Preview

A Class Divided: a Brown Eyed/Blue Eyed Experiment Essay Example

Satisfactory Essays
Open Document
Open Document
450 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
A Class Divided: a Brown Eyed/Blue Eyed Experiment Essay Example
Task 3

TDA 3.6(2.2) Claire Havard

After watching "A Class Divided", a teacher used an experiment on her class, a brown eyed/blue eyed experiment. The experiment was to help the children understand about prejudice and discrimination. In the experiment Mrs Elliot told her class that blue eyed children were better than the brown-eyed children. The brown-eyed children had to wear collars so that they could tell each group apart from a distance. Mrs Elliot told the blue eyed children that they were smarter, nicer etc. than the other group, they also had special privileges, five minutes more recess time, drinking from the water fountain while the brown-eyed group had to carry on working and use paper cups, the blue eyed children were not allowed to play with the brown eyed children. Before the experiment started all of the children were friends and cooperated with one another and got along well, but during the experiment they started to turn on one another. The children from both groups started to show discrimination to the others straight away, during recess one child from the blue group started to call a child from the brown group names resulting in a fight even though they were friends before the experiment. The brown-eyed children lost interest in learning, playing and in their own abilities, they were demoralised, felt sad and worthless and withdrew socially from the blue group with the lower achieving children taking it harder. The reason the class started to act this way is because they actually believed that their group was better than the other, and the group that wasn't started to feel that they weren't being treated fairly. The children showed hatred towards the opposing group, even showing hatred towards their teacher because of what she made the other group believe and how they reacted. Mrs Elliot later changed things around when she told the brown-eyed group that they were now better than the blueeyed group, resulting in a reversal of yesterday’s

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    Eisenberg (2007) and Trudell (2006) both indicate that the Sixth-Grade Centers integration plan ultimately wound up being successful for their families, but still held that the time spent on the bus was unfair to black students. Trudell (2006) claimed that she may be in the minority, but she did feel the plan was successful for her son (p. 44). Despite all the conflict, the mandatory desegregation for these schools was a way for white students and black students to see each other as human beings, and to learn that they have more in common than they could have…

    • 1698 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In this book, written by Johnathan Kohl, we are given a rare and candid glimpse inside the educational system in the city of Boston in the 1960’s. As Kohl describes the treatment that minority students endured at the hands of their teachers, it becomes clear that the title of the book is an accurate depiction of the times. As we read about teachers calling students terrible names and treating minority students with contempt and disgust, it is apparent how the spirit of the students were slowly dying inside. Although this was over fifty years ago, this type of treatment still occurs everyday in schools all over the nation. Whether a child be a minority race, have a learning disability or have behavior issues, it is not uncommon for them to be treated in a way that negatively effects their self esteem, causes them to dislike school and eventually, little by little, takes away their hope. No child should be left hopeless. Everyone needs something to be proud of, whether it be one small talent they possess or just one person who believes in and respects them. It is the job of a teacher to build a child’s self-esteem and self-respect and above all, their hope for the future. Without hope, a child will not aspire or dream. There must be procedures in place to ensure that teachers know what is and isn’t acceptable in terms of interacting with children. I have experienced this first hand in my personal life. My son has Asperger’s syndrome. He can be difficult to handle. Because he misreads social cues he wold often misunderstand what his teachers were asking him and answer incorrectly. He repeatedly told me that his teacher yelled at him and didn’t like him. He wouldn’t even tell them when he was sick because he didn’t want to make them angry. One of his teachers screamed at him so loud at the end of the school day that he was literally shaking when he arrived home. I understood their frustration but I didn’t…

    • 1136 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    This chapter follows Dalton through his first academic experiences where he is introduced to the concept of race through personal experiences. In his first classroom experience his mother was given the choice of enrolling him in a predominantly Black, Puerto Rican, or Chinese class. He describes the fact that his mother was given the choice of which class he should join be stating, "The choices our race gave us were made quite explicit- by a government institution, no less."…

    • 1052 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    She states that "I treat everyone the same. But treating people the same is not equal treatment if they are not the same", but she didn’t display that throughout her class experiment(Tannen 349). For example, She broke the classroom into small groups to analyze the reading. The way she divides the class into groups is by “ the degree program they were in, gender, and conversational style (Tannen). That’s not treating everyone the same because she’s making exceptions for students. In that case, yes, she might be helping students get into their comfort zone to talk and learn, but might be hurting other students education. It’s obvious that people shouldn’t have equal treatment if they are not the same ,but people should have the same opportunity. For example, a teacher can’t treat a disable student the same as to an average student, but the teacher can support them with more help to have the same opportunities in class. For another example, a Japanese woman was the biggest talker in the class. Then she was to put into a small group where she didn’t do that well. She was “ overwhelmed by how talkative the female students were in the female-only group”(Tannen 348). Many students have different needs to participate, but a teacher can't satisfy everyone's needs. Treating everyone the same might be easier from a teacher perspective, but student with major needs should get it. That's why there Disabled Students Programs and Services in…

    • 1302 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    In this paper, I will state my reaction on two videos, Eye of the Storm and A Class Divided. These videos are inspired from Jane Elliott, a third grade teacher, who tested a group of her students in teaching them about discrimination. I definitely agree with Elliott in her process of teaching people the importance of ethnicity and discrimination.…

    • 599 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The purpose of this paper is to reflect upon and react to the exercise "Blue-eyed/Brown-eyed" conducted by Jane Elliot in relation to the ideas of diversity, race, and privilege. The objective of this exercise was to give white people an idea of what life is like to be something other than white. Elliot 's exercise pointed out both blatant and indirect ways that prejudice demoralizes people of color. Elliot facilitates everyone involved aiding their recognition of the cost that prejudice and racial behavior has on an individual. This exercise employed an open dialogue approach on topics that may be looked at as most people as off limits. The dialogue encouraged through the "Blue-eyed/Brown-eyed" experiment allows people to understand what it 's like to feel dispirited and the role they can play through daily interactions with people of the opposite race that promote the aspects of being supportive and understanding.…

    • 1067 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Jane Elliot's Experiment

    • 912 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Jane Elliot’s experimentation with stereotypes first began within the walls of her 3rd grade classroom. Before the experiment began she asked the students for their opinions on minority groups. Many of the students answered with statements regarding black people as being dumb and different than whites. They also discussed how African Americans do not have the same opportunities as white people do because of the color of their skin. Jane Elliot continued by effectively dividing the students into unequal groups based on eye color. From the initial division, Jane Elliot treated the students in the brown eyed group as if they were inferior to those in the blue eyed group. She set a vast amount of boundaries limiting what those in the bottom could do, and in contrast expanding what…

    • 912 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In today’s society we have had to accept people of different color or different race more than in the past. On top of that, the United States has a black president, in Barack Obama. Even though we have improved whites still connect white skin with good, brown with bad, and black the worst. When it comes to blacks the order is flipped on the way blacks view themselves. The article speaks about how it is hard to believe that it will ever change because of the way children grow up believing these assumptions. Another example the article talks about is how, one of the first things a child learns in school are their colors, and colors are related to specific items and even symbols. For example the color red can be associated with blood which then means danger. A study, that took place at the Max Planck Institute, showed that children are not the only ones that react these ways to colors. In an experiment two groups of volunteers were given a picture of a banana and carrot. The difference of these groups was that one was given black and white pictures, but when asked to report what they had seen both groups said they had seen the items in their original colors. These facts helped determine that once you learn an item has a specific color, you will always associate that item with that color. The same goes with humans when they look at the skin color of each other.…

    • 706 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    A Class Divided Summary

    • 773 Words
    • 4 Pages

    A Class Divided, a lesson taught by a third grade teacher by the name of Jane Elliot to have the youngsters experience discrimination. Jane Elliot was a third grade teacher and anti-racism activist, as a…

    • 773 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    In this experiment Jane segregated children in the classroom based on their eye colour. She told them that one group was inferior to the other and watched how the in-group help prejudices against and discriminated the out-group. The next day she switched the groups and the inferior group got a taste of what is was like to be discriminated against. Jane Elliot 's experiments are well known around the world today for giving the minority groups a chance to experience feelings of power and voice their opinions. They also give the in-groups the chance to experience what in feels like to be the out-group. Often people don 't understand something until they have experienced it themselves. Once someone knows the outcomes of their actions their actions often change. Even just reading about Jane Elliot 's experiments changes peoples attitudes and it is thought that they have contributed to a decrease in prejudice and discrimination. (Marsh…

    • 3102 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    A Class Divided Analysis

    • 624 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In the video, A Class Divided, a third grade teacher, Jane Elliot, used eye colors to separate her class in an attempt to make them feel the way people of color feel when they are discriminated against. In the exercise all children with blue eyes were considered smarter, more fortunate, and over-all better people than the children with brown eyes. During recess, only the children with blue eyes were allowed to go on the playground equipment, and brown eyed children weren’t allowed to talk to the blue eyed children. At the end of the day the class took a test, and it turned out that the blue eyed children got better test scores. Also, many of the brown eyed children were upset, and one boy with brown eyes even punched one of his friends for…

    • 624 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    I think that Jane Elliot was a woman before her time. What she put together to teach the children about discrimination was brilliant. I not only watched the first and second parts in class, I watched all six parts on You Tube. I laughed and cried watching all six parts. I see that just putting the idea into ones mind can make things happen. I think the most upsetting part of this experiment is that if you place children in the subordinate group they immediately did poorly.I feel that more people need to see this video. I think it needs be a teaching tool in schools, businesses and in the home It seems that these children were given a great gift going threw this. They seemed to catch on fast and understood, that discrimination was a bad thing and not only did they feel discrimination from their teacher but by fellow peers also. In my opinion, discrimination not only then but now is worse then ever. Today there is not just the black and Indians being discriminated against it is everyone. This is happening because people in a whole have become close-minded due to many events that have happen in the world. From World War II people started to discriminate against Japanese people to present day when 9-11 happen now, people have started to discriminate against people who are from the Middle East. Discrimination has also become a problem with people with disabilities. In addition, growing up in a small town like the children in this film I saw how discrimination is a fully learned thing. For example, I grew up in a town that was 100% white there were no African Americans, Indians or other races. The only race was white. If a person of any other race came into town they were ran out of town. Moreover, when we would go into the city and we would see a person not of our race we were told to roll up the windows even with it being 100 outside we rolled up the windows and locked the door because we were told that people of all other races were bad and…

    • 495 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Freedom Writers

    • 1633 Words
    • 7 Pages

    For the most part yes youth are respectful to each other’s differences. No there are not similar problems to those in Wilson High. But if there was then the steps I would take to initiate change would be to tell the teacher to maybe to a project were we learn about another person we don’t get along with so that by the end of the project the two could maybe see eye to eye and get along.…

    • 1633 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Sexism In Classroom

    • 916 Words
    • 4 Pages

    There is a strong connection between racism and classism. Classism is differential treatment according to social class. Some classism stereotypes that educators take into classrooms are poor students lack motivation and there is no parental involvement. This stereotype continues to surface in schools today. It often leads to low expectation, teachers fear students that are of no threat and it prevents educators from addressing the real issue of unequal access to human rights. Classism is a key player in education. The harsh reality is that children from low income families tend to experience homelessness, suffer more illness due to inadequate healthcare, which in turn impacts student…

    • 916 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Gender and Personality

    • 365 Words
    • 2 Pages

    - Testes of males begin to develop around the seventh week after conception and for females the ovaries around the twelfth week…

    • 365 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays