Preview

Mill's Argument For The Legalization Of Gay Marriage

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
933 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Mill's Argument For The Legalization Of Gay Marriage
Gay marriage has been an issue is America for quite some time now, and since the legalization of gay marriage, the issue has gotten somewhat worse, but in the same way better. It has gotten worse by the fact that people are finding more extreme ways to disallow service to gays, such as the use of religion. For these people, they should really take some advice from John Stuart Mill. John was a very well known English spokesman for the ideas of the rights for women. He advocated this using his ideas of opinion, speaking out against other’s opinions and generally analyzing the whole situation and figuring out what was best. Mill would give the oppressors of gay marriage some good advice on how to figure out the best possible solution for their …show more content…
Mill would first help them on what they have to do to help understand. So by saying this, Mill would tell them that they need to examine the whole truth, and not just public opinion ( Mill 380). Public opinion is an opinion that is shared by many different people throughout the nation, but as quick as Mill explained that, he would state that since it is just an opinion, and backed by many people, it doesn’t have to be true (Mill 382). Mill would probably then send them on a mission to talk to others and read even more into the issue than what they already have. Then he would he would help them to develop their own answer to this problem. So, following those steps, he would help them with find answers to who to talk …show more content…
Mill’s knew this was very important as well and would be very willing to help them find great readings. Like last time, he would send them away from his side of the issue, as they only have what they want their people to hear, and it may not be the whole truth (Mill 385). Although he could compare it to their works, Mills would send them to the other side again. Those on one side, again, get no truth or facts, but simply a public opinion that is going to be supported no matter what. That person would then get more knowledge that would allow him to access the situation with greater detail (Mill 385). He would probably also send that person somewhere that had factual evidence rather than just opinion, since an opinion is just an opinion. After this step, Mills would have even more to say to

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    In Thomas B. Stoddard's article "Gay Marriages: Make Them Legal," Stoddard begins by defending homosexual marriages through partners, Karen Thompson and Sharon Kowalski. Both women were denied a legalized nuptial by the state of Minnesota even though they resided together and exchanged vows. On November 13, 1983, Kowalski was severely injured by an intoxicated driver and was inflicted with a coma. Kowalski's parents opposed Thompson's petition that she have custody over her companion. Thompson was furthermore forbidden all contact with Kowalski. Only after Kowalski had regained conscience was Thompson permitted to visit. Here, Stoddard appeals to his audience on an emotional level. A feeling of compassion, pity, and understanding is realized through the injustice and unfairness Thompson and Kowalski had to endure. Their account, however, provides little relevance in advocating same-sex marriages because their circumstance is exceptionally unique. Good laws are apt to harm some people and such was the case with these women.…

    • 786 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Throughout this paper I discussed Mills view on Nature verses Nurture which is he is belief that we are who we are because of our education and upbringing rather than our nature. I also explained how Mill became a supporter of women’s rights. Next, I explained Mills view of Representative Democracy and how to minimize corruption. After that, I discussed how enlightenment plays a role in Mills views on the tyranny of the majority. The fifth topic that was discussed was about the voucher system and how Mill believes it will lead to higher quality education; followed by Mill’s belief that the middle class should be the backbone of politics. Lastly, I have discussed Mill’s views on inheritance. In conclusion, the views of Mill that have been discussed thus far in class include Mills views on nature verses nurture, women in the Victorian Era, representative democracy, tyranny of the majority, voucher system, middle class and inheritance as well as my opinions on some of these…

    • 655 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Gay Marriages: Make Them Legal is an article written by Thomas B. Stoddard, an executive director of a gay rights organization called the Lambda Legal Defense and Education Fund. In the aforementioned article, he painfully illustrates the injustices and imbalance of the typical “traditional marriage” and its impact on average, devoted homosexual couples. More than just state his opinion on marriage between homosexuals, he emphasizes the injustice by accentuating real world situations. Not only does Stoddard denote the negative effects on loving gay couples, he illuminates the idea of gay marriage as something beneficial not only to gay partners, but society as a whole (722).…

    • 396 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Mill Shared Humanity

    • 1063 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Mill feels strongly about people being free to express their opinions. There are a few reasons Mill states of why it is so important to society and for shared humanity. First off it is healthy for the human mind individually. Shared humanity is about being there for others and being kind for no reason. So by listening and helping and individual feel great mentally, it shows that is important to shared humanity. If people were not to listen or deny people of their right to express their…

    • 1063 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Mill vs. Rousseau

    • 1129 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Both Mill and Rousseau agree that the “greatest good for the greatest number” is what counts the most in society. They both believe that because humans are rational beings so they will rationally come to realize the full truth about a situation. Both views do have ways of justifying the protection from the government of the people hurt by the natural disaster. However, they both have dissimilar philosophies on how this is obtained. Rousseau’s…

    • 1129 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    An excerpt from Exploring Ethics, best exemplifies the comparison from Mill and Kant. Kant's ethical system concentrates exclusively on the reason for an action and does not take into account its results, Mill's system focuses only on consequences. Mill's explained "that this is the singularity is the basis in which you use to judge morality, with those being morally right being those that will manufacture the most happiness because in the end all humans seek happiness above everything else." He also argued that fame, money, and virtue could not replace happiness but could be used to obtain it. Mill’s believed that happiness is the guiding arch that drives…

    • 848 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Consider, for example, the issues of free speech and argument, the engines that are going to drive society's progress. Where are the forums for these debates? Mill would no doubt argue that these are to be found in all sorts of places—in the newspapers, legislatures, public meetings, universities, novels, plays, and so on—in short, in the political, social, and literary culture all around everyone.…

    • 1533 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    If Mill's arguments are applied on a macro scale, then the answer to whether or not they are successful lies in the sort of society that we wish to create. If we agree with Mill and want to create a society of “intellectually active people”(Ibid., p 87) then his arguments are good reasons for implementing freedom of speech. Therefore Mill's case for freedom of expression is…

    • 2570 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    One of the most controversial topics of today’s matter is whether gay marriage should be legalized or not. There are numerous reactions when this subject comes to discussion and can sometimes lead to a heated debate. Some individuals believe that homosexuality is unethical while people who agree with gay marriage believe to put in consideration that the sexual preference of another human being is necessary. With every conflict comes pros and cons and this topic is like pulling a tight-rope if ever brought up in a debate because you never know who will pull the rope tighter. Gay marriage has a vast influence on the society today, relevant to it becoming legalized, it is bound to impact future generations, and will affect the establishment of marriage later in life.…

    • 697 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Whether an individual is against gay marriage or for it, we all have an opinion on the issue. Andrew Sullivan’s describes how marriage as a basic need for individuals no matter their sexual orientation. However, William Bennett believes that “same- sex marriage would do significant, long term social damage” (1138). Whether we like it or not gay marriage influences marriage institution, culture, and their children.…

    • 687 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Gay marriages have been one of the hottest and controversial topics in our society. There are still problems concerning this issue of homosexuality and gay marriages. Same sex marriages are legal in Hawaii, but in all other states couples must be of the opposite sex to form a marriage. Hawaii’s decision to legalize same sex marriages is considered a milestone victory for gays and may cause a ripple affect for similar action in other states. Those who support gay marriages justify their position by the concept of love. These supporters of gay marriages feel as though gay people are being deprived of their right to love. Many people believe that gay people deserve the right to love and to take that love and form a marriage. These people believe that gays want to feel justified, meaning that as a couple they should be able to define their own marriage for themselves and make their own set of rules. Supports of same-sex marriages feel as though homosexuals are being deprived of their God given right to get married. They believe that arguments against same sex marriages are unconstitutional, and they simply do not justify a ban on same sex marriages. It is not the idea of two people of the same sex getting married that frightens people so much, but it is the thought of change and the fact that the federal government will redefine marriage to allow same sex unions. When people picture the results of same sex marriages, they see images of unstable homes. Everyone would probably agree that homosexuality has changed our society, and legalizing same sex marriages is not likely to be an exception. It would be an injustice to discriminate against a person if he or she were…

    • 305 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    From Kant’s ideas it can be implied that he would tell the rescuers to go for the greatest good of saving more people rather than less because that is the most rational thing to do as a human, to save the most. This would create the most desirable outcome, because it is the most rational (Dpadvertisingco). When examining the two philosophers there will be flaws in the ideas, as any would. In examining Mill’s the main criticism I have towards his work is the idea of receiving pleasure by others. Although it is not a negative thing, I do believe we receive pleasure from ourselves just as much as giving pleasure to others.…

    • 1435 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Try to imagine life in a society that refuses individuals to marry who they love. Imagine people being around their partners, but not having the legal rights to call them their wives or husbands. The fact of the matter is one does not have to try to imagine this because this is the state of current society. People can argue about whether church and state should be separated, the banning of polygamy, and not legalizing gay marriage, but the major importance is the institution of love (Sullivan). Gay marriage should not be opposed, but embraced by society with joy. Gay marriage should be legalized in the United States because denying this right is unfair and unconstitutional; marriage is not about money or judgment of society, but about a couple’s love for each other, and it will help reduce or solve social problems.…

    • 968 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    A prominent issue of today is the question of whether or not to grant the right of marriage to same sex couples. Although same sex marriage has been legalized in many parts of the country, the majority is still on the fence about the issue. There are questions of if would harm the traditional institution of marriage, if it’s religiously righteous, whether it’s constitutional to ban gay marriage, as well as what it would do to the economy. The pros and cons of legalizing gay marriage are almost equal, leaving the issue unresolved.…

    • 887 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    John Stuart Mill

    • 1708 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Mill was a philosopher, economist, and (like his friend Jeremy Bentham) was a proponent of Utilitarianism. Utilitarians believed that an action is right if it tends to promote happiness and wrong if it tends to produce the reverse of happiness -- not just the happiness of the person involved in the action but also the happiness of everyone affected by it. In other words, things that produce the greatest happiness for the most people are good. He particularly approves of common sense morality. There are things people do without systematic thought.…

    • 1708 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays