Preview

Does Imprisonment Work or Not?

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
334 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Does Imprisonment Work or Not?
I believe whether imprisonment works or not depends on each specific case’s victims, offenders, and how the case was handled by the court and prison systems. Imprisonment alone does not work, but combined with other methods like rehab or therapy, it can work. Locking away a prisoner and throwing away the key does not help society. Although it does accomplish one of the goals of punishment, incapacitation, imprisonment does not work. I think that imprisonment is overused, especially in the United States. We have the highest incarceration rate today. Americans represent 5% of the world’s population but we house 25% of the entire world’s inmates.

Age should be a huge factor in what types of criminal offenders should be locked up versus other types of penalties. Prisoners do not have the rigorous rehabilitation that is needed to turn youth into productive members of society. Incarceration is ineffective in controlling the behavior of youth due to the unfinished development of the brain and is therefore not a good deterrent. There are far more consequences, like a high recidivism rate, when young people are put into prison. Incarceration does not teach the skills necessary to be a successful member in their community.

Fines are a good punishment for less-serious offenses especially committed by first-time offenders. An example would be for traffic violations. For a more serious offense or if the defendant already has a record, a fine and another form of punishment like community service or probation should be combined with a fine. Incarceration should be the last resort. An instance when this should be used is for a second underage drinking charge or caught with a decent amount of marijuana. It should be taken into account if a defendant has mental issues, an addiction, or previous traumatic event and to seek a rehabilitating way to help while dealing with their punishment. Although a long imprisonment may seem ideal for victims, the rights and justice due to

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays
    • 471 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    If one is old enough to do the crime, are they truly old enough to do the time? If so, does that time include being placed within a facility originally designated for those at a different age and mental capacity? There are countless disputes and problems regarding the justice system and its decisions. Among those decisions is the decision to sentence a juvenile as an adult and place them within a adult prison, rather than in a juvenile detention center. Just as in most things in life, the justice system is not black and white. Some agree with juvenile incarceration and others reckon children should be treated true to their age and as what they are, children. These academic journals, articles and opinion pieces attempt to make some sense of…

    • 1279 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    There should be no special treatment for convicted young offenders. They should be treaded as adults.…

    • 2297 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Even though incarceration should be about rehabilitating prisoners and releasing them back into society as productive members, unfortunately it has become about politics. Those running for office always want to appear to be tough on crime, and indeterminate sentencing appears to some to be too soft. Allowing prisoners to earn their freedom before they have served their maximum sentence is not punishment in the eyes of those that believe prisoners should be locked up and made to do hard…

    • 825 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Typically, juveniles who display a propensity for committing crime will continue to do so, even as they get older. Their crimes may even become more serious in nature. Therefore, teens that commit heinous crimes should be punished for their obnoxious behavior. In “Juvenile Doesn’t Deserve Life Sentences” by Gail Garinger, he states that “a juvenile doesn’t deserve life in prison because most teens haven’t reached their full maturity”.…

    • 440 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Sending young offenders to adult prisons means that we as a society do not care for them, and means we have given up on them. We are basically setting them up for failure in the adult prison, because they have no chance of getting out, because of their undeveloped mind constantly telling them that the jail life is necessary for survival. Instead of sending them to these prisons, we should send these young offenders to juvenile hall, where they could be treated with rehab, and a second chance at life for the mistake they’ve committed at such a young age. And if they show no sign of wanting to improve, and love their old habits, then, and only then should they go to adult prisons. But until then, they should not be tried as adults, and go to adult…

    • 937 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    In the United States, anyone who is charged for committing a crime before the day of their 18th birthday is considered a juvenile and depending on the severity of the case shall be tried as a juvenile. There are some cases; however, where the juvenile justice system should be harder on the juvenile, but in most cases they should not go to an adult prison. There are most certainly some cases in which the juvenile should face the adult justice system, but for petty instances, a juvenile court will suffice. I find it hard to agree that a juvenile convicted for crimes dealing with drugs, alcohol, traffic violations, etc. should be tried in an adult court to receive punishment; however, I do believe that someone who commits rape, murder, kidnapping, or any other major crimes of the sort should be taken to an adult court. “Old enough to do the crime, old enough to do the time,” is a quote I remember hearing as I was growing up, but I was not taught that it applied to small or minor crimes, but often serious ones involving the harming of another individual. Placing juveniles in adult prisons can cause them to be put in danger, when in reality many of them can be “fixed”…

    • 1464 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Politicians feel that best solution is to lock up youth offenders for long periods of time. Most studies demonstrate that putting young offenders in adult prisons leads to more crime, higher prison costs, and increased violence. Yet, our nation is spending more and more on prisons, and less on crime prevention efforts. Some states spend more on prisons than they do on education. The cost of keeping juveniles in prison as compared to putting them into rehabilitation programs is astronomically higher. It can cost five thousand dollars to keep a juvenile in prison, when all they need to do is go to high school. Also the effectiveness of prisons preventing juveniles from becoming repeat offenders is low. Kids, who have already spent time in adult prisons, are far more likely to commit…

    • 1427 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    On the topic of Juvenile offenders being tried, sentenced and jailed as adults, Researcher and Journalist Mike Allen claims that “report after report have concluded that trying teens as adults does nothing to deter crime -- and that sending teens to adult prison makes them more likely to become repeat offenders”. While I agree that sentencing a youth offender to a term of punishment to be carried out with adult offenders may continue the devastating cycle of violence in our culture, I do not agree that juvenile offenders should receive a smaller sentence or easier punishment on the basis of the affects of cross imprisonment. Instead I would argue that the justice system of America must evolve to adequately evaluate and implement punishment and reform that is conducive to the development of juvenile offenders. Youth crime in America is becoming an unavoidable circumstance that is poisoning our culture and hindering many of our youth from the ability to pursue fulfilled and successful lives. Just as Derrion Albert was an innocent bystander who loss his life to reckless and senseless acts of violence, our world has lost its viable claim of goodness to acts of hate against humanity.…

    • 588 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    I believe mandatory sentences could be effective if the correctional system was expanded to accommodate the increase of prisoners. From what I have learned so far, the political climate of the country has a lot to do with sentencing laws. It can be a rollercoaster of tough on crime methods to programs designed to lessen punishment. Mandatory…

    • 201 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Adult Prisons

    • 2156 Words
    • 9 Pages

    Is sending kids to adult prisons and trying them as adults the best solution for our crime problem or would rehabilitating juveniles be a better option? Most people agree that kids who commit violent crimes need to be punished. However, do they really learn anything from being punished as an adult? In today’s society, punishment and rehabilitation has always been a big problem within our views in the Juvenile Justice System. Rehabilitation beats punishment! Adolescents who are tried and convicted of a crime should be placed in a rehabilitative system rather than a punitive system in order to shift behavior as rehabilitative systems lower recidivism rates.…

    • 2156 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    In cases like these we should look real deep in the case not just because is rape or sexual assault but rather than is the offender may have done this before. Therefore we should consider a bigger punishment for them. We also got to consider that many people that done this type of crimes there old and have committed their first crime. We must think a realize that why are we putting people for their rest of his life in a prison and why we won’t just give him or she a death penalty. We are leaving someone for life in facility he or she is going to live on and die on. Now the elderly offenders are just taking space and money from the facilities. The money and the space can be use for more products to produce and farm to grow their food…. We most do something about it ether at a certain age we released those who In the facility behave good and follow directions we can make them go in work so when they get out of prison. They all ready will have a job to progress in the real world . I been asking these questions to family members, friend, teachers, and students. “What do you think about releasing offenders at age of 65? I got some interesting opinions. Like if they commit some type of crimes like sexual abuse whit a minor, first degree murder. What really cut my eye is that most of the surprising answers where from the students. That the facilities…

    • 758 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The steepest rise in crime accompanied the greatest rise in imprisonment (You decide, 2017), which suggest that despite the rise in incarcerations crime rates continue increase so putting criminals in prison does not reduce crime. There is no concrete evidence that correlates with the idea that an increase of incarceration aid in the decrease of crime rate. Needless to say there are high risk criminals that need to be housed permanently out of society but non-violent offenders don’t need incarceration but possibly rehabilitation not in a jail setting.…

    • 807 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Incarcerating the Elderly

    • 2560 Words
    • 11 Pages

    First, the pros of incarcerating the elderly criminals will be discussed. Contrary to popular belief that after a certain age criminals stop committing crime, the age of elderly offenders ranged from 60 to 99 years old which shows that no matter how old someone is they may still commit crime. Also, 86.36 percent of elderly offenders knew their victim personally (Patel 442). This is a scary statistic for friends and family that are close with elderly criminals. The first pro for incarcerating the elderly is that in a study conducted between 2006 and 2010 rape against young females was found in 31 percent of the elderly incarcerated, 36 percent of elderly incarcerated were found guilty of murder or attempted murder, and 4 percent were found guilty of selling minor girls (Patel 443). This shows that they are dangerous criminals no matter what age they are. The people that argue that elderly people are harmless are clearly wrong. Rape and murder are some of the most serious crimes in society; if someone is able to commit such crimes they are able to serve time for those crimes. Furthermore, because society is aging more and more, criminals are committing serious crimes at an older age.…

    • 2560 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Imprisonment is the most popular major penalty for offenders in many countries in the world. But whether it is effective, especially when dealing with pretty crimes?( should not use question in introduction or however, many people doubt about its effectiveness on pretty crimes ) I think those pretty criminals should be punished to work for local communities rather than instead of being put into jail, for the sake of a local community.…

    • 4407 Words
    • 18 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics