Preview

Representative Democracy In America

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
925 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Representative Democracy In America
When the Founding Fathers began designing America’s government in 1787, one of their greatest fears was the possibility of the dumb majority using their power to pass uneducated and disastrous legislature. They feared “the mob”, the everyday citizens that had little schooling and knew almost nothing about politics. To avoid giving the voters too much power, a Representative-Democracy style government was created, a system where citizens would vote for a person or group to represent them in making legislature. Referendum votes bypass the politicians and ask for the people’s opinion directly- they are direct votes where the entire country is invited to vote on an issue, which give the people a chance for their voices to be heard. While a good …show more content…
But perhaps referendum votes aren’t the correct way to navigate imperative issues. Citizens elect politicians for a reason- people appoint experts into office with the expectation that they will vote in their constituents best interest. Trust in politicians has grown increasingly low, but even if representative democracy is flawed, it’s the government many countries have, and it functions better than a direct democracy/referendum style government would. Perhaps instead of reforming referendum voting, Washington should focus on improving legislature around politicians and the accountability of trustee voting. America has a constitutional referendum, which gives residents a chance to help set the precedent for morals in their country. In a New York Times article, Richard Ekins explores the necessity of referendum voting, writing, “In general, self-government should be by way of representative institutions. Still, there are times when it is reasonable for the legislature to put some question to the voters themselves for decision by way of a referendum, especially in relation to constitutional change. The constitutional referendum is a legitimate technique of representative democracy.”

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    Correct. The English nobility gained the most benefits from the Magna Carta, which established limitations on the power of the king.…

    • 2223 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Referendums can be exciting and engaging, but sometimes other means can influence and bias voters, as they are only people, so their true beliefs aren’t represented and then the whole referendum was pointless. For example, during the Northern Ireland Sovereignty Referendum, the leader of the SDLP organised a boycott and told the members to ignore the referendum.…

    • 941 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Contrary to this, referendums are ‘top down’ as the representatives still have the final say. It is argued that initiatives and referendums involve the general public as they are part of the decision making process which encourages direct democracy. This can be challenged, as the voter turnout if often below 50%. Therefore, the referendum or initiative is not truly representative of the public opinion. This could indicate that the result is lacking legitimacy and thus, not democratic in practice. Furthermore, the low turnout demonstrates initiatives and referendums are more democratic in theory than in practice, an example for this is the vote on proposition 8, the elimination of same sex marriages in the state of California. The proposition passed, with 52% voting for the band and 48% against the ban. Theoretically, this process is democratic however, the voter turnout was below 70% and the margin between the majority and minority was no more than 4%. Therefore, not a true majority vote and does not represent the view of the nation. As a result individual rights and civil liberties were taken so; initiatives are not democratic in…

    • 907 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    A referendum is a general vote by the electorate on a single political question, which has been referred to them for a direct decision. In the UK since 1975 there have been seven major referendums. The last being the Scottish independence that was only a few weeks ago on the 18th September. The result was a ‘NO’ to independence winning by 55% to 45%, with a turnout of 84.6%. To see if referendums should be used more widely in the UK the ‘Pros and Cons’, turnout rate and past successes will all be analysed.…

    • 1040 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    After an extensive review of ten articles, I have developed the following information: The President of the United States is not chosen due to popular vote, but rather due to the fact that the framers of the constitution created the Electoral College. Americans have questioned the system since its creation. (Uselton, 2008) The Electoral College was born due out of the the debate whether congress had the power to elect a president, or did the public’s national vote. One wonders if because we have such a democracy in place, does the American vote really count? Recently during the 2012 Presidential election, this researcher asked her husband if he had voted yet. He replied “yea, but who cares, it didn’t count anyway”. (W. K. Ellis, & M. J. Ellis, personal communication, November 13, 2012). It boggles the mind to think how many Americans think that and don’t even bother to get out and vote. I think as Americans we have lost our way in the political system. It is complex and difficult to understand. No longer do people gather at the barbershop to talk about politics and process. They spend their time watching sports on the big screen while waiting for their haircut. Poplar vote wins you nothing in the political arena; the big game takes place at the Electoral College. Let us start with the origins of our political system. The Electoral College was developed to assist in the debate of who…

    • 2317 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    I will discuss the concept of a Republic, also known as a Representative Democracy. The Openstax American Government textbook describes a Democracy as a political system in which people govern themselves (pg. 8). This system can come in the form of a Representative Democracy or a Direct Democracy. Direct Democracies are ones in which the citizens themselves participate directly in making laws (pg. 14). This type of government occurred in Ancient Athens. The United States Government, on the other hand, comes in the Representative Democracy form. This means that, instead of directly creating laws, the citizens choose representatives that do this for them (pg. 13). President Donald Trump is now one of those representatives. His job is to represent…

    • 405 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Congress Dbq

    • 683 Words
    • 3 Pages

    When citizens become faithless in the core principles of democracy, than that democracy will fail. The congress people have no role in enforcing their specific leaning on their thousands of constituents[Doc B]. It might be the case that legislators become overconfident in their abilities to be a free agent in terms of legislating. When legislators lose focus of the purpose of democracy, than America become more of an oligarch than it does a democracy. As JFK said, “[saying] f the people... would deny the obligation of a representative to be bound by every impulse of the electorate”[Doc A]. This is especially true in context in the context of a democracy. It becomes infinitely regressive for an elected official to disagree with the conclusion their constituents fall upon. This denies the autonomy of a whole population of concerned citizens to participate in the governmental system. The governmental system become corrupts when elected officials become the center of the political system. They say why not this change, then why agree with any other decision that the electorate has. This creates a dangerous system that would not be possible if the congress people were more directly tied to the decisions of the people who elected…

    • 683 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    American democracy is one of the very calm kinds of government in the world while it is a long way from ideal. The American democracy in which we exist has several strengths and weaknesses. Neither strengths or weaknesses out weigh one another, however it is important to have both due to the changing definitions. A democracy is a government that is run by the people. The politicians that we elect to run…

    • 1637 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Upon the founding of America, a great deal of pressure was placed onto the Founding Fathers to create a system in which the central government will not acquire too much power and the citizens will be well represented. A representative democracy was, overall, a more effective answer to the question of how to govern the new country rather than a direct democracy after seeing the effects that the Articles of Confederation created when too much of the power of the government was given to the people and their states. A stronger central government was needed without taking away the voice of the people, and that’s what was decided on. However, even though this way has proven to be the most effective way to govern a country, it has its flaws within the system. Corruption finds its way through the system in ways of interest groups and political parties. This system is not immune to factions nor the effect of those factions, and those effects often make their way to important matters within the government.…

    • 292 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Citizens believe that their one vote does not really matter or make a real difference, and they are basically correct.…

    • 606 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    In other words, the votes of some are 15 times more powerful than the votes of others. Loenen makes note that the purpose (of the right to vote) cannot be less than to guarantee to citizens their full democratic rights in the government of the country and the provinces” (Loenen, 1997). He also mentions that such a fundamental right must not be diluted for some citizens by giving greater weight to the vote of others (Loenen, 1997). The court seems to be unaware that plurality electoral system regularly produces majority governments from a minority of the…

    • 900 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    A referendum is a general vote on a singular political question which requires a ‘yes’ or ‘no’ vote on the particular issue. The first argument against referendums consists of the idea that unless there is a high overall turnout, the results are dubious and do not represent the whole community or country. The 2011 Wales referendum on the issue of giving the Welsh Assembly primary legislative powers only gained a 35% turnout. The effect of this can lead to many situations; firstly, it shows the lack of support and therefore lack of power to the current governing party which in turn leads to doubts regarding the Prime Ministers authority and its government. Regarding the example above, Welsh Lib Dem leader Kirsty Williams said that the low turnout was somewhat of a ‘wake-up call for the current politicians.’ Secondly, the low turnout may not be due to the lack of care of the people; however, it could be due to lack of advertisement and campaigning. This could then lead to tensions in the country as a decision has been made questioningly ‘by the people’ when in fact they simply did not know the facts. Therefore, referendums should not be used.…

    • 466 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In today’s society voting and our government is an abundance of the reason we have conflict within our country. Voting is a way to voice your opinion on whom you feel would do the best job at running our country. It is important to vote because it allows you to have a say in our future government, and how our country is going to be led. Many citizens in today’s time era, criticize our government and country. If these citizens did not voice their voting, then they can not criticize the way our government is run.…

    • 424 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the beginning of the chapter, we are told what is power, in the political sense, and who has the authority to use it. There are two different understandings of democracy: direct democracy (the rule of many) and representative democracy. The US government uses representative democracy, everyone is given their own power, even if it's as minimal as voting for a leader to represent you. The Framers of the Constitution believed a direct democracy would lead to people following the popular opinion instead of the common good for the nation.…

    • 332 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The United States Constitution has endured as a covenant between the government and the people of the union for hundreds of years, evolving with the changes from culture to industry. As a result, the true origins have become misconstrued to the people. Common citizens allot credit to the great John Locke for philosophies regarding the earliest influences of the colonial ideals of government; however no sole contributor created the fire that started for American liberty and relationship to a new government (11). Another misconception lies within the idea that American democracy exercised and established in the Constitution lives as a derivation from Greek and Roman ideals, yet many European philosophers and politicians such as Montesquieu provoked…

    • 1555 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays