Co Curriculam

SUPERVISION Introduction The important function of supervising teaching traditionally fell in the realm of the school inspector alone. Progressively, however, this function is being shared with other supervising officers who have a direct or indirect influence on the classroom teacher’s motivation and morale. The function of supervision is now the responsibility of all education managers, including heads of departments, headteachers, school inspectors and other senior education officers at the school, district, provincial (regional) and national levels. As an education manager, you are expected to provide the professional support and guidance that teachers need so that they can approach classroom instruction with confidence. This unit is intended to assist you to develop the necessary skills. Objectives After completing this unit, you should be able to:  Define supervision.  Explain the purpose of supervision.  Identify the types of supervision in education management.  List and justify reasons for planning school supervision.  Explain the concepts of feedback and follow-up as they  relate to supervision. Definition of Supervision There is no single unifying definition of the term supervision. However, for the purpose of this unit, supervision is viewed as: A process of facilitating the professional growth of a teacher, primarily by giving the teacher feedback about classroom interactions and helping the teacher make use of that feedback in order to make teaching more effective. (Glatthorn, 1984: 2) Therefore, supervision broadly refers to the professional guidance and support provided by you as the education manager. You are expected to offer the teacher assistance that will enhance and improve teacher motivation and classroom instruction. Purpose of Supervision The reasons for conducting supervision will vary depending on the area supervisors focus on. Supervision can be directed at two possible areas that relate to the classroom teachers. Supervision can be directed at the management of the environment in which the teacher is operating. When this aspect is the focus of supervision, the purposes may include the following:  checking on the availability of teaching-learning materials,  advising on the appropriateness of the teaching-learning materials in use, • assessing staff levels, • advising on the school climate,  assessing the availability and quality of advising and support services available to the teacher, • promoting curriculum change and innovation, • timetabling, • attending to the welfare of teachers,

• • •

attending to institutional problems, data collection to facilitate planning and decision making, and monitoring policy implementation.

When the focus shifts to the teacher as a professional operating in the classroom, some of the reasons for conducting supervision would be: o providing feedback on teacher performance, o identifying needs for staff development, o identifying potential for promotion, o conducting quality assurance checks, o ensuring teacher motivation and morale, and o providing professional support and guidance to the teacher. In both of the above situations, supervision ensures that the professional environment is supportive of the teaching and learning process. The ultimate objective of supervision is to improve the quality of teaching and learning. This means that you need to play the roles of a planner, organiser, leader, helper, evaluator or appraiser, motivator, communicator and decision-maker (Beach and Reinhartz, 1998: 11). Learning Activity 1 What would be the possible effects of lack of supervision on the teacher and the school? Types of Supervision A variety of supervision types can be perceived to lie on a continuum with two extremes. One extreme is a type of supervision in which the supervisor acts as a friend and provides a shoulder for the supervisee to lean on. At the other end of the continuum, supervision demands strict accountability from the supervisee. Here, the supervisor may be interested in fault-finding. The Commonwealth Secretariat (1998b) Module 4: PersonnelManagement lists the following types of supervision: • Critical friendship. The supervisor acts as a friend and guides the supervisee. • Mentoring. The supervisor acts as a role model for the supervisee. • Monitoring. The supervisor checks on progress and any problems as well as advising on solutions. • Advisory. The supervisor assumes a relatively superior position in terms of knowledge and skills. • Clinical supervision. In this situation, the supervisor and supervisee engage in face-to-face interaction that is primarily based on the observation of performance and an emphasis on collegiality. • Hard accountability. In this case, the supervisor performs the traditional inspector's role, demanding strict accountability from the supervisee. Learning Activity 2 An education manager may use different styles of supervision depending on the situation and purpose for which supervision is being conducted. Identify three styles of supervision that you would use as an education manager. Have you been supervised by anyone using these styles?

Beneficiaries of Supervision In conducting supervision, it is important for the education manager to decide on the target group or aspect of the school that you want to supervise. Your supervision must be focussed in order to achieve the desired outcomes. Below is a list of possible beneficiaries of supervision: o teachers o heads of departments o headteachers o inspectors. When supervision is effectively and efficiently undertaken, it benefits the learners. Effective supervision can lead to: • improved physical learning environment, • improved quality of teaching, • provision of adequate and appropriate teaching and learning materials, • improved management and administration practice, • improved teacher motivation and morale, and • effective planning. Planning for School Supervision Planning is the first step to take for any education manager who has decided to undertake a supervision exercise. Planning involves the ability to determine in advance what should be done, how it is to be done and the time frame within which the task is to be undertaken. Failure to plan is planning to fail. Jackson (1968), as quoted by Beach and Reinhartz (1989: 10), concludes that “planning is a prerequisite for supervisors so that they can help teachers to be proactive.” When planning school supervision, education managers should address the following aspects: o identifying the target group for supervision, o identifying people to be consulted, o deciding on the purpose of the supervision exercise, o deciding on the time frame for the exercise, o deciding on the cost of the exercise, and o deciding on follow-up activities. Teacher supervision can be both rewarding and frustrating. Duke and Stiggins (1986) concur that effective teacher supervision can lead to improved performance, personal growth and professional esteem. If the supervision is poorly done, anxiety or boredom can result. Talented teachers may even be driven from the profession. You must carefully plan supervision in order to yield a positive outcome. Feedback and Follow-Up As stated earlier, supervision has to be meaningful and beneficial to both the supervisor and supervisee. You must interact with the supervisee in order to address the purpose for which you are conducting the supervision. The supervisee benefits from the feedback and follow-up activities you provide as part of the supervision process. Providing feedback to the supervisee is beneficial in that you are: • identifying the strengths of the supervisee and building • on them;

• • •

identifying weaknesses of the supervisee, which provide a basis for staff development; and providing an immediate audience with whom the supervisee can discuss experiences.

Feedback can be provided to the supervisee through oral briefing, lesson observation reports, appraisal forms, checklists and written reports. It is essential that once feedback has been provided, follow-up activities be identified and undertaken. These follow-up activities can take the form of: o staff development, o staff movement or transfers, o guidance and counselling, o disciplinary measures, o recognition and celebration of success, and o review of school development plans.

Learning Activity 3 • Results in mathematics at one of your schools have been disastrous, as only 1% of the students passed the final Junior Secondary School Learning Examinations. You have decided to conduct a supervision exercise at the school with a view to redressing the situation. Outline the steps you would take in carrying out the supervision at this school. From your own experiences as a supervisor, what would you consider to be key characteristics of an effective supervisor?

•

Summary Supervision is important in promoting teaching and learning. Supervision was defined and its purpose clearly articulated. The unit highlighted the different types of supervision and the beneficiaries of supervision. It stressed the critical importance of planning for supervision, as failure to plan is planning to fail. The unit concluded by examining feedback as a strategy for enhancing the effectiveness of supervision and underscoring the importance of follow-up activities in consolidating the findings from the feedback. Reflection As an education manager, what aspects of supervision would you handle differently now that you have studied this unit? Learning Activity 4 Using your experience as an education manager and your understanding of the supervision process, develop a list of guidelines that you and other supervisors could use to help teachers become more effective in their classroom instruction.

Suggested Answers Learning Activity 1 You may have cited the following effects due to the lack of supervision: • low motivation of the teacher, • use of inappropriate teaching and learning materials, • inadequate teaching and learning materials, • lack of adherence to policy requirements, • unchecked teaching loads, • falling education standards that go unnoticed or • unexplained, • poor school-community relations, • poor school climate, and • school development plans that are in disarray or nonexistent. Learning Activity 2 You may have included any three of the following styles in your answer: o critical friendship o mentoring o monitoring o advisory o clinical supervision o hard accountability. Learning Activity 3 1. The steps you could take are outlined below. • Identity the target officers to be supervised, as well as heads of departments and teachers. • Check for the availability of syllabi and other support materials. • Check on the subject department. Focus on teaching and learning materials, management styles and academic records. • Check on the overall school organisation and management structures and how these support and promote the teaching and learning environment. 2. An effective supervisor must be: o a good communicator o a good negotiator o a good listener o a good planner o objective o fair o a good decision-maker.

Learning Activity 4 Your answer to the unit test may include the guidelines below: • Observe the teacher in the classroom situation. • Evaluate the teacher's environment. • Examine evidence of teacher performance such as pupils, books, schemes and records of work and lesson plans.
• • • • • • Be an advisor and not a fault-finder. Provide immediate feedback after supervision. Check whether teachers are members of professional associations. Be open, honest and objective. Check on trends in test and examination results.

Note that planning for supervision is the key to teacher motivation.

--------------0000-----------------