Was "Troy" the Movie Accurate According to Homer Essay Example
Was "Troy" the Movie Accurate According to Homer?
Did the movie Troy, released in 2004, accurately depict the story of Homer's epic poems the Iliad and the Odyssey, and was it a good movie from a critical point of view? I think it was a good movie from an entertainment standpoint, but it fell short in it's comparison to Homer's epics. As a fan of "epic" movies, I have watched the movie
Troy a couple of times. In comparing the movie to the epic, there are various discrepancies between the two. First I'll address the overall flow of the movie, in other words the organization and coherence of the movie. The movie Troy was a lavishly produced movie, often quoted as a "Blockbuster", it was a movie with a large budget and big name actors. But was it accurate? The time period involved with the legend of Troy is basically attributed to around 1334 1184 BC depending upon several individuals who chronicled events in that area. Many believe the excavations at the site discovered by Heinrich Schliemann in
1871 are of the city of Troy. If true, this excavation dates the burning of Troy to around
1200 BC time which is close to the traditional date of 1184 BC generally associated with the siege of Troy. So how did the movie reflect these times? Was their presentation of weapons, ships, clothing and such accurate?
"Homer's warriors are often described as being heavily armoured with bronze (Iliad
5.698, 13.372, 14.383), while the epithet commonly used to describe them collectively is bronze-armoured Achaians' (Iliad 1.371, 3.131, 10.287). The regimented figures depicted on the Warrior Vase (LH IIIb/c), found by Schliemann at Mycenae are the best representations of warriors from the Trojan War period. The bearded warriors wear plumed horned helmets, body armour and greaves, and carry shields that are round except for a scallop on the bottom; they are armed with short spears." (Mycenaean)
Based upon the excavations at
Did the movie Troy, released in 2004, accurately depict the story of Homer's epic poems the Iliad and the Odyssey, and was it a good movie from a critical point of view? I think it was a good movie from an entertainment standpoint, but it fell short in it's comparison to Homer's epics. As a fan of "epic" movies, I have watched the movie
Troy a couple of times. In comparing the movie to the epic, there are various discrepancies between the two. First I'll address the overall flow of the movie, in other words the organization and coherence of the movie. The movie Troy was a lavishly produced movie, often quoted as a "Blockbuster", it was a movie with a large budget and big name actors. But was it accurate? The time period involved with the legend of Troy is basically attributed to around 1334 1184 BC depending upon several individuals who chronicled events in that area. Many believe the excavations at the site discovered by Heinrich Schliemann in
1871 are of the city of Troy. If true, this excavation dates the burning of Troy to around
1200 BC time which is close to the traditional date of 1184 BC generally associated with the siege of Troy. So how did the movie reflect these times? Was their presentation of weapons, ships, clothing and such accurate?
"Homer's warriors are often described as being heavily armoured with bronze (Iliad
5.698, 13.372, 14.383), while the epithet commonly used to describe them collectively is bronze-armoured Achaians' (Iliad 1.371, 3.131, 10.287). The regimented figures depicted on the Warrior Vase (LH IIIb/c), found by Schliemann at Mycenae are the best representations of warriors from the Trojan War period. The bearded warriors wear plumed horned helmets, body armour and greaves, and carry shields that are round except for a scallop on the bottom; they are armed with short spears." (Mycenaean)
Based upon the excavations at