Preview

Assess The Concept Of The Two Culture

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
2581 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Assess The Concept Of The Two Culture
Outline the concept of the ‘Two Cultures’. To what extent, if any, is it relevant today?
Introduction:
The “Two Cultures” are commonly known to be the arts and the sciences and it is the lack of communication and understanding between the two disciplines which defines the concept of this ongoing debate. It has posed many questions over time in various discussions and publications regarding the education system and the progression of science. In my essay I will explore the extent to which the “Two Cultures” has relevance in today’s society.
An outline of the Two Cultures:
We could argue that despite the idea of the “Two Cultures” being associated mainly with C.P. Snow’s publication, his ideas originated from those explored in 1880 by T.H. Huxley
…show more content…
This prompted the most significant opposition to Snow’s work in 1962 when F.R. Leavis released a critique which strongly disagreed with his authority and ideas. The way in which Leavis went about his critique was extremely controversial, it turned out to be more of an attack on Snow personally rather than on his ideas of the Two Cultures. Leavis undermined Snow’s scientific and literary background claiming he had no foot to stand on when discussing both the arts and sciences as a failed scientist and unsuccessful author. (Hall, 1997, pp 145-148) Leavis’ claimed that his main aim through his critique was to ensure that those making claims, such as Snow had, had the authority to do so. He believed that the British public at the time were uneducated and that those in positions of power were as a result of economic affluence. (Hall, 1997, pp 152-155) Leavis wanted people with authority to be capable of making decisions and, in order to be so, would have to be substantially qualified in both science and …show more content…
As genetically modified organisms are becoming more widespread there is a battle between scientists and humanists on where to draw the line. The huge benefits that genetically modified organisms could reap mean that extensive research is still carried out and funding continues to be put in. For example, the Human Genome Project conducted from 1990-2003, marked the first successful sequencing of the human genome. This breakthrough led to many ethical questions being raised, although this new science had the potential to shed new light on the medical sciences, it brought with it a concern that it would create new kinds of discrimination. However, if humanists had the knowledge that scientists had they would understand the risk of discrimination is small as it would be too complex to create genetic tests for human traits which are heavily influenced by the environment. (Henderson, 2013) This does not mean there are no ethical issues arising from genetic engineering however, it does mean that if humanists are misinformed this could lead to money being wasted on issues which don’t match up with the science. This again signals the ever-increasing gulf between the two cultures with those on either end of the debate unable to understand the opposition. The challenges faced by society, with such a rapid advance in science and technology, cannot be answered by science alone. It becomes crucial for

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    Humans are on a constant quest in the search for perfection and advancement in all areas of life through progressive scientific knowledge. From such a stance, the future of humans appears boundless with all the potential possibilities biotechnology provides, but such developments will cause ethical, social and biological implications.…

    • 1631 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    David Baltimore’s written work of Limiting Science: A Biologist’s Perspective discusses the controversy of research in molecular biology and its limitless freedom, disputing there should be freedom in which direction science heads, but the public should decide the pace at which it goes. Baltimore first begins his argument with the discussion of how molecular biology began. It was born from individual sciences where attempts at trying to solve the mysteries in these fields led to the realization that the answers lied in genetics. Advances in the field are what really are at the heart of this discussion though. The most critical one is the development of recombinant DNA where DNA can be multiplied for an indefinite period, but the potential of this process has scared some scientists, even Baltimore himself, about unforeseen events. This led to even more unsettling questions that inevitably hurt the field of genetics, which Baltimore goes on to explain that the dangers have been blown out of proportion. The most common subject that comes to discussion through these fears is genetic engineering. Baltimore delves into the two techniques for altering imperfect genes, and then raises two questions that normally pop up. Who gets to decide what genes get altered and how will they decide it will be done? For Baltimore this presents a dilemma of both ethics and morals and thus presents the real problem at heart. To clarify the argument against recombinant DNA research Baltimore presents to the reader similar arguments. After he gives us the danger of actively researching genetic engineering, Baltimore flips the coin and argues the danger of restricting it. His theory is that the criterion used to decide how science should be handled reflects a dominant principle of governing. This should not be allowed to control scientific advances nor should science be the servant to this ideology, mainly because of the repercussions on society it could…

    • 529 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Cultural diversity is a reality and here to stay, it will not vanish overnight. People do things and think differently in diverse parts of the continents. In the same context, bringing up African children in foreign nations is not easy as the children face cultural shock (Nwokeafor, 2008). The parents or guardians must develop strategies that bring out mutual understanding between the children and the host culture. Surveys have indicated that people originating from diverse…

    • 339 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Miss

    • 8881 Words
    • 29 Pages

    The use of GMOs in medicine and research has produced a debate that is more philosophical in nature. For example, while genetic researchers believe they are working to cure disease and ameliorate suffering, many people worry that current gene therapy approaches may one day be applied to produce “designer” children or to lengthen the natural human life span. Similar to many other technologies, gene therapy and the production and application of GMOs can be used to address and resolve complicated scientific, medical, and environmental issues, but they must be used wisely. Sociological Effects Prospered Groups and Organizations Because GMOs are novel life forms, biotechnology companies have been able to obtain patents with which to restrict their use.…

    • 8881 Words
    • 29 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    In “Genetically Modified Humans? No Thanks,” the author Richard Hayes is responding to Ronald M. Green’s article on gene therapy. Hayes is a visiting scholar at the University of California at Berkeley and has a Ph.D. in Energy and Resources. He has also addressed the United Nations about banning human cloning worldwide. The author argues against using genetic therapy in human research because of the risk it provides for human rights. He believes that it will likely result in the escalation of social inequality. Hayes is wrong, but also right at the same time. He is right about how gene manipulation has the potential to cause some real harm, but is wrong about how people should never use genetic technologies.…

    • 532 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    There are many current legal and ethical issues in bioengineering and biotechnology including athletic and cognitive enhancements, stem cell research, cloning, genetic engineering, and genetically modified organisms. Biotechnology is “the manipulation of biological systems and organisms through technological means”(p. 471). There is tension between valuing liberty to pursue happiness of biotechnologies, and the potential negative outcomes of these technologies. Bioengineering, is the construction of machines to alter or supplement organisms.…

    • 1620 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Compare culture and social organisation in any two societies, making reference to at least two different sociological theories and key concepts associated with them.…

    • 1316 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    With the development of genetic modification scientists have created a chicken that has a dinosaur leg in a reverse evolution experiment, a goat that produces spider silk, featherless chicken, glow in the dark cats, sheep and monkeys and recently in February 2016 British scientists were granted permission to genetically modify human embryos. Just as Etienne Geoffroy St. Hilaire and his son Isidore Geoffroy St. Hilaire created malformations in chicken embryos, scientists in the 21st century are creating malformations in animals in the name of science – for “the good” of human beings. Wherever a person situates themselves in time, whether it is in the 18th century or 21st century, people need to understand that there will always be consequences for what we choose to do with the knowledge we gain. Knowledge can create and knowledge can destroy- both in the physical realm and in the moral realm. Morally speaking, knowledge can change how individuals (and collectively human beings) view themselves in the world and how individuals view other animals and material things in the…

    • 1710 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Human genetic engineering is the process by which the human genome is being modified and manipulated in order to remove or select certain genes. Moreover, traits that are desirable can be selected, and preventing the genetic causes of diseases is possible. Human genetic engineering, as a new field, has raised a lot of questions and ethical issues. I argue about where we should put the limits for our genetic editing. Should we just use it to prevent harmful diseases or can we carry on with the modification and choosing the desirable traits of our future generations? Who decides? Who has the right to object? I will try my best to provide reasonable answers to those questions throughout my series of blogs, based on scientific articles that talk about its controversial and ethical aspects.…

    • 255 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    English 112 Essay

    • 1670 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Hayes, Richard. "Genetically Modified Humans? No thanks". Current Issues and Enduring Questions. Ed. Bedford/ St. Martins. 9th ed. Boston.519-521. Print.…

    • 1670 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    As the Dalai Lama said, “The rapid increase in human knowledge and the technological possibilities emerging in the new genetic science are such that it is now almost impossible for ethical thinking to keep pace with these changes” (Dalai Lama 133). Society needs to be able to be reasonable about the use of a new technology if it the ethics surrounding it is not right. There needs to always be an emphasis placed on the problems that theses technology bring in order to prevent a person ’s right from being taken away from them due to that technology. This requires that here is always reason-forcing conversation when the use of a new technology is being…

    • 1693 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The argument between whether genetic engineering is wrong or right rages on every day, and will continue to be an issue until everybody can come to an agreement on what can and can’t be done. Mary Shelley, the author of Frankenstein, writes about how she feels and questions the progression of modern science and how far we can go until it is just morally and ethically wrong. Through the mind of a young scientist, Mary pictures the possibility of what could happen if we venture too far into the unknown and how could it harm everyone. Knowing the line between continuing and finding things that can help society and knowing when to stop is essential to stop something from happening just like in the novel Frankenstein. Not only that, but many people argue over the fact that modifying the human body is wrong and go against the will of many different…

    • 973 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Despite rapid scientific progress, many people of the public feel somewhat excluded from the debate surrounding the application of science in new technologies and products. Moreover, as scientific progress becomes increasingly fundamental to society, it is becoming equally difficult to stop it from clashing with long-held ethical values. One common and long standing debate is gene therapy. In 2005, a public survey was conducted to see people’s attitudes towards human gene therapy and while 82% stated that they would accept somatic therapy for major illnesses like heart disease, only 64% supported…

    • 479 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Genes are what code particular traits and characteristics and are the influence to health and disease. Ongoing advances are now making it available for parents to genetically modify implanted embryos aiding in the creation of ‘designer babies’. In my essay I am going to discuss the case of a British couple that will have Britain’s first designer baby. I will cover the ethical issues regarding the topic of genetic engineering and also theories of Kantian Ethics and Utilitarianism to justify if genetic engineering is morally right.…

    • 1816 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Defining the Humanities

    • 787 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Today when one thinks of the humanities he or she will think of those areas concerned with the advancement in other disciplines such as the sciences, math, and psychology and other disciplines and professions all of which are a part of human culture.…

    • 787 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays