Preview

What Are The Similarities Between Kevin And Sheridan

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1318 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
What Are The Similarities Between Kevin And Sheridan
The similarities in Rufus and Kevin’s actions reflect the never-ending cycle of oppression that continues on even as time goes by. Dana is constantly being oppressed due to her gender and is looked down on by Kevin and Rufus. Rufus and Kevin’s action reflect the idea that women were and are still inferior to men. In the antebellum south, Dana must deal with the segregation that comes with being an African American and a woman. Similarly in her present time, Dana is still being silenced due to her gender. The act of both men asking Dana to be a secretary, and only write down a man’s thoughts instead of her own represents the idea that men were thought to be smarter and women’s ideas should not be heard. Dana notices a similarity between Kevin …show more content…
The act of Kevin, a white male, asking Dana to type only his words and thoughts is a representation of the oppression women were still facing in the 1970s. Kevin assumes Dana will want to type for him as she is a woman and enjoys writing her own stories. Dana still types for him the first time he asks perhaps doing a favor for her fiancé yet in the end she begins to refuse Kevin. Kevin begins to anger, another sign of the privilege he holds over Dana, and “The third time when I refused again, he was angry He said if I couldn’t do him a little favor when he asked, I could leave. So I went home” (109). Dana is kicked out of Kevin’s home for simply refusing to be subjected to a secretarial job, something she has never wanted. The act of being Kevin’s secretary would stop her from writing down her own stories, and instead she would only be writing a man’s thoughts. Dana was literally and figuratively being silenced. By only being able to write Kevin's thoughts she is figuratively not being able to express her own words. And after refusing to still be Kevin’s secretary he kicks her out, further silencing her own dreams. Although it is her present time, Butler draws the parallels between the two time periods. Despite the fact that time has passed and life for Dana should theoretically be better, a man is still oppressing her. However this scene does …show more content…
The details in the book surrounding Dana being asked to do secretarial work support the claim that Dana is still being oppressed and silenced even in her modern day time. An idea that everything gets better as time goes on is refuted in this book. Dana is being guided into doing a job she hates. She will be writing down someone else’s thoughts and words as opposed to writing her own. Meanwhile in the 1800s Dana is being subjected to the job she hates, as she would be worse off if she refused the secretary job. Although Dana’s life seems easier in the present daytime, Butler uses the offer of writing for a man as a way to conclude that the cycle of oppression will never end. In the present daytime it is illegal for Dana to be outright discriminated against due to the color of her skin, yet she is still being censored. The cycle of oppression will continues to subject minorities to be burdened with the thought that their thoughts and opinions are not as important as someone else’s. This is represented by the fact that although the country has come along way from slavery, there are still people being silenced by the ‘superior’ people. Octavia Butler weaves a story of time travel that has an underlying current. Butler uses her story to fight against the obvious signs of

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    A modern woman in her late 20’s named Dana time travels back in the nineteenth century when the 13th amendment did not exist, yet. Based on her knowledge, she firmly presumes the reasonings for her voyages is due to her ancestor, Rufus. It seems to be that whenever Rufus is in a troubled situation, Dana goes back in time. On one of her perilous journeys, she brings her husband, Kevin Franklin. But, Dana did not want Kevin to be apart of this horrendous trip. While, Dana was getting dizzy, Kevin held her. She tried pushing and shouting at him to get away. But, it was too late. Once, they arrived at Rufus’ time period, she stated, “ In this place, he was probably better protection for me than free papers would have been, but I didn’t want him…

    • 214 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    For Dana to do her best for Alice, she would need to protect her from harm. The best thing for Alice is to have Dana prevent Rufus from raping her, but this is not what is best for Dana. Although it is so important for Dana to help Alice be liberated and free from being forced to do anything she doesn’t want to do, Dana knows that if she were to stop Rufus and Alice from having a baby, Dana would most likely not exist. I do believe that Octavia Butler wants us to critique what Dana did and think about why she did it, but she does not want us to criticize her. I believe that she wants us to critique Dana so we can realize what a tough situation she is in.…

    • 683 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    1. Rufus had grown comfortable enough to Dana to know that she could not resist helping others and not seeing others getting punished harshly without due. He used that against her when he threatened to have Alice whipped if she didn’t talk to her about having sex with Rufus.…

    • 500 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    In referring to slavery, Weinberg recalls that John Hope Franklin stated, “We should never forget slavery. We should talk about it every morning and every day of the year to remind this country” (Weinberg 3). Society cannot forget because abolishing slavery with the Thirteenth Amendment translated into Jim Crow laws, racism, and lynching (Weinberg 3). Despite the Civil Rights Movement, racism still existed in Dana’s time in the novel and even today. The aftermath of slavery requires African Americans, to resist its effects daily which the novel represented through Dana’s narration. She and Kevin go through a daily struggle of how their families’ view their interracial relationship. Kevin describes his sister’s reaction as, “She didn’t want to meet you, wouldn’t have you in her house – or me either if I married you.” (Butler 110). These views of African Americans stem from the negative way plantation owning whites abused blacks as slaves and viewed them as inferior. Dana also experiences the origins of the racism in her time when she exists in the Antebellum South through her time traveling. She becomes a slave herself and experiences the whippings slaves received (Butler 106-107). She has to resist this and her negative feelings until her job is done of preserving her family ties. As Franklin stated,…

    • 2247 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In Kindred, Dana begins to go through weird little phases, almost like flashbacks of the past that she’s living for the first time. Her husband, Kevin, doesn’t necessarily believe her about her flashbacks, even though she physically moves and disappears when she’s going through them, but he soon goes encounters them with her. I believe that Butler felt the need to have Kevin stay in the past because Kevin didn’t understand Dana and why she did the things she did. Kevin knew about slavery and how blacks were treated, but he didn’t experience being a slave so he didn’t fully understand how hard and painful it was. Dana knew exactly how slavery was because she’s been experiencing the flashbacks or whatever they are longer than Kevin has, so Butler…

    • 201 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Undeterred In Kindred

    • 1002 Words
    • 5 Pages

    In the novel Kindred, it is told through Dana’s point of view. Because of this it has a certain effect on the reader. Dna goes through living a normal life to suddenly time traveling back in time to where her ancestors were born and violence on Blacks was the main topic. Even though she was aware of what happened before she was born, it was different when she had to experience it…

    • 1002 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    As they share the journal, Laurel tries to write something but undesirably, she stops writing. “I opened the journal she’d given me. I looked out the window, trying to decide what to write, search for lines…, and I gave up trying to write.” (Parker, 25) The journal symbolized the moral truth telling that even though racism remains to be a problem that provokes hatred it is not wise to act upon it.…

    • 910 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Throughout history, and even today, we see how women are repeatedly oppressed and have their voices silenced. Usually the result of cultural beliefs or religion, women are often given roles to play and instructions on how to live their lives, but they are more than just somebody’s mother, sister, or wife. These beliefs and faiths sometimes prevent women from pursuing roles other than a housewife. Anne Bradstreet, the first woman to have her poetry published as a resident of America was under public scrutiny at the time of her first publication. In her poem, “The Author of Her Book,” Anne defended the quality of her works by acknowledging that they were published without consent and we also we get a glimpse into how the Puritans believed that women were not meant to be in the spotlight.…

    • 569 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Judith Butler's theories of gender provide insight into the subversive status of the ungendered narrator. According to Butler, gendering, or assuming sex, is part of a complex process that constitutes subjects, ushering them into the symbolic and allowing the appropriation of the "speaking I'" (Bodies 3). Butler goes on to explain that the formation of the subject simultaneously produces a “domain of abject beings, those who are not yet ‘subjects’, but who form the constitutive outside to the domain of the subject” (3). Butler uses the term “abject” to describe the “unlivable and uninhabitable zones of social life” populated by those “who do not enjoy the status of the subject, but whose living under the sign of the ‘unlivable’ is required to circumscribe the domain of the subject.” She claims that this zone functions as a “site of dreaded identification against which, and by virtue of which, the domain of the subject will circumscribe its own claims to autonomy and life” (Bodies 3). If assuming sex…

    • 2659 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    It was his first day back at work, and after spending the last three days holed up alone in his apartment, the cacophony of noise assaulting his ears grated heavily on his frayed nerves. He longed to turn around and flee to the sanctuary of his home, but he knew if he did, it would raise suspicion amongst his captain and friends. The last thing he wanted was unwanted visitors turning up on his doorstep and asking him if he was okay and interrupting his solitude. Except, he wasn’t being entirely honest with himself. There was one person he wished would knock on his door, but that person appeared to have vanished into thin air. After explaining he had things to do, Booker had not made contact for four days, and during that time, Tom had gone through a full range of emotions. First he had experienced the loneliness of abandonment, and he had wallowed in self-pitying misery for an entire day, staring morosely at the door, waiting for the knock that would signal his friend’s arrival. Next came anger, and he had stomped around his apartment, loudly cursing Booker for being such an inconsiderate prick. But when Sunday morning dawned, worry replaced his anger, and he had spent the day pacing the floor, procrastinating over whether to call his friend or let sleeping dogs lie.…

    • 595 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    For perspective, it is important to note that the role of women in today’s society is as a result of great changes and transformations from yester years when women were considered inferior to men. However, today play bigger roles in many different areas of society where they are treated as equals to men and compete with men in almost all positions on offer. Although there are some societies where gender discrimination is still rife and women are subject to vast stereotyping, it if fair to say that in most modern societies, women are continuing to play prominent roles as do men, particularly in the American cultures. This is similar to the role that women have been conferred with within societies in the novel. There is equality between men and women, and although there are some roles that are distinct, no women is considered inferior to men but all genders work hand in hand for the betterment of the communities and the society at…

    • 1417 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    A Room of One's Own Essay

    • 3993 Words
    • 16 Pages

    Women writers, this is to say, have been treated differently from men because they were women; and this has affected how they developed.…

    • 3993 Words
    • 16 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Judith Butler’s Gender Trouble is no less of a performance art; her language and use of quotations acting as props to the stage. In her book, Butler reinforces the belief…

    • 486 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Gender

    • 1078 Words
    • 5 Pages

    In our society today there are certain notions that many people have about what are “right” and “wrong” for males and females to wear, think, and act. There are certain things that are expected out of males- a toughness about them, an attitude that declares them as “the man of the house”- that is unfairly labeled upon every male in our society. Females are expected to be the ones who constantly act “girly” and let the males do everything involving manual labor- this is an unfair label that is placed upon every female in our society. The video that Judith Butler takes part in is an example of a certain female who does not believe in conforming with the problems of the rest of our society- taking a stand against the “normal ideas” of the public. Judith Baker’s ideas are expressed throughout “Fionna and Cake” and “Berengier of the Long Ass,” when Fionna , The Lady, and The Knight expose these misconceptions by swapping roles; The Lady and Fionna act as the males, while Prince Gumball and The Knight act as the females. The idea that Fionna and The Lady “act as the males” in these stories define the problem that our society has when it comes to the definition of males and females. There are certain expectations that must be fulfilled when it comes to being seen as a male or female, but…

    • 1078 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Oppression is defined as “unjust or cruel exercise of authority or power”. Oppression has been classified into 12 types these being: sexism, heterosexism, cisgenderism, classism, racism, colorism, ableism, lookism, sizeism, ageism, nativism, colonialism. Yet the type of oppression which is seen in “The Story of an Hour” and “The Yellow Wallpaper” is sexism. Sexism is defined as a discrimination based on a person’s gender. In sexism people from one gender look at the people from the other gender as inferiors. Sexism can refer to either the belief of the person doing the discriminating or their words and behavior. Dr. Rick Nauret did an article titled “Negative Effects of Sexism” In this article he explains how sexism affects women in a negative way for example he states that “the abuse extends to eyewitnesses. In other words, the actions of one sexist man can affect how female bystanders feel and behave toward men in general.” Reading Dr Nauret’s article a person can conclude that sexism can affect a woman’s point of view, just one action could mark her for life. In an experiment mentioned in the article two women named Stephenie Chaudoir and Diane Quinn, did an experiment on 114 women showing them videos and reactions of men towards women. The experiment analyses showed that women were more likely to think about themselves in terms of their gender group identity thus feeling greater anger and motivation to take direct action toward men, in general, when they are bystanders to sexism. Keeping in mind that this experiment was done after the 2000’s where women now have their rights. Meanwhile in the two stories Jane nor Mrs. Mallard could ever act out of order no matter what they felt because they lived in a patriarchal society. In both stories that took pleace in the 19th century are able to see the The ideology of Separate Spheres. The ideology of separate spheres…

    • 1530 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays