Preview

Harrop's Argument Analysis

Satisfactory Essays
Open Document
Open Document
314 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Harrop's Argument Analysis
Nice job! Your responses are fantastic and well-thought out—they aided me in following along with your thought process.
I didn’t read many responses which stated that “stacking deck” was a form of logical fallacy that Harrop included in her essay, so reading about it was a unique view—I didn’t really see it in the essay until I read your response! It’s excessively common for advertisers or political candidates to argue using only data supporting their side of the argument. Though it may see as if doing so would make one’s argument more effective, it only weakens the argument. As you mentioned, including a counterargument in her essay would have made Harrop’s argument would further its effectiveness because it would help the reader understand

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Anderson and Graff have an argument about setting battle room scenarios unfair or not. Ender is placed in the Rat Army. The commander, Rose De Nose, immediately hates Ender and warns Ender to stop practicing with the Launchies. Ender sees Dink, (Ender is assigned to Dink’’s platoon) as a kind soul,but is suspicious sometimes because of Dink’s actions. Ender and Dink talk one day and Ender finds out that Dink was promoted twice, but refused to be commander because he didn’t believe in school. Dink says the real enemy is the teacher, not the students. Dink doesn’t want the adults to ruin his childhood and life. Dink tells Ender that he thinks the Buggers have vanished and the school is running to keep the I.F. in charge. Ender doesn’t believe…

    • 229 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The author employs sufficient sources and data to support her claim. Miller cites from various and professional organizations to strengthen her argument. For example, Miller utilizes a study done by Bettina Hoeppner from Harvard to illustrate the discrepancy of alcohol consumption between men and women. Miller often refers to NIAAA for her argument and uses the data from NIAAA as a baseline for excess alcohol consumption. Miller also seems to favor one specific intervention program, the BASICS program, that helps to prevent and decrease dangerous drinking activities among teens and young adults.…

    • 92 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Two separate arguments take place: the old vs the present, and then the present vs the new. The old is denounced with statements such as “those times have passed” (Tolstoy & Katz 137) and “What barbarous views of women and marriage!” (Tolstoy & Katz 139). Then Pozdnyshev jumps into the aftermath of this first argument and shakes them all up with his statement about how love is always temporary: “this preference for one [person] may last for years…more often for months, or perhaps for weeks, days, or hours” (Tolstoy & Katz 140). Pozdnyshev is portrayed as winning this argument, as he is given the last…

    • 106 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    As stated in Lee Bollinger's article, "admissions policies do not meaningfully affect a white student's chances of admission" so there is no actual proof that affirmative action is reverse discrimination against whites. Also affirmative action does not demean individual accomplishment, but enhances it because according to Nell Irvin Painter "without affirmative action, it never would have occurred to any large, white research university to consider [her] for professional employment." So if anything, affirmative action helps individuals have more successful lives by providing people with better opportunities than they would otherwise have. I think that Lee Bollinger's argument is the strongest, since he provides concrete evidence and actual…

    • 129 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Carnegie has inspired women and men to use their funds to their communities. Although he advised other wealthy to use their money to benefit the communities and help in the preservation of the political system and America economy. I believe Mr. Carnegie’s argument is persuasive and is still relevant today. The wealthy, as well as small business owners, are the job creators in our society today. Their vision and leadership help to support the lower class in earning a decent living while allowing them to realize their own potential. The lower class today has more opportunities that were not available to them generations ago. While government is there to provide a safety net for those less fortunate, it is the wealthy and job creators that…

    • 128 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Dockterman builds up her argument before she even states her opinion. She goes into depth about the positive and negative to education and technology. The thing that she doesn’t do is state her opinion right away. So to me, she is continuing to keep the reader's attention by not stating her opinion. She asks questions that makes it seem like she’s going to state her opinion, but she still continues to build up each side. For example, “ So who’s right-- the mom trying to protect her kids from the perils of new technology or the dad who’s coaching his kids to embrace it”. With the question added in, she is impacting the audience because she is not just stating facts and statistics without some type of hook or catch. Dockterman backs up her reasons and claims with facts and statistics. “80% of U.S. school districts say they are on the cusp of incorporating Web-enabled tablets into everyday.” It will impact the audience’s thoughts because without the facts, the audience wouldn’t believe what the reader is trying to get across because it’s not…

    • 701 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Blinder begins his argument by describing how the labor market has changed over the past few decades. Today, a college degree is something that is considered necessary for getting a good and well-paying job. In contrast, thirty years ago, many jobs were filled with high school graduates or even high school dropouts. Blinder states that this shift is thought to be a main cause of income inequality, which means that now, the lower skilled and uneducated workers face a big disadvantage (441). During the 1990s, a few steps were taken to fix this problem, like raising the minimum wage. In this decade, there has been a push to send more kids to college and further educate them. As we look forward to the future, however, the issue is not with education…

    • 161 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    CYP 3.4 Evidence 1.4

    • 2532 Words
    • 9 Pages

    Formal observations may be carried out to support the teacher on assessing a pupil’s level of development such as a controlled assessment or a speaking and listening test.…

    • 2532 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Kimball Argument Analysis

    • 324 Words
    • 2 Pages

    I really enjoyed this article. It has been one of my favorites thus far. Kimball had many quality arguments and opinions on what needs to change within the church. His main point of this article is stated on page 86, "I believe true emerging churches must go deep within, and form the inside out, rethink. reshape, and revalue how we are about everything as culture changes. We must rethink leadership, church structure, the role of a pastor, spiritual formation, how community is lived out, how evangelism is done, how we express our worship, etc. It is not about what we do in the worship service, but about everything". I agree with Kimball that the Church still has a lot of growing to do, and trough that growing there must be some changes made along the way. Over the years we have lost our way, and need help guiding us back on the right path.…

    • 324 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Kabot-Zinn clarifies that it is only required to pay attention and see things as they are in order to activate awareness, it does not require alteration. An attitude that can determine if awareness is activated is non-striving. When we just simply observe our thinking process and sensations rather than criticizing ourselves, we are allowing these things that we experience to be here in the present moment with us. Criticisms would only stimulate more negative thoughts and emotions. Moreover, our minds are always filled with thoughts we can’t explain, words we can’t say, and emotions we can’t express. But as Thich Nhat Hanh expressed, if we “mindfully observe, we’ll be able to see and understand.” Through the process of seeing and understanding, we will be able to escape from these thought’s we couldn’t seem to explain before, words we couldn’t say before, and emotions we couldn’t express before, and explore our true desires.…

    • 1037 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    In reality, people are able to be ethically responsible instantaneously at hand through their capability in doing so. People act ethically responsible when one is in need of assistance because their they let their sympathetic feelings of compassion take over their intentions. Ethical responsibility is a duty or obligation to ensure the individual’s well-being through specific commitments such as saving someone from tragedy. One piece of text that revolves around people having the capacity in demonstrating sudden acts of ethical responsibility is “Can the Law Make Us Be Decent” by Jay Sterling Silver. Though many may argue that Silver’s argument is invalid, most will agree that his argument is in fact agreeable because the emotions of one…

    • 1265 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    In February of 1968, H. J. McCloskey’s published an article called, “On Being an Atheist.” In this, he argues that atheism is a more comfortable, logical and realistic than theism. He mentions the evil that is in the world and how it doesn’t make any sense to find comfort in a God that purposely causes pain, disease and natural disasters. McCloskey also mentions it is unreasonable to live by faith in this world. In this article, he argues the three theistic proofs including, the argument for design, the teleological argument and the cosmological argument.…

    • 1490 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In 1787 our founding fathers created the Constitution of the United States. It took lots of compromising, convincing, but in the end they created a new form of government. One compromise was that the Constitution needed a list of rights that were given to American citizens and could never be changed. This list was called the Bill of Rights. The introductory statement to the Constitution was called the preamble. The preamble summarized everything the Constitution would be explaining the purpose of the Constitution and its guidelines.…

    • 557 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    It was truly my pleasure reading your article and I thank you for taking the time to read this.…

    • 310 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Thirdly, my gratitude goes to my dorm mate and best friends for their constrictive suggestions and comment, and to Henok, Yibeltal, and yohannes who provided me their computers for editing purpose.…

    • 12329 Words
    • 50 Pages
    Powerful Essays