Preview

Participation Trophy Definition

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
771 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Participation Trophy Definition
Participation trophies, while often frowned upon for their unsavory title as one of the peaks for liberal ideology, are actually quite plentiful in redeeming qualities. Participation trophies provide psycological boosts, a benefital bottom line in competetive sporting activities, and are surrounded by an opressive and negative stigma that stops the general public from realizing the encouraging personal reaps of getting them.

Psycological boosts when participation trophies can be seen right away in adults who still hold onto them. "They were "tiny," given simply for participating. But the men had kept them and clearly valued them. Perez argues these trophies act as an important marker, to say 'I did this, I finished this." This is an important
…show more content…
It is often speculated that participation trophies are grand trophies that are decorated in detail and made with care to celebrate each individual, even whilst the folk participating might not be the best nor even care about the sport at all. This assumption is false. Participation trophies (medals and ribbons included) are often made in groups and collectively handed out to all (in sports) players that helped contribute to the win or loss of a game and/or serious competiton. They provide a healthy bottom line that allow the kids who might be struggling or lacking in the area to continute to strive. Also, it is often believed that the kids who do shine in the areas are forced to sink down to a singe participation trophy to accomodate to the feelings of the other children. This is also false, as secondary trophies are usually handed out collectivly to the shining kids within the group in additon to the bottom line trophies. These secondary trohpies are often more grand and are given for stricer crieria that other children don't meet. This allows the children who climb above other to be recognized whilst not putting any other teammates down for not being as good as the others. The children still leave with something, such as a memento of the memory of playing as shown in the lines, " I would have been 7 years old, and this is likely my very first award for participation. I have no idea how it survived for three decades — whether I saved it or my mother scooped it out of the dust bin years ago — but it did, this fragile little ribbon. And so I'm inclined to make that another Yes vote in the participation debate." That small ribbon was able to be the only physical memory he had of his childhood that he had taken for granted whilst living it. One final point that is often brought up

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Heffernan’s argument supports participation trophies by focusing on her own personal experiences with the issue. While she does reference research by Kenneth Barish, Tom Farrey, and Allison Slater Tate that does support her argument, but she put a large focus towards her own experience. She calls that participation awards her children received at a young age “adequate rewards for practicing”. She states with her argument that the reason that we keep these trophies is that they teach children the lessons of participation and growth. The use of her own experience and explaining the lessons of participation…

    • 432 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Varying opinions have been proposed on this subject. Corey Turner from the NPR Ed states both sides to the argument in the short article, "Should Kids Get A Trophy For Showing Up?" Although both sides have valid arguments,…

    • 945 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Participation Trophys

    • 228 Words
    • 1 Page

    Participation trophies lose their meanings at times.youth athletes take them for granted. Coaches spend $2000-$3000 on participation trophies every year. Coaches could spend those funds on sports organization…

    • 228 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Rewarding Mediocrity is dangerous, especially with kids, because it will shape their expectation to be winning trophies in everything they attend. Because as a kid, they will ask themselves “ I have achieved this big trophy, why don’t I have this one?” and over the time there will be 2 things can happen. One is this kid will have a mindset of winning and have narcissistic about themselves about being number one, then when they attend a true competition or selective events, they will extremely disappointed and criticize with themselves hardly if they’re not a winner or if this kid is actually a top performance and see what they get is exactly the same with who did not try, they will ask themselves “why I need to work hard while what I…

    • 252 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    First, Merryman claims that, “when living rooms are filled with participation trophies its part of a larger cultural message: to succeed, you just have to show up.” This is exactly what many think. If children just are given trophies for a certain period of time, they will soon understand that they are going to get the trophies no matter what. This will cause them to underachieve. They will not try hard. In Article 1, Tarshis believes that kids are getting the amiss message by stating, “In life, most people are not rewarded for simply doing what’s required. A student doesn’t get an A just for going to class. An employee doesn't get a raise just for arriving to work on time.” So why do kids get trophies even though they are not among the best of their teams? Think about it, if a student got an A just for showing up at class, would they work hard? Exactly. No, they wouldn’t give their fullest because they know they are going to get a good grade. Similarly, kids do not give their fullest. They think even if they don’t do well, they will still receive a trophy for participating. In all, kids get the misconception that it is okay to underachieve because they are still getting some form of a…

    • 1096 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Success in sports is, arguably, the determining factor of overall success and public admiration of a man today. We find that many men look to the athletic world as a means of escape, liberation, or fulfillment of their lives. While all this may be true, there are many costs associated with the game, both health and relational, and just about everyone who aspires to this type of success falls victim to these costs. However, despite the fact that many are fully aware, they seem to have little weight in people’s decision to pursue a professional athletic career. On the other hand, this ignorance is justified as some see the costs as just part of the job, and as Michael A. Messner suggests in his essay, “Sport and Gender Relations: Continuity,…

    • 1972 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Some people claim that it is worth a few bucks to put a smile on someone's face. However, their money can a lot of other emotions too. Some people can get this trophy and say ,"why did I try so hard to get a trophy everyone else gets for standing there ,and doing nothing?" That is someone that is mad. Depression can be caused by the trophies ,for participating in the same sport over and over again. Trophies can make young athletes worry about if everyone gets a trophy," what is the point of trying my best?"Giving trophies can be harmful to the young athletes out there and the programs. Help young athletes…

    • 479 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    If we as a parent are expecting a small simple glass, metal or plastic trophy to build self-esteem or motivation towards your kids then I am afraid to tell you that you are giving those prizes way too much accountability. Children are fed with many false expectations and it hinders them from maturing. Therefore, it is important to let them face reality and receive no participation trophy because when you are no longer there, they will not know how to handle…

    • 468 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    My brother is on a soccer team every summer with the same teammates. He’s been playing on the same team for 3 years now and he loves his team. My brother also showing off his trophies and awards all the time for whatever game it is. If it’s a just a scrimmage or actual real game, he loves getting trophies. The fact that he gets a trophy is saying that he did something right, so when he brings it home and shows them to people. He talks all about what he did to get that trophy even if he loses he gets one and he enjoys it. One time he didn’t get a trophy and he was upset after his game. It’s not that fact that he got just a trophy for participating, he got one for trying and worked hard. That's what I see in my brother when he talks about his trophy and the love for it.…

    • 630 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The subject of sports and participation rewards is a major controversy in today's society. Several kids take part in a sport at some point in their life. When the season is over, rewards will generally be given to the higher level athletes on the team. With only some kids receiving awards, a problem arises with the other kids who feel they deserve one too. This then leads to the question of whether or not all kids who take part in an activity should receive participation awards. Participation awards should not be given to all kids because they will view it as an entitlement, kids may get the wrong impression of themselves, and may then have a hard time accepting defeat and failure.…

    • 967 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Though in my experience when i was given a trophy for participating in softball that made me think that i was good and i practiced and practiced so i was good and i felt good. Yet as the years proges the kids are rewarded for everything from behavior to actions. For example at a summer camp in Maryland gives awards every day-this “day” is just one hour long. The American Youth Soccer Organization gives out roughly 3500 trophies and awards every season. That right there tells you that kids are given and rewarded for things such as participating and to think that, that's only in two cases. There are other cases where children are not awarded a trophy but there parents may keep saying that they are so proud of you and your great at a sport when really you probably just sat there playing in the dirt.Sound familiar?.This will probably make you feel really good about yourself but have you ever stopped and thought do i really deserve this…

    • 383 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Merryman and Berdan argued that these participation trophies were bad, and send dangerous messages. Abate on the other hand argued that participation trophies were a good fueler for kids self esteem and desire to do better. Personally I agree with Merryman and Berdan, participation trophies are awarding children for simply putting in minimal effort. Merryman argues that children need to know its O.K. to lose. Not everyone can be a winner in life. However, Abate does a tremendous job of persuasion. Abate uses personal experience, and he strikes the readers with a feeling of pity because of statements like, “Watching a peer receive a trophy and not receiving one yourself can be degrading.” Readers know the experience can be true because of either experiencing similar or watching someone else experience the degrading feeling of not winning. Though Abate’s article may be full of pathos, he doesn’t give the reader’s much logos to look at, granted he does have some personal experience but he hardly introduces any research supporting his view. Out of the three articles, Merryman has the most convincing article because of her incredible amount of research, that includes links that the reader can follow; her ethos and pathos. Berdan, like Abate, uses a personal anecdote to support her claim, however…

    • 895 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Not everyone should get a trophy for participation because it is teaching the kids that losing is so terrible that we can never let it happen. In the New York Times article ¨Do We Give Kids Too Many Trophies?¨ by Michael Gonchar says ¨If children always receive a trophy - regardless of effort or achievement - we're teaching that losing is so terrible that we can never let it happen.¨It also says that¨In study of Gold Medal Olympians, they said that a loss was key to their championships.¨ This shows that if we give kids trophies, then we are teaching kids the wrong lesson that losing is horrible even though losing is sometimes key to a victory. This makes it really hard for kids to…

    • 397 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The ones who don’t work for what they earn, turn out to be the people who ask for things rather than just earn it themselves. By not giving these participation trophies to children, you teach them that they need to earn it. If they just show up, but don’t do anything of importance, they shouldn’t get a trophy. This will show discipline and success. Betty Berdan once said, “Trophies should be given out for first, second and third; participation should be recognized, but celebrated with words and a pat on the back rather than a trophy.” This is a very good way to put it. Winners should be rewarded while the rest should learn an important lesson and shoot for the stars next time. They think that this trophy is really important, until they grow up and realize that it means nothing.…

    • 575 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    What goes through a child’s mind when they receive a trophy? Is it how hard they worked to be recognized or that they are just being a part of a group? In society there is an arising opinion that not all children participating in activities should receive a trophy. According to Reasons-Rupe Poll, “57 percent of Americans say only winning, and deserving kids should receive awards. Another 40 percent say all kids on a sports team should receive a trophy for their participation” (Ekins). These views are a result of many children showing a feeling of entitlement, an increased cost of programs, and lack of ambition.…

    • 563 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics