Preview

How Did Erasmus Use Folly to Criticize the Catholic Church

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1347 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
How Did Erasmus Use Folly to Criticize the Catholic Church
How did Erasmus use “Folly” to criticize the Catholic Church of his Day?
It may seem odd or different to admire and acclaim Folly, but there is a definite benefit to foolishness: the freedom to tell only factual information. In Praise of Folly, Erasmus put this independence to good use in repeating to the readers, a civilization significantly besmirched by mature worries, that a person is unable to serve both God and Mammon. He leveled over his irony by promising us that "there is merit in being attacked by Folly" (7), and closed with the recap that "it's Folly and a woman who's been speaking" (134), a renunciation that permitted him to be as brutal as he desired to be in his condemnation. He definitely found necessity for severity, for the standards he saw at the center of Christianity, the sympathy and detriment of the Scriptures, were everywhere stunned by gluttony, drive, and fallacy. Having the disguise of Folly, Erasmus critiqued the developing middle-class financial values, policies of hierarchy, and even Catholicism itself, and in the course he safeguarded the traditional Christian ethic, which appears as Folly to the world. Obviously, the affection of Christ was distant from the princes of Christendom, having been substituted by egotism and exploitation. While Erasmus remained faithful to the Catholic Church, Erasmus observed many exploitations among her ministry, theologians, and untrained persons, and he dedicated a huge apportion of the Praise of Folly to disapproval of the sleaze in the Church. The sleaze of the clergy was similar to that of the princes, and like the princes their existences made ridicule of the "linen vestment, snow-white in colour to indicate a pure and spotless life" (107) and other symbols of the ideal Erasmus envisioned for the cardinals, bishops, and popes. Their greatest care was "netting their revenues into the bag" (107). The popes were biased by the fraud of "their wealth and honours, their

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    "I sin in envying his nobility;And were I any thing but what I am,I would wish me only he. Aufidis—Act 1 sc. 1 page 230…

    • 330 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The Catholic Church of the 16th century was perceived as being corrupt and unpopular due to its social hierarchy within its society of ordained men, and their abuse of power to take advantage of the laypeople and their strong faith to extort money out of them for their own greedy purposes. The sources A, B, C and D all depict this corruption in one form or another.…

    • 557 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    How did both John Calvin and Sebastian Castellio respond to Luther’s paradoxical skepticism? By asserting the supremacy of scripture while simultaneously advocating for the reliance and utilization of one’s consciousness and reason to fully understand and believe such scripture, Martin Luther triggered the Northern European quest for religious knowledge and Truth. John Calvin provided an additional element to Luther’s paradox—an inner persuasion, given to us by God, guiding us towards the true meaning of God’s word (Popkin 10). Calvin adopted Luther’s ideas regarding scripture’s supremacy yet amended and elaborated upon Luther’s stance on conscience and reason. In my opinion, Calvin’s addition of the notion of inner persuasion was an attempt…

    • 292 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Erasmus, Desiderius a humanist, criticized the deeds of the church such as monks blindly reciting prayers and the sale of indulgences. For example, when in the book it states” Erasmus, though his life and work, made clear that many loyal catholic’s wanted major reforms in the church long before the Reformation made them a reality”. This supports the fact that Erasmus criticizes the church with the sale of indulgences to citizens to repent for their sins. In addition, Erasmus also…

    • 435 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In his work Praise of Folly, Erasmus criticized the corrupt practices that were rampant in the church. Erasmus used humor to poke fun at the clergy’s abuses. He found it amusing that monks worked so hard following the church traditions only to break them at some point in time. For example, one of his monks had fasted so many times, but erased his hard works by revealing that “his fasts have always been broken by a single meal.” (Erasmus) This is one of the instances where the pretense of following church traditions made a complete mockery of church tradition. Erasmus outlined the fact that the monks insisted on following church doctrines carefully when they themselves aren’t even doing the same thing.…

    • 121 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    IDS 104 FINAL PAPER

    • 2448 Words
    • 10 Pages

    Voltaire goes after religious hypocrisy in chapter three of Candide. An orator asks Candide whether or not he supports “the good cause”. Candide, being a man of reason, responds by saying “there is no effect without a cause”. The orator, feeling challenged by Candide’s reaction challenges him right back by asking Candide if he believes the Pope to be the Anti-Christ. Candide doesn’t know and changes the subject bringing up the fact that he’s hungry. The orator declares that Candide does not deserve to eat because of his lack of affirmation toward believing in the Anti-Christ. The orator’s wife suddenly enters the scene and sees Candide as one who does not believe that the Pope was Anti-Christ. She proceeds to pour trash on his head. This is an example of Voltaire jabbing at Protestants and Catholics of the world. He is explaining his views, through the use of satire, on religion.…

    • 2448 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The text details how the Church had become corrupt and far too powerful. Popes, who were not supposed to be married or engage in sexual intercourse had mistresses and held parties devoted to sex. Pope Alexander VI, otherwise known as the Borgia pope, was rumored to even have had sex with his own daughter, Lucrezia, and had fathered a son with her. Nepotism, overspending, and indulgences were additional things the church was guilty of. To combat this, Erasmas and Luther both spoke against the corruption. The text…

    • 911 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    On the surface, Voltaire’s Candide seems to be about every stupidity, every transgression, and every immoral act conceivable to man. It is a satirical and absurd look at life and religion. It makes a mockery of organized religious institutions and leaders. The hypocrisy of the actions of these leaders makes the reader wonder if Voltaire is against every religious order and even God, or is it simply the hypocrisy he abhors. In examining this book, it is a satirical way of looking at the hypocrisy of actions while holding true that goodness outside of these institutions and inside the person is what is important and imperative. Voltaire seems to write this book as a rebuttal of the theory of Leibniz.…

    • 1196 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In the High Middle Ages of Europe, a particular argument over the appointment of churchmen turned into a general struggle for leadership in Christian society. During this time, Henry IV was emperor of Germany and Gregory VII was the Pope. The controversy between these men brought about many issues. In 1706, these issues are brought up in a long letter written by Henry IV. He addresses this letter to the Pope (Noble 250).…

    • 458 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In his work, Candide, Voltaire uses satire as a means of conveying his opinions about many aspects of European society in the eighteenth century, a period known as the Enlightenment. This Age of Reason swept through Europe, offering differing views on science, religion, and politics. The following essay will outline the philosophical theory of Pangloss, a character of the novel and suggest how his optimistic worldview is challenged by numerous disasters. I will also justify the reasons Voltaire attacks hypocrisy, most prevalent in religion, and displays the cruel actions of the priests, monks, and other religious leaders. In the novel his anger becomes obvious towards the church and the nobility. I will relate to findings how Voltaire expresses his views about society. His belief that the separation of class, hypocrisy of organized religion, rampant materialism, lack of Free Will, and deficiency of compassion for others, all contributed to the lack of human liberty in the eighteenth century.…

    • 1437 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    During Voltaire 's lifetime, traditional social institutions and government systems held power. Arguably the most influential of those was the Catholic Church, which was considered sacred and above the state in authority and importance. Although Voltaire was a deist, he despised the Church clergy for its corruption, impiousness, and hypocrisy. Having been sexually used by teachers while attending a Jesuit school, he harbored a special hatred towards the Jesuits. Yet his abhorrence of religion extended past Catholicism. Voltaire condemned Protestant clergy in much the same way as Catholic priests. Furthermore, although in theory Voltaire believed in religious equality, he held strongly anti-Semitic views, even calling Jews "abominable" in his Dictionary of Philosophy. Muslim clerics were described in much the same way. Clearly, Voltaire hated all religious institutions and customs. In his most satirical and important work, Candide, he incessantly mocks not only the Catholic Church, but also Protestants, Jews, and Muslims.…

    • 956 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Martin Luther Influence

    • 547 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Added to the criticisms of indulgences that the Church was practicing, Luther was also reflecting on the popular sentiments in regards to the “St. Peter’s scandal.” Luther was questioning why the pope, whose wealth by then was more than the wealth of the richest Crassus, end up building St. Peters Basilica with the money of poor believers rather than building it using his money. Luther, through his translation of Roman’s 3:28 understood that faith was the key to salvation, which was not fully in use by the Church during his days.…

    • 547 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Ogygius Vs Thomas

    • 747 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Considering that St. Thomas was very involved in helping the poor and even lived a life of desolate poverty, I thought that these men who portray themselves as being protectors of the physical relics and in turn religious beliefs of the saint are dishonoring his desires and beliefs. Furthermore, it was interesting that the men would have been kicked out of the church and severely condemned by the keeper and custodian if the archbishop had not recommended them. This suggests that there is an obvious differential treatment of the people who go to the church depending on their wealth and religious and political connections. This was very disheartening for me because I have always assumed and took comfort in the fact that every single person is equal in the eyes of God and therefore should be treated equally in the Church. Thus, Erasmus is perhaps again criticizing the differential treatment of worshipers by the church in accordance with their economic or political…

    • 747 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The baroque era faced a significant amount of resistance in the domains of religion, politics, and society in general. The Catholic Church faced a lot of criticism from Protestants, fueled by Martin Luther. His critique was focused on the greed and abuse of power portrayed by the church. Rome was referred to as ‘the whore of Babylon’ because of the expensive art, extravagant banquets and grand architecture present in the church. In its defense, the Catholic Church responded by addressing the issues from corruption from within and defended the doctrines that Protestants were against.…

    • 267 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    I do not believe that when Erasmus speaks of how to read the Bible that is talking in the same way that Luther promotes sola Scriptura. This is because sola Scriptura means through scripture alone, thus all biblical knowledge comes from the Bible. Erasmus on the other hand promotes dedication to the study of the Bible, but also suggests reading other written works whether from pagans or philosophers. He says, “You should not refuse food advice from anyone, not even a pagan. The pagan authors sharpen your mind, and will help you understand scripture, which takes preparation. The Bible is not very fruitful if you stick only to the simplest literal sense of it, you need to understand the allegorical sense as well, in which the pagan poets will…

    • 408 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays