Preview

In Vitro Fertilization And Surrogacy Essay

Satisfactory Essays
Open Document
Open Document
321 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
In Vitro Fertilization And Surrogacy Essay
There are many women in the United States that are incapable of giving birth. They rely on advances in science to produce an offspring. In Chapter 4 of the Bioethics book, Munson examines cases of in vitro fertilization (IVF) and surrogacy utilization to illustrate their benefits and risks and allow readers to analyze the ethicality of limiting their use. One significant example of IVF usage was the story of “Octomom.” This woman wanted many children so she requested to be implanted with 6 embryos and gave birth to 8 children. The children lived, nevertheless, by not terminating any of the embryos, the mother risked their lives. A multiple pregnancy increases the risk of miscarriage, prematurity, and cerebral palsy. Despite these risks, because the mother desired these children and the IVF allowed her to attain happiness, there are many who support its uncontrolled use. …show more content…
This is more complex than IVF, but gives women a more natural method of producing a child. As many as 5 people can be involved in a surrogate’s pregnancy. Because of this, there are many people who do not believe that surrogacy is ethical. There can be confusion of who the genuine parents of the child are. An example is with baby M’s case. Her birth mother was a surrogate who decided to keep her and took her away from her birth father and his wife. When baby M was found, there was confusion over which family she belonged with. IVF and surrogacy give women who cannot give birth options to produce their own children. However, regardless of their benefits, there are more risks involved than there is in a natural birth. In chapter 4, benefits and risks of IVF and surrogacy are weighed and the extent that the usage of these methods should be limited is called into

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    References: Aronson, D. D., & Matthews, M. (1999, February 8). Symposium: Should health insurers be forced to pay for infertility treatments? Insight on the News, 15(5), 24-27.…

    • 2962 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    A new ethical discussion is emerging in the oncology world due to overwhelming advances in fertility preservation in all age groups. The journal article “The Ethics of Fertility Preservation for Paediatric Cancer Patients: From Offer to Rebuttable Presumption” addresses the pressing need to discuss the ethics of failing to preserve fertility as this current practice may no longer be considered ethically appropriate for populations for whom established techniques are available. The current standard practice involves merely offering the option of fertility preservation procedures to children and young adults with cancer. Previous ethical discussions of fertility preservation have focused on the question of whether it is appropriate to perform fertility preservation procedures for a particular patient. The question at the heart of this article suggests the new discussion needs to address the question, “is failing to proceed with fertility preservation ethically justifiable?’” (McDougall 2015). The article gives some…

    • 982 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Surrogate parenting is a process where an arrangement is made and an individual who is not a parent is given the parental rights, duties and the responsibility of parenthood either it is court pointed or voluntary. Another example on the more scientific level, an infertile couple can pay another woman who agrees to carry the baby for the infertile woman (couple) through artificial insemination. (Medical Encyclopedia, 2013). The ethical dilemmas surrounding parenting involves several parties, the surrogate, the intending family as well as the child. Some of the dilemmas from the surrogate are is she going to be able to let the child go once it is delivered, after taking the pain of carrying and delivering the child not to mention the stress that comes with it. The dilemmas on the intending family can be questions as, is the surrogate able to carry the child to full term, is she going to change her mind by trying to keep the child, is the child truly theirs since another person carried it, are they going to disclose this information to the child one day?…

    • 1281 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Most people would go the religious way and say that if you can’t have children, then you shouldn’t because God has a different path for you. They could even argue about the cost of IVF. In the time and money you put into the treatment you could’ve gone and adopted a child. IVF is incredibly expense and to pay for it isn’t possible for most Americans. Some insurance companies won’t cover the procedure because of the amount of loopholes in laws that let them off and hurt the public. Many parents that go through this with their children could end up with birth defects. Many scientific studies show that there are more birth defects in children who are born from IVF than normal babies. The birth defects range anywhere from cardiac defects, to cleft lip, to gastrointestinal defects, to cancer of the eye. Even though IVF can help people have children there are many risks. The mother could have the baby prematurely or a low birth weight. The mother could also end up with ovarian hyper stimulation syndrome. This is when the ovaries become swollen and painful; it could lead to rapid weight gain and shortness of breath. It could also lead to a miscarriage, many birth defects, ovarian cancer, and more (Mayo Clinic Staff).…

    • 846 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Recent evidence by Stanford University has shown that a surrogate’s womb may act as more than just a home for a fetus, in fact, the womb may effects how a child’s genes will be programmed (Moss and Baden). If this study is correct it would suggest that surrogacy may be more than just a service. Additionally, this evidence would change the role of a surrogate to lean farther away from a service provider, and closer to selling a child with whom a surrogate has genetic ties too. Studies like these have amplified anti-surrogacy arguments like those of Barba Rothman. In her article, “On Surrogacy” Rothman rejects the idea that, “a woman can be pregnant with someone else’s baby… it reduces a woman to a container.” Furthermore, Rothman insists that surrogacy is baby-selling.…

    • 1113 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    One of the major drawbacks of the procedure is the risk of multiple pregnancies. This stems from the transfer of more than one embryo. Although the chances of pregnancy increase, so do the risk of multiple pregnancies that often lead to unhealthy infants (Van Voorhis 382). Another risk is a child with birth defects. According to several studies, cardiovascular and musculoskeletal birth defects occur more frequently among the infants conceived through IVF than among the naturally conceived ones (Van Voorhis 383). There are also several potential health hazards for a female. They include infections, allergic reactions, complications during birth, and others. Finally, there have been some claims that IVF infants are more vulnerable to genetic and developmental illnesses (Mahmoud, Punukollu, and Mahmood). However, those statements are not backed by scientific researches. Apart from medical aspects, the usage of IVF has been a topic of major disputes. The public acceptance has considerably increased since 1980s. Nonetheless, the term “test-tube baby” associated with IVF conceived infants has not lost its negative connotation yet (Brian). Consequently, a couple should carefully weigh the benefits and risks before turning to this…

    • 622 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Cafs

    • 728 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Surrogate motherhood raises difficult ethical, philosophical and social issues. There is debate in the community as to the wisdom of surrogacy arrangements. There is scope for disagreement as to the morality of aspects of such reviews the arrangements. This Chapter reviews the arguments for and against surrogacy, including the moral bases for making judgements about surrogacy. In raising these issues the Commission is seeking guidance on community attitudes to assist in formulating principles on can he made.…

    • 728 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Essay On Infertility

    • 378 Words
    • 2 Pages

    There are few cases where the conventional options cannot be used for having a baby. In such cases, couples can solicit the assistance of a third party to provide sperm, egg or carry a child for them. This is termed as ‘surrogacy.’ Women without uterus or with uterine diseases or with hysterectomy done can choose surrogacy for having a…

    • 378 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Surrogacy today involves a woman who carries and gives birth to an infant for another couple, who usually is infertile; however, recently more non-traditional couples like those who are same sex, are also utilizing this process to complete their families. This pregnancy is established by way of a pre-arranged legal contract. The idea is that the woman will carry the child throughout the duration of the pregnancy and then upon birth, relinquish all parental rights. The whole process is a miracle in itself. The very fact that couples have another option to adoption including the ability to use their own biological material for conception is truly remarkable. “Scientific advances and increasing social acceptance for non-traditional methods of family formation have made surrogacy both possible and more popular.” With society on board Just ask couple’s who have tried to conceive or same sex couples that now hold babies in their arms, how life changing this process is. It has been established that for this process to work, you must have an alternative womb. So where do surrogates come from? Many states have laws that prohibit surrogacy or make the whole process so difficult that many…

    • 1457 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Henig (2004), a poll in 1969 showed that about 50% of American adults believed that IVF was against God’s will and would encourage proximity. Louise brown therefore served as a proof that the process of IVF could indeed produce healthy children and an estimate of 1 million babies have been conceived using the IVF method. Although widely accepted, religious protesters still see the process as ‘playing God’ and should not be thought of as a means of conception. Some also believe that producing children artificially could also lead to some deficiencies in the children and they might be more prone to diseases or might not be as mentally stable as naturally conceived children. A study was conducted by Ceelen.M (et al, 2007) to investigate the difference between IVF children and naturally born children. The results stated that IVF children have a defective body fat composition although it was also said that more research was needed in order to arrive at a valid conclusion. Despite the concerns, the IVF process has become an alternative most people now agree on and the number of artificially conceived children is rising steadily even though the success rates of IVF conception is far less than what is…

    • 1024 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Surrogacy In Canada

    • 417 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Surrogacy in Canada is a legal alternative for those who have had difficulty creating a family on their own. Recent media report (Staff Reporter’s 2011, Toronto Star 2011) has reported a case that a 20 year-old girl poses with the twin boy and girl she delivered June 28. After agreeing to be a surrogate mother for an infertile British couple, She was left with the babies when they split up. It has raised concerns among the public about potential problems associated with the use of Assisted Human Reproduction. Further, there are some ethicists believe that surrogate mothers are cold and uncaring because they are unattached from…

    • 417 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The Ethics of Surrogacy

    • 2400 Words
    • 10 Pages

    There is controversy surrounding the concept of surrogacy in the United States. There is nothing in federal legislature the addresses the issue directly. Different States have different laws concerning surrogacy. Some forbid it and some enforce surrogacy contracts in court. Finding a surrogate mother, for some is their last chance to have a child that is biologically their own. There are people that believe that surrogacy is morally wrong for several reasons. I believe that if it is done properly then it can be a blessing for a family that would not have been able to have their own children, otherwise.…

    • 2400 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Surrogacy has been attacked in many different ways, but a majority of arguments against surrogacy have to do with harm to the surrogate or the children, and the exploitation of women who are poor and vulnerable in some way. Surrogate motherhood has been labeled by its opponents as reproductive…

    • 405 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The number of children conceived through in vitro fertilization has doubled over the last decade. The technology that has made these children possible has also challenged inheritance laws, especially in circumstances when a child is conceived after the death of a parent.…

    • 306 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Surrogacy

    • 1268 Words
    • 6 Pages

    With commercial surrogacy not being a topic talked about much in the United States but is in other countries such as India. Many people think that commercial surrogacy is demeaning to women. Nancy says, “To respect a person is to treat her in accordance with principles she rationally accepts—principles consistent with protection of her autonomy interests” (149). In other words we should respect women who make the rational decision in their own lives to become a surrogate mother. She goes on to say “To treat a person with consideration is to respond with sensitivity to her and to her emotional relations with others, refraining from manipulating or denigrating these for one`s own person” (149 & 150). We should respect the emotions that come with surrogacy and not manipulate anyone in to becoming one if they don’t rationally chose it for themselves or pay them less because of where they come from. Women aren’t allowed to have any say in the whole birthing plan along with not being able to have a mother-child relationship. Debra Satz disagrees with the idea that connecting female reproduction and profit, alienates women from beauty and power of pregnancy. Commercial surrogacy is a demeaning to women, if there isn’t a change on what happens during the pregnancy, such as whether or not the surrogate mother has an option on how she gives birth, the prenatal vitamins she takes, or even the food she consumes while pregnant, fewer women will become less willing to become a surrogate.…

    • 1268 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays