World Literature
Professor Sophie Weeks
5 November 2012
Much Ado about Nothing
To quote the lyrics of a famous pop star:
I can 't believe I believed everything we had would last
So young and naive of me to think she was from your past
Silly of me to dream of one day having your kids
Love is so blind it feels right when it 's wrong.
The display of human emotions is an everyday occurrence. These emotions range from happiness to sorrow, love to hate, aversion to desire, all of which are revealed in Shakespeare’s play, Much Ado About Nothing. Wide assortments of emotions are displayed in abundance throughout this work. There are times when the characters’ strengths are shown, and when their weaknesses are exposed. There is, however, a common goal of the male and the female: to find true love and happiness.
Shakespeare’s treatment of love in Much Ado About Nothing differs from his other romantic comedies. Sure, it shares the same stagy plot, which finishes with the lovers finally getting back together, but Shakespeare also mocks the conventions of courtly love which was popular at the time.
In Much Ado about Nothing, there are many examples of deception and self-deception. The games and tricks played on people often have the best intentions—to make people fall in love, to help someone get what they want, or to make someone realize their mistakes. It is said that "love is blind," yet the emotions that oppose it are in the same way arresting and controlling. Clouding the truth that was once seemingly evident, these emotions in opposition tend to create a chaos. This chaos is the same which Shakespeare portrays as the inconsistency of love. Shakespeare 's Much Ado about Nothing illustrates how anger, jealousy, and betrayal cause this to be so.
Beatrice and Benedick are said to have an ongoing "merry war.” When analyzing their relationship throughout the storyline, however, “merry” is the least accurate word that comes to mind. The words they exchange are consistently witty, cruel, and directed at each other 's hearts. Benedick calls Beatrice "Lady Disdain" and thinks that she is forever "possessed with a fury." Beatrice, in response, calls Benedick a "disease.” Although these arguments appear to be jokingly humorous, one of the two always seems to take it way too personally. These word wars are quickly forgotten as the fog of anger is cleared from their eyes. This is due to the fact that they overhear each other saying they love one another. Don Pedro is the cause—falsely forcing this couple together! When they hear of this supposed love, the anger is driven away, and they both bid their “contempt, farewell" and their "pride, adieu." Their outlook on love, in turn, is radically altered, and undoubtedly, they were better people because of it.
As Beatrice and Benedick 's emotions begin to evolve, so does the feelings that Leonato have towards his daughter, Hero. The feelings in this father-daughter relationship, however, are inconsistent and unpredictable. In the beginning, Leonato is described as a "father that so loves his child" and it was said that his "joy of her so overwhelmed," but towards the end of the play, he seemingly cares more for himself than practically possible. While his daughter has been ruined, he feels that the wrong is on him.
He so selfishly challenges Claudio to marry his daughter. Leonato even goes so far as attempting to kill Hero, calling death the "fairest cover of her shame.” Leonato is overwhelmed with anger which blinds his fatherly love for her; the love that should be unconditional and forever unchanging. It takes the kind words of the faithful friar to calm Leonato 's anger. Additionally, it was with the conviction of Borachio and Conrad that Leonato 's "love" for his daughter abruptly returns; this also implies the shallowness and inconstancy of love.
Whereas the first couple is blinded by love, and Leonato is blinded by anger, Claudio is blinded by jealousy and ultimately, what is seemingly betrayal. In my opinion, it is Claudio that endures the most extreme and frequent changes of all the characters in Much Ado about Nothing. His relationship with Hero is not like the other relationships. This is mainly because he didn’t have very many conversations with her. In fact, it is the mere sight of her that confirms his love for Hero.
Claudio believes "she is the sweetest lady that he ever looked on,” which provides him with enough reason to ask for her to marry him. Even in conversation with Don Pedro, Claudio mentions that he "looked upon her with a soldier 's eye that liked, but had a rougher task at hand." This proved that his love had no foundation, and is ultimately only skin-deep. Thus, the love and trust that Claudio has for his friend Don Pedro falters as well. He believes that "the Prince woos for himself" and is drowned with jealousy and a sense of betrayal.
After freely falling back in love with Hero, Claudio irrationally believes the words of Don John as well as what he think he sees. They trick Claudio into thinking Hero has another lover by having her servant dress in her clothes and talk to Borachio who calls her by Hero’s name. Claudio hears this and becomes angry, and rightfully so. He then goes out on a whim, deciding to "marry her tomorrow” only to “shame her" publicly at the wedding. Claudio, once again, gains a sense of betrayal. This time it is much more powerfully blinded by anger. The rage that Claudio 's attains does not allow him to think logically. He, in turn, does not attempt to confirm the legitimacy of Hero 's alleged actions before publicly disgracing her at this wedding. This, in addition to the love at first sight, proves that he was not well aquatinted with Hero, and that his love insincere and shallow.
Therefore, the question remains, is love blind? In Shakespeare 's Much Ado about Nothing he doesn 't prove that love is blind or now. However, he masterfully proves that love is a force that is vulnerable misguided emotions. Love survives, despite, the inconsistently that it so consistently reveals. In the face of anger, jealousy, and betrayal, love appears weak, yet it triumphs in the end, and as a result, love is proven not to be so blind after all. Leonato: “A kind overflow of kindness: there are no faces truer than those that are so washed. How much better is it to weep at joy than to joy at weeping!”
Works Cited
Dansby, Uriah. "Synopsis: Much Ado about Nothing." The Quarrel of Benedick and Beatrice. Utah Shakespeare Festival, 01 2011. Web. 02 Nov 2012. <http://www.bard.org/education/studyguides/muchado/aboutnothing.html>.
Tolbert, Robert. "The Ale House Jester and Wit of Beatrice and Benedick." Utah Theater . Amanda Mabillard, 01 2012. Web. 4 Nov 2012. <http://www.shakespeare-online.com/plays/muchado/beatriceandbenedick.html>.
Cited: Dansby, Uriah. "Synopsis: Much Ado about Nothing." The Quarrel of Benedick and Beatrice. Utah Shakespeare Festival, 01 2011. Web. 02 Nov 2012. <http://www.bard.org/education/studyguides/muchado/aboutnothing.html>. Tolbert, Robert. "The Ale House Jester and Wit of Beatrice and Benedick." Utah Theater . Amanda Mabillard, 01 2012. Web. 4 Nov 2012. <http://www.shakespeare-online.com/plays/muchado/beatriceandbenedick.html>.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
“You can tell an artist is excellent when he denies his own perfection.” (Shakespeare 78 -79) Based on the characters Beatrice and Benedick the conflict between the two is that they have trouble expressing their love for each other, throughout the book the foil insult each other until they realize they love one another. In Much Ado About Nothing by William Shakespeare, Benedick serves as the foil character of Beatrice by which Beatrice’s reasonable taste are illuminated through Benedick’s bearing thoughts; thus, compound the twist and conflict to the plot.…
- 606 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
As the dancing commences, we learn a great deal about their personalities. Beatrice, who recognizes her own rebelliousness and bluntness and their effects on others, especially men, has been hurt by Benedick sometime in the past; Benedick is vulnerable to Beatrice's insults (by the end of the scene, Benedick is at his most infuriated with Beatrice's insults, referring to her as a Harpy and as Lady Tongue; he asks Don Pedro to send him on any errand, no matter how ridiculous, just to get him away from Beatrice). This shows the clear divide in attitutdes however , if analysed deeper it seems as if there are evident similarities between Benedick and Beatrice. They’re both exposed to each other’s abuses and somehow feel threatened by…
- 833 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Beatrice's cunning and haughty barb to a masked Benedick shows her averseness to Benedick. In addition to this, she further insults Benedick by the words 'dull' and 'fool.' it impies that Benedick is gray, boring and imbecilic, contrary to what Benedick thinks about himself. The choice of words add further insult to Benedick as they are strong words, not used in their ordinary fights, showing Benedick the true hatred of him by Beatrice for a variety of reasons. The satirical paraphrase 'only his gift is devising impossible slanders' is particularly wounding to Benedick as it alludes to the fact that he is useless, and is not good at anything, from love to war, it's clearly sacritical as it amuses other people, while still affecting Benedick and her…
- 1600 Words
- 7 Pages
Good Essays -
Of all the characters from Shakespeare’s “Much Ado About Nothing”, Beatrice is perhaps the most interesting. As a brilliant and outspoken, her character is quite the opposite of her cousin, Hero. One must ask, “In what way is Beatrice different from other women during Shakespeare's era?” And furthermore, “for what purpose did the author write her as the firm character she plays as?” Beatrice’s character cannot be adequately pegged down by the interpretation of the reader, as she is both seemingly realistically presented and yet fictionally portrayed by the author.…
- 1614 Words
- 7 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Out of the 37 plays and 154 sonnets that Shakespeare wrote, “Much Ado About Nothing” has become one his most popular pieces. The comedy follows Don Pedro, Claudio, and Benedick after they return home from war. Upon meeting Hero, Claudio immediately falls in love with her, and with the help of Don Pedro, Hero agrees to marry him. As they prepare for the wedding, Don Pedro plans to get Beatrice and Benedick together while Don John plots to ruin Hero and Claudio’s relationship. Both succeed, as Beatrice and Benedick admit their love for each other, and Claudio shames Hero at their wedding, believing that she had cheated on him. By the next day, they discover that Don John had staged the scene, and Claudio and Hero still got married, and Benedick got engaged to Beatrice. Throughout the play, Shakespeare uses character foils to emphasize the traits of his characters, and add to his story. In the play, “Much Ado About Nothing” by William Shakespeare, Benedick and Claudio are foils of each other because of their personality traits, choices, and reaction.…
- 990 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Benedick is almost a match for Beatrice as a memorable Shakespearean character. His apparent misogyny and unwillingness to make a commitment to a woman are almost stereotypes early in the play. His use of language, especially in his "merry war" with Beatrice, prevents him from being the clichéd male who refuses to commit to a relationship.…
- 366 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
In the novel, Benedick and Beatrice hate each other with all their might. They talk bad about each other to one another any chance they get. The first form of trickery in Much Ado About Nothing is when the Prince and Leonato plot a story to trick Benedick. They knew Benedick was listening to their conversation so they knew exactly what to say. Benedick believed their lies and began to change the way he saw Beatrice…
- 424 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Shakespeare clearly presents Beatrice and Benedick rooted in animosity towards one another. They frequently express their certainty of this; for example when Benedick labels Beatrice as ‘Lady Disdain’, so she retaliates by naming him as ‘pernicious’. Shakespeare shows conflict between two complicated characters in a transparent way through their ‘merry war’ of derision, which often descents into a brawl of weaponly words like ‘you are a rare parrot-teacher’ – the pomposity of which camouflages their raw doubts and uncertainties.…
- 1911 Words
- 8 Pages
Powerful Essays -
In this play, the reader can compare the two different couples and quickly realizes that Beatrice and Benedick take their time, don’t rush, and compared to Hero and Claudio it wasn’t love at first sight. Right from the beginning of the play, during their first conversation they try to use a type of language that hides the real feelings they have behind for eachtoher. " What my Lady Disdain! Are you yet living? " This quote is said by Benedick to Beatrice, when he comes back to Messina. They try to be very unpleasant to each other and act like they don't care, as they don't want to admit it to the other but to themselves as well. It’s not until the end of the play that Benedick and Beatrice share their feelings and tell each other that they are in love, which shows how they took their time, and really waited for the right moment to let everything go. " Do not you love me? " " Why no, no more than a reason." This quote shows that they still hide their real feelings from each other until the last minute,when they finally feel like it's time to deliver their feelings. Those words said by Benedick show the delivery of all this secret " A miracle! Here's our own hands against our hearts. Come, I will…
- 1031 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Well, this was signior Benedick that said so.”. (2.1.27-29) This quote is Beatrice acting as she does not know it is Benedick who is under that mask. It is debatable whether Beatrice knows that Benedick is the stranger behind the mask but if she does happen to know this then she is deceiving him to make a fool out of him. Of all of deception and trickery that runs through “Much Ado About Nothing” one of the most prominent is the love affair between Beatrice and Benedick. It starts of as “a merry war” that goes on with both Benedick and Beatrice denying the fact that they have romantic feelings towards each other. The signior Benedick and Beatrice first hide their love/feelings with each other. They have a love hate relationship in the beginning as Beatrice says, “What should I do with him? Dress him in my apparel and make him my waiting gentlewoman?” (2.1.34-35). Her meaning of this is that she has no interest in him only using him as a follower. This all changes with the help of being deceived by Hero, Ursula, Don Pedro, Claudio and Leonato lying telling Benedick and Beatrice are strongly in love with each other. With them thinking that the other is in love with them they start to show their true feelings towards each other on their…
- 825 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
The Shakespearean comedy, Much Ado about Nothing encompasses themes such as the importance of honour, the ideal of social grace, nevertheless uses a plot which primarily revolves around the theme of deception re occurring in various forms. On one hand deception is used throughout Much Ado About Nothing in a malicious manner, however on the on the hand it can be portrayed in a benevolent and beneficial manner such as the fooling of Beatrice and Benedick and deceiving them into proclaiming their love for each other. The use of both forms of deception often makes it difficult to distinguish between the two, such as when Claudio announces his desire to woo Hero, however Don Pedro takes it upon himself to woo her for Claudio. However Shakespeare’s use of deception is neither completely a means of malice nor a mean of showing traits of kindness between characters, the use of deception aids the development of the plot and creates a path for other elements necessary in the play such as its comical elements.…
- 1460 Words
- 6 Pages
Powerful Essays -
One of these moments where we can begin to understand their relationship is during the First Meeting. In Act 1 Scene 1, Benedick uses imagery of a bird to mock Beatrice. On line 126, Benedick says to Beatrice “Well, you are a rare parrot-teacher”. Benedick could be mocking Beatrice by suggesting that she can’t say anything original and only copies what others say, therefore relating to the imagery of a parrot. However, the word ‘rare’ shows that Benedick recognises the unique characteristics of Beatrice and that she is standing out from the crowd, consequently hinting his disguised love for her. Additionally, this quotation also relates to the context of time as women, in those days, could be punished for talking too much. Benedick could be taking advantage of the conventions of time to put Beatrice in her place in their relationship with each other. The parrot imagery can also relate to a poem called Sonnet 130. This is because, in Sonnet 130, the poet says “I love to hear her speak, yet well i know, That music hath a far more pleasing sound;”. We can link the first phrase of Sonnet 130 with Benedicks quote of a ‘rare’ parrot-teacher. By including the word rare before the imagery of a bird, suggests that although Beatrice may talk too much, Benedick still enjoys listening to her speak hence relating to Sonnet 130 “I love…
- 823 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Firstly, the relationship betwixt Beatrice and Benedick could possibly go back further than the play lets on. This is guessed by some based off of the hinting in Act, 1 Scene 1, when Beatrice inquires, “I pray you, is Signor Montanto returned from the wars or no?” In this, she is expressing slight concern in regards to his safety, while covering it with a slight teasing. Secondly, in this same scene, Beatrice says to Benedick upon his return, “I wonder that you will still be talking, Signor Benedick. Nobody marks you.” Though perhaps she is insulting him by saying nobody listens to him, she is also showing that she is, in fact, listening to him. Another hinting toward their previous closeness are the words in Act 1, scene 1, after their brief conversation of insults, Beatrice states, “You always end with a jade’s trick; I know you of old.” This rather blatantly implies that she has argued with him like this before, and the constancy of such arguments was probably the demise of their relationship.…
- 958 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
This essay talks about the role of love as it used in Shakespeare’s comedies. It directly talks about “Much Ado about Nothing” and “Twelfth Night”, and how they use love in their stories. “Shakespeare expects us to accept wonder as having some kind of value in itself and in its relations to the action that has gone before. We are presented with the wonderful as an incitement to knowledge and to pleasure; and we are asked also to consider the dramatic fact that those who participate in the happy ending must be ready to set aside their human confinement to the probable and accept an intrusion of the improbable into their lives.” (262-263) Wonder and love are on equal footing in Shakespeare. He expects us to accept that the characters fall in love with each other as well. Love is a vital part of every romantic comedy whether it’s a play written by Shakespeare or a movie like “How to Lose a Guy in 10 Days”. The essay also makes a note of how the characters change through the plays and compares how it works in both stories. The author of the essay…
- 301 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Beatrice and Benedrick have a completely different love story compared to the one between Claudio and Hero. They “despise” each other when they first meet, they constantly made fun of and threw verbal jabs at each other. They were a pair who loved to argue. They both refused to admit their feeling towards each other to anyone, even themselves. This is where their pride comes in. They would attack at each other’s weaknesses with harsh words. We get a glimpse into Benedicks feelings as he inadvertently hinted his fondness towards Beatrice when he says:…
- 1129 Words
- 3 Pages
Powerful Essays