Preview

Paul's Case and Metamorphosis Comparison

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
941 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Paul's Case and Metamorphosis Comparison
Joshua Butler

Professor Scott

English 102

27 July 2011

Essay # 2

Willa Cather's, "Paul's Case" and Frank Kafka's, "Metamorphosis" are short stories written in the early twentieth century, merely ten years apart. When comparing and contrasting these short stories, the reader finds that both stories share a similar point of view and the recurring themes of alienation and money run throughout these works.

Both "Paul’s Case” and “The Metamorphosis" are written in third person with a very restricted point of view. The point of view in Cather's work is limited to just that of Paul which changes early on and becomes omniscient. Kafka chose to keep his work in the point of view of Gregor, the protagonist, which becomes omniscient at the end of the story once he has died.

Cather's and Kafka's works share a common theme that creates a powerful message to their readers. Alienation is the theme that runs throughout both of these short stories. Paul is emotionally alienated from his family and peers, which may have led to his eventual suicide. Paul loathes his life on Cordelia Street where, according to him, the people look like their homes, ordinary and middle class. His contempt is demonstrated in his lack of concern for his education, his teachers, fellow students and his home life. He steals money and runs away to New York City. His behavior is typical of a person who has a psychological disorder and/or inferiority complex, and often attempts to compensate this frailty by being rude and aggressive toward others. People with this ailment often are loners and avoid situations where they may feel humiliated. Paul submerges himself in the arts observing those who participate, and this unhealthy escape eventually leads to his demise.

Gregor is also alienated both emotionally and physically after his transformation into a beetle. He at one point refers to this change as his "imprisonment." After his metamorphous, Gregor is no longer

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    In Part I of Metamorphosis, Kafka ends the part by illustrating the rejection of Gregor by emphasizing that even before his transformation in an insect; a situation which forces him to hid away from others, Gregor has always been isolated from others. Due to his job as a traveling salesman, Gregor is unable to make any friends or stay close to anyone at all for that matter, turning him into a very reclusive person (though Kafka never states is Gregor has always been this way or if is simply the job that caused this). When we come to the end of Part I, Gregor is also in extreme anxiety due to the fact that he was supporting his family and is now unable to work. This effect Gregor so much that even after he has transformed into a bug, he is still trying to find ways to be able to work. This conflict causes Gregor to feel trapped, like a bug locked in a room, hidden away under the settee.…

    • 465 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Gregor undergoes his metamorphosis without complaint.When he was transformed into an insect, he never questioned the cause, or attempt to take action to change his absurd condition back to normal. However, he accepts his metamorphosis by taking the physical comfort provided by his new body as an escape from his past suffering on his job as a salesman. After the removal of…

    • 651 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Statistics show that 1 in 10 Americans have suffered depression, depression often being a result of isolation and alienation from society. In the short story “Metamorphosis”, Franz Kafka utilizes point of view and anthropomorphism to develop the theme of alienation.…

    • 305 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The theater and Carnegie Hall was where Paul "really lived". To him, the rest of his life was but "a sleep and a forgetting". The moment Paul stepped into either one of those places, he felt he was in his element. He "breathed like a prisoner set free". Paul's life was so monotonous and dull in comparison to his theater life, which he felt was his "secret temple". This alone provides insight into his character. He truly believed that he belonged to the arts. This makes Paul's case so sad because no one believed in him. This is what caused him to flee to New York to be in a place where he would be accepted for his true selt.…

    • 610 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Paul's Case

    • 821 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Several examples of symbolism are represented in Cather’s story. For example, Paul often wears a red carnation on his shirt. These flowers represent Paul himself. Early in the story Paul wears a red carnation when he talks with his teachers. They see this as him being rebellious, and they would be correct in their assumption. We see the flowers again at the end of the story. By this time the weather is cold and Paul’s flowers have died. Also, Paul buries the flower in the ground before he jumps in front of the train. This is meant to briefly foreshadow that he is going to kill himself. Cather’s use of color is probably the strongest symbol in the story. Its affect on the mood of the characters is evident as well. We connect the color yellow with the fact that Paul cannot stand his home. He doesn’t like to think of returning to his room and staring at the yellow wallpaper. Later in the story, when Paul is at the hotel, he associates the color red to the man at the desk. He has a red face and a red mouth which are meant to give us a window into his former life. As in many stories, rich and wealthy people are often found wearing the color purple. He also orders purple flowers for his room at the hotel to feed his lie about being rich himself. Paul is represented by the colors blue and white. He obviously has some emotional issues and these show in his pale face. On the opposite end of the spectrum, white can be a positive color for him. Snow is often present when he is happy. Blue is much more popular than white in the story. The veins on Paul’s face are blue. Paul obsesses over the blue Venetian and the blue Rico, and listens to the Blue Danube. He also mentions a blue sea that he wants to be carried into. Paul talks about the theater being a “bit of blue-and-white Mediterranean shore,” and we’re also told he pictures the sea before he gets hit by the train. Food is also a popular symbol throughout “Paul’s Case.” The…

    • 821 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    A compare and contrast Analysis of Frank Kafka’s, The Metamorphosis and The Things They Carried.…

    • 1069 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Paul is a strange young man, often leaving his peers confused about his actions and his motives. The strangeness is best depicted by Paul’s physical appearance, “his master had noted with amazement what a white, blue-veined face it was; drawn and wrinkled like an old man 's about the eyes, the lips twitching even in his sleep…” (Cather). Also he is described in another instance as displaying the characteristics of being addicted to the drug belladonna. Paul has no care for his physical appearance at school; in fact, he does not even care to be at school, and he did not try to hide his feelings. Paul tells his classmates how appreciated he is elsewhere and fills them with wonderful stories of his experiences at Carnegie Hall. Often when Paul runs out of stories, he comes up with new lies and excuses for when he cannot fulfill the lies. Cather describes Paul’s school life by stating:…

    • 1283 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Franz Kafka’s “The Metamorphosis”, the protagonist, Gregor Samsa, in desperate need of appreciation, took the responsibility and obligation of maintaining his unappreciative family member’s every day life. While traumatic instances occur, the limits of the family’s loyalty and sympathy for Gregor’s needs are rejected by the ones he cherishes the most. Obviously, one can notice the unconditional love Gregor shows his family, but the profound transformation he physically endures leaves him now as his family’s burden (SparkNotes Editors). Although many instances occur throughout Gregor’s transformation that shows new profound realization of his unsympathetic family, one can analyze the many symbols shown in this tragic story.…

    • 823 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The family members who used to depend on Gregor to survive changed to the degree…

    • 563 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Pauls Case

    • 556 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Cordelia Street and Pittsburgh is the bearer of all the “ugliness in the world” (208). Paul despises his home on Cordelia Street and refuses to show up on night and rather sleep in the basement, imagining his father shooting him mistakenly for a burglar. This provides evidence of how Paul would rather sleep in the cold, dark basement than see his father and sleep in a comfortable bed. Both the Pittsburg society and his father hold Paul back from who he really is. “His experience of life elsewhere was so full of Sabbath-school pictures, petty economics, and wholesome advice as to how to succeed in life” (201). Cather also hints Paul is gay which makes since for his exclusion in society, the early 1900s was also not a time that welcomed or comforted gays, but made them rather confused and felt…

    • 556 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Paul's Case

    • 1061 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Set in Pittsburghin the early 1900s, the story depicts the dull and conformist overtones the Industrial Revolution and steel industry cast over the city. Carnegie had recently created his steel empire, employing most of the town in the steel mills to work long hours at monotonous jobs. Due to the long working hours combined with low wages, there was little time or money for cultural activities to develop. Despite these challenges, Carnegie was also a philanthropist and established many artistic venues with his wealth; (Hicks)Carnegie Hall being one of prevalence in the story and most well known today. Although these activities were generally only available for the social elite, their presence alone created aspirations and imagination material for the working class. Paul’s infatuation with this higher class and the privileges afforded to them was a major influence on his quest to find individuality.…

    • 1061 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    To begin, although Gregor has very few human like aspects before becoming a bug. He kept a "huge picture he cut out... it showed a lady fitted out with a fur hat and fur boa... towards the viewer" (1 and 2) throughout Gregors transition this picture remains to be his one…

    • 487 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    An individual cannot prevail positively or productively with all fundamental needs met without the dynamic of society. Society engenders restrictions on man. Our society has created many stereotypes which has blinded many individuals, resulting in leaving one confined to the realms of the world, crippling humanity. In the fictional novel, The Metamorphosis by Franz Kafka, a salesman named Gregor Samsa was left in his own bubble to suffer alone, simply because he didn't measure up to the prevailing social standings that were upheld in this society. Kafka demonstrates the theme of alienation, from a unique perspective through the utilization of tone and imagery.…

    • 233 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the story the main character that goes by the name of Gregor suddenly wakes up one morning to find that he has transformed into a bug, but the fact that he is indeed a bug he feels he must go to work for his family. His whole family is very lazy and he has to get the money for them, so after Gregor changes to a bug they are all rather shocked in the beginning but slowly begin not to care about him and basically shun him from the family by locking him in his room. With this said you can see a change of the family towards Gregor just because of this change and he is no longer useful to them, this shows the families true colors by the end of the story. At one point in the story his father hurts Gregor by throwing an apple at him and it gets lodged in his back but in the story it says “No one dared to remove the apple lodged in Gregor’s flesh so it remained there as a visible reminder of his injury”, his family are so disgusted with what he has become they won’t help him even in a moment of pain just because of the way he…

    • 1069 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The story begins with the line, “When Gregor Samsa woke up one morning from unsettling dreams, he found himself changed in his bed into a monstrous vermin” (1). Although it never explains how Gregor is transformed into a bug. Even as a bug, all he worries about is getting to work and does not give a thought to having the body of an insect. Gregor has devoted himself to a life of work. In fact, when the office clerk, who came by to check why he was not at work, runs out of disgust because of Gregor’s appearance, and Gregor tries to explain to him, “ I’ll get dressed right away, pack up my samples, and go. Will you, will you please let me go? Now sir, you see, I’m not stubborn and I’m willing to work; traveling is a hardship, but without it I couldn’t live (…) A man might find for a moment that he was unable to work, but that’s exactly the right time to remember his past accomplishments and to consider that later on, when the obstacle has been removed, he’s bound to work all the harder and more efficiently” (15). He had lost his humanity because of the dehumanizing effects of his job and life in general. After realizing that this life would never be the same again Gregor starts realizing certain truths about his existence, which had not come to his realization before. He starts to reflect on his own being. “On the wall directly opposite hung a photograph of Gregor from his army days, in a…

    • 1221 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays