Preview

Ashley Smith Inhumane

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
962 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Ashley Smith Inhumane
Over the years, mentally ill persons, especially the youths, have been the subject of harsh treatment by the society. Such is the case given they portrayal as criminals that need incarceration to rectify their behavior. A depiction of this kind does not reflect the sympathetic character that human beings must exhibit when dealing with the mentally ill. Mental illness is like any other type of medical conditions that requires equal and nonjudgmental treatment and care of sufferers of this fate. In illustration of how the society has failed on this account is a case study of Ashley Smith who undergoes painful experiences until her dying day. She is a young mentally ill Canadian woman whose experiences are unthinkable and inhumane given the obligation …show more content…
A case in point of their fair share to this fate is on exhibition through their action of ordering their correctional officers not to intervene unless Ashley reaches the point that she demonstrates breathing difficulty. An order of this kind was inhumane as argued by the member of Ashley's family through their advocate. Such is the case since they believe that the absence of this command to the correctional officers would have ensured that Ashley Smith would still be alive. In logical terms, this is accurate since her death was evitable at all cost (CBC News, 2013). Evidently, this depicts the significant role played by both the prison warden and the deputy prison warden in the death of this youth that deserved more …show more content…
Such is the case given the prominent roles played by the various stakeholders in this instance. The propagators include but not limited to the frontline managers of the prison (prison warden and the deputy), correctional officers and the psychotherapists. The important lessons drawn from this case are the recommendations that have been put forward since the incidence. An example befitting of these recommendations is the availing psychotherapy services for the mentally ill persons within the initial 72 hours of admission. Also, the jury came up with a proposition of treating mentally ill individuals in a treatment facility as opposed to a prison as a criminal. With such measures in place, an instance like Ashley's case will not be observed anytime soon. Thus, using this scenario as a reference point, the society should change its perspective about mental illness, if such instances are to become avoidable in the

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    It is easy to just follow along with the laws and rules of the health care system; however, a nurse must advocate for the patients. In the case of dealing with an individual with mental health issues that requires treatment; it is necessary that a nurse provide resources that could benefit the patient and their family. Not only did this book, greatly and positively impact the nursing care that one provides, it also showcases how skewed the healthcare/mental system is. This system is focused on the laws, that are focused on the rights of the patient, and therefore fail to note that some patients with psychological issues, lack the insight or judgment to make informed decisions. The three categories to involuntary detain someone only help a small population. What about someone that is wandering the streets talking to themselves, clearly needs help, and is made fun of by the community. This person is labeled by society as “Crazy”, yet because they are not a danger to themselves, not a danger to others, or gravely disabled, they can continue to roam the streets without treatment. The healthcare/mental health system, is greatly influenced by the legal/justice system. The legal/justice system is also skewed, as this system focuses on the rights of the patient, and fails to address what is medically best for the individual. There is a disconnect with what is medically correct, as…

    • 1093 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The elimination of state mental hospitals was not based on human need, but rather a political policy decision. The shortage of mental institutions creates a shift in the role of prison systems and presents several different issues for mentally ill inmates. The inmates are not medically treated in…

    • 252 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Mental illnesses are often stigmatized and ridiculed, and many people have difficulty grasping how serious they can be. The public’s major concern in this controversy would be recidivism. But once people are educated they will realize that many mental illnesses are treatable and their victims can lead productive lives in society if they receive proper help and medications. Public fear or rejection may lead a victim of mental illness to self-harm or more violence. The tragic crime has happened because of an illness and it does not mean that the victims will always be predisposed to violence. What they need is understanding, treatment, and acceptance. Tim Mclean’s family, maybe with time, has an opportunity to help educate Canadians about mental…

    • 145 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In a publication “The Essential Elements of a Mental Health Court (2007)” explains that how mental health courts are a recent and rapidly expanding phenomenon. This interpretation discusses in the late 1990s only a few courts were accepting cases of this nature. Since then numerous mental health courts have been established to examine defendant’s cases that suffer with a mental illnesses. According to the publication “The Essential Elements of a Mental Health Court (2007)” these courts emphasized their differences and their diversity is undeniable; the similarities across mental health courts share common characteristics.…

    • 1136 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Mental illness has been portrayed in the media for many, many years. Often times the media will over exaggerate the characters or portray the illness in a negative, unrealistic, or offensive manner. The character will usually be portrayed as slow and unintelligent, sometimes even a murderer. This poor portrayal of mental illness can lead to negative stereotypes and continue to long standing stigma of “the mentally ill.”…

    • 302 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    Arrest, prosecution, trial, sentencing, and punishment are the distinct phases of the criminal justice system. Rehabilitation and therapy are near the end of this sequence of events. Rehabilitation in the criminal world is the idea of ‘curing’ an offender of his or her criminal behaviors and habits in hopes to alternate their outlook and personality to prevent committing future crimes. It seeks to prevent a person from re-offending by taking away the desire to offend. Depending on one’s belief of the just right to healthcare as a human, prisoners should be allowed to receive full access to any healthcare provision, despite their incarceration. Prisons are placed to protect and improve society. Therapy and rehabilitation are offered to prisoners…

    • 1827 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    This letter is about stopping the human rights violations of severely mentally ill immigrants by detaining them in prisons for an unspecified amounts of time. The Canadian Border Services Agency and the Immigration and Refugee Board are claiming incarceration is being used to prevent “flight risks” or “a threat to public safety”. The effects on the incarcerated are not even considered even though The national institute of mental health status “Most Severely Mentally ill are not violent” and “Most violence is not done by the mentally ill, and are more likely to be the victims”…

    • 473 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The population of the mentally ill in prison is growing in result of the individuals not being treated properly in the community and while in prison. Officials believe that if you confine dangerous criminals it will decrease their sense of violence; however, Segregation is not an effective form of punishment for these individuals. Fitter treatment needs to be provided in prison for prisoners with mental illness as well as after their release. If the prison system does nothing, then mental illness associated with criminal behavior will be a never ending cycle in our society. Solitary confinement is detrimental to mental health; the conditions of solitary confinement increase the prisoner’s symptoms and mental illnesses and provoke…

    • 1096 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Best Essays

    Justice and the mentally ill. (2006). Berkshire Eagle. Retrieved September 1, 2008 from ProQuest database.…

    • 2206 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Better Essays

    Uninsured Mental Health

    • 1561 Words
    • 7 Pages

    The mental health person does not have the capability of the people in normal society they can be put in centers and sometimes shipped to institutions and prisons. In addition, to their condition or their illness. Most of them are humiliated and rejected by their families or treated in and inhumane way. The faces of mental health range from any age, any color, and any background. They…

    • 1561 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The mentally ill are often incarcerated instead of being treated, in American prisons and jails they housed an estimated 356,268 inmates with severe mental illness in 2012 (Swanson, 2012). That figure is more than 10 times the number of mentally ill patients in state psychiatric hospitals in the same year—about 35,000 people (Swanson, 2012). Beginning in the 1950s there was a movement to deinstitutionalize mental health facilities when the public psychiatric hospitals in the early 20th century came to be criticized for inhumane and disturbing treatments. Prisons are poorly equipped to properly deal with mental illness. Inmates with mental illnesses are more likely than others to be held in solitary confinement, and many are raped, commit suicide,…

    • 120 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Reading this article, I was taken back to when mentally unstable people were considered bewitched and horrible people. It opened my eyes to see that unfair treatment of the mentally ill still occurs today but not to the same extremities. The mentally ill get neglected in today’s society whether it be from their loved ones or the community. The community has neglected them because of the decreased amount of help there is for those with psychiatric needs. Sick people are being jailed instead of taken into facilities to be given the proper medical attention. Neglect is what America’s homeless mentally ill are…

    • 3455 Words
    • 14 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Therefore, there is no social responsibility to continue with the study as it is detrimental to individuals and society. The study focused on understanding why inmates and guards behave the way they do including being aggressive, and submissive (McLeaod, 2008). The findings are useful in developing a new culture in prisons to avoid harassment and mistreatment of inmates. Nevertheless, the study is unethical as it causes harm to the prisoners. The subjects were arrested at their households without being warned and taken to the police stations where they were blindfolded and taken to the psychology department. The deindividuation process started after the inmates were taken to the prison. The inmates were stripped naked and given prison clothes and beddings and also they had a locked chain on the ankle which was considered dehumanizing. The inmates were insulted and dehumanized and punished using push-ups (McLeaod, 2008). Further, the researcher ignored the principles of informed consent and voluntary participation and this could have affected the participants’ decision to participate in the research. It was not clear whether the subjects voluntarily took part in the research and understood the benefits and risks such as the risk of developing depression, dehumanization and mistreatment. Therefore,…

    • 996 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Mental Health Stigmas

    • 1616 Words
    • 7 Pages

    At the same time, we have also “pitied” anyone with mental problems claiming that due to their cognitive disabilities they were not responsible for their actions (Perlin, 1994). It is indisputable that there are a long standing, complicated and conflicting views when it comes to mental health, however, those views can and do become even more incalculable when mental health is incorporated into the criminal justice system. Society has had many flaws, that have become more evident through time, however, one must understand that being able to provide some sort of defense to individuals with mental illness once they have committed violent crimes, is not just an excuse so said individuals do not have to answer for their wrongdoings, it is a way that they can receive equal and fair representation within the system (Slobogin, 2000). In addition, it is a way for said individuals to receive the appropriate punishment that will be equal to his or her crime, especially when said individual is not “in control of themselves or their cognitive abilities” due to their…

    • 1616 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    For those who suffer from mental disease it is often too severe to live a normal life. At this stage of mental illness, the mind is in a bondage that is near unbreakable, and within society these individuals are not typically interacted with as peers. They are a mental illness instead of have; they are characterized by what they suffer from and are no longer socially accepted. Schizophrenia, autism, Alzheimer’s disease, bi-polar disorder, and borderline personality disorder all have a place in this frame of classification. Psychiatric hospitals aim to remove these problems, but in most all cases they only can protect the person suffering from the illness from others around them and from themselves. These more complex mental illnesses are often the result of pre-disposition, genetic factors, or severe trauma that exacerbated already present indications. Until further research is made in the field of psychiatric treatment, illnesses of this magnitude will continued to be shunned among many circles of…

    • 1308 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays