loving home for her unborn child.” Sez

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    Aquinas developed the Natural law Theory, with which he proposed five ‘telos’ that he believed were our duty to follow. His 5 primary precepts- ‘Worship God Ordered society, Reproduction, Learning and Defend the innocent’ are deontological. However, whilst being deontological, Natural Law does have some flexibility with the more teleological, secondary precepts.…

    • 1013 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Thomas Aquinas proposes a number of laws that exist in the world. He believes that God is responsible for eternal law. Aquinas points out that eternal law the way the universe is structured. He understands that a rational being must exist, who is responsible for the structure of the universe, and that rational being must be God. This category of law applies to all things in the universe ranging from rocks to human beings. All of these things have natural tendencies that…

    • 1257 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Many people believe that abortions should be legal because women should have the right to choose whether or not they want to bring a baby into the world. They believe a woman should have property rights which include the body and the fetus. They also believe a woman should have privacy rights which means the state should not interfere with private matters. These people are called pro choice. At the same time many people are anti-abortion because they believe “Life is present from the moment of conception” (526). In Don Marquis’s essay, “Why Abortion is Immoral” he takes the position that abortion is “morally unjustified” (525). The purpose of the essay is to go against the belief that “The anti-abortion position is either a symptom of irrational religious dogma or a conclusion generated by seriously confused philosophical argument” (525). Abortions should be illegal because they are morally wrong except, in cases beyond our control.…

    • 1058 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Vanity vs Honesty

    • 825 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Many people find themselves caught up in the everyday acts of vanity and honesty. Everyday people make decisions out of honesty or out of vanity. The changing of our society in everyday life is due to vanity. Even though most people are constantly acting out of vanity, you will find in some cases when circumstances change, people act more honestly, but ultimately vanity rules over honesty.…

    • 825 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Aquinas Vs Hobbes

    • 1535 Words
    • 7 Pages

    As a theologian, Aquinas believes the supreme good derives from the eternal God, rather than a worldview good. The Natural Law theory is central to his work because it connects Aristotle’s argument and harmonizes it with the Church teachings. Unlike Aristotle, Aquinas believed the city was a mean to reach the ultimate end, which is God’s will. In his broad conception of explaining laws human beings should obey, the most virtuous ones are derived from God, not from man. He articulates the principle of obedience and how each person is obligated to perform their duties to society. This also is a slight critic from Aristotle’s teaching. Aquinas stressed the significance of duties, rather than performing deeds. Even though both words are relative to preserving and protecting the city, the teaching of obligations solidity the expectations of moral…

    • 1535 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    “The ability of a woman to have control of her body is critical to civil rights” (Linda, 10 Arguments: for and Agents Abortion). To have control of your own body is critical to rights under the U.S. constitution, to not have the ability to do what you want to your body. If someone else controls one thing of your body, they are violating your rights, even carrying something like a child, if you don’t want it attached to your body they are violating your rights, even when carrying something like a child, if you don’t want it attached to your body you should have it removed.…

    • 907 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the play "Death of a Salesman" by Arthur Miller, the character Willy Loman displayed characteristics of deep emotion and despair. He blames society for his misfortune but in reality society was not the cause of his turmoil, it was within him the whole time. He made himself crazy by trying to please everyone, in doing so, he became a psychopath.…

    • 810 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    For many years, abortion has been perhaps the most controversial issue in America. The controversy is between protecting an unborn child’s life and taking away a woman’s constitutional freedom to choose. Those who are Pro-Choice believe that a woman should be allowed to control their own body and no one has the right to compel their morals on them. Pro-Life advocates like Jennifer Simmons, believe that a constitutional amendment should be pass giving equal protection to all including unborn children. To voice her opinion and spread her beliefs, Simmons wrote a paper to reach out and convince those undecided minds that Pro-Life is morally the only choice.…

    • 532 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    However, what about separation of church and state? If abortion was illegal mainly because of religious groups, wouldn’t that be a breach of our first amendment? Pro-life groups feel that fetuses are humans; therefore, the act of abortion is wrong to do. While fetuses have the potential of human life, they are fetuses or embryos. They cannot survive on their own or have any human functions until later in pregnancy when they are usually not aborted. Although, stating that abortion is murder seems like more of an opinion than a fact. Actually, “a fetus is not legally or scientifically a person or human being so abortion cannot be equated to murder or taking a life since the fetus is not a person nor alive” ("Why Abortion Should Be Legal"). The only way a fetus is surviving is because it’s relying on a mother for nutrients, much like a parasite would. Now that doesn’t mean that a fetus is a parasite, but it is similar in the way it relies on its host. “Embryos and fetuses are not independent, self-determining beings, and abortion is the termination of a pregnancy, not a baby. A person's…

    • 1193 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Imagine a young child at the playground, slipping down a slide, swinging on the monkey bars, and laughing with glee. When a mother decides to get an abortion, that entire image goes away with a blink of an eye. What that mother might not know is her child might be the next person to cure cancer or be the greatest movie star of all time. The public is divided on this issue and they do not know if one should be pro-life or pro-choice. People that believe in pro-choice think the decision should be up to the mother. It is the mother’s body and she should have the right to decide what happens to it. However, every life matters and the child should not be in the cross fire of the mother’s decision. Abortion violates the child’s right to live and…

    • 1161 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Roe V. Wade

    • 1586 Words
    • 7 Pages

    The U.S. Supreme Court declared abortion to be a “fundamental right” guaranteed by the U.S. Constitution in the 1973 abortion case Roe v. Wade (www.abortionprocon.org). This ruling was based on the Constitution giving “a guarantee of certain areas or zones of privacy,” and also “This right to privacy… is broad enough to encompass a woman’s decision whether or not to terminate her pregnancy.” The U.S. abortion debate has raged on ever since this decision, making it a huge religious, political, and moral issue. The pro-choice proponents claim that choosing abortion is a woman’s right which should not be confined by religious and governmental prerogatives. The pro-life opponents adhere to the notion that personhood begins at conception,…

    • 1586 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Abortion is a constitutional issue that questions whether it is ethically acceptable or a violation of the Constitution. It is a constant debate that revolves around moral, religious, and political values and effects several groups including pro-life supporters, pro-choice supporters, the state government, the federal government, courts, mothers, fathers, and most importantly, the child inside the womb. For one reason or another, these groups have their reasons and this essay will explore those arguments and their ethical value, while citing many of the conflicts that have arose in the United States over this highly controversial, constitutional topic. I believe that abortion should be outlawed in the United States with the exception of rape cases and other severe situations.…

    • 2155 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    As cryptic a question as it comes across sonically, a pondering wonder under the microscope of liberty. We are the land of the free. Home of the brave! As brave as we are we must show a sliver of courage in tackling the issue of abortion head on without intent of further prolonging. Referring back to the land of the free, we must regard our very words sang in tune to our pledge of allegiance and practice the proud words we preach. A women’s body is a sacred place, for her and her only. To infer to the women of America that pregnancy means a guaranteed ride through labor and the birth of her child in the same breath that we preach freedom is a tale of irony for the ages. As beautiful as a new life is, the government is not the one going through the nine month journey or living through the ambiguity of what may happen under the women’s situation. As cherished as a new life is, not always is it the best option for the women and to force a women through an unwanted process to bear an unwanted child is unfair to not only the women, but the child brought into the world unrequested .These very thoughts can so easily drive one into depression. It’s inconceivable that people will fight a fight they have no business in, especially when the Constitution gives a “guarantee of certain areas or zones of privacy." In a world where fundamental rights are slowly slipping through the grasp that once clutched the pole to our flag, it is essential to fight any naysayers of the rights involving personal issues, especially…

    • 1437 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The United States has prided itself on making “life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness” stated in its Declaration of Independence as accessible for its citizens as possible. Recently, the country has tried both politically and socially to reduce the exclusion and discrimination of any and all groups of people from society as evidenced by topics such as gay marriage, equal pay for women and the frequently debated topic concerning the constitutionality of abortion. The Fourteenth Amendment of the Constitution states, “no state shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States” (US Const. Amend. XIV). Many pro-choice arguments defend that the choice of abortion is a right of women…

    • 251 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Somalia is by means an exception in the above situation. There are substantial challenges in the country including water scarcity. Located in a very advantageous region bordering both the Indian Ocean and the Red Sea, Somalia (see Figure 1) geographically lies in the Horn of Africa, adjacent to the Arabian Peninsula. Despite being politically disintegrated, Somalia has ethnically and culturally homogenous society. In 1992, severe consequent droughts combined with bloody civil war resulted the largest UN humanitarian efforts and peacekeeping operations in history.…

    • 1599 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays