Preview

Compare And Contrast Obedience And Conformity

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1764 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Compare And Contrast Obedience And Conformity
In this assignment I will be comparing and contrasting the terms conformity and obedience. I will also be answering the following questions:
1) Does research into conformity and obedience explain the horrors of war atrocities, such as The Holocaust, the Mi Lai Massacre in Vietnam or the abuse suffered by Iraqi detainees in Abu Ghraib prison?
2) Does research into independent behavior suggest these atrocities could be averted in future conflicts?

Conformity is a form of social influence in which a current state of thinking, or “held beliefs” undergo alterations in order to fit in with a group, this alteration or change is a reaction/response to “real or imagined group pressures”.
Real group pressures refers to the physical presence of others
…show more content…
Future atrocities could be averted however the choice remains burdened to the individual who experiences them. There are other factors to be noted in war such as economy, latent prejudice, collective will but first and foremost situational factors. As in Zimbardo’s experiment, a large group of carefully selected males were chosen to participate in what became to be called the Stanford Prison Experiment. In this experiment half of the PPs were chose to be guards and the other half prisoners. I will not recount the story, but after six grueling days the experiment was called to a halt. The prisoners were suffering from mental breakdowns due to the horrific conditions they were forced to live in by the guards. Several of the guards claimed that they had just been following orders. Several of the prisoners stated that once they had put on their uniforms; they started to develop the psyche of a criminal. It is interesting to see how behavior changes so dramatically when the environment changes. A video published on various websites shows an interview with a prison guard and a prisoner. When asked by the prison guard what the prisoner would do in his place, the prison

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    When people are given little to no direction or training, and are faced with dealing with people they may perceive as a threat to their own safety and the well-being of others, they have a propensity to overstep what most would consider reasonable behavior. The “guards” in the experiment were put into a position of authority and took the steps they deemed necessary to maintain order. In spite of the fact that they knew it was an experiment, they were immersed in the situation and played the role given them. The “prisoners” played their part and were so wholly immersed in the role and the environment that their entire perspective of reality was altered. They began to believe they were helpless and unable to help themselves out of the situation they found themselves. They had become powerless to change the situation, in spite of the fact that it was just an…

    • 1846 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    PSY 301 Week 3 DQ2

    • 567 Words
    • 3 Pages

    For this discussion, please review Solomon Asch’s (1958) study of conformity. The results of this study, demonstrate how many of the individual participants conformed to the group despite the fact that the group was clearly wrong, and the individuals were clearly right. In addition, watch the video on the ABC New Primetime: Milgram Experiment Update video. Through this experiment we observe how perceptions of authority directly influence obedience. For example, even when the action ordered by the authority figure caused physical harm, the participants were still obedient. What are some explanations for this type of behavior? Can you think of an example of when you disregarded your own desires or values for the sake of obedience or conformity?…

    • 567 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Control of the experience was quickly lost. The prisoners have suffered - and accepted - treatment humiliating and sometimes sadistic on the part of the guards, and in the end many of them suffered from a severe emotional disturbance.Experience…

    • 264 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    It has been found by Milgram that people obey for four main reasons these are; legitimate authority, the momentum of compliance, the agentic shift and passivity.…

    • 1043 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    I feel like the prisoners would feel betrayed by their fellow researchers. I would hold a grudge against the guards because they didn’t have to go through that trouble. I don’t believe that the guards felt bad about the prisoners because they’re free now, but the prisoners were starving and treated poorly. I think that the prisoners and the guards both felt relieved that the prison was reconverted to the basement lab because the prisoners have spent horrible days in there; starving, restless, and bathing in their filth. The guards probably were relieved because they didn’t have to stand around and watch over the…

    • 1083 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    There are many reasons as to why people obey which have been justified gradually over several decades.…

    • 629 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    During any war, many acts of brutality were committed by soldiers on both sides; and most people seem to realize this. Nevertheless, when we look at photographs of the dead women and children from any massacre, it seems impossible to understand how soldiers could participate in such an atrocity. However, in psychological views, we can easily explain their behavior by using conformity and obedience.…

    • 932 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    For example, Tzu stated that "Whatever a man lacks in himself he will seek outside. But if a man is already rich, will not long for wealth, and if he is already eminent, he will not long for greater power. What a man already possesses in himself he will not bother to look for outside." (87). Just like in the experiment, the guards were capable of being tyrants which is why they changed their demeanor for their roles as authoritarian figures. For instance, the guards started practicing sadism by abusing their authority and using aggressive, demeaning language towards the prisoners. In addition to this, they began using brutality such as forcing them to do excessive excercises like scrubbing toilets in the middle of the night to prove their superiority to the prisoners. This portrayed how they lost their true sense of identity by fulfilling their new persona. The uniform's they wore, such as the sunglasses, also increased the sensibility that they lacked humanity and empathy. As for the inmates, they got to experience what it was like being institutionalized in an oppressive prison-like setting by which resulted in them to partake in abnormal behavior as well. Imprisonment and captivity caused them to become obedient and submissive towards the guards as they simulated to prison-life where they were humiliated and dehumanized…

    • 838 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Those involved had forgotten they were playing a role. The prisoners were "behaving in pathological ways" and no longer realized that they were free to quit at anytime (Zimbardo, 2006). The guards had either become sadistic or allowed the behavior, believing that they were unable to do anything about it; and as previously stated, even the researchers playing a role had begun to lose their grip on reality (Zimbardo, 2006). This experiment showed just how detrimental inhumane prison conditions were to the health of everyone in the prison system from Super-Intendents to guards and prisoners.…

    • 641 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “We are half ruined by conformity, but we should be wholly ruined without it.” - Charles Dudley Warner. We have created this boundary between conformity and individualism and often times these traits get abused, thus creating someone who is too individualistic or a society that is too conformed. Individuality and conformity are both essential parts of society however, if one is held above the other in the wrong manner we could be dealing with people lashing out in inhumane ways or people not being able to think for themselves. In order to have a functioning society we need to find the perfect balance between conforming with your peers and having individual thoughts and actions.…

    • 578 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Throughout civilization, humans have used conformity and obedience to be accepted in society. They do this in order to be praised by superiors for following orders. This can happen with anything in their lives, from working, religion, and even at school. However, there is a darker side. Many of the greatest atrocities of human civilization have occurred because of the desire to be obedient and conform. Even if it means that they must violate their own values, they will do so in order to maintain their own life and for the survival of their families. Scientists have performed experiments to prove human behavior under these circumstances, such as the ones conducted by Stanley Milgram and Solomon Asch.…

    • 1301 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Is it possible for adolescents or anyone to be a nonconformist? To those who follow the crowd this query might pose a simple response, most likely to be no. Any person who has ever participated as a non-conformist will confirm that any being, no matter what size, color, height, age, or gender they posses can abide as a nonconformist. Though different people may fabricate different replies to this question the answer will reflect if the person is a conformist or a nonconformist. In order to answer this important philosophical question first the characteristics of a non-conformists must be established, then how society might influence adolescents to stray from nonconformity, and lastly how one can become a nonconformist.…

    • 852 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Conformity: The Compliance of Standards During Conflict Conflict is caused by many things, and conflict affected many lives. There are many ways to deal with such conflict, one of them being conformity. Conformity is convenient and effective tool that is used in a time of conflict. Susan Bartoletti, the author of Hitler Youth: Growing Up in Hitler’s Shadow, told the story of Sophie Scholl’s conformity and Joanne Oppenheim, the author of Dear Miss Breed, shared the experiences of young Japanese Americans in internment. Both these authors, along with a few other authors, showed how conformity can help in a time of conflict, reasons not to resist the ways of the other party, and how one can comply while resisting the ideas of the other party.…

    • 1436 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    1) Do you think conformity with norms in general is a good or bad thing? Why? Conformity can come in useful when we are in unfamiliar surroundings or activities. Everyone has done it in some way or another throughout their life and it really can come in handy with unknown situations. I would say it can be good and bad, if there is a social norm that is meant to keep order and peace, then conforming to this standard can be considered good.…

    • 1208 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The average prisoner life was of course, terrible. They awoke every morning with freezing, diseased ridden beds every day. Even when standing in line for roll call, they sometimes died when in line. A punishment at roll call would be such as standing outside all day, freezing to death. Their lunches consisted of a quart of water as well as rotten rutabagas and carrots. Breakfast was black, tasteless coffee and 12 ounces of bread. They had a ten second monitored…

    • 908 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays