Preview

Ethical Dilemmas In The Military

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
991 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Ethical Dilemmas In The Military
Ethical Dilemma: Health vs Integrity
David Vanik
ORGL 2300
Fall 2016

Ethics and morality is the cornerstone of the military mindset. How do decisions affect not only the individual, but the team. Does the individual act professional and consider the ramifications of their actions when viewed against the larger organization and the core value instilled in the individual since basic training? Without discipline, ethics and morality guiding the hand of a military machine, the military is nothing more than a highly weaponized mob. But like any other career field, the individual can still be confronted with ethical dilemmas. Placing the team and the service over your own needs is necessary in combat, however it must also be tempered
…show more content…
The first two core values conflict many times when dealing with the medical status and flying status. For an active duty Airman, the idea of being grounded due to medical is easy to absorb, the office is typically fully staffed, another crew member is usually on standby as a backup and most importantly, the grounded flyer is paid regardless, crews are staffed according to availability with their civilian career, there are no backups in the event of a call off, and most importantly, the Reservist’s pay is directly impacted by their flight status. This presents a dilemma to the airmen flying as a reservist, “I am supposed to be honest and report to medical any sickness or injury. If I do this, they will cancel the flight, I will not get paid, and the rest of the crew will lose training opportunities.” This quandary leads many individuals to take the path is most beneficial to themselves and the team as opposed to the actual rules and …show more content…
It can be something as complex as an order issued that you oppose due to personal morality, like firing on area that may contain friendly forces due to that area being a threat to the overall mission. It can also be something as simple as a clerical or administrative classification that may be incorrect and benefits you individually, while creating challenges for others on the team. Medical clearances for aircrew members present a unique problem for reserve aviators. By attempting to be forward leaning and attempting to complete the mission, even training missions, the individual puts service before self but lapses in integrity. The individual may be injured or ill in a way that can negatively impact the whole crew while performing flight duties if they do not follow established procedures for medical clearance, yet they will lose out on pay and their removal from flight status due to this illness or injury could cancel any future training missions this person is assigned too. The underlying message of this ethical dilemma can be describe as this; perform your duties to the best of your abilities, if your illness or injuries hinders this ability, you must follow the medical grounding procedures, regardless of its impact on you personally. The crew is counting on you in flight to be able to make the right decisions, sometimes those decisions can me the difference between life and death, not

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Before this course, my conception of the roles military officers in society and government had was that they were distinct individuals of a higher moral and ethical caliber. With these values came a voluntary but clear support of their chain of command and mission to defend the citizens of the United States of America. Prior to attending West Point, I observed an awkward separation between members of the armed forced and civilians due to lack of knowledge and familiarity of both worlds. Therefore, while I was aware that…

    • 514 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    There is still a concern amongst Paramedics that they have no defence against negligence apart from transporting every person they attend. In some instances this has not been the case. Documentation provides a defence; and as such, documentation is an integral part of the treatment for each patient a Paramedic attends. It is an established legal truism that a person of sound mind has the right to self-determination; they can choose what is done (or not done) to their body. The voluntary choices and decisions of an adult person of sound mind concerning what is or is not done to their body, must be respected and accepted, irrespective of what others, including doctors, may think is in the best interests of that particular person. The difficulty arises when there is doubt over whether a person is of sound mind. However, in cases where the person does have an adequate mental capacity, a patient does have the right not to be transported. As such,…

    • 1118 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Professionals often refer to their profession as a calling not a job. They earned the trust of their clients by the applied Ethics in their perspective professions. The Profession of Arms often prides itself on its transparency which allows the American people, the client, to maintain the trust of the public it serves. The Army profession must reflect on the character of its relationship with the American people, faithfulness to the Constitution and the values of the Nation. (The Profession of Arms, 8 December 2010). The trust is fundamental in the Profession of Arms by the American people after all it is them who elect the civilian authority that enforces the oath of its Soldiers, the Constitution . American people trust the Army as a profession to get it right and place leaders at the right levels who are qualified, competent, and leaders of character. The clients understand and trust that they Army Ethics provides this as the framework for developing leaders and Soldiers professional character. (The Military Review: The Profession of Arms, September 2011) The professions morals and ethics must be enforced within all ranks of the Army in order to allow the client to maintain the…

    • 681 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Eisenhower demonstrated sound moral judgment in choosing to deal with the Vichy French leader Admiral Darlan. Eisenhower encounters ethical challenges when he endorse Admiral Jean-Francois Darlan being appointed civil and military Chief of French North Africa, whereby he considered saving lives as one of his key objective in his decision. Colonel Don M. Snider identifies 7 ethical principles that all Army professionals must exemplify according to the Army Doctrine Reference Publication (ADRP). For the purposes of this paper, three of these principles are examined as it relates to Eisenhower’s leadership: Loyalty, Duty, and…

    • 1690 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Others have questioned the need to increase influenza vaccination rates among HCWs, claiming that HCWs should simply avoid patient contact when ill. Unfortunately, although HCWs say that they will stay home when sick, in reality, many HCWs routinely come to work with symptoms of influenza-like illness.32,46,47 In addition, people may shed influenza virus during the 24 hours before the onset of clinical illness48 or in the absence of clinical symptoms,49 which enables HCWs to transmit the virus to their patients, even when the HCWs feel well. A variety of ethical issues are involved in a mandatory program such as this. In sum, one attempts to balance the benefits that accrue to patient safety against the loss of the individual’s right to choose.50-52 During the planning process for our program, the ethics committee was involved, and we enlisted the help of outside ethicists as well. Overall, it was felt that the importance of protecting our patients was paramount. However, a mandatory program needs to be flexible enough so that valid reasons for avoiding vaccine use can be accommodated. We include both medical and religious reasons as part of this process.…

    • 258 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Individual actions are to support the goal of protecting the United States as a whole. A soldier who qualifies as an expert with the M-4 rifle is an example of virtue theory. The excellence of this soldier will increase the effectiveness of the team or company similar to utilitarianism. Obeying a direct order is part of the foundation of the Army. Shooting to kill in combat can go against an individual’s morals and ethics but deontology states duty is the primary factor regardless of individual belief.…

    • 612 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Deviance in the Military

    • 912 Words
    • 3 Pages

    This weeks’ writing assignment is to “discuss how members of a military unit could openly bring themselves to commit murder against some individuals and not feel any sense of deviance or criminal wrongdoing for the act. Be sure to include ideas from the work of Stanley Milgram in your answer.”…

    • 912 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    As professional military officers, we have the duty to uphold the highest standards of the Jus In Bello and sometimes that may be necessary in spite of policy makers in Washington. This responsibility resides with us because unlike those policy makers, we devote our lives to the protection and often times the taking of lives. Ethical leaders understand the enormity of this responsibility with which they are trusted. The taking of human life, more than any other action, injects a tangible sense of the…

    • 945 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Poor choices with regards to politics in the work place can lead to punitive counseling. Political ideologies and ideas are inappropriate in the work place. Senior leadership should understand that unethical political choices pose a negative impact to those around them. Utilizing the Navy Cores Values and Navy Ethos as a guide will curve the behaviors to steer in the wrong direction. This research essay will address real life ethical decision-making scenario and give discussion involving the impact, that resulted.…

    • 524 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    1a) Our justice system has always stated " innocent until proven guilty." The war in Iraq has brought out several ethical dilemmas since significant changes in the military action and homeland security. Holding terrorists suspects without legal representation, charges or court hearings is almost absurd. However, using the paradigm model, it really explains itself. The paradigm of short term versus long term is best suited for this type of dilemma. The government is taking immediate present action, due to the need of human safety since 9/11 and hoping this will help build the future. However, they government at the same time could be risking the future by holding the suspects without normal U.S. laws and court procedures. Is the government…

    • 1313 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The way that one lives, acts, and reacts to various situations; along with the level of accountability that they have for themselves within their general environment, are all characteristics that combine together to form the basic behavior of an individual. There are many qualities of life that can affect behavior, but experience is the most prominent. This essay will consist of comparing and contrasting the behavior of the military experienced and the non-military experienced group in an attempt to prove why the militaristic behavior is superior. This will be done through the examining of the characteristics of knowledge, commitment, and discipline to see the variances and the similarities between the two groups.…

    • 630 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    However, once the patient has been stabilized and moved into more of a long-term care, patients are being removed from the hospital and transferred to another hospital, which could possibly be located in another country. There are four very important negative aspects that need to be looked at when discussing forced patient repatriation. The first is that forced patient repatriation can mean transporting a sick patient a long distance, with limited equipment or personnel during the transportation, causing possible health complications. The second negative aspect is that repatriation allows hospitals to physically remove patients from one hospital to another countries hospital with fewer resources and protection from federal regulations. The third negative aspect is that repatriation serves as a form of deportation without going through the government and formal deportation proceedings. Finally the last negative aspect is repatriation moves patients from one hospital and takes them to a hospital in another country; where the patient may be unfamiliar with and away from having their family near them for…

    • 1355 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Army Values-Integrity

    • 498 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Integrity is one of the most talked about and most abused of the Seven Army Values. First we must define integrity it is doing the right thing consistently. That means that we must do the legally and morally correct thing every time. Just because something is hard or unpleasant does not mean that we can look the other way. Doing the right thing is not a matter of deciding do I help my fellow soldier and let him slide on an Army regulation or do I uphold the regulation. It means doing both they are both equally important. Sometimes helping a soldier means that you must enforce the regulations and in some cases that can mean discharging them from the Army at other times it means fighting for the soldier and getting them the help that they need to succeed in the Army.…

    • 498 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    The Importance of Accountability Is so you know where everyone is so if you need a person for something you will know where to find them. It is also necessary to have accountability to make sure everyone in your unit is safe and so you make sure they are where they are supposed to be. You also want your unit to be on standby so they are ready for anything that may happen. It is also needed so nobody goes UA.…

    • 1527 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Respect in the Military

    • 5062 Words
    • 21 Pages

    Respect, especially in the Army is a very important value to live by. It is much more than just talking kindly and listening to someone. It is the process of taking into consideration someone’s emotions, feelings and needs. You must also focus on their ideas, thoughts, and preferences. It is showing someone that you value their time; that you care what they have to say. Showing someone respect allows that person to know and acknowledge that you are tracking them and that you comprehend and believe in what they are saying, It is important to allow someone to feel your respect for them. It will ease the conversation and create trust. Behavior and attitude will allow the person demanding respect to feel that respect. When we respect each other, there are fewer conflicts. People get along easier and avoid the un-necessary drama associated with a lack of respect. For those of us in the military, this is very important.…

    • 5062 Words
    • 21 Pages
    Good Essays