Preview

The Role Of Minorities In The Canadian Judicial System

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1449 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Role Of Minorities In The Canadian Judicial System
Introduction:
The judicial system in Canada strives to maintain the position that those who enter the courts are innocent until proven guilty. Many minorities enter the courts for various reasons, sometimes opposing bills, other times for offences that are not always correct. Bills have been passed that target certain groups, minorities face the possibility of their ethnicity affecting how they are treated by the police and courts and, in particular, the indigenous people face negative victimization in criminal courts and correctional facilities. There has proven to be an over representation in the criminal justice system of Black, Asian and minority ethnic individuals and the system seems to be uninterested in the issue (David Lammy, 2017).
…show more content…
A study in 2012 found that people of colour make up a small percentage of federal judges, provincial judges and practising lawyers (Nicholas Keung, 2012). Judges and lawyers hold very important positions in the judicial system and the underrepresentation of minorities among them should not be so evident. Among police officers in Canada there is a lack of diversity, with numbers such as only 19% of the peel regional police being non-white (Jacques Marcoux, Katie Nicholson, Vera-Lynn Kubinec and Holly Moore, 2016). It is no wonder minorities are overrepresented in correctional facilities and interactions with the police with very little representation of minorities working within the Canadian judicial system. These numbers are concerning and reflect blatant racism in the Canadian Judicial System. Minorities are victims to the justice system, as they are victims in society to racism. Jobs such a police officers, lawyers and judges are long term jobs, meaning many people are employed for up to 30 years or more. This means that minorities will struggle to be represented for many years to …show more content…
The colour of someone’s skin or their ethnicity should never affect how the laws apply to them. The racial bias in the criminal justice system is evident for African Americans and Indigenous people. African Americans are being placed in maximum security prisons when they do not require so and judges are not taking into consideration the history of aboriginal people in sentencing. Although crimes still need punishment prison can not properly rehabilitate someone who is suffering from alcohol or drug abuse. Aboriginals are discriminated against in the prison system with tests of security being biased against them (Kathleen Harris 2017) The test does not account for the language barrier between Aboriginals and officers (Kathleen Harris 2017). Lastly, the over representation or aboriginals and African Americans can be link to their low representation in the police force, as lawyers and judges. There are very little minorities in those professions to advocate for the treatment of them or make a change to the

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    Under section 15 (1) of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms and Section 3 (e) of the Canadian Multicultural Act, proclaim the rights of residents to be free from discrimination (Griffiths, 2013, 2008). The lack of community relations between the police and the community they serve creates a potential for distrust and misunderstanding by both parties. This sometimes leads to targeting specific people or profiling entire minority groups with criminal activity (Griffiths, 2013, 2008). “Racial Profiling can lead to racial discrimination, which may manifest itself overtly, subconsciously, or systemically” (Griffiths, 2013, p. 299). Research shows that Aboriginal people represent 4% of the Canadian population and 1 in 5 inmates in federal prisons (Griffiths, 2013,…

    • 1738 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Stephen Lawrence aged 18 lost his life due to a fatal stabbing at a bus stop on 22ndApril 1993 in a racist and unprovoked attack. This was a case which the police were deeply criticised for in respect of their role of responsibility and the reason why the case is so well known is because until now, 10 years on no one has been convicted of his murder (Macpherson Report, Ten Years On, 1999). The real question is: have policing strategies changed since the case of Stephen Lawrence and has the MacPherson report resulted in extinction of institutional racism? Ethnic minorities have always been disadvantaged in some category, if not education, then employment and these disadvantages can change a person’s lifestyle. For example black people are more likely to be stopped and searched whereas Asians are less likely to be stopped. The smallest issues like these have become today’s major problems as ethnic minorities feel they are treated unfairly. Is there a link between the criminal justice system and black people and if there is then how has it been produced? This essay aims to examine whether changes in policing arising out of Macpherson report has resulted in the extermination of institutional…

    • 2043 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    he text, Diversity, Crime, and Justice in Canada edited by Barbara Perry highlights the fundamental knowledge on topics discussed in Canada and its society. The text examines the concept of racial difference. It delves into topics like society and crime, minorities, diversity, inequality, culture and all how all of these subjects intertwine with the criminal justice system in Canada. The specific chapters that will be discussed in this paper are in regards to conceptualizing difference. These chapters examine the ways various racial groups are subjected to similar marginalization, victimization, and criminalization.…

    • 1389 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Canadian criminal justice system is often represented by the balanced scales of justice. These scales symbolize the need for the law to be viewed objectively in order to ensure a fair determination of innocence. The criminal justice system incorporates the values of the scales of justice in an effort to control crime and impose proper penalties on those who violate the law in society (Griffiths, 2011). However, despite justice being supposedly impartial, there is an overwhelming representation of Aboriginal people in all stages of the criminal justice process, from the charging of the individuals in court to their sentence in prison (Pfefferle, 2008). This is a clear indication that the criminal justice system is not adequately representing…

    • 992 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The goal of this paper is to prove, using distinctive evidence that the Canadian Criminal Justice System is unfair. This paper argues that many Canadians of different race, religion, and sexual orientation are treated unfair in the Criminal Justice System. It is extremely important to argue that the Canadian Criminal Justice System is unfair because most Canadians are unaware of the vast majority of hate crimes committed by the police. As mentioned previously, the majority of Canadians are overall pleased with the Criminal Justice System, however, they may not be aware of the victims affiliated to the unfairness of the justice system.…

    • 303 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Racial disparity in the criminal justice system is widespread and it threatens to challenge the principle that our criminal justice system is fair, effective and just.…

    • 1799 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Systemic Injustices: Life Imprisonment, Disparities for People of Color: In the United States, the shadows of the justice system, more often than not, obscure the path to equality, which casts a wall over the lives of people of color, who find themselves caught in a system of inequality. As individuals try to navigate this complicated labyrinth of the American Legal System, they encounter multiple barriers. These barriers can obstruct access to fair and equal justice. They show systemic flaws that cannot be ignored. There are clear signs of injustice: The disproportionate number of life sentences for people of color unveils systemic flaws in the justice system that include, racial bias, socioeconomic disparities, and disparities in similar…

    • 1414 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    This theory grounds itself in the reality that if one wants to know what group in society is at the bottom, all one has to do is look at who is in prison. Inevitably, those at the lower end of the socio-economic scale find themselves in conflict with the law and in prison. Poverty is one of the best predictors of the chances of an individual coming into conflict with the law. Year after year, statistics confirm that Aboriginal people have lower life expectancies, lower levels of education, lower levels of income and higher incidences of poverty and disease. If an Aboriginal offender receives the same sentence as a non-Aboriginal offender, they are not likely to serve the same sentence. The Aboriginal offender is more likely to receive a higher classification level, serve more of his or her time in custody and more likely to have parole revoked. The criminal justice system is not a uniform or coherent whole across Canada and selective enforcement from police often occurs. Racial profiling or profiling based on one’s socio-economic status is a common practice undertaken by police officers in Canada. The systemic discrimination and racism in the criminal justice system is still very…

    • 1198 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    As the Federal government is now doing, all state agencies as well need to continually document and collect statistical data that identifies the race of those individuals processed through the criminal justice system. In the areas of administering justice (police, courts, and prison authorities), we need to pay specific attention to and hold accountable individuals for any instances where racial discrimination exists. As a society, we need to be concerned¡Xand express this concern, at the all-encompassing patterns of racial discrimination. By pressuring our governments to take urgent action to stop racial discrimination in our country¡¦s justice system, perhaps we can begin to prevent or reduce the incidence this practice. By effectively acknowledging that there is a problem in the criminal justice system, we can clearly communicate the expectation that discrimination on the grounds of race or ethnicity is unlawful and a violation of an individual¡¦s…

    • 836 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In modern U.S. history and in past U.S. history, there have been many events that occurred that has involved interactions between the authorities, minorities, and the criminal justice system. However, the interactions involving minorities and the american legal system have not always been equitable and credible. I support the statement that reveals that minorities face prejudice treatment in the american legal system.…

    • 599 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Ethnic Diversity In Canada

    • 1333 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The largest areas of culturally diverse societies consist within the 5 major metropolitan cites of Canada which are, Toronto, Montreal, Vancouver, Edmonton, and Calgary (Mercer, 1995, 174). Most crimes occur in these large metropolitan cities, where many cultures are mixed within the large communities. As a result of many of the large Canadian cities being home to a majority group of people from a distinct array of ethnic identities, patterns of crime are often quite similar. For example, statistics have shown a large population of at risk black youth in the City of Toronto often indicted for street crimes. Or, the City of Vancouver, where the Asian youth gang phenomenon is at large (Mercer, 1995, 181). It is very important that the police forces in these communities represent or to the least have knowledge and sensitivity of these ethnic groups. Many of these at risk youth are either immigrants or first generation Canadians; therefore the police must be able to service them with the sensitivity of their background. Although, there have been efforts to diversify Canadian police there is still much work to be done. According to Geoffrey Li, the Law Commission of Canada has noticed through census statistics that: “in spite of concerted efforts to increase diversity in police services in Canada, women, members of visible and ethnic minority groups, as well as Aboriginal peoples, remain significantly underrepresented, compared to their representation in the communities being policed"(Li, 2008, 6). The enforcement and motivation for a more diverse police force is extremely important as the face of Canadian society is becoming less predominantly white males and more women, ethnic minorities, and Aboriginal, fueling the…

    • 1333 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Description of the Problem America is the most diverse nation in the world. In this diverse nation one would assume that equality would exist. However it does not, especially in the Criminal Justice System. Racial Disparity in the Criminal Justice System results from the dissimilar treatment of similarly situated people based on race. The history of racial disparity in the Criminal Justice System in the U.S has been longstanding.…

    • 1437 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    There is much evidence to suggest that ethnic minority’s progress within the UK shows that equality is not a principle which is being met. The Telegraph reported that the Macpherson Report – which stated that the Metropolitan police force were ‘institutionally racist’ - recommended that the Metropolitan police force filled at least 25% with ethnic minority officers; however the figure still stands at around 9.6%. This does not reflect the demographic of London very well as currently 29% of Londoners are non-White, this should be shown in the number of minority police officers but it is not so this suggests that the Metropolitan police force need to address the racial under-representation within the ranks.…

    • 2087 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    “Diversity on the bench is critical. As practitioners, you need judges who 'get it. We need judges who understand what discrimination feels like. We need judges who understand what inequality feels like. We need judges who understand the subtleties of unfair treatment and who are willing to call it out when they see it” (Schultz). Discrimination is a differentiating treatment of an individual based on their race, gender identity, color, age and others. It has existed in many traditions, ideas and laws, in every part of the world since the beginning of humanity. The effects of racial, sexual, and religious discrimination have both mental and physical consequences such as: depression, stress and anxiety.…

    • 763 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    crime essay

    • 974 Words
    • 4 Pages

    If the criminal Justice is a ‘system’ in England and Wales, describe and examine how the agencies within contribute to the over-representation of Black and Minority Ethnic populations in prison.…

    • 974 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays