Preview

Security Theater By Bruce Schneier

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1783 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Security Theater By Bruce Schneier
There is a thin line dividing genuine security from staged countermeasures done to pacify the public. Living in a modern society where technology made it possible to do almost anything, how are we to know which security measures are real or not?
Security is both a feeling and a reality, and they're different. You can feel secure even though you're not, and you can be secure even though you don't feel it. A renowned expert of Security Theater, Bruce Schneier coined the term “Security Theater”. This term refers to security measures that make people feel or have the illusion of being more protected without doing anything to actually improve their security. It is a show that agencies put on to make it look like they are doing a lot to protect us
…show more content…
These measures are only effective if we happen to guess what the next terrorists are planning. If we spend billions defending our rail systems, and the terrorists bomb a shopping mall instead, we've wasted our money. If we concentrate airport security on screening shoes and confiscating liquids, and the terrorists hide explosives in their brassieres and use solids, we've wasted our money. Terrorists don't care what they blow up and it shouldn't be our goal merely to force the terrorists to make a minor change in their tactics or targets. It just makes that person feel safer. But, is the illusion of feeling safer any good? Schneier noted that “The feeling of security isn’t worth it for one has to give up essential freedoms and privacies to get it.” Also, it is certainly dangerous to present the aluminous security when the system is actually quite vulnerable to …show more content…
It can cost money, time, concentration, freedoms and so on. It can come at the cost of reducing the things we can do. Most of the time security theater is a bad trade-off, because the costs far outweigh the benefits. But there are instances when a little bit of security theater makes sense.
We make smart security trade-offs -- and by this I mean trade-offs for genuine security -- when our feeling of security closely matches the reality. When the two are out of alignment, we get security wrong. Security Theater is no substitute for security reality, but, used correctly, Security Theater can be a way of raising our feeling of security so that it more closely matches the reality of security. It makes us feel more secure buying over-the-counter medicines, going to malls and flying on airplanes -- closer to how secure we should feel if we had all the facts and did the math correctly.
Of course, too much security theater and our feeling of security becomes greater than the reality, which is also bad. And others -- politicians, corporations and so on -- can use security theater to make us feel more secure without doing the hard work of actually making us secure. That's the usual way security theater is used, and why I so often malign

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    Before the attacks on September 11, 2001, the United States’ government was relatively weak in terms of its tactics in response to terrorism. Overall, no matter what people have to say in the country’s defence, the fact is that it was a much easier target compared to how it is today. There were not as many stringent regulations in place that would normally stop potential terrorists from making a move, nor were there any efforts to actually catch them in action right before such a drastic event occurred. But if the country was as protected as it is today, the attacks would not have occurred. And now, the reason there are so many rules and regulations in place is in response to them.…

    • 1254 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The author also explains that involving the people would be critical since presuming their submissiveness risks creating resentment and lack of cooperation over time. It is important to make the people to understand the appropriateness of security measures to increase their willingness to collaborate to achieve security goals. Further, the author advocates for opening up of homeland security work to avoid working in secrecy and involve the private sector and the general public. The author sees the move to insulate information from the public as undermining the defense of critical…

    • 872 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Case 2 Harley Davidson

    • 467 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Harley Davidson is an American build and recognized name; they leaded the way for future entrants. Harley-Davidson strong American brand and have dedicated clients that will continue the motorcycle trend. Based on the information in this case, I can’t be reasonably sure that the United States had a comparative advantage in producing motorcycles. If it were, then the U.S would produce the bikes at a lower opportunity cost than Japan. If the United States no longer has a comparative advantage in producing motorcycles, there should be a tariff and quotas to be imposed to ensure the survival of the U.S motorcycles. The Japanese are accustom to competition, and they can excel in product innovation; this is why they can keep their prices low.…

    • 467 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In the United States, the safety and protection of the American people has always been a primary ideal of the United States government. In the past five years, new technology has emerged that has aided the government in ensuring this ideal. In the novel 1984, by George Orwell, Orwell uses a dystopian society to portray a government which utilizes technology and procedures to make it seem like they are protecting the citizens, but in reality is generating fear to control and have complete power over the people. In modern America, the government has been accused of similar actions and procedures. However, the United States government does not have the same intentions. Given the domestic and international threats present, heightened security like security cameras in schools as well as other public grounds and the Transportation Security Administration (TSA) are used solely for the protection and preservation of the liberty of the American people.…

    • 1973 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The primary purpose of this essay is to critique the United States homeland security system and its capabilities to meet both the new issues and future challenges. Besides, this exposition will address and analyze the existing efforts of apparent dichotomy that are crucial to homeland security on one hand while maintaining civil liberties on the other side.…

    • 959 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    We are told by our leaders that there are trade-offs when considering our security; that in order to create a secure America we must give up some freedoms and rules of our democracy for the protection of all. Homeland security involves many factors it does decrease civil liberties and individual freedoms and it totally increases governmental power; a thing ends its impossible to construct a counterterrorist system that ensures complete protection, allows for maximum civil liberty, and protects unrestricted freedoms of movement matter of fact the government is sacrificing some of its own branches to place more authority within one for each, the executive branch (White, Jonathan, 2006).…

    • 1830 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In this year's presidential campaign election over one billion dollars will be spent on campaigning .Some candidates who drop out have spent around 4 times as much as the candidates who are still in the race. At the same time many of the candidates preach government spending and how to fix the nation's debt. Our nation is in about 20 trillion dollars in debt so why are we spending so much on our campaigns .The United States of America is the country with their most debt…

    • 248 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    We need to remember that the government has advanced the security of our nation for the safety of its citizens. Airports have had one of the largest changes to their security. Before 9-11 the only security was a metal detector.“Due to events that have occurred such as the terrorist who attempted to blow up an airliner with explosive chemicals in his underwear” (How Has National Security Changed Since). We as America have changed the security. Now when you go into an airport you are scanned patted down and your luggage is searched. The changes that have been made to our national security have helped to protect the lives of innocent people of the United…

    • 528 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    International Relations

    • 2065 Words
    • 9 Pages

    Security can be defined as the ability to thwart internal and external threats of a nation (Lawson, 2003: 78). As a concept however this is a very broad term and within its broad term lies why it has become a contested concept even in this post-cold war era. The IR theories – especially the Realist and liberalist theories – shall be used in the following essay in unearthing the real issues behind security and why it remains the talk of this new era.…

    • 2065 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Is everything actually secure, or do they mislead us into false hope? The FBI, CIA, and our troops fight vigorously for our safety, but they are only human and cannot stop every crime. A national surveillance system in the government could stop actions before it happened. If violent crimes could be stopped before it happened, who wouldn’t jump to the cause? Millions of people could be living in peace. While security is important, some might reject being monitored because it is against their will. A surveillance system will know everything in people’s public lives and calculate every action. Private things will now turn into public business. If we were stubborn enough to reject an idea of a surveillance system, then we are letting the population die by violent hate crimes. The violence in our country will only grow in time, we must take action to stop it. We must be willing to sacrifice, believe, and fight for justice. There is no protection in the submission to crime. We must take action in the well-being of to nation. If it were to mean giving up some of our rights, it is for a worthy cause. Let’s stop crime and protect our beloved United…

    • 993 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Homeland Security: Necessary prevention or invasion of freedoms? “Our nation owes a debt of gratitude to the 9/11 Commission members for their valuable service and important recommendations to improve homeland security. ”-Jim Ramstad The United States has for a long time developed many agencies with many different purposes. Some agencies moderate currency while other handle law enforcement.…

    • 1324 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The TSA Incompetence

    • 1288 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Security theater means creating the illusion of security. For example, in an article by Bruce Schneier (2009), he reports that in the months after 9/11, National Guard Troops were stationed at airports, however, their guns did not have bullets (p. 1). One could suppose that having National Guard Troops stationed could scare terrorists, but what if a terrorist tried to attack them? The National Guard Troops would not be able to shoot them without bullets. Since there were not any bullets in the guns, then they did not intend to keep people safe if a threat arised. They tried to look as if they were keeping people safe. This instance is a perfect example of security theater. The deceitful practices of security theater can also be seen through experiences of people like Jeffrey Goldberg. Goldberg is a man who has experience with reporting terrorists. He also managed to sneak past many items through airline security that he should not have been able to do so. Goldberg (2008) recalls that due to his past with reporting terrorists, he has a collection of al-Qaeda T-shirts, Islamic Jihad flags, Hezbollah videotapes, and inflatable Yasir Arafat dolls. He managed to carry these items through various airport securities. In one screening, however, the TSA only took a pair of nail clippers, and in another screening, they took a can of shaving cream (p.1). Why would the TSA even take nail clippers? Yes, one could cut people with nail clippers, but even then, terrorists would probably try to hurt people with more dangerous items, would they not? Obviously, having a collection of Al-Qaeda T-shirts should make anyone seem suspicious, yet the TSA let him through. This shows that the TSA is bad at its job. They are just there for show. Goldberg (2008) also claims that the training for a TSA officer is about a week (p. 1). If the TSA is supposed to stop threatening terrorist,…

    • 1288 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The concept of homeland security is not new; since the bloody birth of the United States in 1776, Americans have been engaged in securing and defending the homeland. However, the current manifestation of the expression Homeland Security was created in the crucible of modern terrorist attacks, most notably that of September 11, 2001. As Noftsinger, Newbold, and Wheeler (2007) note, today’s idea of homeland security was created in response to the increasing terrorist threat, when it was recognized that the increased terrorist threat could not be combatted through conventional means.…

    • 1332 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Homeland Security

    • 3491 Words
    • 14 Pages

    The security of the United States and living without being under a constant threat should be very important to all citizens and those who visit this country. The research revealed some interesting facts, it is impossible to secure every commercial building, airport, bridge, bypass, and government building. One element of the security is that terrorists will not have the ability to attack every place in the United States. However, everything is a possible target and terrorists want to do as damage as possible and cause the greatest amount of disruption in our way of life as possible.…

    • 3491 Words
    • 14 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    When athletes use performance enhancing drugs, it gives them an unfair advantage, and it ruins the spirit of competition. Imagine the athlete that has been dreaming of playing collegiately or even advancing so far as to go to the Olympics and win a medal. This athlete may do whatever it takes to achieve their childhood dreams. “Most serious athletes will tell you that the competitive drive to win can be fierce”(Mayo Clinic Staff 1) and because of that “the use of performance-enhancing drugs has become increasingly common” (1). Sports are one of America’s great pastimes. Athletes want to be outstanding and make a name for themselves. One way athletes can get a boost in their performance is by utilizing performance enhancing drugs. These…

    • 382 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays