Preview

The Destruction of Black Elk

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
792 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Destruction of Black Elk
Cassie J. Escobar
English T/Th
9:40-12:50
9/4/13
The destruction of Black Elk Black Elk Speaks written by John Newhart is a biography of a Native American. In the biography Neihardt takes us thru Black Elk’s experiences as the Wasichus (white man) take over the land he lives on. The Wasichus have always been monsters to the Natives. Young kids see them as monsters that will get you if you misbehave and adults see them as merciless murders, due to the fact that they killed many Native women and children; Wasichus also took away culture and tradition from them. We can see through use of pathos, logos, ethos, and diction that Black Elks attitude toward the Wasichus was resentful. John Neihardt writes this biography because Black Elk came to him with the purpose of showing Americans both physical and emotional pain they’ve inflicted on them in desire to expand the United States. This biography isn’t only for sorrow; it’s of great appreciation to the Native Americans because this is the first of their stories that is actually being documented. Having written by a white man is of great importance because through this biography the readers see that Black Elk is hostile toward white men. Once the Wasichu comes back for the second time they begin to expand taking land from the Natives, forcing them to live in reservations where they are stripped away from their culture. For example the Natives are forced to live in square cabins rather than their spiritual tepees. Tepees are an important part of Native culture because they are circular it resembles the Power of the Earth, which to them is very important. “..all our power came to us from the sacred hoop of the nation, and as long as that hoop was unbroken, the people flourished”. Neihardt (155) This shows the reader that the white men really took something that was a key element in their culture. The Wasichu also lied to the Natives by telling them there will be enough food for there entire tribe, which isn’t the

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    First and foremost, before the colonist arrived the Indians had the strongest connection to this land; they understood and had an intense love for nature and respect for the life that the earth produced. Throughout Standing Bear’s essay, it’s clear that to him the white…

    • 698 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Black Elk Speak Summary

    • 333 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The reading called Black Elk Speaks brings out many problems that the white people did to ruin the Native Americans way of life. Black Elk is telling his story to John Neihardt and John translated it. Black Elk is telling a story about how the white people roads ruin the way of life for the Native Americans. He relies on pathos to inform us on what the white people did.…

    • 333 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In the annual editions article, “The Nez Perce Flight for Justice” Edmunds discusses the Nez Perce Indians’ trials and tribulations faced when fleeing Idaho in search of a better life. Before 1877, the Nez Perce were proud of their relationship with the US and tried hard to avoid conflict, but soon they were being forced to relocate, and the young tribe leader, Chief Joseph, reluctantly agreed. While they agreed to relocate, after violence, they quickly realized that they needed to flee and had to travel a long ways, faced with death, disease, and destruction every step of the way, Edmunds shows this through impactful events from the time period, such as the Battle of White Bird Canyon and the assassination of Looking Glass, a heartfelt quote…

    • 299 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Black Elk Summary

    • 569 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Black Elk talks, about a personal story, that has different characteristics of several genders. biography, testimony, and history. However, the black elk is contains of 25 chapters, which discovered black elk's early life. The story draws the black elk as a savior and glorified man that has all the power, which ensured to him since he was young. It recorded the shift of the Sioux nation from previous reservation to reservation culture,because of their engagement in the war of Little Bighorn. Black Elk provides evidence to the price where human struggle that the Sioux paid for the westward extension of the US. As an appreciation, it graves the passing of innocence and free American Indian and the current cultural rescission.…

    • 569 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Elk, also known as Wapitis by the natives once roamed the forest and country sides of Pennsylvania all the way to Georgia. Due to the expansion of society, disease, and constant hunting elk were eventually exterminated from the area. By 1850 most of the elk that remained in Pennsylvania took sanctuary in Cameron, Elk and McKean counties. A mere few remained in Elk and Cameron counties by the mid 1860’s. A decade later there would be no more elk in the area. In 1895 the Game Commission was formed and played a large role in the restoration and fortification of endangered animals. In 1912 talk began of reintroducing elk into Pennsylvania along with deer, turkey, and quail which were already being purchased by the game commission and released into the wild. Thanks to the rapidly growing amount of elk herds in Yellowstone National Park, due to their refusal to allow people to hunt the animals the U.S. Department of Agriculture 's Bureau of Biological Survey and Department of Forestry decided to relocate some of the elk. The first shipment of fifty elk arrived by train in 1913, and later that same year an extra twenty two were purchased and sent to different counties throughout Pennsylvania. That same year a law was passed protecting elk from being hunted for the next eight years to guarantee their survival and continued growth. Only two years later the game commission bought ninety five more elk and dispersed them throughout the state. Although poaching still occurred on occasions Pennsylvania’s elk population slowly began to rise once again (Kosack).…

    • 1024 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Neihardt’s Black Elk Speaks. Neihardt claims to authentically give voice to Black Elk of the Oglala Sioux. However, as Martin reveals, the work actually “gives a highly selective and romantic vision of the man and his religious life” (679). DeMaillie’s annotations in the Premier Edition of Neihardt’s work show that the poetic descriptions of Black Elk’s speech are framed by the author’s biased desire to present an image of the poor, deprived Indian. This is evident when Neihardt includes Black Elk’s discourse as, “you see me now a pitiful old man who has done nothing, for the nation’s hoop is broken and scattered,” for which Demallie reveals is “Neihardt’s summary” (218). Such distorted interpretations of the deprived Native American spread throughout the United States in the 1960s and 1970s when “the book exploded into surprising popularity” (Preface to the 1972 Edition). Therefore, the biases of an author writing history have the potential to influence society on a great scale, reinforcing false images that erode difference and erase agency of diverse groups of…

    • 534 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    His excerpt begins with background on the Indian lifestyle, immediately making it clear that the white people have ruined nature. Lame Deer accuses white folk of raping and violating the land through use of bombing ranges and national parks. His insight into the Indian background, through his work as a medicine man, indicates that natives are in touch with nature and animals. They can feel the power, the same power that white people have taken away from the animals. Almost as though they share a connection with nature, a connection that the white people lack. The tone Lame Deer uses through out this article suggests that the Sioux Culture in general is far superior to that of white people. The article references lack of knowledge and…

    • 937 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Montana 1948

    • 1318 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The whole white population within Mercer County were partly responsible for the terrible events of Montana 1948. The social environment was one that favoured the white people’s value and discriminated against the Indians. The Indian’s lived away from the whites in little reservations allowing the Indians to have little or no contact with the white people. This had already proved the racial treatment within Montana. Furthermore Ollie Young Bear was an Indian but he was accepted from the whites because he lived as white. He was successful through every aspects of life and married a white woman. But the Indians, on the other hand had regard believing that Ollie young bear wouldn’t “be happy until he was white.” The white societies within Montana were all well aware of the crimes committed by Frank against the Indians. When Wesley and Gail were to take action on the claims made by Marie about Frank’s wrongdoings, David heard a remark made by Daisy McAuley saying “Just the squaws though.” Daisy…

    • 1318 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Sacred Power In Black Elk

    • 2412 Words
    • 10 Pages

    In Black Elk Speaks, Studying Religion was showed in a lot of instances in his journey in life. Black Elk went through a lot of drama happened when he made the conversion to a Catholic Church. Black Elk stood with the analogy by turning the other cheek. In the following paragraphs I’m going to talk about the ten areas that are shown in Black Elk.…

    • 2412 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Black Elk Speaks Essay

    • 1253 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Before reading Black Elk Speaks I thought that Native Americans were all the same they fought wars and rode around on horse. They either won or lost the wars they fought in and they all lived in teepees. I really didn’t have much knowledge on them. I’ve always know that they had a very deep spiritual connection to nature and their world around them but I didn’t know the reasons why. Before reading I didn’t think about things as much like the world and animals; I just thought they were here just as we are and that we only used them for food and different things we need over time. I didn’t have a great appreciation for nature and what it actually gives us. I started to think about what the world thinks to be important in life and I started looking at what the Native Americans to be thought as important. It made start to question my own ways and look at the bigger picture, the world and what’s on it.…

    • 1253 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    From these journals, we see the perspective of the American men who journeyed west and how their presence effected trade relations and peace with the Native American tribes. Yes, many argue that the journals, and the expedition itself, lack importance due to individuals moving west, even before the expedition returned to St. Louis. However, from the evidence provided in the words of Meriwether Lewis and William Clark, historians can see the effects of the interaction with the Corps of Discovery and Native Americans and the suppression of Sacajawea’s perspective not recorded in the journals. This expedition is a part of American history, whether or not people enjoy the story or simply want to forget. Americans need to address and confront the truth; not disregard the facts because it makes them uncomfortable, like it seems to do to Stephen Ambrose. America cannot be the land of the free if the American government continues to lie to its people and native tribes that the government once made promises to. America needs to apologize and begin to make amends for what occurred during the Lewis and Clark Expedition, giving Native Americans an ultimatum to either: assimilate, relocate, or face death for not cooperating, and giving Sacajawea a false voice furthering their longing for Manifest Destiny and Imperialist ideologies. The government could have brought Native American’s on the journey of progress but instead let racial superiority exist between Americans and Natives. We as a nation, by studying the negative affects during and after the expeditions return to the United States, can begin to mend and abolish hostility that the expedition caused. Overall, working…

    • 1570 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    His usage of literary terms shows how the white people began slowly to control them. "I saw my evil day at hand." This demonstrates how the white people quickly betrayed the Indians and cheat their way into their society. Black hawk saw how soon his home was being destroyed. "They poisoned us by their touch." The white men were like a virus quickly spreading and damaging everything they set out to take.…

    • 158 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Luther Standing Bear observed the White men treat his family, nature, horribly. As detailed in the guided reading, the White men cut down many trees and destroyed dams, belonging to beavers. The White men caused great destruction among nature and its habitants, while Luther Standing Bear watched in anguish. Luther Standing Bear felt nature was as close to him as his wife and children, but the White men, according to their actions, felt nature was an awful bother. William F. “Buffalo Bill” Cody is a prime example. Buffalo Bill was a White man and, according to his actions, he felt only bison were important in nature. Buffalo Bill slaughtered a vast amount of bison over a period of one year to feed his construction crew and interrupted…

    • 176 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Even in present day Aboriginal issues are often a mere afterthought for the majority of Canadians; during Ed’s early years it was accepted for society to scorn Canada’s indigenous peoples. In the novel, when Ed attempts to free himself from Mike Pasko, his rapist, when Ed considers informing the police he thinks, “Had I been born in a different body with a different history, I might have gone to the police…but I wasn’t wemistikoshiw. Our stories were different” (Metatawabin, 127). Ed had seen firsthand how the RCMP treated his people; he had such an apprehension about going to the authorities that he chose to stay trapped in a house with a sexual predator who abused him on a daily basis. The Canadian Government created a widely accepted dogma that indigenous peoples must be subjected to strict regulations for the betterment of Canadian society. At one point in the novel Ed informs his father of his plans to lobby against the government in order to improve the autonomy that Cree leaders would have within their own reserve. Ed’s father mentions how he had attempted to dispute the Indian Agent on housing rights regarding the reserve and he explained to Ed: “Remember when I tried to fight the Indian Agent on housing?...The Indian Agent didn’t think much of the idea. Said it wasn’t my land to begin with” (Metatawabin, 269). the Minister whose job is to supervise the government affairs with Canadian Indigenous Peoples has a lack of apathy for the well-being of those living on…

    • 976 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Cultural Experiences

    • 419 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Writers have long written about their cultural experiences, so much that they have become speakers for their culture. Chief Joseph, of the Nez Perce, is one of them. He shares his struggles of being forced from his homeland to a reservation, miniscule is size compared to his original safe haven. He shows the emotional undertakings that he endured through his speech I Will Fight No More. In said speech, Chief Joseph sued imagery to show the physical and mental hardships all native tribes had to undergo.…

    • 419 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays