Preview

Dana Hall School Argumentative Essay

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
910 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Dana Hall School Argumentative Essay
S02d2-Dana Hall
Capella University-Dr. Elena Kays
October 21, 2013

The Dana Hall School was founded in 1881 by Henry Durant, with whom he and a friend, Charles Dana, allocated resources to construct. As an All-Girl’s school, they initially began as a boarding only school for girls in grades 10-12. Unfortunately, despite a plateau and then decrease in registration, the organization now must face a decision based on three options:
Continue to operate a failed model until they run out of land to sell.
Invite boys to apply and make the school coeducational.
Find a way to get the existing model to work better. (McFarlan, 2007)
Specifically, the dialog below is provided to reach the following objectives:
Identify the academic and social values that undergird the history and mission of the institution
Identify the deep seated values brought into conflict in
…show more content…
I realize that it is opposite of the manner in which this school had begun, but it seems as though we have little choice. We already have a faculty unit that is looking to form a union due to the budget crisis, we should probably consider coming back to them with a better long-term plan in place.
Wiliam McMurtrie: How could we eliminate the key to our original mission- An All-Girl’s School?
Elaine Betts: I do understand the culture and history, but we need to consider what is best for the big picture of the school-its legacy. What about raising endowments and completing more fundraising activities?
William McMurtrie: Elaine, I’ve really been doing a great deal of research on this issue and Dana Hall already has a Higher Endowment than the average school by $19 Million Dollars (Dana, 2013)-I doubt we’d get any further monies.
Elaine Betts: What about converting to a co-educational environment? We might even be able to offer a trial of co-ed

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Recently, there have been talks that Portsmouth City Council is considering closing the doors of I. C. Norcom and building commercial property on the land, possibly a retail shopping center. The Portsmouth residents became extremely worried that their high school students would not have a place to continue their education. The legacy and the schools community value is highly important. I. C. Norcom high school has been given students in this community the opportunity to succeed, no matter color, religion, gender or economic status. It is important that the educational doors of Norcom High School stay open so that it will continue to give equally opportunity to everyone who come through.…

    • 685 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    How does everyone involved make this a smooth transition for all? How do you ensure equal right for all stakeholders involved, parents, students, teachers? What problem arises from how teachers are chosen to teach at the school that remains? Whose interests were primarily considered throughout this merger? What could Principal Jones have done differently to maintain loyalty to all stakeholders? What could the district have done differently to ensure equity for all? Exploratory questions presented by the authors of this case are: How might aspects of a principal’s social identity factor how collaboration unfolds between the school and its surrounding communities? As principal, how would you have collaborated with community groups, leaders and organizations? What are some strategies and tools a principal (Who is new to a community) can take to know and communicate with the communities served by the school(s)? How would you assess the cultural needs and assets of the students prior to consolidation? What cultural knowledge might have informed Principal Jones’ actions? (Karanxha, Agosto, Black & Effiom, 2013, p.37 &…

    • 631 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    COED SCHOOLS

    • 1607 Words
    • 7 Pages

    In conclusion, single-sex schools and mixed schools both have advantages and disadvantages. A compromise may be the best answer: girls and boys could attend the same school but be taught in different classes. Perhaps this is the way forward. (245 words)…

    • 1607 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Single Sex Schooling

    • 1635 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Major arguments are weather single sex schools district would increase confidence and self esteem, increase academic test scores and grades, and increase students socially. There should be single sex public school districts. Single-Sex Schools have been discriminated against by many due to the belief that students will not be able to function comfortably with the opposite sex when leaving to attend a co-educational College or University. This belief is also tied with the thought that single-sex schools represent segregation; many people do believe that these types of schools promote the separation of males and females. Some also believe that all single-sex schools result in people not being able to function socially with opposite gender when place in the real world. However, all of these beliefs are far from the truth. Studies have shown that attending single-sex schools can be very beneficial in succeeding both academically and socially. Gender-separate format can boost grades and test scores for both girls and boys (Haag, 2000). Single-Sex education is especially beneficial for young females and young males. This type of education offers both genders a more comfortable way of learning, students feel more comfortable asking questions and speaking up in a classroom setting. Teachers can focus on gender issues facing young females or males today, such as body concerns as well as focusing on more challenging subjects for young girls and boys (Messinger, 2001). Through studies made from various single-sex female schools, as well as the research made through comparisons to coeducational schools, the belief that single-sex school as being a bad idea is shown to be not only incorrect, but also a completely misguided beliefs.…

    • 1635 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    My organization is in a state of transition. The high school population has out grown the space that we have available. Our high school currently consists of two campuses, a mile apart. One campus houses the ninth graders and half of the tenth graders. The second campus houses the other half of the tenth graders as well as the eleventh and twelfth graders. After much planning and research, the decision has been made to remodel and expand the current Sr. High campus to accommodate all 9 through 12 students. This project will be completed in phases over a three to five-year time-period, and begin in the summer of 2107. In addition to this impending construction, both high schools are now under the supervision of one principal. This year has brought…

    • 965 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    single sex schools

    • 547 Words
    • 3 Pages

    It has been argued that single sex schools can improve learning where behavioral issues promptly subsided, attendance increased and the boys participated more actively (the advertiser, 31.8.2012) and in multi sex schools classes girls are scared of raising their hands to answer the questions because they are afraid of giving the answer wrong and the boys laughing at them (miahuang, 11, 2010).But in multi sex schools learning improved .Where it turns out that there is competition between both sexes in the classroom and this shows increasing the level of memorization of the student. Most importantly, single-sex schooling decreases boys’ and girls’ opportunities to learn from and about each other. Boys and girls must learn to work together, and the classroom is the ideal setting for such practice because it is both purposeful and supervised. (Valerie Strauss, 6, 4, 2012).…

    • 547 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    single sex schools

    • 845 Words
    • 4 Pages

    It has been argued that single-sex schools produce students from different sexes to learn from and about each other. Male and female students can learn from each other’s approaches and learn to collaborate, each bringing their style to bear in working for common goals. This is claimed as in important learning opportunity by advocates of education. However, according to Leonard Sax, founder of the national association for single-sex public education agree that placing boys in separate classrooms from boys accomplishes little. However, as head of the national association for single-sex public schools has pointed out that boys and girls have distinct needs in the classroom, for example, girls do better in warmer classrooms while boys prefer cooler ones. Separating them allows those needs to be met, which will help them to learn more effectively. Moreover, ‘A 2001British study of 2954 high schools and 979 primary showed that male and female students learn and perform better In single sex schools, regardless of socio-economic and ability levels’.…

    • 845 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    In 2000, a concerned principal at Thurgood Marshall Elementary school in Seattle Washington was alarmed by the amount of office referrals he was seeing daily as well as the poor standings his school was in, in comparison to national standards. Through one simple change he reported: “Overnight. The change in the atmosphere happened overnight.”(Wright). There was no need for new teachers, new kids, or a new curriculum to bring on this change in the atmosphere, just separate gender classes. Because segregation in gender maximizes the quality of children’s education, creates a safe and stable environment for kids to learn in and breaks stereotypical boundaries for both sexes, it is a valid choice schools throughout the world are making in their quest for a better education system.…

    • 1340 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Single Sex Schools

    • 457 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The advantages and disadvantages of single-sex schools are still debated in the field of education. As the name implies, single-sex schools or single-sex education separate male and female students so that they learn in either all male or all female classrooms and environments. This was a common practice in the past but fell out of favor with charges of unequal access to quality education and opportunities for female students. The advantages and disadvantages of single-sex schools are the focus of pro-con essays on single-sex schools. Are single-sex schools better than coed schools? Who benefits and who loses from single-sex education? Can separate but equal be attained in single-sex education? These are just some of the questions addressed in pro-con essays on single-sex schools. Also, keep in mind that pro-con essays on single-sex schools are similar to distance learning essays, school inclusion essays and essays on the pros and cons of homeschooling as all are concerned with how we deliver quality education to children.…

    • 457 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Single Sex Schools

    • 356 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In conclusion, I recommend replacing all middle and high schools to single sex schools. Why? Because the game of who likes who, who’s going out with whom, and who’s cool and who’s not, begin in these ages. So to broaden the student’s horizons, to allow them to feel…

    • 356 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    for single sex schools

    • 1084 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Co-educational schools attempt to establish uniformity in the teaching of two groups, boys and girls, who typically learn and develop at different speeds and using different methods. ‘They do not develop in the same way or at the same time; boys favour visual processing and do not have the hand-motor control that girls readily achieve in early grades’.[1] It is widely accepted that ‘boys develop more slowly than girls..that’s true at every level of analysis’.[2] Furthermore, they develop physically at different speeds, girls often developing earlier which can lead to bullying from the opposite sex for those who either over-develop or under-develop. Therefore, it should come as no surprise that, at least in the United States, elementary school boys are 50% more likely to repeat a grade than girls and they drop out of high school a third more often.[3] If they were taught separately and the curriculum and teaching was tailored to their needs, drop-out rates would not be so high nor as vastly disproportionate.…

    • 1084 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Single sex classrooms create opportunities that do not really exist in a coed classroom for students. Teachers can create learning strategies in all girl classrooms, and in all boy classrooms, which do not work as well in coed classrooms. Many public schools are beginning to adopt the single sex classroom ideas and seeing dramatic improvement with grades and test scores. The strongest proof yet, that separating boys and girls works, is the drastic improvement in grades for both sexes. But to simply place girls in a classroom and boys in another classroom is not going to work. Teachers should have special training for practical gender-specific classroom strategies and learn the best practices for these gender-separate classrooms. In the book “Gender and Education” the authors Barbara Banks, Sara Delamont, and Catherine Marshall specifically state: “Teacher interactions with students are at the heart of the hidden curriculum and are important means by which informal lessons about gender are transmitted in schools” (Banks571). Single sex classrooms simply create more opportunities and a better learning environment for our children that coed classrooms do not create. Girls in all girl classrooms and boys in all boy classrooms are more likely to study subjects that they would not necessarily choose if the class was coed. It also expands ideas of educational opportunities and core values for both boys and girls, and the classes generate custom created learning strategies and instructions to better learning.…

    • 1844 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Single-sex classes

    • 1183 Words
    • 4 Pages

    This research is looking into ways to improve the students’ education level. Now a days schools are looking for ways to increase student motivation and academic achievement which ought to consider offering single-gender classrooms as one highly effective change that can address students’ needs. The single-gender education is a legal option for any K-12 public schools. Our state has 160 schools now offering these options for students. One of the highest in the nation is in Washington and 100 more already considered doing so for the 2010-11 school year. Currently, single-gender classes are offered in kindergarten through 9th grade in urban, rural, and suburban districts across the state. While these types of teaching approaches may be thought to improve grades, test scores and college acceptance rates, there’s some evidence that shows sex-segregated classes improve educational outcomes. A 2005 U.S. Department of Education comparison of same-sex and coeducational schools found studies examining academic benefits and concluded that the results are mixed and conclusive enough for the department to endorse single-sex education. This research is looking into ways to improve the students’ education level. Now a days schools are looking for ways to increase student motivation and academic achievement which ought to consider offering single-gender classrooms as one highly effective change that can address students’ needs. The single-gender education is a legal option for any K-12 public schools. Our state has 160 schools now offering these options for students. One of the highest in the nation is in Washington and 100 more already considered doing so for the 2010-11 school year. Currently, single-gender classes are offered in kindergarten through 9th grade in urban, rural, and suburban districts across the state. While these types of teaching approaches may be thought to improve grades, test scores and college acceptance rates, there’s some evidence that shows sex-segregated…

    • 1183 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Secondly, the grades of the students are very important. The grades are important because in some cases, it could help the student get an acceptance letter to a good college. This is why students should keep grades above average and also get involved sports. Test scores would be higher and the school’s academic success would be increased by being in a single sex school. Students would stay in school rather than drop out because they feel like someone cares about their education. Single sex schools would have better connection with their students. Students would also have high class grades because they can focus more without the other gender.…

    • 308 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    gender differneces

    • 1972 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Interviews done by Hubbard and Datnow of students and staff in California schools offering single-sex classes showed that both groups felt that a major contribution to student success was the lack of distraction from the opposite sex. In 2008, a U.S. Department of Education study found that “both principals and teachers believed that the main benefits of single-sex schooling are decreasing distractions to learning and improving student achievement.” (Hutchison & Mikulski, 2012). As part of a long-term study of Australian secondary schools, which had been single-sex schools and then converted to co-ed schools over a two-year period. Interviews with teachers and students showed that girls appeared to do better socially in a single-sex class (Jackson & Smith, 2000). Teachers who worked in single-sex classes and schools reported fewer discipline problems to Gurian and Henley (2001), and administrators and teachers in Florida single-sex schools reported dramatic improvement in student performance (Isensee & Vasquez, 2012).…

    • 1972 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays

Related Topics