Preview

Only The Doctors Fault For Lia's Life

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
432 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Only The Doctors Fault For Lia's Life
Some might disagree with Fadiman’s claim because they might think that it is only the doctors’ fault or only the Lees’ fault for Lia’s life. Because it a doctor’s job to take care of their patients, some might think that the doctors should have done better to make Lia’s life better or make communicating easier. For example, the Lees should have been provided with a quality interpreter so that the doctors would have better understood the Lees’ needs. On the other hand, it is also the parents' job to love and take care of their children. The Lees were not compliant simply because they did not believe in Western tradition, but they did not think that their own decisions would impact their own daughter. The Lees’ ignorance to Western tradition caused their daughter to be taken away from them several times. The parents should be trying to take care of their children, not have them be taken away from their own care. …show more content…
The fault should not fall on any one party, but on how each party treated each other. They treated each other with ignorance and noncompliance without acknowledging others’ beliefs or traditions. If the fault were to fall an anyone, it should fall on both parties because the doctors failed to acknowledge the Lees beliefs, and the Lees failed to acknowledge the doctors’ traditions. In a place where a child’s life is at danger, people should not be disagreeing on what to do because it only makes it harder to choose what to do for the child. Instead, they should be trying to communicate and come to a consensus with each other so that they understand each other’s intentions and find a common

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    This book focuses on the “clash” of cultures that occurs between the Lee family, immigrants to the US from Laos, and the doctors that treat their daughter, Lia, who has been diagnosed with epilepsy. Lia’s parents, Foua and Nao Kao believe that Lia has fallen ill because she has “lost her soul”.…

    • 6372 Words
    • 16 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    healthcare professionals being trusted to look out for the best interest of the child. It seems that…

    • 1368 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    With Lias parents unable to give her the correct dosage of medicine as well as their belief that spirits were causing her seizures, American doctors clashed with the Lee family. They were unable to efficiently treat her due to her parent’s cultural background.…

    • 487 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    It is evident that Marianne’s husband values life because of the fact that he “wants to try everything” (Blais & Hayes, 2011, p. 175). The children; however, seem to value the quality of life. They do not want to risk surgery if it does not offer body and mind functionality. Marianne’s husband may be in denial about the condition of his wife as well as being in shock because of the suddenness of the accident. The conflicting opinions of Marianne’s family will need to be addressed and further explored with the ethics committee before a final decision can be made. It is the health team’s responsibility to understand the family’s values, opinions, and desires for Marianne when preparing for the meeting to discuss her future care. The team must also understand any values or opinions they may bring to the situation at hand. Unlike the…

    • 901 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Based on these lenses, you must recognize your duties as caregiver. We as nurses must always follow rules and policies. By advocating for the patient, accommodation of parents harming her is not the right choice. The best care possible must be given to prevent harm to Rachel or the baby. By informing the parents of any risks and benefits regarding Rachel 's care, this allows them to make informative decisions. During this process, the parents values are maintained and the patient receives effective care. By using these lenses, the nurse is also trusted to provide safe care to the patient and safe delivery for the baby without unnecessary pain. My decision was influenced by these lenses because they help determine the value of the stakeholders and the impact it made. In my workplace, concepts from this situation would help because we encounter patients who are minors and patients who have relative with control over their plan of care, such as a POA, or power of attorney. This would guide us toward the right direction for providing safe and competent care, respecting the wishes of the patient, and preventing…

    • 767 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The China Coin

    • 1060 Words
    • 5 Pages

    “Grandfather … wrapped his arms about Joan. ‘Welcome back, Sister.’” This is a touching scene that demonstrates Chinese community is welcoming towards their relatives which escalate their sense of belonging. A further example of community acceptance is when Joan had an accident and Leah was left alone. Ke, the son of the Zhu family, recognized Leah as a family member from the letter from Joan’s father and offered hospitality. “Leah should stay in my family’s house. She is my family.” This contributes to increase Leah’s sense of belonging as Ke assisted her when she was helpless because of Joan’s accident.…

    • 1060 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    What I will be covering in my paper is how communication was the biggest role in what happened to Lia. If Lia's parents better understood the doctors it could have prevented a lot of things. But however, if the American Doctors knew about the Hmong people's culture, language and the Lee's thoughts on what was going on with Lia it also could have been prevented a lot. The Lee's thought the reason why Lia was sick was because her sister slammed the door too loud and it caused her soul to leave her body and become lost. However, the Doctors said she had epilepsy. Both of them had different views of what was going on with Lia, spiritual problem and mental problem. The American doctors should have had a few translators early in treatment that was familiar with the Hmong people that could explain to them and Doctors the cultural difference of what each party thought was going on. The Doctors and Hmong people faced many troubles and barriers when trying to communicate with each other. Doctors should be more educated and experienced with patients they deal with like their language, culture and history. If the doctors knew more about the Hmong people and their religions it could have prevented so much.…

    • 1072 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    They obviously feel sympathy towards their child as well as worried at the fact that their child could possibly die. The emotion invoked in the parent of a child cannot be felt by a doctor that is not emotionally connected to that child. This is why the doctor could never get the same response from the readers as a parent telling the story could. Since it is not told from their point of view I instead have feelings of anger towards both parents for not helping the doctor out more and for the father just becoming angry and ordering his wife to get out since she clearly was not helping. If they had told the story it would have been obvious that they knew their daughter and they were hurting from not knowing what was wrong with her, as any parent would most likely feel in this situation. Where the doctor made it seem as if the parents were not at all helping, if told from their point of view it may seem the exact opposite. That in fact they were doing all the hard work and the way the doctor was acting was what was making their daughter unwilling. There is no possible way to know, however, since it is not told from the perspective of the…

    • 931 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The hospital/healthcare providers disregarded simple ethical codes, and the safety of the patient, Bethany. The purpose of accountability is to keep the hospital/healthcare providers from breaking ethical codes, and give safety to the patient, and employees. The hospital broke two ethical codes veracity and autonomy of the patient. Bethany was never given the appropriate information for a full understanding of the surgery, therefore Bethany could not give consent to the surgery. The hospital/healthcare providers failed to tell Bethany the truth about the surgery she was undergoing, they did not tell her the aftermath that would have followed the surgery.…

    • 499 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Adeline’s ignorant father had always considered Adeline a waste of time, space and money. He always listened to his new wife and sent Adeline off to many boarding schools across the country. He even sent to her to a boarding school in Shanghai during the time when the communists were arriving. At that time most families were pulling their children out of schools and fleeing. Poor Adeline stayed at boarding schools for years and never had a visitor or any mail from her family. In one incident Adeline’s father even forgot her own name and birthday! ‘The stewardess asked me to fill out these cards. I’m afraid I’ve forgotten your Chinese name. Is it Jun-quing? No father. That’s little sister’s name. Mine is…

    • 615 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The family was informed that nothing more could be done. One parent wanted to keep their child with no brain functioning alive and wanted Doctors to do “everything” possible. The other parent understood that their child would not wake up and would never have a good quality of life again, so he decided it was best to let him go. However, the medical staff does not have the right to refuse a continued treatment requested by a parent. Therefore, in this situation the healthcare team ensured that both of the parents were informed about the benefits and risks of medical treatment.…

    • 687 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Sophia Chua-Rubenfeld’s essay “Why I love my strict Chinese mom” is a response to the all the negative feedback her mother had gotten for her essay “Why Chinese Mothers are Superior”. The intention of this essay is to persuade and inform the reader of why Amy Chua raised her daughter Sophia the correct way. Chua-Rubenfeld’s first argument is that the critics (the outsider) have no clue of what the Chua-Rubenfeld family is like (p. 2, l. 21). The fact that Chua-Rubenfeld is stating that “you don’t know what you’re talking about, because you don’t know me and/or my family” makes this a classical argument, which in reality is no valid argument. However, her main claim throughout the essay is supported by a strong warrant and ground.…

    • 865 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In “A Pair of Tickets”the character Jing-mei, is an American woman on a pilgrimage to China to meet her half-sisters, who were also abandoned by her mother in China during World War II. She didn’t want to go back to China and meet her sisters because she was afraid that her half-sisters will blame her for their mother’s death. For example, when she was speaking to her aunt about how she couldn’t tell them that her mother was dead through a letter. She explained how she felt as though her mother’s dead was her fault. “They’ll think I’m responsible, that she died because I didn’t appreciate her.”(Tan 266) Jing-mei didn’t worry much about her mother while she was alive. She didn’t pay much mind to the things her mother would tell her, for example during a conversation they had Jing-mei denies at all being Chinese. Her mother responded with, “It’s in your blood, waiting to be let go.” (Tan 263) Her mother knew all about genetics and always said, “Once you were born Chinese, you cannot help but feel and think Chinese.”(Tan 263) Jing-mei didn’t believe in any of this and wouldn’t until she actually experienced what her mother was trying to tell her all on her own.…

    • 1344 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Discussion on Tanjong Rhu

    • 1027 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The main theme of this story is the distinction between traditional habits and ceremonies and modish patterns and behavior. In the story, Chinese tradition as praying to the ancestor and the dead has been mentioned as an important element. From the description of the writer, we know that the protagonist, Mr. Li’s mother values the importance of this traditional practice. This can be proved by paragraph 5, line 1 to 8 at page 118 in the textbook. ““If something is to be done,” she said with the loud solemnity which she reserved for the altar room, “it must be done properly. If I am to visit your place of work, I must tell your father properly.” Carefully, she unlocked the top drawer of her mother-of-pear inlaid cabinet, where she kept all the paraphernalia for tending the altar: tiny porcelain wine cups, gold-leafed sheets of ceremonial money, candles and joss sticks and countless packets of incense.” As we read through the story, we know that father of the main character, Mr.Li has passed away long ago. The lines mentioned above shows that Grandma pays attention on praying to the ancestor and dead as she keeps all the necessary things for praying and arrange in the drawer. As a traditional thinker, she thinks that it is important to let Mr. Li’s father know what those livings do even though he has dead as she says “I must tell your father properly”. In Chinese traditions, praying to the ancestor and the dead is important to every family. This is a practice whereby Chinese believes that the ancestor and the dead will bless the living family. This…

    • 1027 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The Hermanson

    • 379 Words
    • 1 Page

    I do not practice a religion with that kinds of beliefs that involves medicine and faith, and for many people find it hard to understand that kind of determination and confidences to religion that would never do something that contradicts her beliefs, the Hermanson loved their daughter, also they had this belief, and with it, they did what they thought that could save her, maybe this Christian methods were not infallible, but neither is traditional medicine, both have their risks and people that choose one of these they will have to live with the consequences, but it doesn’t turn them into criminals.…

    • 379 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays