Preview

Comparing Carlin And Luczak's Poetry Analysis

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
675 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Comparing Carlin And Luczak's Poetry Analysis
Four common characteristics of minorities that underpin affiliation are (1) the group shares a common physical or cultural characteristic such as skin color or language, (2) individuals identify themselves as members of the minority and others identify them in that way, (3) there is a tendency to marry within the minority, and (4) minority members suffer oppression. To a large extent, members of the Deaf minority also share a common language (ASL in the U.S.) and, because of their common physical characteristic, that language will never die out. On the second count, Deaf people do indeed identify themselves as culturally Deaf and, third, they marry Deaf nine times out of ten. Both Carlin`s and Luczak`s poems, for example, reflect the opposite oppression that members of the Deaf World experience. In some ways like the members of other language …show more content…
Similarly, the Deaf child, however raised, has a Deaf heritage form birth. Most children who cannot communicate well in spoken language will, when allowed to, learn signed language, become acculturated to Deaf culture, marry Deaf, and identify themselves as members of the Deaf World. A distinguished otologist has contended that Deaf children start out in mainstream hearing society and enter the Deaf World in adolescence. Most children in the Deaf World cannot communicate with their parents who know no sign language, and while their home may be nurturing, it cannot be substantially acculturating. The anormality of having culturally different parents is then both a centrifugal and centripetal force in the Deaf World. At the same time, the anomaly propels Deaf people toward the Deaf World, since identification with the Deaf World offers pride, language, instruction, role models, a culturally compatible spouse, and more than cannot be had

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    In this book, Deaf in America, by Carol Padden and Tom Humphries, the two authors wrote stories, jokes, performances, and experiences of Deaf people. They also wrote Deaf culture and Deaf people’s lives from various angles. This book is great navigator of Deaf world for hearing people and even Deaf people as me. There are several factors attracting reader. To begin with, I could learn about backgrounds of deaf people and hearing people. Authors wrote about a Deaf boy who was born into a deaf family. Until he discovered that a girl playmate in neighborhood was “hearing”, he didn’t notice about “Others”. Authors explained, “She was HEARING and because of this did not know how to SIGN; instead she and her mother TALK” (Chapter 1). This story strongly impressed me. I was born into a Deaf family too, but I grew up with hearing grandparents. In my childhood, I did intensive oral training with my grandparents. So, I can sign JSL and talk Japanese smoothly. Therefore I never felt emotion like this occasion, “Others” to hearing people. The next factor is difference of “Deaf” and “deaf”. For example, the capitalized “Deaf” people are not only “deaf” but also user of Sign Language. I haven’t known the meaning of “Deaf” and “deaf” exactly before, thanks to this book, now I can understand. When I analyzed myself, I identified as “Deaf” because I truly cherish Sign Language. In addition, Sign Language is explained as a primary mode of communication for Deaf people including me. It has full access to communication for us. Unfortunately, some hearing people misunderstand that Sign Language is a kind of gestural communication. Authors wrote about it, “ASL are often thought to be direct representations of spoken words” (Chapter 3). In my country, Japan, there are some misconceptions about JSL too. Sign Language has both iconic and abstract concept.…

    • 620 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Redefining D.E.A.F

    • 776 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Ryan Commerson, producer and host of the movie “Media, Power & Ideology: Re-Presenting D-E-A-D”, states that all the preconceptions societies have about people being born deaf is because of “ideology”. He uses Valentin Voloshinov’s definition of the word to later explore its significance in more depth. Ideology: “The dimension of social experience in which meanings and values are produced”. Furthermore, he continues exploring the first persons that tried to describe deaf people back in the 18th century. He explains that at first these persons, like author John Conrad Amman, one of the first ones to write about speech and how deaf people could learn how to communicate, had many misinterpretations of how deaf people really is and what are they capable to. Commeron continues saying that even thou they used very degrading terms to describe deaf people they were judging them wrongly since most of deaf people grew up without any education. The fact that all these people wrote about them, Cammeron says, it brings this false ideology to our present.…

    • 776 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Deaf Culture Book Report

    • 1072 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Thomas K. Holcomb’s book, Introduction to American Deaf Culture, shines a light on the deaf community and the culture they experience. The intended audience, however, is the hearing. It gives the reader insight on deaf experiences and how the atmosphere is different, even though the environment is the same. All aspects of culture are covered. The book starts off with how the culture is formed through the 5 hallmarks (p. 17). Next, the book focuses on the identity of a deaf person. This is not only limited to, labeling from the rest of the world, but also by how the person sees himself. After, the book discusses the core values the deaf community has. These values are much different when compared to the hearing community. They focus on the person engaging as a full member of society. This is done through communication, interacting, and having a sense of self-worth in the community (104-107). Eventually, literature and art are mentioned. The classifications are difficult to place. There are American works, but with the growing awareness in the recent year they have earned their own Deaf category. This is important to the deaf community because it allows “Deaf people’s lives to be better…

    • 1072 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Sound And Fury Analysis

    • 1909 Words
    • 8 Pages

    In comparison, hearing people speak to communicate. Cochlear implants are controversial amongst the deaf community because they fear that the use of cochlear implants will threaten their established culture and sign language. DEAF SCHOLARThey fear a deaf child with an implant may choose to leave the deaf culture because they are ashamed of their true identity. This may inevitably cause low self-esteem and lack of self-acceptance. The deaf believe cochlear implantation exploits the idea that being deaf is wrong or a disability that needs to be “fixed,” which decreases their potential of living life to its highest potential. Deaf scholar This is a common view of hearing culture, but the deaf community disagrees. A critical aspect of the cochlear implant debate has to do with the concept of deafness and at how hearing people perceive those who are deaf. (Deaf scholar) The deaf community does not think that they have a disability to be cured. They fully embrace their inability to hear and they stress the importance of accepting yourself. DEAF SCHOLAR Those who are hearing assume that spoken language is essential, yet they fail to see the importance of ASL and to understand the needs of the deaf community kind of from perspective of deaf PERSPECTIVE OF DEAF The deaf community also fears cochlear implants will cause separation. When deaf children have the implant, they will likely be exposed to only spoken language and will never learn ASL. FROM DEAEF SCHOLAR Because a child with a cochlear implant may want to speak more often than use ASL, it could potential create a language barrier between the child and the parents. Cochlear implants separate deaf people from deaf culture because they have the ability to hear, whereas their peers do not. Because of this, the deaf community may reject the child as a part of their community. The hearing…

    • 1909 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Cohecular Implants

    • 341 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Many members of the deaf community are content with their unique culture and do not regard deafness as a disorder or something that needs to be cured. Within the deaf community, particular scorn is reserved for the practice of placing cochlear implants in young children. The National Association of the Deaf, maintains that there is no evidence that deaf children who receive implants early are better able to acquire English or have greater educational success than other deaf children.…

    • 341 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Being a hearing person in a world submerged in the deaf culture could be very difficult; it was a place that she could never fully understand; "the deaf, their deaf culture, their deaf friends, and their own sign language - it is something separate, something I can never really know, but I am intimate with" (Walker, Ch. 2). "A Loss for Words" is full of beautifully written, candid moments, as when Walker admits that there were times she resented her parents for being deaf. the fact that her parents couldn't hear. Just as anyone would, Lou Ann found it difficult to fit into the close nit deaf…

    • 641 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    hough I am not Deaf and I have never grown up with the experiences and the oppression that Deaf people faced in their upbringing, I do know what it is like to feel oppressed and undervalued. As an interpreter, I keep that in mind when I am out on an assignment and whenever I am at a social in the Deaf community. One thing I try to do recognize my privilege as a hearing person so that I do not come off as oppressive or paternalistic toward Deaf people and lead then into reacting to me negatively. Earlier I mentioned my view on what “privilege” was and related it to how white people have privilege and how straight, white, cisgender and able-bodied men have privilege. In learning about privilege, I have come to realize that everybody has it.…

    • 449 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Deaf Again

    • 724 Words
    • 3 Pages

    After reading Deaf Again I learned a lot of new things I didn't know about Deaf culture and was drawn in by the story of Mark Drolsbaugh. "The hardest fight a man has to fight is to live in a world where every single day someone is trying to make you someone you do not want to be " – e.e cummings. I was brought into the book immediately from this quote and realized how difficult it must have been for Mark to find his identity. He was trying to hang on to his hearing in fear of going deaf as if there was something wrong or not proper with being deaf. It took him a long time, twenty-three years to realize that the Deaf culture is receiving and it was there for him to embrace the entire time. It would be difficult to be able to hear and then slowly lose your hearing while having to communicate in the world we live in. Both his parents Sherry and Don were Deaf and I enjoyed reading the part where Mark was brought into this world through childbirth and the signing and conversation that was going on inside while the process was taking place. Like the anesthesia machine not working, which had to have been painful.…

    • 724 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    163-164 in ADC where it talked about majority oppression was interesting. I know that many minority groups in the US are treated unfairly but I had not connected them as the book states on page 163. “The Deaf community has had to face many of the same linguistic and cultural pressures that various other minority groups in the U.S. have had to face: being viewed as inferior by the majority culture, schooling in an institutional setting, almost exclusive instruction under majority group teachers, discrimination in an exclusion from teacher training programs, forced instruction in the majority language, the prohibition of the minority language in the school, etc.” However the Deaf community faced additional pressure then the other groups. Such as “1. The Deaf community has had a more difficult time overcoming inferiority stereotyping by the majority culture. 2. In the Deaf community less than ten percent of Deaf children have Deaf parents. 3. The primary language of the Deaf community differs not only in code structure but in channel structure from the majority language.” This causing language oppression to be doubly sever for Deaf people. I thought it was interesting to see how the Deaf community and other minority groups are…

    • 610 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    If one considers the normal trajectory of children, it is understandable the increased difficulty for children with a hearing loss when it comes to literacy (Schirmer & McGough, 2005). Literacy achievement continues to be difficult for deaf and hard of hearing children compared to their hearing peers. There has been considerable advancement in hearing technologies including cochlear implants, updated hearing aids, and sound amplification systems that has contributed to the progression of intervention for deaf and hard of hearing children (Harris, 2015). In spite of this, some children still are considered to be at a disadvantage due to their functional hearing loss due to lack of access to appropriate amplification and/or early intervention, as well as many other cognitive and environmental factors. Early language…

    • 605 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    deaf school can be private or state schools. All the students in the school are deaf…

    • 72 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    According to Mellon et al. (2015), 10,000 deaf children are born in the United States each year. Of these infants, more than 95 percent are born to hearing parents (p. 781). Often times hearing parents view their deaf children as disabled and try to “fix” them by giving them a cochlear implant (a device that is surgically implanted into a person’s cochlea to help them perceive sounds), or by mainstreaming their child in the public school systems, forcing them to learn to lip-read and speak. I don’t think this is fair to the children. They should have the option to learn American Sign Language (ASL) because it introduces so many opportunities that they wouldn’t otherwise receive.…

    • 1106 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Visual Impaired Children

    • 520 Words
    • 3 Pages

    According to this article, 96% of children who are born deaf are born to hearing parents. Often, this leads to a delay in intervention due to variety of reasons. Research has proven that early exposure to both oral and sign language increases individual abilities to learn language and learn in other areas, as well. In 2009, 47 states including the District of Columbia have passed legislation requiring universal newborn hearing screenings within the first three months. Hearing impaired students develop language through not only auditory but visual cues. Often, expressive language milestones are achieved in earlier with sign language communication than in spoken language. However, speech…

    • 520 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    This essay will discuss how the hearing impaired children can be strongly influenced by the social environment to learn language. Firstly, the essay will define some key terms such as hearing impairment and social environment. Secondly, it will discuss how the social environment can strongly influence hearing impaired to learn language.…

    • 1533 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    About 1 in every 1,000 American infants is born deaf.Over 90% of deaf children have hearing parents.These children are often delayed in language and complex make-believe play.…

    • 925 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays