When Sinclair conversed with the parents he learned why they would not let Doctor Franklin operate on the boy. It interfered with their spiritual belief system. The violation of the body would harm the soul, meaning they rather him die and his soul be saved than cursed. This would be a violation to the species culture. Once he talked to Shon he learned that he wanted to live, but he wanted his soul more. He carried these same beliefs, and the decision to operate on him anyway would be a violation to his rights as a person. Finally, the Commander weighed in his decision to operate on one of the ambassadors to save their life. This ambassador's people had similar beliefs on operations. The consequence of him making the same decision would likely compromise the base’ neutrality, and his position as commander. Sinclair handles himself admirably in the situation, gather all the facts and weighing the options together along with the outcomes of each. He decides that it would be best if he did not let Doctor Franklin operate. This allowing the base to stay neutral, the parents and their race to be happy, and regrettably allowing Shon to
When Sinclair conversed with the parents he learned why they would not let Doctor Franklin operate on the boy. It interfered with their spiritual belief system. The violation of the body would harm the soul, meaning they rather him die and his soul be saved than cursed. This would be a violation to the species culture. Once he talked to Shon he learned that he wanted to live, but he wanted his soul more. He carried these same beliefs, and the decision to operate on him anyway would be a violation to his rights as a person. Finally, the Commander weighed in his decision to operate on one of the ambassadors to save their life. This ambassador's people had similar beliefs on operations. The consequence of him making the same decision would likely compromise the base’ neutrality, and his position as commander. Sinclair handles himself admirably in the situation, gather all the facts and weighing the options together along with the outcomes of each. He decides that it would be best if he did not let Doctor Franklin operate. This allowing the base to stay neutral, the parents and their race to be happy, and regrettably allowing Shon to