A troubling example of minors' rights taken much too far is the federal law that permits minors to obtain an abortion without parental consent. The reasoning behind such a law is that a girl will be less likely to get the abortion she wants if she must disclose her intentions to her parents. What these supporters fail to consider is that just because a minor wants to get an abortion does not mean she should get one. Think about it. Do you want your daughter to make an impulsive decision about such an important matter? This law needs to be changed before more teenagers’ lives are destroyed.
Compare the situation with that of a young child who is terribly distraught over a particular bully's constant taunting. The child may want to retort with nasty remarks or a physical fight.
Only after consulting with a parent will the child realize that a confrontation yields more aggravations and possible physical harm.
Similarly, a girl who discovers she is pregnant will be overcome with emotions—regret, confusion, guilt, disappointment, and fear. With these emotions weighing on her, she is likely to act unthinkingly. She needs the mature and rationale guidance a parent can provide to avoid making an impulsive decision.
Supporters also argue that involuntary parental consent will only damage the parent/child relationship by escalating conflict and stress. Just the opposite is the case, however. Parental consent requirements prevent disastrous scenes that will inevitably occur if parents discover their daughter has had an abortion without their consent.
Of course, some tensions may arise when the daughter reveals her pregnancy, but this initial tension is a small price to pay for an open and honest relationship. Statutes that allow abortions to be administered without parental consent prevent girls from seeking the advice of the people who care so much for them.
These anti-parental-consent laws developed out of a legitimate concern for a minor's rights, but what about the rights of the parents? Law requires parental consent when a minor is to undergo any medical procedure. A minor can be refused medical attention until a parent consents, except in emergency situations. This law even applies to a minor's wish to get his or her ears pierced! In such cases, the law recognizes the parents' right to know the state of their child's well-being. It is a denial of this right, therefore, to permit minors to undergo the medical procedure of an abortion without parental consent. If the government considers the safety and health of a minor so important, then it should protect that safety in all instances.
Also, parents need to know if their child has had an abortion in case she suffers any physical or emotional side effects, which are nearly inevitable. In a survey of gynecologists, 91 percent had treated patients with complications from legal abortions. These complications included uncontrollable bleeding, hemorrhaging, seizures, infections, abdominal pains, and cervical lacerations. Equally damaging are the psychological effects, such as post-traumatic stress disorder and depression. A recent research study shows that teenage girls who have experienced abortion tend to experience depression at a much higher rate than do those who have not. Perhaps most frightening is another study showing that 60 percent of women who have post abortion trauma have suicidal thoughts.
If parents are unaware that their daughter has undergone an abortion, then how can they be attentive to the warning signs for suicide and the other disorders? The answer is that they can't; and without proper treatment, these side effects may become more damaging to the girl's health than if they were attended to immediately.
Those who disagree with parental consent requirements often cite well-known organizations that share their view, such as Planned Parenthood. But Planned Parenthood rejects the requirements for economic reasons rather than ideological ones. The organization's caseload of teen pregnancies decreases by as much as 85 percent in states where parental consent is mandatory for an abortion by a minor. The result of a reduced caseload is a reduced cash flow.
Obviously, Planned Parenthood is not going to support a practice that is not profitable for them. Not everyone is deceived by these organizations' professed support. In several polls, over 70 percent of people surveyed were in favor of parental notification laws. Also, many religious organizations have voiced strong support for such laws. Yet, liberal courts and an unresponsive government are failing to address the public's wishes. What the courts and the government do not understand is the importance of fostering communication between children and parents on the sensitive issues of the day.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
Having an abortion is ultimately the right of any woman for her own personal reasons. It is…
- 643 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Emotional/Psychological – Humiliation, bullying, making threats, shouting or swearing, racial abuse, constant teasing or poking fun…
- 1732 Words
- 6 Pages
Good Essays -
“Should Parental Involvement Be Required for Minors ' Abortions?” by Hyman Rodman. In 1973, the U.S Supreme Court gave constitutional authorization to women’s’ right to abortion after Roe vs. Wade case. “The basis for the Court 's decision was a woman 's right to privacy: "This right of privacy, whether it be founded in the Fourteenth Amendment 's concept of personal liberty and restrictions upon state action, as we feel it is, or, as the District Court determined, in the Ninth Amendment 's reservation of rights to the people, is broad enough to encompass a woman 's decision whether or not to terminate her pregnancy"…
- 1722 Words
- 7 Pages
Better Essays -
It is also very important to express genuine interest and awareness of children’s different issues they might have and ensure they can trust the person that they communicate their issues to.…
- 1082 Words
- 5 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Now Maria who is a freshman in high school, straight A student and a great player for her schools soccer team, has a kid on the way. She is not only humiliated, she’s mortified. This isn’t her fault. Should she have to live with the consequences? This is why I believe in pro-choice. In these cases people should be able to get an abortion with hassle.…
- 816 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
The choice of her keeping the child would result in her having to get a job to support the child and lose her education. I know many young teenagers that went to school with me and dropped out because they were pregnant and had responsibilities to take care of. The cycle will continue over and over and there will be more high school dropouts. With the choice of abortions many people will not have to deal with these issues.…
- 482 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
A choice is a choice; it is as simple as that. Abortion is a huge controversial issue in the United States that many people disagree on. In the essay, “Owning up to Abortion” Ehrenreich believes that women should not keep in the dark about their abortion, but instead own up to it. Although abortion may be frowned upon by some people, no one should be entitled to judge another women because of their choice. No woman should feel ashamed of having an abortion because it is her choice and no one should make her feel like her choice is invalid.…
- 246 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
1. Suppose her husband/boyfriend does not want her to have an abortion at this time and offers to help raise the child.…
- 1966 Words
- 8 Pages
Good Essays -
In most of the United States, a minor must have a parental consent before undergoing the procedure of abortion. This is a problem because many of the girls who become pregnant become fearful and attempt suicide, run away, or they commit crimes, such as killing their new born. The law deprives teens of their rights and their privacy. In developing countries, as many…
- 833 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Abortion is never an easy decision, in fact its one of America's most controversial issues in today's reality, but women have none the less been making that choice for thousands of years. Studies show that about 43% of American women will have one or more abortions during their lifetime, and women's centers and hospitals perform more than a million abortions on an annual basis. Women have many reasons for not wanting to be pregnant including age, marital status, economic status, and the circumstances of their pregnancy, and thus seek out an abortion. Although many citizens view abortion as an immoral act of brutality and strongly contest its usage, others believe the choice belongs solely to the mother and the mother alone.…
- 1055 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
they have not yet experienced that certain part of life that helps all adolescents become adults.…
- 816 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
home, a child creates a bond with a family member that is inseparable. Then one day because…
- 1060 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Significantly, some of these problems that relates to abortion are ethical, and religion. However, a woman has right to do whatever she want to her own body and upon her own judgment, whether it is to keep the baby or to have an abortion. In Fact, a woman has the authority to make the decision whether to have an abortion or not based on her personal desire, financial status, or unwanted pregnancy. Kenny, Ph.D. and Swope (2013) have provided information regarding the circumstances and how abortion can affect a woman mental state of mind. Most important is to deny a fetus by terminate the fetus merely does not mean that the person is slaughter a person. It could be that the pregnancy was an unplanned pregnancy from rape, incest, or the feeling of not wanting to bring a child in the world under certain circumstances. An example would be a medical condition that may be a live or dead situation or simply because she not ready for motherhood because of her age. For instant, a teenage girl between the age of 14 and 20 still in high school and going to college and who is struggling with finances are liable to have an abortion. She may become…
- 419 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
The average age at the time during the abortion was 21 years old. Out of all the women, 45% of them said they were not satisfied with the decision they had made at the time. 95% are not satisfied with their choice they’ve made now. 84% surveyed felt their decision was not well thought out. These results show the regret these people had when the chose to go down the decision route. Most felt they would have kept the baby had they known what they know now. A lot of the women felt unprepared about the abortions and the alternative routes they could have taken. Women are unsure about their decisions before and after the…
- 495 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Abortion might effect the future life of a women regarding relationships. A study by Jones, Finer and Singh (2008) shows that “33% of all abortions by women aged between 20-24”, and 25% of them cannot conceive a child after the abortion. This changes a women’s life. Because of something irresponsible she did while she was young, many people will see this as a disadvantage. She won’t be able to get married; therefore the inability to bear a child has many issues that would hurt her chances of having a relationship or children.…
- 717 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays