Preview

Richard Manning's 'Polyface Farm': Article Analysis

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1111 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Richard Manning's 'Polyface Farm': Article Analysis
According to the International Food Policy Research Institute, the harsh reality is that the world needs to produce more food with fewer resources. In terms of the amount of energy currently being used by agriculture, there needs to be a balance of conserving energy while recognizing that in order to feed the growing population a great amount of energy will need to be utilized. The general public, intensely depends on the least difficult, yet the best approach to deliver sustenance for the greatest number of individuals as they can. As a result of that reason, unless a more straightforward method for cultivating tags along, it is unclear if changes will be made. Richard Manning focuses more on the inefficiencies that the agriculture industry …show more content…
Polyface Farm is all about practicing complexity how one change has implications or impact on other parts. On Polyface Farm, the animals do some of the work for the farmers, by doing this the farmers save a great amount of money on fertilizers, pesticides, parasites, and antibiotics. Like stated above, Polyface farm is all about efficiency. Pollan claims that the workers at Polyface Farm, “take advantage of each species’ natural proclivities in a way that not only benefits that animal but other species as well” (348). For example, they use the cow’s manure, which is rich in nitrogen, for a heat source in the winter and when spring comes along they use it as a food source for the pigs. “In an ecological system like this everything’s connected to everything else, so you can’t change one thing without changing ten other things” (347). Everything works in a loop at this specific farm, everything is so connected. Pollan’s thoughts on turning into a monoculture farm are that since everything is so connected it would be nearly impossible to find the start or the end of anything to begin the …show more content…
Monoculture farming has been the utmost efficient form of farming for years. Pollan elaborates on the meaning of efficiency by saying, “how you choose to measure efficiency makes all the difference, and industrial agriculture measures it, simply, by the yield of one chosen species per acre of land or farmer” (348). He looks at the word efficiency from a different point of view; he claims that the word efficacy by definition is “the very opposite of simplification” (348). Polyface Farm’s main objective is all about “mimicking relationships found in nature and layering one farm enterprise over another on the same base of land” (348). In order to measure efficiency, according to Pollan, the cost of the pesticides, fertilizers, antibiotics, and parasites need to also be included in the production cost, not just the end products that are being produced. The meaning of efficiency for Richard Manning is not quite the same as the one for Michael Pollan. Manning’s way to deal with settling the issues that agriculture finds a way to farm that is organic and using the least amount of energy. The kind of adequacy that Pollan discusses depends more on the essence of the nourishment created, and cash and assets being spared. The kind of viability that is centered around the industry today is how much and how rapidly our food is produced and

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Pollan provides a base for the purpose of his noted dilemma by providing history, data and background information in three chapters titled “The Plant”, “The Farmer”, and finally “The Elevator”; providing a detailed argument that today’s food production is very un-natural in what was once a very natural process.…

    • 374 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    After reading The Omnivore’s Dilemma CH 8-10 by Michael Pollan, he mainly talks about the organic farms and the importance of grass in farming. Joe Salatin uses many modern technologies and many biological ways to create a natural ecosystem. In Polyface Farm, there are many species of animals and plants, and the fresh grass is all over around which makes the farm more natural. The reason why Salatin consider himself as a “grass farmer” is that the grass has a high status in Salatin’s farm, which is one of the main factors that make the high quality of this farm. The industrial farm setting includes “a great machine, transforming inputs of seed and fossil energy into outputs of carbohydrate and protein” (Pollan 130). In the other hand, the industrial farm makes everything perform like a machine, which makes the food become not natural any more in the process of producing food. Comparing the Salatin’s farm to the big organic farms, Salatin gets a different farming system, less trading, healthy soils and localized transport. In contrast to the Naylor’s farm, Salatin’s farm seems that he intends to make a more natural crop farming system, and he makes diversified species which keeps the balance of the ecology. I think that it is better to get a small-scale organic farming, which provides the high quality food; however, the requirement of the organic food is much higher than the outputs of the small-scale organic farming so that…

    • 492 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Not only this, but “the farmers profit margin dropped from 35% in the 1950 's to about 9% today.” (Mckibben, 54) This means that “to generate the same income as it did in 1950, a farm today would need to be roughly four times as large.” (Mckibben, 55) As a result of this perpetual growth and centralization, problems like “huge sewage lagoons, miserable animals, vulnerability to sabotage and food-born illness”(mckibben, 61) have become commonplace. Not only this, but “we are running out of the two basic ingredients we need to grow food on an industrial scale: oil and water.” (Mckibben, 62) The situation has become so dire that “we are now facing a near simultaneous depletion of the underground aquifers which have been responsible for the unsustainable, artificial inflation of food production.” At this point of realization, Mckibben begins indulging the reader in a large number of facts that promote a more localized form of farming as the solution to a seemingly endless number of issues. Initially the point is raised that “sustainable agriculture leads to a 93% increase in per-hectare food production.” (Mckibben, 68) The next idea raised is that, “since World War 1, it has been cheaper to use…

    • 3032 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Meagan Flynn’s article “The Promise of Indoor, Hurricane-Proof “Vertical” Farms,” published in The Atlantic, she explains a new type of farm that is emerging. She uses Federico Marques’s farm as her main example of these new farms. She explains that they are vertical farms, “where plants are stacked in trays on shelves, instead of laid out horizontally across larger plots of land. In these high-tech structures, plants don’t rely on sunlight or soil, rainwater or pesticides, but LED lights and minerals instead” (Flynn). Next, Meagan tells the reader of the benefits of vertical farms: they save space, are a more economical way of producing food, and reduce the costs of getting food to the people.…

    • 551 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    McKibben’s main argument is that there needs to be a basic shift in American economical thinking. We need to focus on building local economies and restrengthening the agricultural infrastructure that used to be in place in every city and village before the fever of efficiency took over the United States. As an experiment while writing “Deep Economy”, McKibben and his family pledged to eat local for an entire winter. As he and his family reside in Vermont, this presented somewhat of a challenge. One his reasons for this experiment was to find out what a “truly local economy might feel like” (p.47). Through his research, and his experiences while conducting this novel experiment, McKibben discovered some interesting things. One of these things is that the rate of growth for local farmers’ markets and community-supported agriculture farms, or CSAs, is steadily increasing in every corner of the country. Indeed, farmers’ markets are the fastest-growing part of our food economy (p.3). For instance, the most urban county in Vermont had a 19% increase in the number of farms in 2005 (p.82). In fact, there are urban farms emerging in every corner of the globe. An obvious benefit to small-scale farming is that smaller farms produce more food per acre, while using far less oil. While it is true that small-scale farming is much more labor intensive, it seems like a natural progression when so many people are currently unemployed. Small-scale…

    • 1846 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Section Two Pollan brings to light organic foods and the difference between mass produced and local farms. He exaggerates, he describes grass as it is capable of becoming something else. Page 126 “End of season Grasses transformed into 25,000 pounds beef, 50,000 pounds pork, 12,000 broilers, 800 turkeys, 500 rabbits, and 30,000 dozen eggs.” All this is within 100 acres of pasture and it comes to show that grass truelt feeds many and all that feeds…

    • 867 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Much of Pollan's argument is not even really about food. He repeatedly takes his argument to energy. Fossil fuel is mentioned 15 times, energy 19 times. The current agriculture system may rely on cheap energy and Pollan wrote that cheap energy will disappear. He was wrong, seven years later cheep energy can still be counted on.…

    • 474 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The following chapter delves into the principles of organic farming and their various implementations in modern America. Pollan shows that as organic food has grown in popularity, its producers have adopted many of the methods of industrial agriculture, while losing sight of the organic movement's anti-industrial roots. A meal prepared from ingredients purchased at Whole Foods represents this food chain at the table. As a study in contrast, Pollan visits a small-scale organic farm, where natural conditions are adhered to as closely as possible, very few artificial inputs are used, and waste products are recycled back into the system. He then prepares a meal using only local produce from small-scale organic farmers.…

    • 615 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Eaarth

    • 630 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Monoculture is mainly used in industrialized agriculture with many inputs of fossil fuels and chemicals to produce large amounts of a single crop. Polyculture is often locally based, and may be found in a subsistence agriculture practice that uses human and animal energy to produce smaller amounts of many different crops. Polyculture and working with nature can provide many and more sustainable solutions to our current challenges, and that in diversifying the food economy we will be much more resilient to future shocks. In doing so we can also reduce our…

    • 630 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Omnivore Dilemma

    • 420 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In the chapter Grass Pollan wants to find out about organic food , and that he did. He went to California to do research when he arrived to California didn’t find an organic farm he found a industrial farm labeled as an organic farm . The fact of the matter is the organic farms are not much different from industrial farms and Pollan proves this in this chapter.…

    • 420 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    The rise of AFOs and other innovative agricultural systems have left a large stain on the environment as a whole. Their many negative side effects have caused serious set backs to organisms and land as we know it. After reading the novel Empty Pastures by Terance Centner, these negative side effects were brought into the light for the public to see. The many issues brought up include contamination of water and soil, pesticide use, animal welfare, and the economic effects on rural communities. With deep background roots in the traditional farming culture, Centner begins each chapter speaking of his childhood allowing for the reader to grasp an idea of his personal upbringing and the effect it has on his thoughts when writing this novel. He…

    • 1143 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Term Paper

    • 472 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In “All Flesh Is Grass,” Michael Pollan moves on from his investigation of America’s industrial food chain and looks into alternative models…

    • 472 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Botany of Desire

    • 631 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The Botany of Desire relates to the topic of photosynthesis. Pollan states that while humans were “learning to walk on two feet”, plants were “inventing photosynthesis and perfecting organic chemistry…” (xx). According to Pollan, a reason for the need for photosynthesis was immobility. Pollan explains that due to “perfecting” photosynthesis, plants were able to design chemicals for defense against predators, which then solved the problem of immobility. The practice of monoculture is also discussed in the book. Monoculture may be economically beneficial, but it can bring serious environmental risks. The growing of multiple varieties of a single crop increases the chance that if one fails, another will have the genetic traits that allow it to thrive. Monoculture also forces the identical plants to be vulnerable to pests and disease. The use of pesticides can be reduced by maintaining pest resistance through biodiversity. Pollan acknowledges those who argue for protecting crops by giving them genes from other organisms; this is known as genetic engineering. Today, many crops like corn and soybeans are genetically engineered.…

    • 631 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    It is true that using nonorganic farming methods makes food in larger quantities, and more…

    • 635 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Clearly factory and free range farming systems have positive and negative aspects about them. Also clearly it is certain that free range farms are better for the animals in many ways. But, it is also evident that free range farms produce food products that are more costly than that produced on factory…

    • 554 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays