Preview

Lumpkin vs. Mellow Mushroom Casebrief

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
628 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Lumpkin vs. Mellow Mushroom Casebrief
Case Brief for Lumpkin v. Mellow Mushroom

Case Brief: Lumpkin v. Mellow Mushroom

Case Name, Citation & Court:
Lumpkin v. Mellow Mushroom, 256 Ga. App. 83, 567 S.E.2d 728, Court of Appeals of Georgia, decided 2002.
Parties & Procedural History:
Trial Court Level: Plaintiff Lumpkin sues Defendant Mellow Mushroom. Defendant filed summary judgment motion, and court granted judgment in favor of Defendant. Plaintiff appealed.
First Appeal: Ga. Court of Appeals affirmed judgment for Defendant.
Facts:
Mellow Mushroom is an establishment that is known for serving beer to underage patrons. On June 7, 2000, Christian sat at Mellow Mushroom’s bar and drank an undisclosed amount of beer. Several witnesses who had seen him that night reported that Christian Lumpkin did not appear to be drunk while others stated that he might have been “mildly” intoxicated. Lumpkin left Mellow Mushroom at approximately 12:30 a.m. and drove to Seth Calloway’s house. Once there, Lumpkin and Calloway decided to buy some beer and visit another friend. They went to the store in Calloway’s Jeep, which does not have a passenger side door. Calloway drove while Lumpkin sat on the passenger seat. During the drive to their friend’s house, Lumpkin unbuckled his seat belt and began hanging out of the Jeep. At some point, Lumpkin lost his grip and fell out of the car. He was taken to the hospital and later died from his injuries. Lumpkin’s parents are suing Mellow Mushroom.
Plaintiff’s Cause of Action:
Negligence
Issue:
The issue is whether an establishment, which serves alcohol to underage patrons, is liable for injuries or damages resulting from the intoxication of the underage patron.
Defendant’s Argument:
Mellow Mushroom is not responsible for the injury and death caused by the intoxication of the underage patron. The Lumpkins cannot prove that Mellow Mushroom’s breach proximately caused Christian Lumpkin’s death. The common law rule creates no cause of action

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    The background of this lawsuit is based on Debbie White suing Patrick Gibbs and his Tavern for the death of her husband . The reason why Debbie wants the bar to be held responsible is due to the fact that Mr. Edward Hard left intoxicated and crashed into Mrs. White 's car and killed her husband . The Gibbs feel his bar shouldn’t be held responsible due to the fact that the bartender didn’t see Mr. Hard intoxicated. Mr. Hard was also an ex-boyfriend of Debbie 's and the bar feels that the accident was intentional. Mr. Gibbs wants the court to dismiss the case based on summary judgment which is “a judgment requested by any party to a civil action to end the action when it is believed that there is no genuine issue or material fact in dispute” (Mosby’s Dictionary).…

    • 1293 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    legal studies

    • 1169 Words
    • 4 Pages

    While Roberts is the manager of Tyler's Sports Bar & Grill and is in charge of operation, both Roberts and Jones are general partners for the business. "Three rules for liability in a partnership are: 1) Every partner is liable for his or her own actions. 2) Every partner is liable for the actions of the other partners. 3) Every partner is liable for the actions of the employees of the business" (QuickMBA, 3). The rules of a partnership state that if one partner breaks a law, the other one is responsible for that as well. The issue that Roberts and Jones are faced with is liquor liability. "The cash bar provider is responsible for all activities, including age verification and addressing intoxicated guests. The cash bar provider assumes virtually all alcohol-related liability" (Caudle, 2). For Davidson to be able to reach a blood alcohol level of .16 he would have been visibly intoxicated. Roberts' and his employees continued to serve Davidson although the risks were visible. Davidson then left the business intoxicated and involved himself in an accident. This leaves both Joe Roberts and Dr. Donald Jones responsible for the actions of Dan Davidson as a third party. "Section 47 P.S. 4-497 provides as…

    • 1169 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Dram Shop Laws

    • 1132 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Dram shop laws are instituted for all places which serve alcoholic beverages including restaurants, taverns and bars. An employee of these establishments may not serve alcohol to minors or those ‘visibly intoxicated’. If the person which consumed the beverage leaves the establishment, gets in an accident or causes bodily harm to another person, the establishment and the server may be held liable for damages. However, this should not be the case. Those who were intoxicated and caused the accident should be the only ones held liable for damages he or she caused to another person. Too many people take advantage of the legal proponent which allows these places which serve alcohol to be held liable.…

    • 1132 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    ginas essay

    • 561 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The dram shop act in Massachusetts states that a business can be held liable if someone underage is over served alcohol and that person then commits an assault and battery or any other violent crime against another person. Technically though the person appeared to be 21 to the server and restaurant so they should not…

    • 561 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Dram Shop Laws

    • 709 Words
    • 3 Pages

    We struggle with the dilemma of morality when it comes to drinking liquor because in most religions it is looked down upon or considered a sin to imbibe alcohol for personal pleasure. Religion aside, liquor is a part of our culture. Since this is so, many states also passed dram shop acts, under which a tavern owner or bartender may be held liable for injuries caused by a person who became intoxicated when served by the bartender. Some states’ statutes also impose liability on social hosts, persons holding a party, for injuries caused by guests who became intoxicated at the hosts’ homes. Under these statutes, it is unnecessary to prove that the tavern owner, bartender or social host was negligent. (Cross, Frank B. and Roger LeRoy Miller. The Legal Environment of Business: Text and Cases. 7th ed. 2009, South-Western, Cengage Learning, Ohio. p. 312)…

    • 709 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    perception of law

    • 464 Words
    • 2 Pages

    1a.) Missouri House Bill HB 2081 establishes “Laura's Law” which specifies that any social host who furnishes a minor with intoxicating liquor found to be a contributing cause of resulting permanent personal injuries or death will be guilty of a class D felony. This law changes the dynamics of any old law (alcohol-related traffic offenses, with penalty provisions) by holding a person who has control over the consumption of alcohol by a minor is now referred to as the “social host”. The social host (parent, guardian, or other adult) who has exclusive use and enjoyment of any property, (licensed retailer, club, drinking establishment, or caterer or holds a temporary permit, or an employee thereof; selling the intoxicating liquor to the minor with reasonable cause to believe that the minor was twenty-one or more years of age; and to purchase the intoxicating liquor, the person exhibited a driver's license, Missouri non-driver's identification card, or other official or apparently official document, containing a photograph of the minor and purporting to establish that such minor was twenty-one years of age and of the legal age for consumption of intoxicating liquor) accountable for the minors actions if and while intoxicated. The reason I believe the bill was introduced is most likely a young girl named Laura had been mortally wounded while being intoxicated, and being “over served” was the mitigating factor. I would also speculate the incident turned political as the bill was introduced by Representative Noel Torpey, whom was also running for political office.…

    • 464 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Hamer V Sidway

    • 412 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The court’s reasoning for the decision was based upon the examination of consideration. Sidway had denied payment on the account that the nephew had benefited from the actions taken, regardless of his uncle’s proposal, and that the promisor, his uncle, was not benefited in any way. The court however was less concerned with whether the promisee happened to benefit from the proposal, but more concerned with how the nephew had given up his legal rights to drink alcohol, smoke tobacco, swear, and…

    • 412 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Drinking age debate

    • 940 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Many feel as though the law of 21 before drinking saves 1,000 deaths per year. The numbers of teens killed in alcohol related accidents have dropped somewhere from 11-16 percent since the 21 law have been implemented. Taking on higher drinking ages allows for a low intoxication level. For instance, in Georgia, where 21 is the legal drinking age, the blood alcohol level to be considered intoxicated is sitting at 0.08 percent. In places such as New Hampshire, where Arizona is the legal drinking age, blood alcohol content level is listed as high as 0.15 (Carter). These levels start to become dangerous when one realizes that one drink can cause a person’s blood alcohol content to be 0.02. If teen blows even 0.01 into a breathalyzer, it is a crime of underage drinking. The punishment of underage drinking includes a large fine and even jail time (Ash). It is taken very seriously in…

    • 940 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    It is often argued that young adults eighteen to twenty are financial savors to club owners. Patron’s eighteen to twenty are considered adults; therefore they are responsible enough to be allowed in clubs serving alcohol, bringing more money into the club every night. This argument does not address the fact, “that when people under the legal drinking age are in an environment where they have access to alcohol 74.3% will try it” (Wagenaar et al.325). They will become irresponsible due to the amount consumed. In the article “Underage Drinking” it states that club owners will and have be fined a minimum of 5,000 dollars, as well as their liquor license removed. It also states that young adults, eighteen to twenty, are not nightclubs’ financial savors, it is estimated that 25 % of what club owners make is being lost to underage drinkers. In my opinion under age clubbers are more of hassle costing more money than bringing in.…

    • 1025 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Many young people are faced with the problem of purchasing alcohol in the stores and restaurants. Sellers are often referred to as absolutely different age- "alcohol age", which ranges from 18 to 21 years, around the world, in the United States of America its strictly 21. It's time to find out why is it wright or wrong to buy alcohol, and accordingly, use it. Knowledge of laws will help you protect your rights with respect to alcoholic beverages, and this is why this topic is chosen. In the article mother of 3 teenagers discussing a topic of drinking age from the parent’s side. She described her frustration in a parenting column of The New York Times, by righting to people and asking how should parents know when let kids to drink alcohol. But…

    • 154 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The objective of the twenty one year old drinking age law is for the protection of minors and young adults from themselves and society. The argument that is presented for such a law is supported by evidence showing that alcohol may have severe effects on the young developing mind. According to the American Medical Association, "Drinking by adolescents and young adults could result in long-term brain damage, including diminishment of memory, reasoning, and learning abilities". The second argument in support for the twenty one year old drinking age law is partially supported by data of potential traffic fatalities that could be…

    • 1193 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    agreeing first. Anyone who supplies alcohol, including both adults and minors, to someone who is under 18 can be charged and receive a hefty fine. This means if someone who is under 18 gives alcohol to someone else who is underage, the person who supplied the alcohol can be fined. This legislation is called secondary supply law.…

    • 446 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Alcohol and Advertising

    • 655 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Much of the debate concerns the possible effects on children and young people. The Advertising Codes prohibit the specific targeting of minors, but the ubiquity of alcohol advertising ensures that it can hardly…

    • 655 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    intoxication

    • 2746 Words
    • 11 Pages

    The law has formulated various rules of uncertain ambit in seeking to strike the balance between on the one hand imposing criminal liability on a party who did not have the mental capacity/element of the crime and the other protecting the public from persons who deliberately put themselves in a position where they are unable to control their actions. For this reason the law draws or distinction between voluntary intoxication and involuntary intoxication, the law generally is more accommodating to those who have not voluntarily put themselves into an intoxication state.…

    • 2746 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Food and Beverage

    • 1902 Words
    • 8 Pages

    (iii) If the customer is below 18 years of age , that too in a restaurant /hotel who has been given a permit for serving alcohol or drugs.…

    • 1902 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays