Preview

Elliot's Microcosm Summary

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
731 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Elliot's Microcosm Summary
In the video, Elliot created a microcosm of society in her classroom and discovered how innocent young children could turn into “nasty, viscous discriminating little third graders” within a day just by the imposition of a discriminating factor: The colour of ones’ eyes.
How could such a small factor make such a huge impact? As Beverly Tatum (1997) pointed out, our concept of identity is shaped by the world around us and the parts of our identity that we focus our attention the most tends to be what gets reflected back on us, often drawn to our targeted identity while our dominant identities go unexamined. So while the whole class consisted of Caucasian children who were perfectly fine with each other a day before, now their common identities were forgotten and the children’s
…show more content…
The dominant also undergoes a change of attitude and begins to feel empowerment and shows a lack of empathy. The dominant blue-eyed also begins to see the subordinates brown-eyed as the ‘others’ who needs to be put in place instead of as their classmates like when Ms Elliot was looking for her yardstick, a blue-eyed student suggested to keep the yardstick on her desk “just in case the brown-eyed people get out of hand!” This was similar to how Richard Wright describes how a subordinate Black would be brutalized by the dominant Whites if he did not “stay in his place” (as cited in Tatum, 1997, p.25)
Miller (1976) points out that those in the dominant groups generally do not like to be reminded of the existence of inequality and do not really understand the experiences of the subordinate. As you would observe, on the second day, Russell was beaming with pride for having blue eyes that he chose not to wear his spectacle to school. Had he really understood how the brown-eyed students were feeling and if he still was fully conscious of the fact that this was but an experiment, he would have downplayed the feature that made him part of the dominant

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    The Angry Eye- Essay

    • 560 Words
    • 3 Pages

    There were several charts on the walls denigrating people with blue eyes such as “Only brown eyes need apply” and “Why can’t a blue eye be more like a brown?” The brown-eyes have been instructed beforehand to treat the blue-eyes as inferior. Elliot tells them that blue-eyed participants are not as smart or clean and they should lower the expectations.…

    • 560 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    When it came to the child’s perspective one of the third graders became defensive about his father. Jane Elliot stated, “Blue-eyed people were smart and Brown-eyed people were stupid.” The child defended his father and saying, “no my father isn’t stupid.” She then convinced him by reminding him that his father had kicked him recently but that the blue eyed children with fathers had not kicked them. There was also a student of color who felt that white people don’t understand what it is like for colored people to be discriminated on a day to day basis.…

    • 514 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    "Teacher's usually did a good job of ignoring the fact that one kid was shorter than another or another was fatter, but it was they, not the other students, who made my skin color an issue. The kids had only picked up on the adult cues and then interpreted them. Moreover, height, weight, and other physical characteristics were relative states. But being white was constructed a as matter of kind, not degree." He describes his social relations with his classmates as predominately a school relationship. He says, "I must have already started to segregate myself culturally, since it never even crossed my mind to invite any of the kids home with me after…

    • 1052 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Crime Laboratory Analysts

    • 665 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Those that that their eye color group was on the bottom felt stupid and worthless, while those who eye color group was at the top felt like kings and like they were above everyone else.…

    • 665 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    From an early age, I can remember going to school and being confined into my own social group of friends conveying in each other about daily problems, emotions, and how our personal lives are going. At those points in my life I had a sense of peace and felt anything I told my peers of this group they could relate and wouldn’t judge anything I said. Why would I give you this little piece of my childhood you may ask? To answer that is not being able to relate to anyone in the class or school who wasn’t from my racial background. As like in Beverly Daniel Tatum’s article I was one of those kids who sat at the lunch table full of blacks feeling as if they were the only people, in the school who I could relate to and understood me being a person of color.…

    • 634 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    From an early age Anne Moody saw the differences between the blacks and whites in her community. Segregation was presented right away, in the living quarters of Anne and her family. Anne Moody didn’t understand what segregation was for a long time. The social aspects of what it was eluded her until the movie theater. She was seven; she made friends with Bill and Katie who lived nearby. She saw that they had things like skates, a bike, a play house that her family didn’t have, but over they were equal when they played together. When her mother took her and her siblings to the movie theater on Saturday, Anne saw Katie and ran after her in the white section of the theater. “I now realized that not only were they better than me because they were white, but everything they owned and everything connected with them was better…

    • 1256 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the documentary, the teacher had white kids in her class and the kids had a sense of how discrimination works out. She had separated the students by having people with brown eyes be more discriminated while the kids with blue eyes have the benefits of having five extra minutes of recess and having their time being taught by the teacher instead of the kids with brown eyes. The teacher ended up switching up the role of students with brown eyes have all the advantages and the kids with blue eyes be discriminated. Later on, in that week, the students with blue eyes had felt like they had all the power and did things to make the brown-eyed students feel bad. The students learned that discriminating people that have a different skin color is not worth it because they had felt that same pressure of being unknown and feeling left out.…

    • 926 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The article says that “Since all four of these dimensions develop during social interactions in school with peers and adults, it is important for educators to recognize that that racism and other forms of oppression are always operating in every social setting.” Afterwards the article gave an example where second graders were evaluated. That example revealed that the children aren’t blind to color, but they are more than aware of race. Then the article explained how engaging in self-reflection as a teacher is very encouraged. The article also gave guidance on how to talk to a child about racial issues.…

    • 641 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    essay on A Class Divided

    • 754 Words
    • 4 Pages

    With that being said, Jane Elliot decided to do a two day experiment to help the kids realize that discrimination is wrong. The first day of the exercise, she split the class into groups of blue-eyed people and brown-eyed people. On this particular day, the blue-eyed people were better than the brown-eyed people. She made the brown-eyed people wear a collar around their necks to help better distinguish between the eye colors. On this day, the blue eyed people were granted extra time at recess, were able to drink directly from the water fountain, have second helpings at lunch, and were allowed to play on the playground equipment. The brown-eyed children were not allowed the same luxuries.…

    • 754 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    remember the titans

    • 723 Words
    • 3 Pages

    I began watching the documentary called a class divided that filmed Jane Elliot as a school teacher in the 80’s teaching a third grade class race and ethnicity issues. It deals with discrimination and documents these kids being divided and discriminated against based on their eye color. These kids rotated days being inferior and lesser of the two based on the color of their eyes and were forced to wear a collar type cloth around their neck and received less time for recess or were not being able to use the playground at all. When the blue eyed kids were told they were smarter and better a boy took advantage of it and he teased the other kids calling them brown eyed and discriminating against them. When just the day before the kid was brown eyed and it wasn’t a problem but once brought to attention it became a bigger insult. The next day the blue eyed kid didn’t wear his glasses to show his dominant blue eyes but that day it was reversed and blue eyes were seen as lesser. They didn’t like these roles being reversed and a few kids just put their heads. So I’m assuming when they were out on recess it was different because the kids would tease the other kids but once it got turned on them they changed attitudes. It was a good way to show how discrimination works being told you were inferior or not as smart overall based on something you had no choice in being born with. I think this video would be informative and entertaining for a class to watch but more so to engage in an…

    • 723 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Summary: A Class Divided

    • 1161 Words
    • 5 Pages

    A Class Divided was an experiment conducted by a third-grade teacher named Jane Elliot. When Martin Luther King Jr was shot, one day later Jane Elliot knew teaching her third-grade class that discrimination was wrong, wasn’t such an easy task but a difficult challenge since their parents raised them to believe discrimination of the blacks was the right thing to do. According to the video uploaded by Jshapplet, Jane Elliot stated on the first day of the experiment that: It just might be interesting to judge people today by the color of their eyes, blue eyed people should be on top the first day here, I mean the blue-eyed people are the better people in this room (Jshapplet). Mrs. Elliot leads the children to believe that those who has blue eyes…

    • 1161 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    As she entered the local supermarket, everyone’s actions came to a standstill. They all watched her as she walked down the aisle minding her own business. Their eyes pierced into her dark flesh, discovering the humility that the woman felt as they watched every single one of her moves. The humiliation that she experienced caused her to question how one’s mind could be so immoral to the point where they discriminate people from society because of their skin color. She perpetually wondered what it would be like to be born a different skin color. It was challenging for the young woman to be a part of society without feeling discriminated by others. She longed for the time where color would not create a rift in society and instead would unite people…

    • 1551 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the article she talks about her kindergarten students and how one student told her that her mother was giving her pills to turn her skin white (Segura-Mora). The moment she shared with this student resulted in a teachable moment that benefited the students all together, but it was a sad moment to have to experience with children of such a young age. Segura- Mora begins to explain that as teachers we are “cultural workers” and “If teachers don’t question the culture and values being promoted in the classroom, they socialize their students to accept the uneven power relations of our society along lines of race, gender, and ability. Yet teachers can-and should- challenge the values of white privilege and instead promote values of self-love” (Segura-Mora,). I fully support and agree with Segura-Mora’s claim and as an educator I hope to do exactly that.…

    • 999 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    A Class Divided Summary

    • 773 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Jane Elliot covered the topic and talked it to them but they couldn’t comprehend, so she had them experience discrimination first-hand. She told her class that all blue-eyed people are better and brown eyed aren’t, the blue-eyed kids felt superior throughout the whole day as the brown-eyed kids felt inferior. Superior is higher in rank or quality, as inferior is the opposite; lower in rank or quality, throughout the day the brown-eyed kids were treated atrociously showing aggressive behavior towards the blue-eyed kids. Causes of aggressive behavior are from an obstacle that stands in the way of doing something, however frustration makes you angry when felt the act what intentional. A prejudice; an unfavorable attitude toward a group of people this situation it was brown-eyed kids. Stereotype is a belief or expectation about a group of people; the blue-eyed students were told at the beginning of the day brown-eyed are lazy and dumb so they drew quick generalizations about them all as a…

    • 773 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Social Navigation Hypothesis suggests that conditions cataloged as "illness, or "disorder" were beneficial to our survival. This theory affirms that what we would categorize as mental illness benefits us by urging us to integrate for a higher rank in society. I would like to think this has no correlation with beauty, or weight as our ancestors did not have IG makeup tips in the past, nor did they care about dieting. However, it does indicate that our mental "illnesses" are actually the motivation for the strive to succeed.…

    • 747 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics