Preview

Ring Of Gyges Analysis

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
642 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Ring Of Gyges Analysis
The Ring of Gyges The " Ring of Gyges " is a short story from Plato ‘ s book, The Republic, written around the fifth century, B.C. Plato believed in an absolute truth and a greater good in mankind, " Ring of Gyges " is a parable told by Glaucon, who retained a more cynical view on us as humans. Glaucon's argument is all people, given the chance to do wrong without consequence, will always do just that. He has no faith in man's desire to do good, or act in a ‘just" manner. This excerpt from the mentioned book, is a conversation between Plato and Glaucon, Glaucon does most of the talking, telling his story of the shepherd from Lydia.
In the "Ring of Gyges", Glaucon tells of a shepherd, named Gyges, who was under the service of the king of Lydia. One day while Gyges was tending the flock, a great earthquake came and made an opening in the earth where he happened to be standing. His curiosity led him into the hole, where he is met by many marvels, including the resting place of what he refers to as, a god-like king. Gyges spots and removes a ring from the finger of the dead body lying in this crater, and then climbs back to the surface of the earth. Once back on solid ground he
…show more content…
In the beginning of the story, Gyges removes the ring from the hand of a dead man, what he perceives as a god-like king. It strikes me odd that this is a parable of someone who is "just" becoming "unjust" in the presence of immunity, when clearly this man is a thief to begin with! Gyges obviously thought the deceased something due respect, he refers to it both as "more than human" and a "body of stature", yet he stole the ring anyway. Although there may be some gray areas in unique situations, I believe those who are just because of sincere and stable beliefs and not because of compromised laws, will almost always remain just in the face of injustice. I understand people to be complex beings, capable of choice and change, good and

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    In Plato’s Republic, many stories are used as allusions and metaphors to describe the issues being discussed. One of these stories is in chapter two and is known as the “Ring of Gyges.” This story has many similarities to the Ring of Power in The Lord of The Rings saga, which also grants the ability to turn invisible. In this essay, I will compare and contrast the “Ring of Gyges” and the events surrounding the Ring of Power in The Lord of the Rings trilogy.…

    • 160 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    First consider the character of Gilgamesh. Do you think his character and actions are to be emulated, or pitied? Depending on how you feel about Gilgamesh on the whole, please respond…

    • 315 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Indeed in the Odyssey, there are examples of people breaking the law of the Gods, for example Tityus in Book 11. He was left with vultures ‘plucking at his liver [...] whilst his hands were powerless to drive them off.’ This was due to the fact that he had assaulted one of Zeus’ partners; therefore it seems fair that Odysseus takes revenge in a similar fitting manner. Indeed, for at least some of the suitors, the punishment seems to fit the crime. Rather fittingly, the first to be killed was the leader of the suitors, Antinous. He was killed in a manner which does seem appropriate, as he reached ‘for his fine cup to take a draught of wine’, he was killed with a spear by Odysseus. As Antinous had broken the rules of xenia and lived a lavish lifestyle from Odysseus’ keep, it seems fair that he be killed. As well as this, the third suitor, Amphinomus, is killed when ‘Telemachus hit[s] him from behind, midway between the shoulders, with a spear.’ As this was a prophecy by Athene, it certainly does seem fitting that this prophecy be fulfilled by Odysseus. Prior to this, the second suitor to be killed was the right hand man of Antinous, Eurymachus. He attempts to talk his way out of death, which is ironic as he often used his cunning tongue to escape from situations and…

    • 811 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    After line 60, it states that “Gilgamesh, in his arrogance and superior strength, abuses his subjects…” surprised me. Up until that moment, I thought Gilgamesh was perfect. I believed that he made no mistakes, never messed anything up. However, that statement completely threw me off. It was interesting to go back and read it all over again with understanding that Gilgamesh was not as perfect as I thought he was.…

    • 365 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Gilgamesh is a boundary pusher. From the first tablet, it is clear that he holds himself in high regard, with little consideration of his subjects. As king, he has completely destroyed the boundaries by taking advantage of his “all powerful” position. With little prior knowledge of this civilization, it would be easy to assume that this behavior was a standard means of rulers demonstrating their dominance; however, the citizens express their concerns to the gods- even calling him a “savage wild bull” (Tablet 1 80). Therefore, Gilgamesh’s tyranny is clearly not the norm. After years of sacrificing warriors and raping wives, he has pushed the boundaries with his people so far that there is nothing else left. Naturally, when he hears of a “journey…

    • 172 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Myth of Gilgamesh Analysis

    • 1501 Words
    • 7 Pages

    As the story unfolds, we begin to see Gilgamesh more as a villain than a hero. For example, Gilgamesh “does whatever he wants, takes the son from his father and…

    • 1501 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Why Does Gilgamesh Change

    • 744 Words
    • 3 Pages

    the gods are angry with Gilgamesh and send down an equal of himself, they send…

    • 744 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the tale “The ring of Gyges” the shepherd Gyges finds a magical ring within unusual bronze horse. Using this ring, he entices the queen and they collaborate to murder the king and takes control of the kingdom. Given his tale, Glaucon come to a conclusion that if similar rings were to be given to unjust man and a just man, then both of them would behave unjustly. Therefore this proves that people act justly only as an obligation by nature and he claims that all living beings aspire more than what they are actually due. This story remains vital to the society today because it covers what we can expect humans to do with authority over others. I do concur with this simile because, for instance, in politics, we give authority to others, expecting that they will do what is right. We better then, watch out because anyone who acquires power without accountability is culpable to use it unjustly. This portrays a negative image in our society as it is a vice for persons to act unjustly to others and can only…

    • 891 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The Epic of Gilgamesh, suggests that the people of Mesopotamia expect their rulers to be strong, heroic, fearless, unselfish, and godly. Gilgamesh is said to be two-thirds god and one-thirds human, is described as being “strong, stately, and wise” and several times throughout the epic as “accomplished in strength”. However, not everyone sees the ruler as being great. Many believe that Gilgamesh exhibits many good characteristics but lacks generosity. The nobles at the beginning of the epic are one of those peoples who complain because Gilgamesh is acting tyrannically. They suggest that although they like how Gilgamesh is heroic and godly, they would like someone more democratic to be their ruler. In one part of the epic, Gilgamesh defeats…

    • 167 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Ring of Gypes

    • 340 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The story of “The Ring of Gyes” says justice is what we created base on what we think is moral, because we would rather throw out our ability to wrong others, than be wronged by others. For the example which Plato mentions in the metaphor, if both two people have a ring can make them invisible, no matter one is just and the other is unjust they would have the same results of using the ring because the justice is how we think we should judge the others. In reality, morality is like a pair of shackle, it imprisons human’s desire. Once the shackle is removed, our desire will become wild. In fact, law is the justice which we made for us to be self-restraint. Morality is a tool for human to prevent from harmful, but if there is an opportunity, people would not want to be ethical for morality.…

    • 340 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Gilgamesh Hero Cycle

    • 516 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Throughout Gilgamesh’s journey many people told him to give up a lot of people tried to let him down and told him to give up. An example of a trial is when Gilgamesh tied rocks to his ankles and went to the bottom of the ocean to get the Plant Of Life. Gilgamesh gave the Plant Of Life to the elders and a couple of weeks later snakes ate the plant. This is a trial because Gilgamesh nearly died for getting this plant and it ended up getting eaten by snakes.…

    • 516 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The author of Gisli’s Saga is very assertive in his support for the new society, including Christianization and a unified national identity, but remains openly sympathetic to the old ways, as well. This same contradiction, a desire to end the vengeance system, while maintaining nostalgia for it, is played out in the lengthy pursuit of Gisli. The hunt for Gisli is drawn-out, and results in multiple senseless deaths. As years pass and many people die, the saga’s author seems to be saying that this method of resolving conflict is ineffective and immoral. “Gisli said to Eyjolf: ‘By my will, you will never earn anything more than the sixty ounces of silver you have taken on my head...you will be disgraced for losing so many men’” (Johnston and Foote 58). Nonetheless, the author also admires Gisli, showing how craftily he avoids capture. His ingenuity, ranging from switching capes…

    • 2585 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    When the story, Gilgamesh, first begins the character is extremely arrogant, self-centered, and cruel. His friendship with Enkidu softens Gilgamesh into being a better person, yet their companionship makes him stronger and a better person. Before the friendship, Gilgamesh did not consider anyone else’s feelings and treated them as cruelly as he could for his amusement. Before Enkidu, no one in the kingdom had ever stood up to Gilgamesh, and he obviously had never been told no. A good example is Gilgamesh having sex with any woman that he wanted even brides on their wedding night and not thinking anything was morally wrong with that. Before Enkidu Gilgamesh had never cared about anyone or anything and he was the first person that he cared…

    • 304 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    bullying on Uruk society.This circumstances are stated in Tablet 1 line 70, by day and by nigth his tyranny grows. People of Uruk implore to the goddess Aruru to solve Gilgamesh's tyranny inUruk. Aruru respond prays creating the new sort of creature which is equall strength with Gilgamesh,Enkidu. In this circumstanece, people of Uruk appeal Aruru because they…

    • 882 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Nursing Journal Entry

    • 1005 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The second week of my preceptorship brought many new experiences for me, and I can honestly say that each day I spend with my preceptor is better than the last. This week I focused on time management of a full patient load with continued documentation practice as well as admission and discharge procedures. I’ve had brief experiences in my past rotations assisting with discharge teaching and admission assessments however I have never been able to fully take charge and complete the process from start to finish, so this was a great learning opportunity for me.…

    • 1005 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays