The text “Why I picked up a gun” is written by Tiffany Hyatt in May 13, 2003. In the year 2001 Tiffany Hyatt drove past a beautiful little house. The house was surrounded by crime scene tape. This made Tiffany think about how she was raped and beaten by men who are commissioned police officers. In the text she talks about how every woman should be able to carry a gun. When Tiffany was younger she had a gun for sport, but after her assault she thought that it was important that everyone learns how to use it.
It often takes a traumatic event to make most women consider carrying a gun. This is often because, women are taught that they are protected by others, as men and police officers. This means that women don’t think that they need a gun.
She thinks that if you should have a gun you need to be educated, trained and ready to defend your whole family. She wrote “I would make sure that little girls were taught self-defense before sex education in school”. That is how important she thinks self-defense is. However she thinks that women should not only have a gun. They should carry a mace, learn physical self-defense skills, and always be aware of their surroundings, like other everyday items can be used as weapons and so on. Her motto is “it is better to have a gun and never need it, than to need a gun and not have it”.
2)
In “why I picked up a gun” Tiffany argues that every woman should have a gun, because then families can prevent stories like hers. She is not arguing for her case by using claims and data, but she is mainly referring back to her own story about how she was raped. Her story is not described down to every detail but you still get the idea that it was horrible.
In the beginning of the story she claims that she didn’t worry about the crime because nothing really bad ever happened in that part of town. Here she has a claim, data and a warrant.
Claim: She didn’t worry too much about the crime.
Data: Nothing “really bad” ever happened in that part of town.
Warrant: Because nothing really bad ever happened she didn’t have to worry.
Tiffany claims that “Owning a gun can give you advantage over assailant” but her argumentation is reasoned arguments because she doesn’t have data to her claims. Most of her claims refers back to “if you don’t have a gun, your children/husband/friends will get beaten up or get raped”. A lot in her text is just information because there is a claim but often no data, for example: “We as women are often taught that there will always be someone there to protect us, but it is far from reality.” Or She claims that “it often takes a traumatic event to make most women even consider carrying a handgun” and again she doesn’t have any data to her claim.
She is appealing to family’s emotions by using pathos for example when she is implying to a situation where children are in a dangers environment and how it is our duty to take care of children. “I say WAKE UP LADIES! Arming yourself is your constitutional right” When she is using capital letters, it makes you believe that she is strong and knows what she is talking about. She sounds like she has authority. When she uses pronouns as, we and you, it feels like she is talking to a lot of people and you get the sense that she is speaking directly to you and it could easily be a part of someone’s election speech.
She uses logos to argue for her case for example when she explains that she worked in two hospitals it makes her seem clever and trustworthy.
3)
In the text tiffany claims that if you want a gun you should get educated in how to use a gun. I disagree on that you should have a gun at home unless that it is for sport, but I think that if you really need to have a gun you should learn how to use it properly. I like that she doesn’t think that guns are the only way to protect yourselves but she gives other examples like learn how to use self-defense or carry a mace.
She is implying that it often takes a traumatic event to make people want guns. When someone experiences a family member or friend exposed for an assault, more and more people get a gun. When a big amount of people get a gun, other people get scared because they don’t have and gun and can’t protect themselves. This means that more and more people get guns because they are scared. This is a big problem in America and I would prefer that you didn’t have a gun at all.
She says in the text that women are often taught that there will always be someone to protect them. I disagree on that, I think that in this modern community women are taking care of themselves. My parents are separated, but both of them still taught me to be independent and to take care of myself. Men and women are equal. We protect our family at home, at work and out in the world.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
“A Peaceful Woman Explains Why She Carries a Gun” is an excerpt from Linda M. Hasselstrom’s essay Land Circle that details why and for what purpose she purchases a handgun and concealed carry permit. In the essay, Mrs. Hasselstrom recounts several instances where men disrespected and purposefully intimidated her in violent ways that truly scared her. Originally, Mrs. Hasselstrom took Kung Fu, but soon realized that if she was attacked by an average male, he could easily over power her just due to his superior size. Now armed with a gun at all times, Mrs. Hasselstrom’s interaction with belligerent man changed drastically. Men still acted disorderly and disregarded her polite requests to cease, but when she displayed her gun the whole overtone…
- 369 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
"Pistol-packing Mama: The Diane Downs Case." Globe and Mail. Gale Biography in Context, 11 Nov. 1989. Web. 23 Mar. 2012.…
- 1910 Words
- 8 Pages
Better Essays -
In the Article, “A Peaceful Woman Explains Why She Carries a Gun”, Linda Hasselstrom explains why she carries a handgun through normal activities, such as driving, camping, or even staying at home. Although Hasselstrom claims she is not paranoid, but the situations that she reacts to would raise concerning questions. To most people, Hasselstrom is slightly more than cautious, she’s paranoid.…
- 427 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
In the article “Why One Women Carries a Pistol” by Linda M. Hasselstrom, Hasselstrom is a woman on a mission. She strongly believes women should carry pistols to defend themselves from being attacked or raped. Hasselstrom learned that any female around the age of twelve can expect to be criminally assaulted, and women around the age of thirty have a fifty-fifty chance of being raped, robbed or attacked. The percentage in guns purchased by women went up and they even modified the weapons to be lighter and smaller so women can be more comfortable using them. I believe women are getting tired of being abused and treated like they are powerless against men. Hasselstrom believes a gun can change man’s perception on women being weak and powerless. I would have to agree with her, a gun is a powerful tool to have.…
- 1007 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
The threat of violence is enough to make sure that women behave in a certain way- what they wear, where they go- even if they are not a direct victim- they feel the fear and act accordingly…
- 2116 Words
- 8 Pages
Good Essays -
In the article it talks about how every person, rather it be criminal or citizen should own a gun. The argument given is for self-defense, and how criminals are less likely to attack a person who has a weapon on hand. Also, it goes with the second amendment of the right of bear arms. The example given in the article is how in Egypt because Egyptians had guns they were…
- 572 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
In the essay called “Shooting Dad”, Vowell states that “during her teenage years she came from a home that was divided”. She compared her home environment to a Civil War Battlefield. Vowell was a gunsmith’s daughter, and her views on the Second Amendment were completely different than her father’s.…
- 492 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Some gun advocates claim that they carry guns as a form of self-protection. However, this has been scientifically proven to be untrue. A study done by the University of Pennsylvania on the 677 shootings over the span of two and a half years indicate that people who carry guns are 4.5 times more likely to be shot than an unarmed person, and 4.2 times more likely to be killed by a gun (Callaway). The author claims that the reason for these statistics is that guns give people false senses of empowerment that make them overreact in volatile situations (Callaway). Carrying a gun not concealed is like painting a bull’s-eye(s) on oneself rather than self-defense, especially when it might foster delusions of empowerment. Even statics discourage gun possession; through legislating stricter gun laws, this can ensure public…
- 1011 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
What would be going through your mind if you were in a restaurant and a mad man came in and began slaughtering people right and left including you family (Swasey 174)? Would you be thinking if they would ban guns this would have never happened? Probably not! What you were probably thinking is if I had a gun on me I could protect not only my family but also the others being slaughtered. This same scenario was on the mind of Suzanna Gratia as written in Elizabeth Swasey essay ”NRA Woman’s Voice”(174). People are starting to see a gun as an object of death and destruction, and not what they are intended to be.…
- 369 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
* Keller, Barbara. “Guns are not An Effective Means of Self-Defense.” Gun Control: Opposing Viewpoints. Ed. Tamara L. Roleff. San Diego: Greenhaven Press, 1997. 104-107. Print.…
- 779 Words
- 4 Pages
Better Essays -
The idea of violence and mental illness in the news can affect society in many different ways. News articles that focus on mental illness is intended to change society’s opinion on gun control to make them believe it is the person’s fault for the gun violence. Instead of finding fault in the guns itself, people want to blame mental illnesses for causing all the problems in the world, “conservative commentator Anne Coulter provocatively proclaimed ‘guns don’t kill people- the mentally ill do”’ (Metzl and McLeish). Blame is being put on people with mental illnesses and no one is blaming the actually weapons. In reality the blame should be put on both the guns and person. The people who are committing these crimes are not sane people, and they have many problems. They can be extremely dangerous to the world, but so are guns. People have discovered that “60% of perpetrators of mass shootings in the Unites States since 1970 displayed symptoms including acute paranoia, delusions, depression, before committing a crime” (Metzl and McLeish). How many of this mass shootings are publicized in the media? The answer is that more than…
- 874 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
The United States of America holds a position of one of the highest rate of reported gun violence that unintentionally caused the death of a child (“Moms Demand Action For Gun Sense in America”). According to the second amendment in the Constitution, citizens have the right to own and bear arms. This is a controversial topic that is often debated and almost all people have their own opinion. Moms Demand Action is a current organization determined to make changes to our laws to prevent gun violence. One advertisement that subjects itself around the issue of gun control depicts two children: one holding a Kinder chocolate egg and one holding an AK-47. It also is captioned with the statement, "One child is holding something that's been banned…
- 1051 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
According to Lepore (2012), “In 1973, there were guns in roughly one in two households in the United States; in 2010, one in three. In 1980, nearly one in three Americans owned a gun; in 2010, that figure had dropped to one in five” (Battle Ground America). The number one reason for owning a gun is for protection. It does not matter whether it is for self-defense, protecting family and friends, or your property. Being able to defend yourself from an aggressor can be the difference between…
- 1904 Words
- 8 Pages
Better Essays -
As Barack Obama once said “My biggest frustration so far is the fact that this society has not been willing to take some basic steps to keep guns out of the hands of people who can do just unbelievable damage...This is becoming the normal.We should be ashamed ”(Obama). All around America many people are killed by gun violence.The issue of gun control has taken place in America for many years now.Now gun control has got out of hand.Due to the amount of gun violnece in the United States,the government has evrey right to dictate to citizens that they should not be allowed to own guns.…
- 527 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Bethany Hansen was teaching her second year at Creek Elementary. When there was an anat there was a shooter outside of her school she was scared but her students weren’t. So she decided she didn’t want to be scared so she talked to her school board and they allowed their teachers to have guns . Now she is one of ten teachers who carry guns in their school. Now she has more confidence and she can focus more on her work. This is why teachers should carry guns in school.…
- 489 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays