DEPT: ENGLISH LANGUAGE
PROGRAMME: M.A ENGLISH LITERATURE (PART TIME)
SESSION: 2011/2012
SEMINER TOPIC: TO WHAT EXTENT THE IAN MCDONALD’S THE HUMMING BIRD TREE REFLECT WEST INDIAN IDENTITY ISSUES.
Introduction
The western Indian literature has gradually gained prominence over the years. What we have today is corpus experiences of a group of people known as the west Indians which comprises of a group of island such as Trindad and Tobago, Jamaica, Antigua and Barbados.Generally, Literature is majorly concerned with mirroring the experiences of individuals and the communal experience of a group of people. It tells the story and it is important to appreciate the place of the story in human history, it is the story that remains long after the we are gone. On the power of the story Achebe submits that: So why do I say that the story is chief among his fellows? …….because it is only the story that can continue beyond the war and the warrior. It is the story that outlives the sound of war drums and the exploits of brave fighters. It is the story, not the others that saves our progeny from blundering like blind beggars Into spikes of the cactus fence. The story is our escort, without it we are blind
Indeed the power of the story is captured in the western Indian literature as her writers poignantly tell the story of a history that is riddled with cruelty, callousness, enforced labor and suppression. This was brought about by the European colonization of the region and consequently it played a major role in defining the themes of alienation, exile, survival and identity formation for the West Indian people in their literary works.
Perhaps the most pressing concern for the West Indian writer is the struggle for self-identity, it is a major concern in west Indian literature as these writers continue to battle to establish a feeling of identity in there works. Thus, a reading of the west Indian Literature leaves one with a feeling the western Indian people are plagued with a feeling of rootlessness as they are in a continues state of cultural limbo. They felt themselves to be caught off from their ancestral roots and thrust into an European culture they do not understand. Hence, Self-identity becomes a major preoccupation of the West Indian writers, Nobel laureate, poet and dramatist Derek Walcott, laments in his poem “Laventile” that slavery exiled the west Indian from his root and his very sense of self.
It is against this milieu that this essay will attempt to explore the extent to which Ian McDonald’s The Humming Bird Tree reflects West Indian Identity issues. We shall also concern ourselves with the themes, and characterization to further appreciate the invaluable role identity plays in
Biography
Ian McDoanld was born on April 18, 1933.He is a Caribbean born writer who is a Trinidadian by birth and Guyanese by adoption. He has also described himself as Antiguan by ancestry.
He revived his secondary school education at Queen Royal college(1942-1951) in port of Spain, he attended clare college and Cambridge University where he was awarded a B.A degree in History and later received his M.A. He was elected president of the Cambridge University of west Indian society. He came to British Guyana in 1955. He has lived and worked in Guyana ever since.
His novel The Humming bird tree was first published by Heinemann in 1969 when it won the Winifred Holby memorial prize from the royal society of literature for the best regional novel. It was made into a film by BBC broadcast in 1992.McDonald has also written short stories and poem some of which have appeared in anthologies. He has been a fellow of the Royal society of Literature (FRSL).Some of the works include The Tramping Man(play).
Setting
The novel is set in post-colonial Trinidad in the earlier half of the nineteenth century. It focuses on an East Indian novel that captures the racial prejudice between the whites and the people of colour,
Synopsis
Ian McDonald The Humming Bird tree is a poignant emotional story of a grown up boy Alan who recollects his growing up days in Trindard.The story centers on a warm friendship he shares but eventually falls apart due to racial prejudice cast upon them by society. As a young boy he hore worship Kaiser who is an older boy but a servant in his father’s mansion and also falls love with Kaiser’s younger sister who is equally a servant. The three spend many memorable hours together in the village river and at a cockfight. But what always cast a shadow on their friendship is his parent disapproval. His mother continually reminds him that he is from a different class and encourages him to play with his fellow white children. On his birthday, his parents do not invite Kaiser and they stand at the door to watch. His whites friend insult and Alan succumbs to peer pressure and joins in insulting them too.
But, Kaiser and Jaillin are trained to accept their place and the friendship is quickly repaired. However the break in their friendship comes when Kaiser and Jaillin are fired after Alan and Jaillin are caught skinny dipping together. Alan experiences no real heartbreak over it until years later when he is able to value the friendship he lost. By this time the gap which seemed great as a child is now a huge chasm. While Kaiser has forgives him because he has always understood that the gap between them him, Jaillin does not, perhaps because she expected him to have the strength of character to acknowledge their love. She therefore grows up hating whites.
Identity Issues in The Humming Bird Tree
History has described the west indian people as being an accident of history to some extent.After the Island was discovered by Christopher Columbous, the European conquest came , but they found the indigenes too physically weak to work on the plantation. They turned thier attention to Africa exploiting the world territories to there own economic advantage. Hence we have the notorious atlantic slave trade where an estimated 50M were sold into slavery and transported across the atlantic ocean. Mnay slaves died underway others committed sucide, thos who survived found themselves in a starnge land bereft of family and friends in a stange lange with different religion nad history.All the thing the thing which go into forging an identity were stripped away from these slaves.Slaves of a particular tribe were deliberately separated so were families, this was doen to preven the formation of group and alliances.After the emancipation of slavery in 1933, the black population were reluctant to contine work on the plantion which reminded them of the slavery and pain.Th eindians where shipped in and forced into forced labour, They were need to plant sugar cane.Colonialsm has been described a sbeing damaging degrading and inhumannot only from the economic angle but from the psychological angle.It rips the colonized of his self respect and makes them see themselves as inferior .The white man is given a demigod status .The direct implication of this is that the colonized tend to copy the whites man culture and mannerism which he has been subconsciously brainwashed to think that it is better.But the irony is that while they discarded their culture and sought to embrace the white mans ,it was still beyond there reach. The result was naturally the growth of extreme frustration and a deep feeling of alienation coupled with identity crises , because it is almost immposible to feel at home and develop roots under such conditions.
Hence it is therefore natural that literature that emmate form the west indian region will be preoccupied with identity issuesThe Oxford Dictionary of English language defines Identity as. the fact of being who or what a person or thing is. the characteristics determining who or what a person or thing
Therefore identiy issues in the Humming bird tree means the problem or challenges that is associated with knowing or defining who the west indian is and also the challenge they have to grapple with in defining their identity.
Eric Dane the former prime minister of India has commented that a commodity so sweet as sugar could cause so much bitterness in the human heart.
Hence west indian writers have taken it upon themselves to lead the struggle for identity in their works
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
In this book the author Tim O' Brien uses many different little stories to sum of the big picture of war. He focuses in on many different characters, stories, and their specific feelings to help the reader get an actual feel of what he felt. Which he states on pg. 171 " I want you to feel what I felt. I want you to know why story-truth is truer than happening-truth". While O' Briens main connection to the title focus's in on what each soldier physically carried, deeper than that is the soldiers own feelings, doubts, and fears.…
- 1307 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
The silence is not about hate or pain or fear.” This illustrates how the protagonist wants to demonstrate to the White society that Indians can be successful by living in the modern world and working in it but always keeping his Indian values and traditions. Additionally, the protagonist gives tribute to his family and community by showing that Indians can succeed and coexist with the White society proving he is very mature. In conclusion, the character assigns meaning to life by paying tribute to his Indian community and demonstrating to different societies that Indians can be very successful and can coexist with the White society, leaving behind remorse.…
- 1136 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
War affects all of us, even those not directly involved. Although both “For 7515-03296” and “Army of Music” have their suffering based on the same war and similar situations, the type of suffering portrayed is based on two different (but not opposite) tones. These tones dictate to whom the characters’ emotions are directed.…
- 766 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Ganson, Barbara. Like children under wise parental sway: passive portrayals of the Guarani Indians in European literature and The Mission. 1994.…
- 1533 Words
- 7 Pages
Powerful Essays -
While conducting the research for this paper, I reviewed a total of five books. The first was our current textbook, The Norton Anthology of World Literature, Volume A. I naturally used this textbook since it was readily available and in my personal library.…
- 1961 Words
- 8 Pages
Powerful Essays -
“But the thing about remembering is that you don't forget.” -Tim Obrien, Tim can never forgot the man he killed he constantly retells his traumatic event vivid dark bloody detail. Tim shows a connection to the man he killed. A moment he will forever carry with him...A war story is about re telling the past the heroic events the past the bravery the solders faced during there battles and tragic experiences that show maybe there was a reason we were there. Maybe we really did help them. Even through all the losses you know that you fellow solders did not die in vein the body you share with every one in your squad. Tim O’Brien shows this the way he felt when kert lemon died. Every one Tim saw died he gave them respect on could vividly describe what truly happened “Let the story tell itself.” Stories tell them selves you don’t listen to a story you relive the past. “By telling stories, you objectify your own experiences. You separate it from yourself. You pin down certain truths. You make up others.” in a story and in war there’s all ways some loose ends that have to be taken care…
- 772 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
True war stories are not about war. So tells us Tim O’Brien, a master in the art of war stories. What they are about is life, love, family, loss, grief, and…
- 720 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
6) Paranjpe, A.C. (1998). Self and identity in modern psychology and Indian thought. New York: PlenumPress.…
- 1157 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
2. Why did the author decide to study ‘Indigenous Writing’, and how did he feel about studying the course? 2-3…
- 2557 Words
- 11 Pages
Powerful Essays -
The stories of history that we often make are formed from uninterested facts that seem cold and heartless. That are molded into epic dramas that show humanity of an event creating a martyr capable of rallying tired spirits and strengthening broken resolve of those under siege by an unrelenting enemy These stories are meant to teach lessons, but often have little based in fact. As legends are required to rally nations not just simple recounts of an event. It is the legend that makes an event significant. A legend can be change to appeal to its audience. Facts however, are stone unable to be shaped. As they lack the appropriate pathos to move the stubborn hearts and minds of many. One such story that became legend…
- 552 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Jean Rhys (1894-1979) a West Indian writer. Discuss how Rhys' style and thematic concerns in this passage are reflective of the period studied.…
- 343 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
War stories is not what everybody believe it to be about. O'Brien offers abstract commentary on storytelling. He also blurs the divisions between what is real and what is not real and author .In the story O’Brien states, “A true war story is never moral. It does not instruct, nor encourage virtue, nor suggest models of proper human behavior, nor have restrain men from doing the things men always done (790)”. Being in wore changes the man that fight them.…
- 456 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
War has both advanced and extinguished civilizations throughout history, it has been present for as long as humans have been around to partake. Whether it is merely in our nature to fight, or civilizations are destined to clash due to cultural differences is a mystery. Without warfare the world today would be a drastically different place- many would argue that a utopia would result. War not only affects those whose lives are in danger, but also the entire nation as families lose members. A veteran of any war has most likely lost somebody they cared about in battle, and have been changed by the experience. Commonly, veterans of war have many stories to share about their experiences abroad. Waltz with Bashir is an animated documentary created by Ari Folman, an Israeli veteran who did his military service during the 1982 Israeli incursion into Lebanon. The film is composed of interviews between Folman and his comrades from the war; he is unable to recollect anything that took place during his service. In Ari Folman’s film Waltz with Bashir it is evident that by witnessing traumatic events he has blocked out a considerable amount of time from memory, and must determine the role he played in such events to feel at peace with himself. Author Tim O’Brien’s narrative, “How to Tell a True War Story”, and Amy Taubin’s article “Drawn from Memory”, provide insight into the relationship between witnessing something scarring and its long-term effect on memory.…
- 285 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Humans are complex entities whose identities are formed through multitudes of experience and relationships.Peoplewere born with connections,connections with people and places, the contrasting in appearance, language suddenly stand out in the foreign country which makes them struggle to fit in or feel welcomed, no one is able to live a life completely alone, the natural instincts of living in a community makes them willing to sacrifice anything to achieve the expectations of the people around them.In Alice Pung’s anthology Growing up Asians in Australia, the narrator Sunil Badami reflects his identity crisis in Sticks and Stones and Such-like. “Neil seemed to fit their mouths better, and I could feel their approval at the effort I was making to fit in.”Sunil abandoned his name which is seen as his identity of being an Indian rather than an Australian. It clearly showed that people are willing to sacrifice anything even their name to make them to be more similar to the people around them. Because differences in individuals is breeding ground for discrimination, which would easily make people to be isolated and bullied. Therefore, people would do anything to achieve the acceptances from the others not just for the sense of belonging but in order to protect themselves.…
- 300 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
In the essay, A Father, by Bharati Mukherjee, the author has three main characters each is caught between the Indian and American cultures. The Bhowmick family, which includes the father, the mother, and their daughter, are all experiencing the constant pull of Indian and American identities.…
- 256 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays