It is also suggested that those who object to a draft could opt out. “Those who
It is also suggested that those who object to a draft could opt out. “Those who
for who was sending them out to danger. It was thought that as long as soldiers were drafted…
David W. Barno writes in “A New Moral Compact,” about the current problem of having a volunteer military. He writes about the current war the United States is in as well as, previous wars like the Vietnam War. Barno’s main issue is that the population has distanced itself from the military and are less skeptical about going to war. He proposes, “. . .that every use of military force over 60 days would automatically trigger an annual draft lottery to call up 10,000 men and women” (20). Barno believes this will draw the population closer to the war effort eventually, becoming hesitant about going to war. Barno states, “It has also effectively lowered our national threshold for decisions to conduct military operations or go to war” (17). As war…
• Reasons men would not enlist would be they would have a big chance of dying, it’s not the adventure they are looking for or expecting and the government service is…
Therefore Barno sees that the public eye needs to be more aware on the situation with the cost of human’s lives being placed on a daily base. To do this he comes up with a plan to make the public see a bigger picture. He proposes by “Every use of military force over 60 days would automatically trigger an annual draft lottery to call up 10,000 men and women.” This move would ensure that the use of every military solider being used would be replaced with some in the lottery draft. This move would cause unwelcome events in the lives of the people who are drafted.…
Young men fight and die for their country in every single war, and Vietnam was no different. However, U.S. forces during the Vietnam War, on average, were the youngest in American history. In previous wars many men in their twenties were drafted for military service, and men of that age and older would often volunteer. During the Vietnam War most of the volunteers and draftees were teenagers; the average age was nineteen. In World War II, the average American soldier was twenty-six years old. At the age of eighteen young men could join or be drafted into the army. At seventeen, with the consent of a guardian, boys could enlist in the Marine Corps. At the beginning of the war, hundreds of seventeen year old marines served in Vietnam. However, in November 1965, the Pentagon ordered that all American troops must be eighteen before being deployed in the war zone. The soldiers sent off to Vietnam can be divided into three categories: one-third draftees, one-third draft-motivated volunteers, and one-third true volunteers. As the war continued, the number of volunteers steadily declined. Almost half of the army troops were draftees, and in the combat units the portion was commonly as high as two-thirds; late in the war it was even higher. These were the majority of the people dying in the war, from 1966 to 1969, the percentage of draftees who died in the war doubled from 21 to 40. Those who could avoid the draft legally through deferments were the upper class, while those in the middle and lower class who didn’t want to fight in the war had to figure out ways to avoid the draft. Because the draft threatened middle and lower class males between the ages of 18 to 35, they united together through protests to oppose the draft by burning draft cards.…
Have you ever taken the time to think about how you feel about the draft? Do you feel it is the government’s right to tell you to serve in the military? In times of war there is always the possibility of a draft. Drafting for military purpose has dated back to the Thirteen Colonies and could still be used today. Although it has been in existence for a very long time the draft has been used in 5 major wars: the Civil War, World War I, World War II, the Korean War and again for the Vietnam War.…
If the draft is brought back, the military would obviously never be weak in terms of numbers. Also, despite the increased wage towards the support of troops, cost would be preserved from the savings of other budgets being cut. And last but not least, it is the duty of a U.S. citizen to defend their country when in need. The reinstatement of the draft would be a great benefit towards the country of the United States of America. This has created a large debate over a military draft. This topic of discussion has been contemplated and deliberated since military forces were created. There are two sides, those for and those against. The debate over the draft is endless. Many realistic points can be made from either side of the argument over the draft, but the most logical and simple solution is to reinstate the…
People that argue that the draft needs to be reestablished have a strong base for their commanding arguments. Some believe that serving in the military is a civil duty, and to live in this country one must defend it. That patriotism is illustrated in this quote by George Washington, "It must be laid down as a primary position and the basis of our (democratic) system, that every citizen who enjoys the protection of a free Government owes not only a proportion of his property, but even his personal service to the defence of it" (Gill). Although not completely relevant to events of today it still emphasizes the fact that we as Americans need to serve our country if we expect the government to serve us. As we, the United States, are at war, people believe that a draft is needed because our "Army is stretched so thin" (Means). An influx of new troops could possibly invigorate the war effort and allow us to pull our young men and women out of Iraq. To go hand in hand with the war in Iraq some seem to think that a draft would open our eyes. A quote in the Boston Globe reads, "Reinstate the military draft and see how quickly the United States ends its war in Iraq" (Vennochi). This again ties to a general concern of the well being of our men and women in arms.…
I do not agree with the reinstitution of a military draft. In 1973 the military draft was lifted in the United States and with good reason. The United States should not rely on a draft to fill military vacancies but rely on recruitment. It is true that the military offers incentives and luxuries that some civilians could not afford otherwise such as food, shelter, and medical care. However, they are just that, incentives. The military is an option and should remain that way. Many enlist for different reasons, some with economical reasons, others with strong political urges, but they enlist out of their own desires, beliefs, and more importantly, free will. Some see the military as a way of life; others see it as the only way to educate themselves in a society where education is valued so highly. With rising tuition costs, many enlist in the reserves as a guarantee for their degree. College is costly and even with the aid of tuition assistance and can leave a graduate drowning in debt. These are all choices all college bound 18-25 year olds make and some just do not have the luxury of choosing.…
My first reason that we should not have drafts is that it violates human rights. We have the right to serve and if we don't want to then we simply don't have to. If we where to have a draft then you would be forced to serve even if you don't want to. Drafts take away are freedom to…
The next generation, all volunteers, echoed Joe's opinion that well trained and well paid volunteers are much better suited to serve our nation in a military capacity. However, the younger men's opinion was that if a draft should ever again become necessary it must be universal by age and not by lottery. Furthermore, each one of them was adamant that there be no exemptions based on sex, religion, sexual preference or disability. Their opinion is based on the fact that they are educated regarding the social inequality and injustice that has governed the military conscription laws in the…
Despite the fact that there were previous war military drafts in the United States, the first peace draft was sanctioned by Congress in 1940. Later, the draft was deferred in 1973 when the United States transformed to an all-volunteer military and finally, through a Presidential Proclamation, draft registration requirement was dismissed in 1975 but later renewed in 1980. Currently, the Selective Service System, together with the draft registration and local draft panels, remains as a contingency should a military draft ever be necessary, but the country has no active military draft at this time. The military draft requires that almost all male U.S. citizens and foreign male living in the United States who are between 18 to 25 years register with the Selective Service (Tritten). The senate has the power to redefine the qualified persons as it deems suitable. Presently the excluded group of people are the men who are already serving on active military duty, certain institutionalized people, and other noncitizens. The general rule, according to Tritten, is that any male noncitizen who migrates into the United States before his 26th birthday must register with the Selective Service. The exempted ones are the men who live in the…
In an attempt to segregate “loyal” from “disloyal” men, the War Location Authority required the men to go through registration, in which they were given loyalty questionnaires. While some men found it easier to just fight in war, others resisted. Draft resister groups in multiple locations were formed, fighting together against the cruelty and unfairness of being drafted.…
All Through the Vietnam War, draft avoidance and resistance came to a peak, nearly crippling the Selective Service System. Joined with the rebellion inside the military and the greater civilian antiwar movement, draft resistance became yet another shackle on the government’s ability to wage a war in Vietnam, and brought the war home in a very personal way for a generation of young men. Many draft resisters filed for conscientious objector status, didn’t report for induction when called, or attempted to claim disability to preserve their rights while many others refused service to win the rights they were never given .…
The controversy surrounding the military draft has since its inception to its repeal in the nineteen-seventies; however the vitality of the draft remains because United States may need more than a volunteer army, it requires everyone to serve, and higher trained and educated people are needed to run new technology. The first reason is the military may need more than a volunteer army to defend the nation in a national emergency. In the U.S. constitution the government has the right the raise and maintains an army as long as the conflict is still going on. The draft was then repealed but is still in effect. The last reason the U.S. may need more than a volunteer army is because the United States may need it to maintain the security of the nation. The second reason the United States needs the draft is because everyone needs to serve their country. Every male eighteen to twenty-six must register for the draft because it is still a law even since it was repealed. It offers a lot of benefits to those who comply to the laws if the draft is used. There are very severe penalties for not registering at age eighteen. This may be considered not a draft even though they must register at eighteen. Not all American males will be drafted for many different reasons. Would the new draft require women to register also? The third reason…