Preview

Transaction Cost Economic Analysis: The Case Of Amazon Mechanical Turk And Upwork

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1505 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Transaction Cost Economic Analysis: The Case Of Amazon Mechanical Turk And Upwork
When reformulating the Gig Economy phenomenon in a Transaction Cost Economics perspective, Proposition 1 arises: theoretically, the greater the uncertainty in the transaction is, the lower firms will recur to On-Demand services.
In the specific case of Amazon Mechanical Turk and Upwork, uncertainty can be determined as: the degree to which the platforms’ infrastructure protect parties and guarantee the transaction (internal uncertainty); the extent to which different countries regulate temporary forms of employment (external uncertainty).
In AMT, the contract is set unilaterally by the requester, whose can set conditions and refuse to accept performance result while keeping the work done. The counterpart has no room to bargain, and the only
…show more content…
Requesters can give feedbacks to Turkers, feedbacks that impacts the future hiring probability of the worker and incentivize freelancer to have a good performance. Though Turkers cannot rate workers internally, but the diffusion of the platform gave birth to some forum or adds-in (e.g. Turkopticon) where ratings on requesters are given.
Overall, AMT internal uncertainty seems to be relevant, especially on the workers’ side; though given the menial nature of the tasks performed and the added value it gives to companies, this uncertainty does not seem to influence negatively the usage of the platform.
In Upwork, on the other side, the contract can also be bilaterally set by the parties. In case of flexible payment model, the company posts the task and the freelancers make and offer with the hourly rate and the estimated hours need; the company, then, chooses manually the freelancer(s) according to needs and preferences.
The platform shows both workers’ profile – with qualifications, feedbacks and work histories – and Clients’ ratings and task history so that the information asymmetry ex-ante is reduced. The service requester can monitor the work-in-progress and pay only for the hours recorded in the Work diary. Overall, Upwork internal uncertainty is minimized as much as
…show more content…
The index “measures the procedures and costs involved in dismissing individuals or groups of workers and the procedures involved in hiring workers on temporary work agency contracts” (OECD, 2016) and considers “regulation of fixed-term and temporary work agency contracts with respect to the types of work for which their contracts are allowed and their duration; regulation governing the establishment and operation of temporary work agencies; requirements for agency workers to receive the same pay and/or conditions as equivalent workers in the user firm, which can increase the cost of using temporary agency workers relative to hiring workers on permanent contracts; regulation for temporary forms of employment”. Country-specific values are visible in Appendix 3,

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    BSA375 Week 4 final

    • 2560 Words
    • 9 Pages

    Riordan Manufacturing Inc. wants to make changes to their current Human Resource Department’s currently used system and has submitted a service request for the analysis of the system. Riordan is currently using a human resource information system (HRIS) to track employee information, namely, pay rate, tax exemptions, hire date, and accumulated vacation hours. Microsoft® spreadsheets are used to track employee training, development records, recruiting information, and complaints. Riordan’s policy specifies that the board of directors is responsible for managing the business of the company (University of Phoenix, 2013). The reason Riordan Manufacturing Inc. needs to do this is to incorporate the devices, officially utilized by the company’s main office to combine and centralize the main system. Riordan Manufacturing Inc. feels that combining all existing tools into a new system has higher benefits and outweighs the risks. Riordan Manufacturing Inc. having a centralized system is the way to cut costs and will make things easier for all departments to use the system. In the following of this request the stakeholders will be identified, the scope of the project will be identified, the feasibility of the planned project discussed, information gathering tools and techniques shown and the design methods suggested.…

    • 2560 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    As one of its goals, Huffman Trucking would like to be the industry leader in using its technology to the maximum efficiencies when providing their customer service and doing their day to day business. They are the first major freight carrier to outsource its information systems support. Their Finance and Accounting System applications are supported by Smith Systems Consulting and are integrated with the Flight Maintenance System and the Enterprise Transportation Application. These systems are tailored to capture the financial and accounting data and information related to the trucking business. Their system also allows them to maintain their customer data along with their historical sales. Marketing is able to make their plans and budgets electronically available to their management and present them as needed at sale meetings. The Sales Department has established a detailed database of its customers that can be shared with other team members. The Human Resource Department uses an HRIS system that was developed by in-house programmers that tracks employees operationally and financially. Smith Consulting has developed a system for Huffman Trucking and recommends that they convert over in order to further standardize their system.…

    • 474 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The proposed system to be implemented will have the feature of logging into a web portal where employees can input data and run reports from. The current data that was housed within excel spreadsheets will now be imported into the web portal. After employee data has been imported into the new system managers will now have the ability to have employee profiles that include resumes, employee files, timesheet information, and salary etc. Riordan Manufacturing’s current human resource software integration with the client-server architecture will meet the system requirements in order to complete the project.…

    • 775 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The three fundamental application architectures are server based architecture, client based architecture, and client-server based architecture. The architecture that will be implemented to Riordan Manufacturing’s HRIS will be n-tiered client-server architecture. This encompasses three groups of computers: client(s), application server(s), and database server(s). The client is responsible for the presentation login and the server is responsible for the data access logic and data storage (Dennis, Haley Wixom, Roth, 2012). With the proposed system HR staff will access and input information using a web portal. Reports can be easily generated and sorted and filtered for the desired layout. Submissions for changes can be requested by an employee’s manager where this request will be logged into the system for future reference. All training and department records will be imported from the previously used Excel files and will now be entered using the web portal. Recruiters will be able to access applicant information for open positions. Resumes will be attached to each applicants profile and accessible using the web portal. Employee files and timesheet information will be integrated with the proposed system and access able by the managers. The compensation manager will enter the results of job analysis, salary surveys, and individual compensation decisions. All complaints,…

    • 521 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    There are many benefits of using software applications in the work place. The simple workflow will improve everyday operations. Staff within the organization can spend less time coordinating activities and more time helping those in need. The use of software applications can optimize the ability to smoothly and securely share clients’ information across multiple programs or agencies. This sharing is done in a client-centric way and enables professionals to focus on the clients.…

    • 1156 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    Most people living in the country or small villages, People rarely strayed more then a few mile from home, Messages traveled no faster then the fastest horse or ship. In alot of ways the way people lived and worked over the last 250 years. Has changed. In the eighteenth century King James II stepped down to be replaced by William and Mary. They had agreed to accept a bill of rights that limited their power.…

    • 1129 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Information systems are constantly evolving as technology evolves. The evolution of information systems helps improve the tools that companies have at their disposal, creating a more effective workplace. Deciding when and how to improve an existing information system is not something that can be done easily. It takes time, careful analysis of the existing information system, proper design, and proper implementation to insure an effective new system. Riordan Manufacturing Riordan requires a new information system for the HR department. The service request specifies that existing HR tools be integrated into a single application. Expected results are to define the business requirements for the development of the HR system, detailed design and project implementation plan, and completion of project within 6 months. Like previously iterated the design and implementation process is not simple and will require three separate papers to completely outline. For the purpose of this first paper we will discuss what key stakeholders in Riordan Manufacturing to gather requirements from, the information gathering techniques and systems analysis tools for the project, key factors to help ensure the information required for the project is gathered successfully, project scope, and project feasibility.…

    • 1532 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Butelman, B., Leveron, O., Kreek, M., Schulessman, S., Yan, Y., (Oct., 2012). Opiate Addiction and Cocaine Addiction: Underlying Molecular Neurobiology and Genetics. The Journal of Clinical Investigation, 122(10), 3387-3389…

    • 1082 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Employees are more expensive to employ because of regulations as a requirement of additional expenditures. Employers also have the option of hiring temporary or agency employees through a third party company. Companies that choose to hire independent contractors eliminate the cost of overtime, and the employer avoids additional expenses such as tools, training or traveling. Independent contractors reduce the cost of required benefits, employment taxes, and taxable dollars the employer pays out. Contract labor does not have to go through the arduous safety orientation and competency check off that permanent employees go through during orientation and yearly.…

    • 481 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Ambiguity is all around us, whether it is in the form of uncertain business or economic conditions, unclear job descriptions or expectations, or vague corporate strategies. Today’s economic environment, which some economists have taken to calling The Great Ambiguity, presents an extreme case of an uncertain outlook. Your nature and upbringing can shape your natural tolerance for ambiguity. Education and early career experiences also play a major role. For example, accountants tend to have little tolerance for ambiguity as their education and experiences are based in clear rules. Marketers may have too much tolerance, and often resist moving towards metrics-driven processes. Engineers (author’s note: my education is in engineering) may surprisingly have the best background for developing this…

    • 1078 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In our society today, when it comes to employment people take on many different roles and job titles. But, as many of us know there are two main groups of workers when it comes to employment; employees and independent contractors. According to the Internal Revenue Service (IRS), an employee is anyone who performs services for you and you can control what will be done and how it will be done. On the other hand, and independent contractor is defined as someone who is contracted to do work for an individual or business according to his or her own processes. In other words, an independent contractor does their work according to a contract between two or more parties for a specific job within a specific time frame. In the workforce today, it is…

    • 1925 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Improving a company’s system helps aid in its success in today’s market as well as in the future of the company’s growth and stabilization. this new system that will enable the company to promptly accomplish these requirements without hesitation and will not interfere with the company’s time management protocols or add extra unneeded expenses.…

    • 753 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Employee Contract

    • 451 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Who is an Employee and who is an independent contractor eventually it comes to the law, especially tax law. For employers, it can sometimes be difficult to determine whether the person who has hired is an employee or an independent contractor, with the US Labor Department said that nearly 30% of the employers from workers classified incorrectly. However, it is important that employers significantly this figure accurately, and failure to do so may lead to the payment of back taxes and fines, and paying the agent. Workers, and accurately determine their type determines whether…

    • 451 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Crowdsourcing

    • 1406 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Crowdsourcing is an innovative way of organising jobs and workers. The collaborative brainstorming enables hundreds or even thousands of people to contribute their thoughts and energies to a single task and can support complicated jobs that conventional means could never manage. Crowdsourcing uses an Internet task market, usually called a crowdsourcing platform, to connect workers to jobs. It enables those workers to take the kinds of jobs that they like and to complete those jobs when and where they want. Employers can find the kinds of workers they need, with the specific skills for their jobs, and pay for only the amount of work they need.…

    • 1406 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    When firms face a “make-or-buy” decision, it means that they have to choose whether to insource a particular production process or service or to outsource it to a third party. The word “insourcing” stems from the union of the words “inside resource using” and indicates the “use of internal labor, personnel and resources to supply the operational needs of the enterprise” . A firm can decide either to insource –i.e. to produce in-house- a production process or a service from the beginning or to take in-house a previously external or outsourced production process or service. For example, in 2009 Volkswagen AG decided to focus more on and to increase by yearly 10% its own production of automobile components. In order to realize this, Volkswagen AG decided to insource human capital in the engineering, production, prototyping and toolmaking fields. A further example is represented by “the insourcing of the funds administration business of Credit Suisse in Germany” by the german subsidiary of the french bank “Société Générale”. The latter “will provide a broad range of administrative and technological solutions to Credit Suisse (Deutschland) AG, including front office services (ASP), funds administration and reporting services” . Instead, the word “outsourcing” stems from the union of the words “outside resource using” and indicates the “delegation of one or more processes to an external service provider” . Firms usually outsource the production of services or goods when the production processes are neither too technical nor standardized. However, they should never outsource activities related to their core competences as by doing so they would lose their (sustainable) competitive advantage in the market. A special case is the “intern outsourcing”, where the third party to which a process is transferred is the holding company. Some examples of outsourcing companies are Chrysler, Ford and Boeing: the first one has outsourced half of its…

    • 775 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays