Preview

Gerald Graff Other Voices Other Rooms Analysis

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1302 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Gerald Graff Other Voices Other Rooms Analysis
Conflict is Needed In classrooms, conflict is necessary to achieve student abilities to devise their own perspective and form different judgement on a topic which helps gain knowledge. In the essay “Other Voices, Other Rooms, by Gerald Graff, a professor of English and education writes about “the chance to try on a variety of clashing ideas, to see what they feel like, is one of the most exciting opportunities an education can provide”, which is known as conflict in a classroom. While keeping a degree of pluralism and diversity between subject, teacher should have a level of communication when presenting material. The outcomes are rewarding for student who go to a “university with already developed skills. Conflict benefits …show more content…
She states that "I treat everyone the same. But treating people the same is not equal treatment if they are not the same", but she didn’t display that throughout her class experiment(Tannen 349). For example, She broke the classroom into small groups to analyze the reading. The way she divides the class into groups is by “ the degree program they were in, gender, and conversational style (Tannen). That’s not treating everyone the same because she’s making exceptions for students. In that case, yes, she might be helping students get into their comfort zone to talk and learn, but might be hurting other students education. It’s obvious that people shouldn’t have equal treatment if they are not the same ,but people should have the same opportunity. For example, a teacher can’t treat a disable student the same as to an average student, but the teacher can support them with more help to have the same opportunities in class. For another example, a Japanese woman was the biggest talker in the class. Then she was to put into a small group where she didn’t do that well. She was “ overwhelmed by how talkative the female students were in the female-only group”(Tannen 348). Many students have different needs to participate, but a teacher can't satisfy everyone's needs. Treating everyone the same might be easier from a teacher perspective, but student with major needs should get it. That's why there Disabled Students Programs and Services in

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Ptlls Unit 1 Essay

    • 1599 Words
    • 7 Pages

    This is the cornerstone of any teacher/tutors job. The question really answers itself. If a teacher/tutor cannot guarantee that each of their learners are given the same equality whilst respecting diversity then they would fail the learner, themselves and the aims and objectives of any…

    • 1599 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Firstly, unequal treatment in the classroom can negatively affect the academic performance and well-being of marginalized students. When students face discrimination, it creates a bad environment where they might feel unsupported. This can lead to a lack of motivation and lack of class participation, which only affects the students’ academic performance. Furthermore, letting these inequalities unaddressed can lead to the reinforcement of societal prejudices and discrimination, which in turn undermines the principles of equality and fairness and marginalized groups of students feel left out. Another issue that the public schools are not able to address is the disparity in teacher quality between working-class and elite schools.…

    • 2398 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    This means that everyone don’t have to be treated the same. People might have different needs, opinions, situations and ambitions. Therefore as a practitioner has a big part I supporting children and young people to live the way they value and choose but let them be “themselves” or be different if they want to. On the other hand every individual have every equality of opportunity.…

    • 327 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    A class divided is a documentary about a teacher named Jane Elliot who teaches her students about racism first hand. She divides the students into two groups, the blue eyes, and the brown eyes. For the first day, the “brown eyed” children are not able to go to recess, or lunch at the same time as the rest of the children. They wear a blue collar around their necks so that they are obviously different at a distance from the other students. They are not allowed to drink from the same water fountains, use the playground equipment, or even play with the blue eyed children. The next day, the roles are reversed. During these two days Jane Elliot would make comments about the children wearing the collars to degrade them. She would point out if one of them wasn’t ready on time, or if they forgot something. She would say things like “That’s how blue eyed people are” “Brown eyed people are better than blue eyed people” (J. Elliot, A Class Divided, 1985). After the children who weren’t wearing a collar noticed Mrs. Elliot saying these kinds of things, they would also chime in and begin saying things about the kids wearing the collars. Mrs. Elliot said “I watched wonderful, thoughtful, children turn into nasty, vicious, discriminating little third graders.”(J. Elliot, A Class Divided, 1985) .The movie showed the students come back for their fifteenth class reunion to talk about this life long lesson that their third grade teacher taught them. All of the students said it was a lesson they have never forgotten and something that changed their lives forever. They talked about how it affected their lives growing up, and how it affects the way they raised or were currently raising their children. Since she got done teaching, Jane has been doing trainings are conferences to teach others. Her movie A Class Divided has been shown in prisons to inmates who are trying to earn a degree. She also did training at a prison in Iowa for the guards and other staff members. When people signed…

    • 1687 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Lens Model of Conflict

    • 376 Words
    • 2 Pages

    According to our textbook, there are two fundamental aspects are important in all conflicts: (1) communication behaviors and (2) the perceptions of those behaviors. Think of the study of conflict as a view through a lens, like the lens of a camera, or through prescription glasses. The lens model of conflict specifies that each person has a view of (1) oneself, (2) the other person, and (3) the relationship. These perceptual pieces form the fundamental views of all conflicts, and combined together they form the mosaic of a particular conflict (Wilmot & Hocker 2010).…

    • 376 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    I think it makes much more sense to treat all learners differently. I think of it as a parent. If I have 4 children it is my responsibility to address each child’s needs. You can raise all children in the same home and they will all 4 walk away with a different experience and interpretation of what went on. I see the classroom the same way. A relationship should be built from the beginning. This way the students know that everyone in the classroom has different needs and I will do my best to meet them all. There is no favoritism just fairness. This has to be explained and revisited throughout the school year.…

    • 272 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    When teaching I will consider it important to treat all learners equally with respect and dignity. It is necessary to remove barriers that they may face regardless of their disability, age, race, gender, ethnicity or social class. Some of these factors can affect the way in which they learn and it is necessary for the teacher to consider this when planning and teaching.…

    • 1068 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Reflecting upon my philosophy statement from earlier this semester, I still believe that every individual should be treated with love, respect, care, and equality, regardless of their race, gender, social class, disability, ethnicity, or other cultural identity. Completing this course has reassured my beliefs about how students with disabilities should be taught and how that aligns with their needs. After meeting classroom guests just as Dr. Levingston, I still believe as a society, we shouldn’t be blind to our differences. We need to acknowledge them, mediate on them, and embrace them. We must handle each other with complete respect and love regardless of all our differences. Although any of my thoughts remain the same from my philosophy statement,…

    • 305 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Constructive Criticism

    • 385 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Linguistics professor and best-selling author, Deborah Tannen explains how “The Argument Culture” wants us to accept that by creating conflict is the best way of getting things done with an adversarial disposition. An essay taken from her book, The Argument Culture: Moving from Debate to Dialogue (1988), Tannen expresses her views on having adversarial dialogue between two sides has weakened communication in our society. Although, we live in a society where we are free to express our conflicts openly, Tannen argues that as a society we should seek to find “constructive” ways of settling disputes and differences. In setting out to find truths, Tannen states that we “assume that every issue has two sides” and by having this assumption we begin to “doubt the existence” of any facts. With diminishing face to face communication and increasing use of technology, Tannen believes that these factors “isolate people in a bubble” while the argument culture makes a “defining impact” on society. By adding more dialogue to debates and not to think in twos, Tannen advises we should use our “imaginations and ingenuity” to explore truth and knowledge.…

    • 385 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    This assignment will review the nature of conflict, from psychologist theories to what form it takes in an educational setting. In order to apply conflict resolution and conflict management effectively in an educational setting, it is important to understand the background disciplines of conflict and theories behind how humans behave in social settings. Comprehending how human behaviour initiates is the key stepping stone to resolving and managing conflict behaviour between humans. We will examine what the concept of conflict is and what shape of from it occurs in everyday life. A brief history of what psychologists have founded in their study of conflict, and human behaviour will lead this examination into conflict in educational settings and how they can arise. It is crucial to look at approaches that can be taken towards conflict in an educational setting in order to resolve and manage them effectively to reduce and minimise all forms of conflict.…

    • 5341 Words
    • 22 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Controversial Issues

    • 566 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Engaging students in discussion, as a whole class or in groups, is a critical exercise that plays an important role in their development as thinkers. How, then, can you have a thoughtful, productive, respectful discussions in class centred on sensitive issues? Here are some pointers.…

    • 566 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Individual Diversity

    • 274 Words
    • 2 Pages

    “Conflict arrives from differences”, but sometimes conflict is not bad, it open the door for new ideas, and different ways of visualize the same objective, and individual diversity provides different areas of knowledge and learning for each member of the team.…

    • 274 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Conflict Management

    • 5784 Words
    • 24 Pages

    Students bring different ideas, goals, values, beliefs and needs to their teams and these differences are a primary strength of teams. These same differences inevitably lead to conflict, even if the level of conflict is low. Since conflict is inevitable, one of the ways in which faculty members can help students improve their abilities to function on multidisciplinary teams is to work with them to develop their understanding of conflict and their capabilities to manage and resolve conflict. To this end, this document addresses the following questions: • What is conflict and conflict management? • Why learn more about conflict and conflict management? • How do people respond to conflict? • What modes do people use to address conflict? • What factors can affect our conflict modes? • How might you select your conflict management style? • How might you apply this information?…

    • 5784 Words
    • 24 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Equal Treatment

    • 557 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Secondly, not only does treatment of equality depend on the circumstances, but it also depends on the ability of the individual. Some students may need more guidance from teachers than others because of the differences of their intelligence levels. For instance, in school, a teacher treats all students equally. However, if a student requires more help on a particular subject, he is…

    • 557 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Better Education

    • 1505 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Throughout the years there have been many arguments on how to educate and in whether changing the mode of education, and what is the best strategic concept to be used in mainly public schools. In the article “The Banking concept of Education”, Paulo Freire is leading an influential figure to guide students into helping them develop their critical thinking and consciousness of freedom. He noticed and studied a dichotomy between the teacher and the student, and realized that there is a “banking concept” being presented in the modern education(Freire 319). He refers to this “banking concept of education” to be a fractional action of communication from the teacher to the student. However, in liberating education, which is called “problem-posing” in Freire’s article, perfectly results in the liberation of the students, students and teachers carry on a dialogue to teach one another. The world is seen as always in the process of becoming, students are seen as parts of that. Therefore, students are active, becoming empowered to criticize the world and so change it. For my English 122 class, I was totally attractive and paid full of attention in the class discussion. Whenever we were assigned into a group and begin to discuss various topics, I was actively participated into the discussion, I would hostly say that each one of us always learn something new from others. Even some question required critical thinking, I welcome to open mind discuss it and totally love this class, thus I am taking with the same instructor for my English 126 class this semester. Problem-posing education allows the students to be creative in their learning and really expand their learning techniques because it depends on communication, where students are encouraged to ask question, recognized the relationship between people and the world, and lead to transformation. More in other way this style of education allows people to develop their human natures fully.…

    • 1505 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays

Related Topics