Preview

Affirmative Action in University Admissions

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
2244 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Affirmative Action in University Admissions
Affirmative Action in University Admission: Liberal Theory

Respect for the autonomy of a person rejects distributive justice in higher education admission

‘All justice involves discrimination’1

Aristotle’s teleological view on justice focuses on the goal of an action rather than its initial fairness. As it is the outcome that matters, discrimination on the way is inevitable in order to achieve equality in a society. The case of Cheryl Hopwood’s rejection to the University of Texas due to affirmative action yields the discussion about distributive justice and whether discrimination in order to achieve an equal society is just. Despite having the same grades as fellow applicants from ethnic minorities, she was denied access to the university on the grounds of her skin color, as the college claimed to favor a diverse student body.
In the light of liberalist theory, this issue poses a great paradox by touching not only upon the question of liberty vs. equality, but also concerning the kind of moral action and intention that is applicable in order to maintain equality in society. Predominantly, however, it yields the conflict between pledges in favor of the phenomenon diversity against the autonomy of a person in social policy. Opposing classical Aristotelian theory, it will be argued that despite three justifications of affirmative action, the liberal principle of personal autonomy should outweigh diversity motivated discrimination in university admissions. The main theoretical justification to this will be an extension of Kantian philosophy, which focuses upon the fact that people should never be used as means to an end but rather an end themselves. This will be extended by Robert Nozick’s principle of the ‘separateness of persons’. Despite acknowledging the importance of equality in a society, Cheryl Hopwood’s rejection to higher education on the grounds of ethnicity needs to be rejected, as equality means equal opportunities rather than equal outcomes

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Have you ever once being denied of school admission cause of discriminated toward you? If you have, you made have been violated of your right. This is based on Equal Protection Clause that forbids state from passing laws depriving any person of life, liberty, or property without due process. The big factor of admission decision serves as a compelling interest in achieving diversity among its student body.…

    • 469 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    never equate social benefits with or on the basis of immutable characteristics like race, on gender…

    • 1224 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The emphasis is on opportunity. It levels the field for many who see them selves not represented in the vast majority of society. Walter Benn Michael’s states in “The Trouble with Diversity”, “ the whole point [is] for [universities and employers] to argue for the desirability for a diverse student body [and workforce] without appealing to the history of discrimination” (728). Institutions are meant to commit to diversification values without stemming into the notion of reverse racism. It is a common misconception that such policies undercut otherwise qualified white males in favor of unqualified marginalized…

    • 1785 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    “Affirmative action was never meant to be permanent, and now is truly the time to move on to some other approach.” (Susan Estrich, 1952- ).…

    • 985 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In this essay I will expose what I see as the shortcomings of the current…

    • 1733 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Should a man be hired for his skills or for the color of his skin? Is racial diversity in the business world more important then the most qualified workers? Affirmative action has become an important topic in today 's society to better diversify the different races in America. Affirmative action is a set of public policies that were designed for the elimination of discrimination toward race, color, sex, etc. These policies are under attack today because of the unfairness toward the more qualified people. Increasing opportunities for a minority that has suffered past discrimination is the cause for affirmative action, and for the reverse discrimination toward the majority. Many people view discrimination toward one race today to compensate for the discrimination of another race in the past as unfair. This reverse discrimination is unfair treatment toward the majority. Affirmative actions are policies created to give preferential treatment to the discriminated, but also discriminate as well.…

    • 726 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    According to my reading from the article of Nancy Canton I have determined that critical thinking was implemented. She used a lot of things about critical thinking, which were allocated from the text. She strongly expresses her opinion throughout the article to allow the reader to understand her points of view. They were also some valid points made as well to give more incite as to the things being expressed in the article. Nancy used two valid points of critical thinking opinions and logic two parts of critical thinking.…

    • 544 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    “President Kennedy, as a way to fight discrimination, first coined the term Affirmative Action in 1961. Later on President Johnson employed Affirmative Action as a means of “a more profound stage of the battle for civil rights . . . not just equality as a right and a theory, but equality as a fact and result”” (“Background on Affirmative Action.”). Over the past few decades Affirmative Action has grown out of where it originated from and been altered to the extent where it has lost touch with its original intent. A prime example of the misuse of Affirmative Action can be seen in the college admissions process. The arguments against Affirmative Action fall into two categories. First Affirmative Action is immoral and causes individuals to act in an immoral manner, and second, rather than positive consequences Affirmative Action has a net negative consequence on individuals. The removal of Affirmative Action programs in colleges will lead to a colorblind admissions process that is fair to all races. The use of law enforcement could ensure that minorities are not discriminated against in the…

    • 2888 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    In 1972 The Equal Opportunities Act of 1972 set up a commission to enforce the…

    • 925 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Affirmative action

    • 1033 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Marielena Hincapie’s article “Let Us DREAM” from the Huffington Post, published December 10, 2010 explains the argument on the passing of the DREAM Act and how she and the DREAMers are hoping for a better future and that will happen if the DREAM Act is passed, Marielena is in favor of the DREAM Act. She is the executive director of the National Immigration Law Center she’s a public interest lawyer who protects the rights of immigrant workers as herself, she serves on the American Bar Associations Commission on Immigration and on the executive committee of the National Lawyers Guilds Labor and Employment Committee.…

    • 1033 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Bias in College Admissions

    • 2328 Words
    • 10 Pages

    Taylor Jr., S. (2003). "Myths and realities about affirmative action." National Journal, 35(15), 1125. Retrieved March 2, 2007, from Academic Premier database.…

    • 2328 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Affirmative Action

    • 790 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Hello Class. Let me start off by saying that I support the Republican Party's ideas and values and I am a proud supporter of George W. bush. Do I have your attention now? good. Founded in 1974, the American Association for Affirmative Action, otherwise known as AAAA is a non profit organization that helps minorities achieve equal opportunity in the work force (www.AffirmativeAction.org). The problem with American today is that we are seen as different people because of our skin color, and a catalyst for this is in fact, Affirmative Action. Don't get me wrong, I personally feel as if diversity should definitely be introduced to every single job that this country has to offer, but the way hiring goes is what's wrong. Let me give you a brief history of this country. Back in 1776 America gained independence from England and in the next 180 years, everyone worked for where they were. In the late 1800 early 1900's immigrants from Italy and Ireland came to American in search for a better life and had to work for every dime they ever made. My grandfather had 13 children, and his hard work and dedication to educate him self made him the man he was. In my opinion, as soon as Affirmative Action began, this country lost its dog eats dog mentality when it came to self achievement.…

    • 790 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Sociologists often follow (Merton 1972, p.20) in defining discrimination as the treatment of a functionally relevant status (such as race or sex) as relevant for the distribution of some reward or penalty. While legal standards of discrimination have changed since the passage of Title VII (Blumrosem, 1993, p. 110), legal scholars theoretically concur that discrimination involves the desperate treatment of similarly situated individuals because of their sex, race, color, national origin, religion or some other protected characteristics (Belz 1991; Blumrosen 1993, p 50). Diversity is defined as real or perceived difference among people that affect their interactions…

    • 1076 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In 1961 the Kennedy Administration put into effect Executive Order 10925 which ultimately became what is now known as Affirmative Action. The premise of this doctrine authorizes the hiring of minorities in an effort to ensure race and gender equality across the board. This decree is not solely applicable to the workforce; it is also in effect in the admittance of minority students in colleges and universities as well. Although its initial objective to ensure diversity and balance is admirable, it has now become quite controversial considering the need for “quotas” and diversity in lieu of qualified individuals (D’Souza, 1995).…

    • 620 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Sterby, James P., Cohen, Carl. Affirmative Action and Racial Preference. New York: Oxford University Press, 2003.…

    • 877 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays