Preview

Book Analysis: Under The Persimmon Tree

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1391 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Book Analysis: Under The Persimmon Tree
(AGG) Imagine living in a world where you wake up everyday and could lose a loved one at any point. (BS-1) Najmah is shaped by early losses from a strong to shocked girl. (BS-2) The loss of her family drives her to find them, later regaining strength. (BS-3) The decisions Najmah makes are based off of loss. (TS) Therefor, Najmah was shaped by loss in the novel “Under the Persimmon Tree.”
(MIP-1) Early losses change Najmah from a strong to a shocked girl. (SIP-A) Najmah was strong and overcame some of her fears before the loss of her family. (STEWE-1) When Najmah’s father and brother were taken away from the Taliban, Najmah is left with the words of her father, “Take care of your mother” (Staples 14). Najmah is motivated to protect and help her mother and baby brother, Habib, now that Baba-Jan and Nur are gone. Najmah understands the importance of family and how it will impact
…show more content…
Najmah now must become strong both, mentally and physically to protect them from the Taliban. (STEWE-2) Najmah thinks of the words of her father as she thinks that her mother and Habib would be in danger, “I get up and walk silently on the balls of my feet to the wall at the end of the house, where I left Baba-Jan’s large, curved knife that I use to cut wheat and grass. I creep to the purdah with it clutched in my hand and push aside the curtain just far enough to see Uncle Mohiuddin standing with his back to the house” (Staples 57-58). Najmah feels

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    As you can see there are many differences in the “Where the Red Fern Grows” book and movie. Note that in the book he has three sisters instead of two unlike the movie and when you look on the cover of the book his dogs where different colors while in the movie there where both red also the book mentions the legend at the beginning instead in the middle of the story. Another difference is that in the book the pickup never shows up at the house but in the movie it does. While I am still talking about differences there were a few scenes were everything was the same. Like how the title is the same also like the cover the boy is blonde and the whole family had a discussion about him having a dog. Mostly things were different than the book like how…

    • 177 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    told himself that he would be his own Indian Counsel. He strongly disliked the way English…

    • 555 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the poem, Tabrizi uses the expression “A Thousand Splendid Suns” to illustrate the beauty of Afghanistan by personifying as a beautiful woman. It is therefore it is ironic that a novel that depicts the destruction of Afghanistan’s culture and the power structure, as in how much they value men to women. In the poem, it says, “May Allah protect such beauty from the evil eye of man!” This along with the concept of female endurance and survival from her own country shows just how corrupt the Afghanistan culture has become from then to now. The title highlights the tragedy of what happen to Afghanistan by making us remember precedent of what happens in the novel. Like the visit to the giant Buddha statues before their…

    • 1939 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Najmah Quotes

    • 1339 Words
    • 6 Pages

    (AGG) The book Under The Persimmon Tree by Suzanne Fisher Staples is a great book to show how one can be affected by loss, and how loss shapes someone for better or for worse. (BS-1) When Baba-Jan and Nur were kidnapped by the Taliban, Najmah became much more responsible, mature, and helpful around the house. (BS-2) When Najmah became a boy in the form of Shaheed, she learned to adapt to her surroundings and use what she had. (BS-3) After Najmah finally reunited with Nur, she became very determined yet mentally sound. (TS) Najmah was shaped by loss in 3 different ways due to 3 different losses, in the fact that she became more responsible and grown up, learned to adapt, and was very determined yet mentally sound after everything she had been…

    • 1339 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    (AGG) Losses can affect a person’s life and how they act by the decisions they make. (BS-1) With Baba-jan and Nur gone, Najmah has to step up and be more mature to keep her and Mada-jan safe and alive. (BS-2) Najmah has seen her mother and baby brother die right in front of her and she has to handle herself. (BS-3) Najmah knows that if she goes back to her homeland she has a chance of saving her farmland. (TS) In Under The Persimmon Tree, Najmah’s losses has changed and shaped her throughout the novel which has affected her decisions.…

    • 1907 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    One of the comments that I was most interested in when reading the Crime chapter in Solomon’s Far from the Tree book, was the mention of three grand risk factors influence the creation of a criminal. A single-parent family since it might increase the probability of them having a low socioeconomic status. This later translates to a high chance at their child dropping out of school, not attending college, working low paying jobs, becoming substance abusers, and later on becoming single parents as well. Abuse and neglect, which often leads the child towards two paths. One includes depression and self-pity, since they see the world as an unsafe place. The other path is the one in which we would be interested since if influences the child to be aggressive and indulge in criminal behavior since they see the world as a war zone in which they need to fight in order to survive. The third factor is exposure to violence. Living in an aggressive household…

    • 618 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “The objective of a terrorist is to create political change in the society he targets”-Tom Clancy. Terrorism is a key conflict in Under The Persimmon Tree written by Suzanne Fisher Staples. It plays a large role in the way the main characters lives are portrayed. It affects almost every aspect of their lives from education to mental health. In the book, the two main characters are Najmah and Nusrat. Nusrat is from America but came here with her husband who is a doctor. Najmah is a teenage girl who lived her whole life in a village with her family. But, when the Taliban tries to take control of Afghanistan a war breaks out. The fictional portrayal of terrorist groups in the text impacted Najmah and Nusrat in a similar way as it affects people…

    • 744 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Najmah had been through many things in the book the Taliban always had an impact on what she was going to do next. " I sit in the dirt besides them quietly, not crying ,not thinking ,not even aware that I am breathing. I must have sat for a long time although I have no recollection of the time passing" (62). If Najmah does not have a mother then she must go and travel alone to find her brother and father. This makes it harder for her because the Taliban ruined her family now she realizes that all of the things that her and her brother have seen shocking, "suddenly I realize that the things Nur and I have seen these past three months make us many ages older because the world we knew has come to an end" (252). Najmah soon turns to remember and think about her family "I retreat into thought of my father and brother wondering where they are wetsuit they have died or if the Taliban force them to kill people " (staples). These people have suffered through so much because of the Taliban they have had gruesome experiences and lost almost all their family…

    • 697 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the book Under the Persimmon Tree the author Suzanne Fisher Staples shows how cruel the Taliban can be. With the murdering, stealing, and ruining lives, Najmah’s life is ruined by the Taliban when they take her father and brother. “‘To repay us for having helped our enemy, you must come and fight with the Taliban.’” (Page 17). Because the Taliban has taken most of her family, Najmah’s…

    • 602 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Cause Of Najmah Conflict

    • 492 Words
    • 2 Pages

    (MIP-3) These symptoms that Najmah experiences throughout the book create the conflict of Najmah's inability to connect that is seen in the story. (SIP-A) Najmah's emotional numbing and disconnection from others creates separate conflicts. (STEWE-1) Her emotional numbing leads to her inability to sympathize or experience emotions. This is clearly shown through her reaction to a young boy being pulled from the rubble, in which she "thinks [she] should feel grateful that he survived, even though [her] own baby brother did not" and then goes on to say that "[this] [was] only [a] [thought], with no feelings attached" (Staples 103). This inability to sympathize or experience emotions leads to a man vs. self conflict in Najmah of her inability to…

    • 492 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Khalisa also learned that she was not even making an impact on the rural areas because it was said that the policies of a country do not always affect the rural areas. In fact, they were only making what they thought was an impact on the surrounding communities that could physically be in earshot nothing good was spreading about them. Things got so bad for her that when she was in public she was fully covered, did not speak, her family was being terrorized, and her life was even threatened, so she was forced to move back to her hometown. This was when she went to a different strategy. First, they went back and apologized and made it clear that they wanted to make it up to them. In the beginning, no one was believing them and did not want to work with them. Later she finally got a chance to make it right and they made an embroidery business and they were also getting educate on women rights and life skills and education. After 6 months the women would graduate and they would bring in new women to teach them the same values. This soon became a problem with the husbands though because the women began to make more decisions and were speaking out and then forced them to stop going to their job. This did not…

    • 682 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The Loss Of Najmah

    • 319 Words
    • 2 Pages

    (MIP-1)The loss of her mother and baby brother affected Najmah in a behavioral way, not physical. (SIP-A)Najmah is in a state of shock that were caused by the loss of Mada-Jan and Habib. (STEWE-1)After experiencing the loss of Mada-Jan and Habib she feels like she has no point to live anymore because every family member of hers has been taken by the Taliban. “I don't care whether the Taliban find me and kill me” (83). Najmah is feeling hopeless now because she has no family left and no one to take care of her or even cares about her. (STEWE-2)Najmah was forced to dress as a boy and didn’t have any other choice. By dressing as boy Najmah has thrown away her old self and now becoming a new person.”You will be safer dressed as a boy traveling…

    • 319 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Viewers now see that Zahed is a brave person to be taking the risk of hiding an enemy soldier to keep him alive from his comrades on the Iran army. One of the longest and hardest conflicts that Zahed had to face was his depression; or himself. Zahed had fallen into a deep depression from knowing that his family thinks he is dead and had moved to a different province in Iran. Also, he had left his old life behind in Iran because he had moved to Canada to restart his life, but it was too much for him to handle, so he contemplates to commit suicide because he can't deal with his life any more, but then he finds Najah at VAST, where Najah saves him from suicide. Viewers find that Zahed is a coward to even think about killing himself to get away from his problems. In conclusion, viewers see in the news; statistics and numbers of deaths in war thinking that humanity must have been stripped from these soldiers for them to kill so many of each other, but in this story, viewers see that humanity is in the soldiers, but instead the pressure to kill or be killed is implemented onto the soldiers forcing them to kill each…

    • 506 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    (AGG) Over 100,000 people die every day, imagine what this must be like for people that lose loved ones. (BS-1) Najmah’s brother and father got taken by the Taliban, which caused her to become even more mature, than what she already was.(BS-2) Najmah’s whole life has changed, the war caused her to loose her mother and baby brother so now, she is in total shock and she has to make dangerous decisions. (BS-3) The loss of her family, caused her to not trust others, but she can trust the close people around her. (TS) In the book Under the Persimmon Tree, Najmah was immature until she experienced losses, which caused a major impact on her, and her whole life changed.…

    • 1491 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Forbidden Clothes Essay

    • 743 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Nasreen's tough and rebellious personality is a cause for her actions for standing up for herself. These rebellious acts will serve as an example for other young women in her situation, who wish to do the same, to fit in to the society in which they are newly accustomed to. Many other people may see Nasreen's achievements,…

    • 743 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays