Preview

David Fletcher Case Analysis

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
648 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
David Fletcher Case Analysis
Why did Fletcher's first attempt to build an effective research team not work out as intended?
Fletcher’s primary mistake was not communicating a clear vision for what he expected of his team and what contributions they needed from him in order to flourish. In her article, “Managing a Team Vs. Managing the Individuals on a Team”, Loren Gary points out the importance of sending the appropriate signals during the initial stages of a team’s creation so that everyone is on the same page (pg. 3). At the time, Fletcher had an opportunity to set the tone and establish cohesion, but by failing to do so he ultimately let the situation get away from him.
Fletcher had unknowingly established a single-leader unit (SLU) during his first attempt, as opposed to an effective team. He hired team members to perform certain functions within the group that didn’t necessarily connect to the work being done by other individuals, which meant that there was very little need for members to work collectively. As the sole leader in the team, this also meant that Fletcher was left with the duty of integrating of all of their individual pieces once the work was complete. He ultimately created more work for himself because he was managing the individuals that made up the team, as opposed to managing the team as a whole and allowing them to take mutual accountability for the work being done.
Fletcher also made the common mistake of ignoring the importance of compatibility when he formed the team. He didn’t investigate each individual’s career goals to consider whether or not they “fit” into a team environment, nor did he consider how compatible each individual was with the other team members. Had he done that then he likely would have seen some of the red flags earlier on; specifically in Whitney and Doyle’s relationship.
What should he do this time around?
To begin, Fletcher should ask himself if a team is the best organizational structure for what he’s trying to accomplish. If

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    In the Case of Donald Marshall where he was charged for fishing offseason, which went against new regulations that the government has been trying to put into place. Marshall had claimed that “the right to fish on a Treaty of Peace and Friendship signed in 1760-1761 between the British Crown and the Mi’kmaq of what are now the provinces of Nova Scotia, New Brunswick, Prince Edward Island, and Quebec” (McGaw, 1), Marshall had the right to fish and hunt offseason due to the fact that his ancestors had fought and signed for him to have that right. The court viewed the Treaty as having no power do to the fact that the policies have changed within Canada, many of the things that were promised in the treaty no longer applied to the current times.…

    • 427 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Michael Blair was faced with multiple charges and years in prison for something he did not do. First Blair would be faced with a really long time in prison for capital murder. Wednesday, Blair was charged with capital murder because of the death of Ashley Nicole Estell, who was abducted on Sept. 4 from a crowded park in Plano, Texas (McFarland). This shows what Michael was charged with capital murder against a Texas teen, Ashley Estell, on September 4th from a crowded park. Second, Blair was already a convicted felon and claimed that he was innocent. A convicted sex offender that was 23 years old was charged with capital murder, says that he did not commit the abduction and killing of a Texas girl (McFarland). This goes more into personal detail about the convicted murderer, Michael Blair, and the fact that he is pleading innocent in this capital murder charge. Michael Blair knew that he was not guilty of capital murder against Ashley Estell, but he would have a long fight ahead of him to get exonerated. The investigation would make him seem more guilty, than innocent.…

    • 1741 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Andrew Hyde Case Analysis

    • 572 Words
    • 3 Pages

    MILLERSBURG — He's already served between 45 and 50 days in jail for his unrelenting pursuit of a Holmes County woman. Now, an 81-year-old Akron man is likely to be released, but only after participating in a psychological evaluation and with a plan in place.…

    • 572 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Unit 531

    • 2061 Words
    • 7 Pages

    be able to see the value of each team member. They are calm and good natured and…

    • 2061 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Our company is one of those believers in teamwork but Hackman argues that most company has misconceptions on teamwork. The first misconception that Hackman mentions is on “harmony.” Many companies feels that if a team has smooth interaction it would avoid wasting time and having debates on how to proceed. (Hackman, 2011) According to Hackman (2011), “Conflict, when well managed and focused on a team’s objectives, can generate more creative solutions than one sees in conflict-free groups.” Conflict and constructive criticism seems to bring out great ideas and help see more than one point of view. The second misconception that Hackman mention was “mixing it up.” According to Hackman (2011), the longer members stay together as an intact group, the better they do. As an employee who participates in groups it easier to continue to work with the same people because you get to know and learn the people in the group which helps with knowing their triggers and fuses. When adding new people to an existing group or changing team could possibly prolong the project because now that team has to reacquaint themselves with each other as well…

    • 1133 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Mr. Jimmie Osborne is enrolled in the Anger Management Group Therapy class I facilitate at the Columbia Center on Mondays at 2:00pm. Up until week seven, Mr. Osborne has been an active participant engaged in group discussions appropriately. During week seven, he became disruptive and inappropriate to the point redirection was no longer effective and he had to be asked to leave the group. After session, Mr. Osborne asked permission to attend future groups and was told he could do so as long as he kept his attitude in check and followed group/center rules to which he agreed. Mr. Osborne came to class for week eight and during check in, he discussed an issue he faced over the weekend which involved him being called a racial slur at the USC…

    • 467 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The features of effective team performance are set out in Brian Tuckman’s phases of team development theory, ‘Forming, Storming, Norming, Performing.’ This outlines the phases that a team will go through in order to become effective and reach maturity. At the ‘Forming’ stage of team development individual roles and responsibilities are unclear and each member of the team is concerned to avoid conflict with each other. From this point the team will go through the ‘Storming’ phase which is when they start to conflict as individuals put forward ideas which will be challenged by others in a bid to gain power and position over others. After this the ‘Norming’ phase follows and it is at this point that individual roles are defined and accepted and ground rules and conduct are agreed. After each of these stages the team then reaches the ‘Performing’ stage which is where they are all working towards the same shared goal. This theory shows that for all teams to be effective each individual needs to be clear on their role, responsibilities and shared end goal. This is achieved through positive leadership, utilising the skills of the team and addressing weaknesses to make the team more effective.…

    • 1111 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    TDA 2.6 1.1

    • 274 Words
    • 2 Pages

    I think that for any team to be successful it requires those people to have common/collective understanding of what their aims and objectives are.…

    • 274 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    When a group of people get together to do the same thing they starts to build a team, Bruce Tuckman in 1965 come up with an theory that explains how a group of people become a good team. He said that there are four stages to make a good team they are: Forming, Storming, Norming and Performing. Forming is the stage when everyone is trying to get to know each over, however is not sure of what they are doing and look to the person in charge, And also not a lot of agreement in the team. Then there is Storming this is when everyone’s trying to finder there place in the group also this is when relationship are formed meaning that it is easy to get distracted from the task on hand, Likewise it hard for the team to make decisions together. Then there’s Norming this is when they fist start to work as a good team it is easy for them to make a group decision, positions and roles in the group are respected and understood. Also this is when they may start to have fun outside of the work meeting up and doing social activities together. Last there is Performing this is when the…

    • 692 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Because Paul Gaffney said this about team work in sports “Teamwork in sport presents a variety of special challenges and satisfactions. It requires an integration of talents and contributions from individual team members, which is a practical achievement, and it represents a shared pursuit, which is a moral achievement. In its best instances team sport allows members to transform individual interests into a common interest, and in the process discover of part of their own identities. Teamwork is made intelligible by the collective pursuit of victory, but moral requirements importantly condition that activity.” (Gaffney, Paul). I believe if the Point University Basketball team first understand the meaning of teamwork and how it can help them win games. There was one insistent of the team agreeing on one thing together. That day both the captains got together and said to the team what is one thing we are trying to accomplish as a team this year the whole team agreed and said the all want to win a conference campion chip or to get a ring. I believe that was the only sign of teamwork that I’ve seen come from the team this year where they all came to gather as a team and said we are going to when a championship this year. I think teamwork is one of the best keys that the team needs to come together and help each other win rather than each time they lost a game one of our player would never take credit for the lose the just took the “non-team player” is to selfish to take credit for the lost they just blame it on the…

    • 1506 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    “Simply installing a team structure with membership of expert professionals does not automatically ensure it will operate effectively” (Miller et al., 2009 p. 254). As figure 1.1 shows, effective team structures, processes and planning should…

    • 818 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Introduction Simmons Laboratories are in a difficult situation following Bob Knowlton’s sudden, unanticipated resignation. This paper outlines what Bob Knowlton could have done differently and identifies specific ideas about teams, organizational culture artefacts and underlying assumptions and organizational and personal values that could have resulted in a positive outcome. Question 1 Appreciation for honest dialogue amongst his team would have aided Bob Knowlton in ensuring supportive team norms. Knowlton had concerns from the first night he met Fester, yet he remained silent. He neglected to be open and honest with his team and with Jerrold, his boss. Knowlton could have demonstrated honest dialogue without personal affront when Fester commented on team ideas, satirically describing how they led to a “high level of mediocrity.” By not addressing Fester’s comment, Knowlton placed Simmons Laboratories theory of “small research teams being the basic organization for effective research” at risk. Knowlton could have stated Simmons Laboratories theory of small research to Fester in confidence after the meeting. By doing so, Knowlton would have increased common understanding and in a non offensive way informed him of Simmons Laboratories underlying theory, as lead by Dr. Jerrold. Knowlton could have actively managed the conflict that was occurring within his team rather than exercising avoidance or withdrawal from the situation. By avoiding the conflict team members were experiencing he may have increased frustration for all team members. Avoidance ultimately led to the leadership of the group being taken over from Knowlton by Fester. Fester could have used a collaborative approach to deal with team conflict which would have shown respect for existing team members and given them the opportunity to openly discuss the issues arising since Fester joined the team. Although Knowlton did privately discuss the matter with two…

    • 878 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    I am asked by the owner of The Friday Shop and the owners of the apartments (Claimants) to write an opinion to establish if they are able to claim for damages from Boutique Bugs (Defendant) for the amount of $1,100,000 based on the elements of the rule in Rylands v Fletcher.…

    • 1054 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    | * Parson never built consensus around what he wanted to do which was against the MS way of doing things. * Superiors called him volatile and abrasive and colleagues were concerned about his lack of team player skills. * Reviews pointed out that Parson was very judgemental and rushed through his decisions.…

    • 496 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The team was able to work together as a team to develop a routine they had in place. The crew was able clarify their performance goals, improve their skills and abilities by rotating tasks every day. All crew members, including Joan were able to interact and have more cohesion by interacting with each other fairly on a regular basis. Having a leader who is able to direct crew members in a fairly manner and reward them for their hard work, motivation will increase resulting in excellent work from all employees. Joan was willing to assist the crew with any of their concerns. The old crew, including Joan, worked together as a team to get the job done. Once next summer came around, the crew experienced new thing within the company. They were given new supervisors where the working atmosphere has changed. The supervisors viewed themselves as higher than all crew members as they did not care to contribute, did not dress appropriately and did not treat the crew members fairly. The team developed poor team development due to the reason that all crew members were separated into groups. New members should have been placed amongst old crew members to increase performance. As time has gone by, the crew members productivity decreased significantly. This has caused sales to drop by 5% and task performance to drop significantly. If the crew and supervisors were able to communicate on a fair level, without shouting and yelling, team development would have been more efficient. It seemed that the new supervisors worked more as a team by implementing their expectations of the job as oppose of including all team members to work together and get the job done. Joan needs to look more in depth in her business in order to increase productivity and decrease employees from leaving their jobs. Although some crew members have decided to come back, it is due to the fact that the pay is decent…

    • 1113 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays

Related Topics