Preview

Open Adoption Vs Closed Adoption Research Paper

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
807 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Open Adoption Vs Closed Adoption Research Paper
Is an adoption beneficial to a child?
Statement of the problem Many teenagers are getting pregnant and not able to keep their children. There are many reasons why teenagers decide to give up their child, they are in school, they don’t have the money or they can’t support the baby or themselves. Adoption is the answer for many of these teenagers. There are two kinds of adoptions open and closed. An open adoption is when the original parents are allowed to visit and communicate with their child. A closed adoption is where there is no contact allowed. Today open adoptions are seen to be more beneficial than closed adoptions. I’m adopted and I have an open adoption and I feel that it is very beneficial to me. In order to understand an open adoption
…show more content…
“Starting in the early 1980’s, society’s view on adoption changed (motherhood)”. There would no longer be a need for secrecy, guilt, or shame for the child or the birth mother. Open adoptions allows the birth parents, adoptive parents and the child to have a relationship with each other. Adoption agencies help birth mothers create an adoption plan that includes their needs and desires and that of their child. Open adoption les the birth parents choose the adoptive family. There are various degrees of the “open” adoption process. For some it means that the birthparents and adoptive parents have some knowledge about each other. For others, the birthparents and adoptive parents form a relationship before the birth and are present at the birth of the child. The relationship that it formed between birthparents and adoptive parents is one of trust and respect. The American Association of Open Adoption Agencies lists in its statement of purpose that “Open adoption is the healthiest form of adoption, it is an adoption in which the birth family and the adopted child enjoy and ongoing, in person relationship” (openadotpion.org), this statement if a reflection of what the majority of open adoptions consist …show more content…
Whatever the fears or concerns that each have the majority feel that an open adoption was the most beneficial to them and the child. Long-term research has shown that “adoptive families generally report that they do not fear that birthparents will return to claim the child and that they child does not display confusion about who is the parent” because of the open relationship they have with the birthparents (openadoption). Birthparents know how the child is doing and can see the security that the adoptive parents provide. Besides knowing the medical history of the birthparents, open adoption allows the adoptive parents to have a better understanding of character traits and that the child may have. An example is when the child tilts their head to the right when is the same as when the birth mother speaks, there are many ways that a child may react that are connected to ways the birthparents would have reacted, it can only be explained when its in their

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    The article Why Adoptees Need To Find Their Biological Parents by Stephen Betchen is about finding closure between an adoptee and their biological parents. At the age of forty Betchen's adopted parents had already passed away and after waiting so long, he wanted to find his biological parents. Because he did not receive any medical records, he has a fear of dropping dead at any moment, which is why he wanted to see his biological parents to get them. Betchen having a daughter, finds it difficult to claim her as his own. Betchen writes about how adopted people sometimes feel like they don't belong. He also writes about how adoptees have the idea that they should be financially stable just in case they get put up for adoption again. Betchen does…

    • 303 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Adoption is the legal process, which permanently transfers all the legal rights and responsibilities of being a parent from the child’s birth parents to the adoptive parents.…

    • 1145 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Have you ever agonized over giving up your child and the only option was to give away your baby never to be seen or heard from again for eighteen years? Well, the good news is that this does not have to happen. There is such a thing called open adoption agreements. And more and more parents are leaning towards this option. Even though the open adoption agreement says limited contact, there are cases where the biological parents get cut off, never to their child again.…

    • 784 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    According to the Cambridge dictionary, adoption is “the act of taking another person's child legally into your family to raise as your own child.” It quickly became a very popular thing to do in the mid-1900s. Since then, adoption has been a very common topic of conversation, more so of argument. Similar to a myriad of other controversial topics, people have their own opinions; many people are actually against adoption and could sit down and write a whole list of reasons why adopting a child is a terrible idea. However, many of those people never take into account all of the positives that come with adopting a child. Adoption is an amazing, indescribable act that I look forward to being a part of in the future. Just like almost everything in this imperfect world, adoption has its cons. As well, adoption has its pros; I believe that the more people partake in it, the better we can make the lives of children in need.…

    • 1121 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Essay On Closed Adoption

    • 753 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Adoption is the social and emotional process in which children, who will not be raised by their birth parents, become full and permanent legal members of another family. Also while maintaining genetic connections to their birth family. Open adoption is when birthmothers or birthparents have adoptive families have an interaction with one another including the adopted child. The interaction of the adoptive child with the birth family includes writing letters, sending e-mails, telephone calls, and especially visits with one another. The introduction of openness into the process of adoption offers new opportunities for children in need of a parent or parents or especially just wishing to expand on the family. Closed adoption also known as “Confidential Adoption” are files of the birth parents are sealed and never will be revealed unless approval of both parties (FindLaw). There is no interaction of birthmothers and the adoptive family.…

    • 753 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Each of our articles focuses on a different aspect such as the different effects of an open adoption compared to a closed adoption, or the mental health and behavioral problems of the adopted child. According to an article titled Behavior problems and mental health referrals of international adoptees: A meta-analysis adopted children (specifically internationally adopted children) are referred to mental health specialists more often than a non-adopted control (Juffer and Van IJzendoorn, 2005). We found this information interesting and decided to investigate for ourselves. We spoke with a family who has 3 internationally adopted children of their own. Through our discussion we found that 2 of the 3 are medicated for ADHD, 1 of the 3 is in counseling, while another is currently seeking a mental health professional to visit with. We found that things these children struggle with are abandonment, anger, and attention deficit, which is also conclusive with our research. These children were all apart of private, closed adoption and do not suffer from common issues of those in open adoptions such as attachment disorders, according to Agnich, Schueths, James, and Klibert, in an article titled The effects of adoption openness and type on the mental health, delinquency, and family relationships of adopted youth. The closed nature of these adoptions has allowed for the children to cope without experiencing the negative external behaviors that come with being in contact with a biological…

    • 695 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Closed Adoption Case Study

    • 1263 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Adoption is defined as the transfer of parental rights and obligations from one family to another. The difference between a closed adoption and an open adoption. A closed adoption is when birthparents and the adoptive parents know nothing of each other... An open adoption is when both parties agree to meet each other and they come to a legal agreement concerning the exchange of pictures and letters and sometimes they agree to visitation between the child and biological parents, family etc. . . . This is where the conflict comes into play. Once the biological parent makes the decision to give their child up for adoption, there should be no further need of contact…

    • 1263 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Imagine not understanding what you are doing, not even fully knowing who is coming to get you, and where you are going is a mystery in itself. These are all thoughts and questions that might run through a childs mind who is being adopted by a family that lives in a different country. This is an international adoption, and it can be controversial in the U.S along with other countries for different reasons. International adoption has gone throughout history adjusting as it has to, but it's not the only thing that has changed both what the parents go through and the children adapting have evolved as time goes on too. No matter how much is done to make this process easier there are always challenges that remain to face everyone affiliated with the process.…

    • 1402 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Best Practices In Adoption

    • 1172 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Most adoptions involve minor children in a legal process that profoundly affects them for the rest of their lives. It is imperative that professionals involved in adoptions act ethically to safeguard the rights of vulnerable…

    • 1172 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Closed Adoption

    • 918 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The choice of an open vs. closed adoption is one of the most important decisions a mother can make during the adoption process. For both processes an agreement is crafted to detail the rights of the birth parents in the life of the baby following the adoption. There are many pros and cons to both options. Both can be seen and evaluated in the following articles that clearly explain and discuss these two options. Also, another form of clarification is the textbook, Marriages and Families by John DeFrain.…

    • 918 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The article not only provided clarity but it also provided positive outcomes to relative adoptions. It showed the difference in outcome between in relative and non-relative care givers. It was proven through studies that kids that are fostered by relatives vs. non relative care givers are given the opportunity to maintain a relationship with their family members. Kinship not only facilitates cultural, spiritual and social growth it serves as an important component in family preservation and…

    • 836 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Laura chose an open adoption because her sister was adopted through a closed adoption and it brought no blessing to her. Laura believed that the secrecy of closed adoption brought her sister to have issues with anxiety and low self esteem. Laura said, “Ariel hasn’t had to deal with identity issues to the same degree as my sister. She knows her birthparents, and with that, she knows a lot more about herself. She knows who she looks like and her inherited medical history. Most importantly, she knows why she was given for adoption and that her biological parents loves her. It is essential that Ariel feels comfortable with her adoption and perceive her birthparents as positive, wonderful factors in her life” (“Open Adoption”). Ariel’s adoptive father also believes open adoption can help a child because, “In closed adoption, you face the prospect of keeping a secret and lying to your child about his or her origin. That violates the most basic relationship between a parent and child: TRUST!” (“Open Adoption”). Having the biological parents in the child’s life to inform them will help them understand who they are and creates a stronger relationship between both the child and the adoptive…

    • 1929 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Open adoption birth parents experience a sense of less guilt as a benefit (Gray 27) of the adoption but what benefit does the child rear? Adoption should be more for the child and less for the birth parents emotional ground. But closed adoption does give the birth parents privacy because “placing a child for adoption is an extremely sensitive and vulnerable choice. Having a closed adoption creates an opportunity for a stronger sense of privacy,” (“N. A. I. C. H.” 1) and it can also reduce fear because “some birth mothers are concerned about explaining their choice, and a closed adoption serves as a way to prevent them from a confrontation with a child placed for adoption” (“N. A. I. C. H.” 1). Closed adoption rids the birth parents of the responsibility they were not ready for in the first place and gives the child a chance at a better life with more responsible individuals. In some cases, closed adoption kills two birds with one stone by riding a birth parent of the embarrassment of not being prepared or financially stable for a child while giving the adoptive child a chance for a better life with an adoptive family that is looking for a child to give love and a good life…

    • 1154 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Imagine being a teen and finding out you’re pregnant. What is your first thought? What will I tell my parents? What will I do with the child? A pregnant teen should learn more about her options. If she knows more about the different options, she will make a better decision. Abortion can be an opportunity that she is able to choose which way to have the abortion. Adoption can be kept confidential or can be open to being able to keep in touch with the adoption family. Parenting takes a lot of time, responsibility, and is very expensive. Teen pregnancy is a controversial problem in the U.S. Options for pregnant teens are abortion, adoption, or becoming a teen parent.…

    • 692 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Birth Record Of Adoption

    • 1196 Words
    • 5 Pages

    For example, supporters believe that adoptees should be able to know their background. In one case an adoptee from Ethiopia named Richard Domingo says that to help someone figure out who they are and to build an identity is to know about their culture's food, music, and language (Schroeder 2). Naturally, every kid wants to know their background to help them grow as a person. Also, people who agree say that adoptive parents should make sure the adoptee has contact with their biological parents. For instance the mother could put her baby in open adoption where biological families can either meet in person or share photos every so often (Akin 3). Without a doubt many mothers who give their child up for adoption want to know how their child is and what's the child is going on in their life. Next, those in favor say that if the mother is going to put her child up for adoption, she should go through the Department of Social Services. In this situation an adoptee named MacNish said "She's the one who brought me into this world, yet she could still have control over my life by saying she doesn't want me to know who she is" (Akin 3). Certainly many mothers want to get to know their child, but there are some who don't want to know their child as much. Therefore, supporters believe adoptees should know their background, should have contact with their biological parents, and parents should use open adoption. These points are widely disputed by those who…

    • 1196 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics