In a broad sense‚ both Rawls and Nozick agree that the legitimacy of a just society is highly dependent on the emphasis of liberty for its citizens. For Rawls‚ it is the first principal of justice‚ and though he presupposes equal liberty as a basic right for each person‚ he makes a point to prioritize its importance. Rawls outlines some basic liberties‚ including political liberties‚ equal treatment under the law‚ and the freedom to hold personal property (Rawls‚ 677). Nozick agrees with this emphasis
Premium Economic inequality Political philosophy A Theory of Justice
Justice as Fairness Rawls first begins with discussing how we are lead to the original position. The original position is a hypothetical argument that considers a society where people do not decide what is right or wrong based on a higher power or emotion‚ but rather on common sense. These ideas establish justice or fairness simply based on the community’s beliefs that they create. However‚ these agreements cannot be made without the “veil of ignorance.” This means that all instances that
Premium A Theory of Justice John Rawls Original position
Rawls’ Maximin Principle: Is It Really The Most Rational Solution? Political philosophy aims to reflect the normative and conceptual dimensions of political life. American philosopher John Rawls is widely recognized as one of the leading political philosophers of the twentieth century. His A Theory of Justice (1971) is one of the primary texts in political philosophy and proposes two principles of justice. The first‚ the liberty principle‚ defines basic liberties and the second‚ the difference
Premium A Theory of Justice John Rawls Original position
Healthy Places/ Healthy People Philipson Thathamkulam American Sentinel University India is the seventh largest country in the world. It covers 3‚287‚263 square kilometers and is also the second most populous country with 1.27 billion people. Even with the fasting growing economy in the world‚ India faces numerous challenges of poverty‚ malnutrition‚ poor health care‚ corruption and terrorism (Countries and Their Cultures‚ 2011). As we explore this widely diverse country and delve into the equity
Premium Population Health care Poverty
Rawls Theory of Justice A contemporary philosopher‚ John Rawls (1921-2002)‚ is noted for his contributions to political and moral philosophy. In particular‚ Rawls ’ discussion about justice introduced five important concepts into discourse‚ including: the two principles of justice‚ the “original position” and “veil of ignorance”. Rawls most famous work is‚ A Theory of Justice (1971) gives an introduction to this body of thought and he emphasises the importance justice has on governing and organising
Premium John Rawls
John Rawls and Utilitarianism Heath C. Hoculock The social contract theory of John Rawls challenges utilitarianism by pointing out the impracticality of the theory. Mainly‚ in a society of utilitarians‚ a citizens rights could be completely ignored if injustice to this one citizen would benefit the rest of society. Rawls believes that a social contract theory‚ similar those proposed by Hobbes‚ Locke‚ and Rousseau‚ would be a more logical solution to the question of fairness in any government
Premium John Rawls A Theory of Justice Original position
results repugnant to our intuitive conceptions of justice. Though these are rules that do not discriminate‚ they cannot be called ‘just’. Eg Indirect taxes like salt tax that all sections of the society had to pay – it posed a burden for the poor people and in that way‚ was not at all just. Contemporary politics is to a great extent about who gets what and why and the criteria commonly employed for the distribution of goods and services are ‘desert’‚ ‘merit’ and ‘need’. The concept of desert
Premium John Rawls Justice Political philosophy
Social justice is what people in society owe to one another in a matter of rights. It is whether people have rights and entitlements to certain kinds of political and social arrangements‚ and as a result‚ to certain social outcomes. Rawls states that social justice is a type of fairness‚ where the social cooperation appropriately distributes the burdens and benefits of society (1999: 4). Rawls aims to do this using the theoretical device of the Original Position. The intention of the thought experiment
Premium John Rawls Risk aversion A Theory of Justice
political theory over the past 50 years‚ and John Rawls’ A Theory of Justice (1971) is widely seen as the most important attempt during that period to articulate a set of institutions and distributional outcomes that rational individuals would see as legitimate. Rawls’ seminal work has spawned a veritable critical industry since its publication (Miller‚ 1999). His elaboration of his project and restatement of his theory of “justice as fairness” (Rawls‚ 2001) promise to sustain interest in his ideas
Premium John Rawls Political philosophy
Rawls’ Difference Principle Rawls believed in the ideal of perfect equality. This meant‚ to him‚ that everyone should have equal opportunity and receive the same treatment. To Rawls‚ there was only one reason why anyone should be treated differently to any other person – to help the worst off members of society. He called this reason the difference principle‚ and in conjunction with his “Justice as Fairness” ideal it formed the basis of his claims about distributive justice. Rawls’ natural
Premium John Rawls Political philosophy Justice