Preview

Railton's Argumentative Analysis

Satisfactory Essays
Open Document
Open Document
266 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Railton's Argumentative Analysis
According to Peter Railton we should feel uneasy when fact/value distinction is similar to objectivity/subjectivity and reason/emotion. If we stop viewing fact and value as distinct the facts may be softened while the values may be hardened. Railton is concerned with generic/non-moral goodness or intrinsic value. The philosophical defense of fact/value distinction consists of the arguments from rational determinability, internalism, and the argument from “queer-ness.” Rational determinability are factual disputes that can be resolved by appealing to reason and experience, but facts are hard. Internalism and instrumentalism supports the fact and value distinction. Thinking of goodness can be similarly relative to “nutritiveness,” that all organisms require nutrition but do not utilize the same nutrients. There is no absolute nutrient, meaning that there is no such thing as something being nutritious for all organisms, there is only relational nutritiveness. Railton also believes that someone being good involves what he or she would want for themselves while being free of “cognitive error or lapses of instrumental rationality.” The argument from queerness (which concerns the nature of reality), provides that human motivational system and situations support counterfactuals to characterize intrinsic goodness. Determinates are factors that influence desires we form and how such desires will evolve In response to many changes including one’s own belief, however an actual individual’s beliefs will fall short of expressing full information. Naturalness consists facts about a given person’s “psychology, physiology, and circumstances that are reduction basis” of his or her dispositions to desire. One’s own good can play a role in evolution in their own behavior even without forming an accurate idea of

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    After Mulholland’s aqueduct operation was done, the World War I began. Since the United States was busy to settle down and controlled the urbanization, US should had been remained neutral. However, to be prepare the surprise attack, US wanted to be able to protect themselves. During the World War I, it was the best time for US to promote more trade and expanded their market toward the world. To do so, federal governments granted money for developing ports and facilities. According to Josef W. Konvitz, through the expansion of shipping, the great port cities acquired a significant manufacturing sector, including shipbuilding, and met the needs of their growing population for food and energy supplies (Konvitz 293). It was true that it was part…

    • 240 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    SNC completed the 5 paragraph order ensuring all of the basic guidelines were covered. The loud and demanding voice of SNC illustrated that SNC was confident in his plan and knew and understood the mission. SNC used the hand and arms signals as the form of communicating with his fireteam. SNC provided a successful security plan that helped the fireteam during the time of friction. SNC and his fire team were engaged by enemy contact and SNC was able to locate the direction of the enemy and return fire and lead his fire team to safety but to also accomplish the mission. SNC made decisions without relying on other suggestions and executed the plan in a tactical manner SNC displayed a sense of urgency instructing his fireteam to move with caution.…

    • 147 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Donald L. Niewyk’s fifth and sixth chapters both deal more with outside perspectives and outside reactions than it does with those who were persecuted. The fifth chapter, “Bystander Reactions,” offers four different arguments as to why bystanders acted they way they did during the Holocaust. The sixth chapter, “Possibilities of Rescue,” discusses three different viewpoints on what foreign governments could have done to prevent the Holocaust. These two chapters conclude Niewyk’s book The Holocaust and wrap up the final sequence of events surrounding the Holocaust and the camps.…

    • 1452 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    LONDON 13th December 2016— Cinesite revisited to the world of Harry Potter, delivering just under 100 VFX shots including environments of prohibition-era Manhattan, set extensions and the creation of a magical dinner. Cinesite worked on all eight of the Harry Potter movies. Supervisor, Andrew Morley led the team alongside CG Supervisor, Steve Moncur and Compositing Supervisor, Helen Newby.…

    • 630 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Grant is asking four men if he could see Jefferson and speak to him. These four white men who have decided to have complete control over how the rest of Jefferson’s life is going to go. Four white men that have decided that they are better and superior to Grant because of their skin color, despite the fact that Grant is an educated man who teaches, which is respectable. In fact, they think that they’re so much more superior than Grant that they kept him waiting for two and a half hours. Even after the blatant disrespect they showed Grant, he is still debating how to treat this discussion. Grant chose to act like the teacher he is, which was very smart. He showed that he was a teacher through his speech, how he formed sentences, his word choice,…

    • 298 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Elizabeth C. Stanton was born in Johnston, New York. As a lawyer, Stanton’s father did not have a need for slaves thus creating the anti-slavery sentiment. Stanton was informed of the abolitionist, and women’s rights movements through her cousin, Gerrit Smith. Furthermore, her husband Henry Stanton was a lawyer who dedicated his knowledge to reforms present in the mid 19th century. Being surrounded by reformers had a great impact on Elizabeth C. Stanton as she used her knowledge from Willard’s Troy Female Seminary to further become a women’s rights activist.…

    • 143 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The question of should the United States seek to remain the “indispensable” country? Creates discussions for former U.S. Senator Hilary Clinton and published scholar and fellow member of the Cato Institute, Ted Galen Carpenter. Each orator discusses their position with reasons supporting their stance on the matter.…

    • 1528 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The two pieces of writing from Sheingold and Polleta both analyze how law can play a role in advancing rights claims in public policy.…

    • 416 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Woody Holton uses several supporting arguments from this chapter to prove the main argument. How the Indians threatened to combine forces with all the Indians tribes to the west of the colonies to unify against the expansion of the Americans into the land they have controlled for many years before the first explorers. However, Holton points out one piece of land that ties specifically to the main topic of debate between the colonists and the Indians, which was an important piece of land for many Indian tribes. That land was where Kentucky lies presently, In the 1760’s Kentucky was the principal hunting ground both for the Cherokees (7,200 people) and for the Upper Ohio Valley nations: the Mingos (600), Shawnees (1,800), and Delawares (3,500)…

    • 304 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    No, I don’t agree with the sentencing because had the judge given the message sentence, that may cause Sandusky grounds for another appeal on the maximum punishment for the numbers of years that he’s already going to serve. The sentence that Sandusky received assures that he will never walk the streets again. The sentence is based on the person and the crime. Given Sandusky age, the sentence is long enough even he was able to walk in general population that would be his death sentence as well.…

    • 87 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Imagine you're a 15 year old boy. You have been out all day, with your friends, or something that would make a great dinner time story for your family. You then come home to find you mother, father tied to chairs, and murdered. Afterwards you walk into another room to see your little sister and little brother, brutally murdered. Sounds like everyone's worst nightmare, but in this case it is one boys reality. Charlie Otero was in 10th grade when he discovered his family in his own home had been strangled to death. It was January 5th 1974 when we lost Julia Otero(the mother), Joseph(the father), Joseph Jr.(brother), and Josephine(sister).The killer said “i derive sexual pleasure from killing.” The police also stated that they found seman at the…

    • 1704 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Elizabeth Stanton was very important in terms of women’s rights. The Passages “The Birthplace of Women’s” and “A Powerful Partnership” both talk about her. They Do talk about her help with women’s right differently. One talk about her and her friend Susan B. Anthony. The Other more talks about the actual Meeting.…

    • 271 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Sigmund Freud said it best when he said, “Every child at play behaves like a creative writer, in that he creates a world of his own, or, rather, rearranges the things of his world in a new way” (Pearson). Playtime is an activity that is constantly being eliminated or greatly reduced, in favor of more structured educational learning activities starting in kindergarten. Many educational facilities have reduced recess or play breaks in the daily, which can lead to the children becoming overwhelmed or act out, because they have not been able to express their energy. Many parents are simply too busy to be able to fully immerse themselves into playing with their children. Parents today are busier than ever and children are enrolled in a multitude of activities they are shuffled to. Often times, parents will believe that they need to provide a wide arrangement of enrichment activities to build up every skill and aptitude so that their child might become high achievers in both high-school and later on in college, and life…

    • 309 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In an effort to establish boundaries for the use of faith in argument, Locke offers descriptions of faith and reason as well as their proper usage. Although Locke believes both can be used to acquire knowledge it’s no secret that he places a strong preference on reason. So much so, that Locke regards all knowledge gained through faith alone as unreliable unless validated by reason.…

    • 257 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    I feel like the first sentence of Earl’s statement is true because those two-thirds of adolescent and adult usually start drinking at a young age. That would make it easier for them to get attached to alcohol . Having people take a written test just to get a drinking license could help but it wouldn’t help as much. I also think that stores would lose money because not everyone that drinks is going to have a drinking license. I disagree with Earl Rochester argument.…

    • 409 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays