Preview

Ojibwa Vs Lakota

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1922 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Ojibwa Vs Lakota
As the United States was expanding westward in the mid-1800s, many Indian tribes in the Midwest were being encountered by the American government, who wanted to take over their lands. Through a series of treaties, the United States experienced great success in obtaining these lands that they desired. Two of the tribes affected by this were the Ojibwa and the Lakota. While there are similarities in their experiences, there are also many differences. The first treaty negotiated between the United States and the Ojibwa was the treaty of 1837. Prior to this treaty, the Fort Crawford meeting mapped out the area where the Ojibwa people were and set clear boundaries between them and the Dakota, who were feuding with one another. In this treaty, …show more content…
First of all, the treaties were mostly fueled by the United States desire for westward expansion, land, and money. In the Ojibwa’s case, the United States was looking to capitalize on the area’s pine and copper and in the Lakota case, they were looking for gold, and area for miners and settlers to live. Along with this, in both cases, the United States came in and separated tribes that were feuding. For the Ojibwa, the establishment of Fort Snelling and the Crawford meeting were attempts by the United States to stop the feuding between the Ojibwa and the Dakota. The Fort Laramie Treaty of 1871 separated the four tribes in the Plains – the Lakota, the Crow, the Cheyenne, and the Arapahoe – from fighting by putting them on separate reservations. In both tribe’s treaty making process, the Americans clearly had the upper hand. They had more resources, land, men, and power. They used this to their advantage and the Indians knew it. In many cases they felt pressured to sign treaties. For example Henry Dodge pressured the Ojibwa chief Flat Mouth to hurry up and sign the treaty even though Chief Buffalo had not arrived yet. In the Lakota case, they did not really want to sign the treaties but the power of the United States frightened them and they knew that if they did not sign the treaties, that the United States would do what they want anyways. That is why …show more content…
The first being that the Ojibwa never had to leave Wisconsin, while the Lakota were moved around quite a bit more. They were completely kicked out of Wyoming, Montana and Minnesota through the treaties. Secondly, in the case of the Ojibwa, members from both the tribe and the American government discussed before creating a treaty in all three treaties. However, in the Lakota treaties, they were already written before the United States even brought it up to the tribes. The Lakota didn’t really get anything that they wanted, they were just being told what to do. And finally, it was a much more brutal and violent with the Lakota than it was with the Ojibwa. The United State was out to kill the Lakota and completely remove them, however with the Ojibwa it was more about getting access to their land than it was about eliminating them. There were no acts of violence between the Ojibwa and the United States. Not everything was done fairly, but there was very little blood spilled. However, in the Lakota case, it was very violent. Officer Custer was very brutal in how he killed the Indians, the United States used starvation to control the Indians, and the ultimate goal was to break their spirit and culture or to kill

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    The Sioux have staunchly maintained that the treaty ratified by the 1877 Act is void for several reasons, among which are the insufficient number of signatures, the coercive nature of the negotiations, and, most importantly, because the Black Hills were never for sale. Despite creating a Court of Claims to allow non-Indians to sue the federal government, claims by Indians were expressly barred until 1920. The Lakota’s appeal for monetary compensation, filed in 1923 and asserting that the seizure of the Black Hills constituted an illegal taking under the Fifth Amendment, represented the only legal avenue for any redress for the loss of their land, and for decades the Lakota pursued the claim despite the inadequacy of any monetary award (Lenane,…

    • 122 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Indians and Europeans were both stubborn making it essentially harder for these two groups to compromise. However, I believe that there were chances to make the feuds between the groups more peaceful but not everyone was willing to accept. Throughout “What Can You Get By Warre?” , “Your People Only Live Upon Cod”, and “Onondaga Chief Canassatego” we are able to examine why things may not work out so peacefully in the end.…

    • 956 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The 1867 Peace Commission was established to resolve and prevent any conflicts with Native American Tribes. The Peace Commission created reservations to protect Native American tribes and allow white settlers to claim former Native American territories and lay down railroad tracks. Treaties were created to bring peace by giving the Native Americans food, blankets, housing, and clothes. However, the 1867 Peace Commission failed to accomplish their goals.…

    • 611 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The recession of the fur trade pushed the US to look to other resources in the Chequamegon Bay area that they could profit from. In 1787, in the Northwest Ordinance the US declared that they would uphold a policy of peace and friendship towards the Ojibwe (Satz 4). However, the United States continually pushed for more and more measures to suppress Ojibwe culture and make them more “American.” In 1816 the US officially banned all foreign fur trade with Native Americans. In 1830 a school was set up on La Pointe and a mission four years later (Ross 83). Despite these attempts to Americanize the Ojibwe, they largely maintained their traditional culture and were still clearly seen by the US government as not American. In 1837, the Pine Tree Treaty was signed, marking the beginning of a long history of deceptions and exploitations of the Ojibwe people by US politicians (Satz…

    • 1557 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The Sioux nation was a powerful proud nation which migrated and traveled over the Great Plains; their hunter gather lifestyle was encroached upon after the civil war in the United States. The Sioux were victimized socially politically and genocidal. The need to develop the western hemisphere of the United States, seen the lifestyle of the Sioux, as savage and a threat to settlers moving west. The government of the United States philosophy was that a good Indian was a dead Indian represented little hope of peace. Though peace treaties were inspired by the American government they held no validity and integrity as they were a means to eradicate the Sioux’s lifestyle. The American perspective in taming the west was to impose boundaries in the form of reservations on the Sioux and take away their freedom to hunt buffalo non-compliant Indians were deemed as hostile and classified an enemy of the United States, this ramification led into the Plains Indian wars.…

    • 3480 Words
    • 14 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Under the Sioux Treaty of 1868, during the spring, a conference was held at Fort Laramie, present day Wyoming, hoping it would bring peace with the Sioux. It was a treaty that the U.S. government hoped would bring peace between the Whites and Sioux who agreed to settle within the Black hills reservation in Dakota territory. This area of Dakota was sacred to the Sioux indians.…

    • 658 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    Birch bark scrolls were used to write down things using pictographic writing. The Ojibway tribe were members of a powerful alliance called the Council of Three Fires, along with the Ottawa indians and the Potawatomi tribe. The Council of Three Fires faced conflicts with both the Iroquois Confederacy and the Sioux, eventually becoming victorious of both.[2] The Ojibway established a friendly relationship with the French Traders. From the French the Ojibway gained guns, European goods, and were able to dominate over their enemies (the Lakota and the Fox). In return the Ojibway traded furs/pelts (mainly of beaver) to the French. Many French even married and had children with the Ojibway women. The result of this friendship was the alliance the Ojibway had with the French against Great Britain and the colonists during the French and Indian War. Due to the victory of the British, many of the land along with Indians living on it, were claimed by Britain. The Ojibway in return allied with them during the War of 1812 against the United States. The Colonists treated the Ojibway 's like they treated the other Native Americans, always trying to force them off their land. The Ojibway 's were more powerful than most Native American tribes, for multiple reasons, which made it harder for the Colonists to force their move. The Ojibway 's were less affected by the European epidemics, and they were better and handling the Whites as to…

    • 1683 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    With the influx of miners into traditional tribal lands during the Gold Rush, many came and took land wherever they pleased. In order to avoid conflict, the federal government and five tribes signed the Fort Laramie Treaty of 1868, which gave certain exclusive land rights to the tribes, such as ownership of the Black Hills. However, with trespassing by gold prospectors onto the Black Hills, the Indians retaliated and attacked, leading to the seize of the Black Hills in 1877. This marked the beginning of the Plains Wars. The federal government’s willingness to deploy unrelenting military force was one of the causes leading to the defeat of the Plains Indians. Hostile encounters with the U.S. armed forces often ended in great loss for the Indians, steadily decreasing their populations, and reducing the numbers of warriors they had. The tribes’ populations had declined so much that they were consistently outnumbered, and…

    • 588 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Chapter 26

    • 1632 Words
    • 7 Pages

    3) Treaty of Fort Laramie (1851) and the Treaty of Fort Atkinson (1853) – The federal government tried to pacify the Indians by signing these two treaties with the chiefs of the tribes…

    • 1632 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the late 1780’s the US began urging the Cherokees to stop hunting and their traditional ways of life and to instead learn about how to live, farm, and worship like Christian Americans. Despite everything the white people in Georgia and other southern states that abutted the Cherokee Nation refused to accept the Cherokee people as social equals and urged their political representatives to take the Cherokees land. The purchase of the Louisiana Territory from France in 1803 gave Thomas Jefferson the chance to relocate the eastern tribes beyond the Mississippi River.…

    • 726 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “If you sign this treaty, you’re not going to ever have to work or hunt again; we’ll take care of you.' Everything will be provided. Every year you’ll get so much money to buy your needs, your pots and pans, but we’ll also have food coming in every month, or once a year for you. The other alternative is: 'We’re going to drive you all the way to the Rocky Mountains where you’re going to starve to death and we’ll never have to worry about you again.” Those were exactly the conditions Indians have to agree with by signing the…

    • 624 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “During the second half of the 19TH century, the United States Government took all appropriate actions to maintain peace with Native American tribes. Furthermore the United States was justified in its aggressive measures used to seize land from unruly Native American tribes during the era.” There little validity in this statement. During this time period American troops were interloping on Native American territory, starting violence, and forcing them out of their homes. The hostility of American Soldiers toward these people led to several tragedies, such as the Sand Creek Massacre, The Battle of Little Bighorn, and The Battle at Wounded Knee. It can be observed that the United States was clearly not, in any way, shape, or form, attempting to maintain peace.…

    • 694 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Disrespect was a major cultural difference. From the beginning of the relationship between Native and European Americans, the European Americans(Europeans) repeatedly dishonored the treaties which they agreed to uphold. Usually, they established the same treaties they betrayed, such as the Treaty of Fort Laramie (1851); which eventually led to the tragic massacre of the Cheyenne Indians at Sand Creek.[1] “The Treaty set forth traditional territorial claims of the tribes as between themselves.” [2] Greedy and eager to completely disregard the Treaty of Fort Laramie and head west due to the discovery of gold in the Rocky Mountains of Colorado, the Pikes Peak Gold Rush resulted in masses of European Americans emigrating west across Cheyenne and Arapho lands.[1] Suddenly, these lands previously deemed useless to the federal government and rightfully owned by the Natives were subject to the Europeans avarice. This resulted in competition over resources, and unlawful settling in Native territories.[1]…

    • 605 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Dakota War

    • 1363 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Through the years of 1805 all the way to the 1850s multiple treaties were made with the Dakota/Sioux people of Minnesota. The originally initiated treaties of 1805 asked the Dakota to sell Minnesota land along the Mississippi river were Minnesota could eventually start building trading posts. As the years passed Minnesota began pressuring the Dakota to give up more land until eventually the Dakota had ceded all land west of the Mississippi. In 1851 the treaty of “Traverse des Sioux” was signed which stated that the Dakota, in exchange for all of their remaining land, would be given one hundred and fifty mile reservations to live upon as well as 30 cents an acre, and annuity payments throughout the…

    • 1363 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    the United States of America marginalizes the Ojibwa culture. The community way of life is damaged. Nanapush alludes about the destructions “I heard the groan and crack, felt the ground tremble as each tree slammed earth. I weakened into an old man as one oak went down, another and another was lost” (Erdrich 2004: 9). Thus the members of the Ojibwa tribe are divided against one another. People become greedy. They are against themselves. Kashpaw family becomes greedy. Paying taxes becomes their main motive. It collapses their community sharing life. They become alienated from their own culture and tradition.…

    • 1003 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays