Preview

The Digital Parent Trap Analysis

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
471 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Digital Parent Trap Analysis
In Eliana Dockterman’s “The Digital Parent Trap”, she argues that exposure to technology early in life is more beneficial than harmful. She uses many elements in order to get her point across. These elements include statistics, rebuttal of the opposition, and rhetorical questioning.
Rhetorical questioning is a third element used by Dockterman. The question, “So who’s right-the mom trying to protect her kids from the perils of new technology or the dad who’s coaching his kid to embrace it?” is found in paragraph 3. She uses this question to express different views on this controversial topic. It forces the reader to see each side of the argument before she goes into her own argument. By doing this, she shows that she knows both sides of the argument. This allows for the reader to see the opposite side of the article before arguing her point. This question also connects to real life by incorporating family and opposing opinions within a family. It may help the reader to relate more to the article.
Throughout the article, Dockterman
…show more content…
Before getting into her argument, she introduces both views on technology. In paragraph 4, she says how “social media...can make kids feel depressed and insecure.” She then slowly begins to introduce her view by explaining the benefits of early technology such as staying competitive. The article is concluded with “parents should keep an open mind about the benefits of tech fluency.” Allowing for the reader to see both sides of the argument can be very beneficial. The reader is able to accept her side of the argument and how it compares to the other side. The author explains herself and why her argument is superior to the opposition.
Rhetorical questioning, statistics, and rebuttal of the opposition are all elements that Eliana Dockterman uses to support her side of the argument. She believes that early tech fluency has many benefits and is a more beneficial choice for

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Dockterman builds up her argument before she even states her opinion. She goes into depth about the positive and negative to education and technology. The thing that she doesn’t do is state her opinion right away. So to me, she is continuing to keep the reader's attention by not stating her opinion. She asks questions that makes it seem like she’s going to state her opinion, but she still continues to build up each side. For example, “ So who’s right-- the mom trying to protect her kids from the perils of new technology or the dad who’s coaching his kids to embrace it”. With the question added in, she is impacting the audience because she is not just stating facts and statistics without some type of hook or catch. Dockterman backs up her reasons and claims with facts and statistics. “80% of U.S. school districts say they are on the cusp of incorporating Web-enabled tablets into everyday.” It will impact the audience’s thoughts because without the facts, the audience wouldn’t believe what the reader is trying to get across because it’s not…

    • 701 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The constant need to be using a source of technology weakens family bonds. Rather than communicating in person, we choose to text or call. As a matter of fact, most adolescents prefer browsing through their endless social media accounts on smartphones, rather than sitting down to have a conversation with their parents. In another one of Ray Bradbury’s short stories, “The Veldt”, he portrays how an attraction for technology is greater than human attraction. In “The Veldt” the mother says, “...I feel like I don’t belong. The house is wife and mother now, and nursemaid. The home is a fine representation of the advancement of technology in which it performs the task that mother might do. Furthermore, the children in the short story grow more fond of the technology in the “nursery” than of their own parents. The story explains that the parents, “..let this room and this house replace you and your wife in your children’s affections”, continuing, “This room is their mother and father, far more important in their lives than their real parents.” Advance technology takes over the family base of love and comfort. “The Veldt” warns the readers of what is to come if technology is more comforting than others…

    • 988 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    She provided various opinions of an author, the local community, government officials, parents, and a universal law professor. Incorporating multiple sources allowed for a stronger writing. The strength of her writing comes from just that, the many sources. Another part of her article which strengthens her writing is that her gathered evidence include both sides of the case. For example, pro-Boomer, a UCLA law professor shares their opinion, while against Boomer, the local community’s opinions were also shared going against Boomer. Simon’s writing has included sources for both sides. The problem with a weak explanation is not present in her article because both sides are presented.…

    • 542 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Disney Princess Effect

    • 534 Words
    • 3 Pages

    She uses bullet points to list statistics from recent studies “to understand why parents are uneasy” (483). This use of organization adds emphasis to the information being listed by providing support to the author’s main idea. The audience is able to read the alarming data as to why parents should be concerned with the effect the media has on young minds. Hanes also uses a series of bold headings to divide her argument into related points. By classifying the information under headings, the essay is able to flow in an understanding way. Similar information is grouped together keeping the same ideas connected and leaving out opportunity for repetition. The headings seem to follow a pattern as well. The essay follows a problem-solution pattern. However, the essay ends with a problem. By ending with a problem Hanes leaves the audience with the ability to establish a solution for themselves. The last paragraph, “We can’t sit there and say, ‘Oh, the kids are so messed up’,” she says. “We have to look at ourselves.” (488) creates a chance for the readers to ponder on how they let the media affect their own children. This writing choice allows the audience to reflect back on the content of the essay and how the information relates to their own…

    • 534 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    However, her reasoning and justification regarding the evidence was more effective in conveying her thesis to her targeted audiences. One example was her personal experiences of her conversation with the call Center worker in Philippines. In the article, she wrote that “He was probably right. He is dispensable.” (Tufekci,2015) Here, she uses emotional appeal to invoke the empathy of the readers towards the worker, establishing a strong rhetorical appeal. Following which, she linked this statement back to her thesis and justify that machines can replace human labour, in this case the call centre workers.…

    • 707 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Toledos counter argument is that the impact that technology has had on students is far more complex than Prensky makes it out to be. Toledo presents other models such as digital recluse, digital refugee, digital explorer, digital innovator and digital addict, each are different models that were put forward after digital natives and immigrants. She suggests that digital immigrant teachers are not completely against technology and would use it in their classrooms if they could see how it would benefit their students. Toledo (2001, pp. 7) Toledo uses a reader’s comment to justify her counter argument because the claim says that the claims Prensky makes are too simplistic and are generalized in saying that all students embrace technology while their educators resist it. Bennett et al reacts to Prensky by saying that his claims are general and the evidence put forward are based on common sense beliefs. Bennett et al believes that not all young people possess the characteristics and skills that are said to be possessed by digital natives. For example, multitasking is said to be a distinctive trait that digital natives possess but Bennett says that this isn’t true because multitasking does not help in the way Prensky says it does. The claim that all students are natives is not true because not all students have grown up immersed in technology and the impact it will have on them will differ due to their socio-economic backgrounds and home…

    • 1135 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The author, Stuart Green, makes a few interesting points in the text, Argument as Conversation: The Role of Inquiry in Writing a Researched Argument. Stuart Green described arguments as conversations. They contain an issue and many viewpoints on the specified situation of the issue. He mentioned the conversations we have are never new; they’ve been discussed before and they will be discussed after you leave the conversation. Also, you, as a reader, need to find out about the ideas said about your specific conversation in the past in order for you to branch out your own idea about the conversation. Stuart Green discussed about framing. He defined framing as “a metaphor for describing the lens, or perspective, from which writers present their…

    • 492 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Walt Watkins Summary

    • 691 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The first showed “at least a third of young children” (397) have the ability to use technology in their bedrooms. The second study found that it is common for tweens and teens to use other devices while on the computer. Watkins implies that learning to use media in the bedroom and multitask at such a young age increases their risk down the road. Consequences could include death, as the 2008 train accident showed. The conductor of the train was on his cell phone instead of operating the train, which neglected him from seeing the warnings and commands to stop the train (400). The result was twenty-five deaths because the conductor was trying to multitask. Watkins’ use of this example appeals to pathos, as death is a very emotional topic. The audience naturally believes what he is saying, as disobeying him could result in another…

    • 691 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The speaker defends his or her point by having back up information with someone who has more experience about a certain topic. “Sources are supposed to know more than most of us. So called experts” (Asking the right questions). In the article the author uses two sources as appeal to authority. First she uses the UCLA research team to prove that the evidence she’s giving to us the readers is valid since researchers studied and expiremnted on it. In the end, she also uses Yalda T. Uhls as well as The Children’s Digital Media Center quote to remind us about the data results. “You can’t learn non-verbal emotional cues from a screen in the way you can learn it from face-to-face communication,” (Why Access to Screens Is Lowering Kids’ Social…

    • 708 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Dumbest Generation

    • 664 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Ever since the advent of the modern digital culture, there have been some heated discussions on the topic of whether technology is a foe or a friend. Some people argue that it is influencing us negatively, scattering our attention and diffusing our concentration, while others believe otherwise, suggesting that it is making our lives more efficient and convenient. The emergence of such technology not only enhances some of our fundamental cognitive abilities, but also enables us to explore more of what is we are truly interested in.…

    • 664 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Synthesis Essay

    • 1298 Words
    • 6 Pages

    In the article “A Silicon Valley School That Doesn’t Compute,” published in The New York Times, Matt Richtel writes how an Elementary school in California would rather go old fashioned than to fall victim to the newest technology. Richtel agrees by stating how employees of the big technology companies such as Google, Apple and so on would rather have their children using pens and paper, not computers or screens. The schools method consists of a teaching viewpoint made up of physical activity and learning through creative hands-on tasks. Everyone who approved this said that computers restrain creative thinking, movement, human interaction and attention spans. One parent, Alan Eagle, whose children attend the Elementary school quoted, “I fundamentally reject the notion you need technology aids in grammar school…the idea that an app on an iPad can better teach my kids to read or do arithmetic, that’s ridiculous” (Richtel, 2). Richtel then concluded that education experts would…

    • 1298 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Technology is expanding around the world; many children use technology in their lives. In fact, technology has become necessary to them, and some kids cannot live without using it. For instance, they use cell phones , iPads, cameras, and other types of technology. Nowadays children spend most of their time playing with their iPads, and cell phones. There are many consequences of using too much technology. Most of supporters think that technology is beneficial,enjoyable, and healthy. However, Technology causes children to be lonely because it makes them isolated from others, and it causes negative effects on them. Furthermore, it leads them to enmity.…

    • 626 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In the beginning, students that used laptops felt they had a higher level of motivation and in terms of the amount of homework received felt that the laptops had also improved the students learning experience The author does not clearly state a position to whether or not technology is beneficial for students. I believe that the amount of biased thoughts put into the essay would put the author in a position to explain both sides and not lean towards one person’s thoughts. I feel that the perspective the author is explaining in the essay is geared towards the idea of technology being in the class room. I don’t feel the author…

    • 521 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Blog

    • 357 Words
    • 2 Pages

    I really enjoyed reading this article! It help me notice students at a young age do not need to be expose to technology it can harm up and help you at the same time. I don’t think smart boards, e-books and I pad…

    • 357 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Did you know, that 29% of children use tech gadgets as toddlers and 70% comprehend them completely by primary school age. Surprising?(Seales & Harding, 2013). Imagine that your children can utilize smartphone or tablet before they can even talk. It is not surprising since children nowadays are disclosed with those gadgets by their parents as a babysitter while they are busy. Most of parents give their kids gadgets to comfort and calm them by watching videos and playing games. As we all know, currently, innovation are developing faster and getting more brilliant consistently and video games can be played anywhere, anytime and even with people around the globe, more likely as intuitive social platform. Most of the social community say that gadgets actually help the children in their learning process through the early stage. But, is it genuinely beneficial for them and their future. Hence, we disagree that gadget can effect their growth positively since mass media and interactive games which children are exposed to can influence or change their psychology and sociology negatively.…

    • 1204 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays