Preview

Should Child Soldiers Be Given Amnesty?

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1120 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Should Child Soldiers Be Given Amnesty?
In the history of war, child soldiers have always played a role in determining the outcome of the battle. These soldiers have lately stirred up a large portion of talk about whether they should be granted amnesty or not. Amnesty is a pardon of all crimes a person has committed, and considering what child soldiers have done; they should not receive that option. While people for amnesty may have excuses for all the problems they have caused, it does not deny that these children have caused many troubles all over the world the world. To exemplify, child soldiers should not be given amnesty because they kill, maim, and do other horrific deeds, their aggressive behavior from their past remains, and killing eventually becomes second nature to the …show more content…
To illustrate, an article called “Kony’s Killers”, written by Samuel Okiror, says “[Child Soldiers] killed, maimed, mutilate, attack camps, abducted children, rape, slavery, torture and pillaging” (Okiror Para 2). This piece of evidence stated helps prove the claim, as it shows all of the merciless things that child soldiers have done. Criminals in America have gone to jail for a quarter of the reasons stated, yet there are still arguments whether child soldiers should be pardoned for all the crimes they committed. Additionally, another piece of evidence that supports the claim from an article written by Gregory Warner states, “… He forced many children to kill people” (Warner 3). This suggests how not only did the young soldiers inflict crimes, but forced other children to do it themselves. While the crimes they committed themselves are simply awful, it seems to be even worse that they forced other children to commit the same crimes as them. When they do this, they force the children to go through and endure the same pain that they had. From this sentence, it can be seen what …show more content…
For instance, one piece of evidence that proves the claim demonstrates, “’I met Ongwen during the peace talks. He was most hostile. I was very scared of him,’ she told IRN” (Okiror Para 13). This evidence suggests how from being a soldier for so long, the hostile attitude they once had remains. If they were to get off scot – free, it would be extremely hard for them to fit in with everyone else, as the aggressive demeanors would likely intimate most other people. Similar to what was just said, an article written by Lauren Blue and Jonathan Woodward says, “’You’re trained how to torture. You’re trained how to kill. It’s all you know,’ he says. ‘Fitting into the community is a big challenge’” (Blue and Woodward 2). What this makes clear is how child soldier’s past would prove a problem in attempting to fit into an average community. It is expected that there would be a large amount of tension, fear and hesitation towards the former soldiers. Moreover, the article written by Jeff Koinange also declares, “It’s as if all the child soldiers went to the same kindergarten. (Where children are forced to fight)” (Koinange Para 24). This section of evidence from the article proves how child soldiers truly grow as hostile people because they went to the same “kindergarten”, which is assumed to be war. Because of this, all of the children

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    Child soldiers should be given amnesty unless they did it voluntarily. Children are kidnapped every year and are forced into the military. Some children join for personal gain revenge, better life, etc.. They have almost no choice in whether to fight or not, It’s usually join or die. This article explores the evidence to answer the question, should involuntary child soldiers be granted amnesty.…

    • 376 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The article goes on to tell about the conditions of the children who are doomed to serve as a soldier. The children often don’t have a choice. They grew up with criminality, their psyches are damaged and often they are leaved by their parents. Instead of going to school or playing in a park, they have been “brainwashed” and work for the…

    • 550 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Amnesty is the only choice, let's forgive these poor children. It was never there doing, it was a do or die situation. Juveniles soldiers greatly deserve amnesty because they were abducted, desperate and brainwashed. These adolescents were desperate for protection food and water. Hunger and pain forced these minors to join the child soldiers.…

    • 1002 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Their growth has been stunted by conflict-induced famines, their psyches damaged by all the killings they have witnessed. "What do I enjoy?" Awil asks. "I enjoy the gun”. To say differently, The piece of evidence shows that children are not getting their education and are now actually liking to fight. This supports my claim that no real justice is being done for the people because since the children are being forced to be a soldier they like to do what they have to do and they like to enjoy something irregular that a child should not like, guns. No one is trying to help what’s left of these children fighting showing how no real justice is being done. Third, According to “Armed & Underage” it states, “Awil is paid about $1.50 a day, but only every now and then, like most soldiers. His bed is a fly-covered mattress that he shares with two other child soldiers, Ali Deeq, 10, and Abdulaziz, 13”.What the author meant to say was children soldiers are living in bad conditions and barely get…

    • 1107 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Essay On Child Soldiers

    • 537 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Thy will be shot or killed but also, they depend on of the commander for food, money, drugs and alcohol.They become addicted and stay to be provided for. It’s a big family, for some of them, they are given a roof over their head that some children there have never had.”Most children are forcibly recruited and even when they enlist they may not have thought carefully about their decision or made an informed choice.”(Child Soldiers, Prosecution, page 11). Some had just witnessed their families death and the adult soldiers take advantage of them. They also think differently than adults their minds are not fully developed until age 22. They should have amnesty because they were drugged and many were forced to do their act. Also, not all fully understood what was happening because they process information differently because they are children.…

    • 537 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Child soldiers shall not be prosecuted because many did not volunteer and many are under pressure. The use of children in war has happened throughout history as drummer boys and messengers. To most armies and militias children are cheap, compliant. Both boys and girls might be active soldiers. The girls are more at risk of rape, sexual harassment and abuse often recruited to be sex slaves.…

    • 572 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    While it may be very true that most average children know their actions, what if those children were not in a ‘normal’ state of mind? Child soldiers were drugged, beat, threatened, and tricked into feeling and thinking nothing except kill, kill, kill. Not only that with all this is emotional and physical abuse, if a child is emotionally and physically abused they tend not to feel anymore, and if they cause a crime then it shouldn’t be their fault, it should be the people who turned them into that, the people who manipulated them with drugs and violence into thinking that's okay. If the UN can give amnesty to the children who have been deprived of their childhood, and jail the people who caused it. That will show the commander what happens to children who they force to fight what…

    • 599 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Child soldiers should not be held accountable for war crimes. They do not choose to fight or kill. There are 200,000 child soldiers worldwide that are being forced to fight against their will. Although they did not choose to fight, some people think they need to be held accountable.” These children knew exactly what they were doing and should not be excused from their actions…” Once their trust is earned, child soldiers can be easily manipulated. “Child soldiers are ideal,” a military commander from the African nation of Chad, told Human Rights Watch.”They don't complain, they don't expect to be paid-and if you tell them to kill they will kill.” Child soldiers should be granted amnesty because they just did what they were told to do.…

    • 480 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    They have to change their mind and body, to go to reality of the real world, instead of life in war. In the article Should child soldiers be prosecuted for their crimes?, the report stated how children need to be held accountable for the crimes they commit by more sufficient and appropriate methods, other than incarceration, empowering them to acknowledge their past and the crimes the execute. (should, 14). Rather than putting children in jail for murder, they should be rehabilitated so they can recognize what they did in the past was wrong. Because just putting them in prison for something they wouldn’t recognize was wrong wouldn’t be helping anyone; it would just be putting a short term solution on a long term problem. In the article Child Soldiers, the author gives “Demobilization and Reconciliation program, often abbreviated TTR and DDR, are far better ways of helping children recover and reintegrate back into society and out of war. The problem with prosecution is that it poses far too many problems” (Child, 18). A child from war needs to be pointed in the right direction instead of them having to dwell on what they did. The adolescent can turn their life around and focus on good things, other than situations of…

    • 778 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Child soldiers are victims, not perpetrators, so they should be granted amnesty. Though to some it may look like these kids are choosing this life, in reality, most aren’t. They either have to join those forces or die, which is terrifying for any child to imagine. Not only that, but they were drugged to kill, making them forget how bad it was that they were doing. And to some of them, that army was the only family that they have, providing better living conditions than those out on the streets. Which is why these children are victims of this terrible event and should be legally forgiven for what they were forced to do.…

    • 995 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    First and foremost, the consideration of whether or not to help children is the issue. Many of them suffer from drug addiction and are basically brainwashed. To help the mass amount of child soldiers, we should give them amnesty. But we can’t just let them loose into the world because they can all still be dangerous. As the Armed & Underage article states, “They don’t complain, they don’t expect to be paid-and if you tell them to kill, they kill.” This is to show that if they are to hear the word kill, they’ll kill. Of course others may say differently. Personal research has been conducted and has…

    • 939 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The use of child soldiers is one of the most blatant abuses of international human rights. There have been a number of treaties that have tried to prohibit these practices, but the use of child soldiers has become more prominent and occurs in approximately 75% of conflicts around the world. Primary causal factors of recruiting children are: social disruptions due to globalization, disease and war which has resulted in further global conflict and generation disconnection which has created a pool of possible recruits and technological improvements with fire arms becoming smaller and lighter allowing children to be more effective. With low draft turnout, conflict leaders see the recruitment and use of children to be a economic benefit. It is low…

    • 1011 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Child soldiers shouldn't be prosecuted as adults for their actions. Instead they should be rehabilitated. Instead they could be rehabilitated. With rehabilitation it could help them heal from the damage caused for such trauma. Others argue that they still have done the crimes and it wouldn't be right, especially for victims, to let them free. The children shouldn't be blamed for what they are forced to do, the people authority should have punishment for having child soldiers. Giving child soldiers adult consequences for their actions would be insensitive and more damaging. Their brain isn't fully developed, making them easily manipulatable. Child soldiers shouldn't be persecuted instead of rehabilitated.…

    • 621 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    “In the last ten years, two million child soldiers have been killed, more than one million orphaned, more than six million left injured or permanently disabled, and more than 10 million diagnosed with psychological trauma” (Invisible Children). But that is only the beginning of this problem and it could get worse. Many young children find themselves in the army for various reasons. They commit many acts that are deemed as crimes. Some people think that they should be pardoned and some think otherwise. Even if people think that child soldiers should not receive amnesty, the child soldiers must be given amnesty because they are not responsible for their actions, they do not always have a choice, and because they have suffered a lot of pain and need help.…

    • 1006 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Not many people echo the idea that child soldiers should be prosecuted for their horrific crimes, but these people are wrong. An example could be Omar Khadr, it states in the article, The Child Soldier on Trial at Guantanamo (2015)”... Khadr threw a grenade that killed Speer and wounded others”(pg1) This is one example of horrible crimes because not only did he kill one person but he wounded others. This situation then escalated into a full on fire fight. Another example of this is from the story written by Ishmael Beah, A long Way Gone, it states,” ‘We burned about three…

    • 614 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays