Preview

Cold Mountain/The Odyssey Comparison

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1246 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Cold Mountain/The Odyssey Comparison
More than twenty-five hundred years ago a renowned epic of Greek mythology was written. This work, known as The Odyssey, illustrates the journey home made by Odysseus, a Trojan war hero, who seeks his wife Penelope. Similar in plot, though written only four years ago, Cold Mountain is a romantic saga which depicts the travels of Inman, a Confederate soldier, at his attempt to reunite with his love Ada. Homer 's The Odyssey and Charles Frazier 's Cold Mountain tell of the struggles faced by the man and woman of each novel 's relationship. Although these works are written thousands of years apart, both incorporate one man 's effort, after fighting war, to return to his love while encountering several obstacles that hinder and assist his journey.

In The Odyssey, Penelope faithfully waits for Odysseus to return home. She is unsure as to whether or not he is alive, but even so, she remains loyal to her husband. While Odysseus is overcoming obstacles along his journey home, Penelope also survives through her own difficulties. She is in the palace with her son, Telemachus, and hundreds of rude, hopeful suitors. In order to avoid choosing a new husband, Penelope devises a plan: she insists that she will choose a suitor upon her completion of sewing a shroud for Lord Laertes ' eventual death. "So by day she used to weave at the great web, but every night she had torches set beside it and undid the work. For three years she took us in by this trick." This plan works for her until a servant betrays her and tells the suitors about it. Another clever scheme Penelope forms is to suggest an archery contest and have the winner become her new husband. However, Penelope knows there is only one individual capable of shooting Odysseus ' arrow through twelve axes, and of course that individual is Odysseus himself. These are two of the tricks that Penelope plays in order to cope with her struggles during Odysseus ' absence.

Charles Frazier 's Cold Mountain tells the story of Inman, a

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Penelope seemed like the epitome of a loyal wife in The Odyssey. She waited years for Odysseus to return, only marrying when it became a necessity. Penny however, not only chose to get married, but she told Ulysses’s daughters that he died in a train accident so she could cover up the fact that he was in prison. Even with that discrepancy, Penny and Penelope both chose to marry for their children. Penelope decided she needed to choose a suitor, so the suitors would leave. She believed that her son, Telemakhos, needed to start his own life, and her marrying would allow him to live in peace. Penny needed someone to provide for her seven daughters. When Ulysses incredulously asked about her engagement, she replied “I gotta think of the Wharvey gals! They look to me for answers!” (O…art thou) Similarly, Penny and Penelope both needed convincing before they returned to their husbands. When Odysseus had returned, Penelope believed a suitor disguised as Odysseus . To test him, Penelope asked one of the maids to move their bed into the hallway so Odysseus could sleep in it. Odysseus became enraged because the bed was carved in an oak tree that grew through the bedroom, therefore rendering it immovable. Penny knew that only Odysseus would know this, so she welcomed him back. Ulysses disguised himself as a poor musician, snuck…

    • 1261 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Odyssey and O Brother Where Art Thou?, are very similar in describing what the society consisted of. They are many society groups and individuals that represent and characterise the Ancient Greek Mythology. These both stories describe men in search of a treasure and all the obstacles they have to comfort in able to obtain it. In The Odyssey and O Brother Where Art Thou? were written in a different era, but they both illustrate the Ancient Greek Mythology. Many would say that The Odyssey and O Brother Where Art Thou? are very different, however they both share the same concept just written in a different period of time.…

    • 415 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    "...We now declare a contest for that prize. Here is my lord Odysseus' hunting bow. Bend and string it if you can. Who sends an arrow through iron axe-helve sockets, twelve in line? I join my life with his..." [Book 21 lines 14-26] Knowing that only Odysseus can bend and string the hunting bow, Penelope uses this as an excuse to get out of marrying any of the suitors and to by more time for her dear Odysseus to come…

    • 461 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Book nineteen of the Odyssey tells how Penelope, Odysseus’ wife, questions her curious visitor whom claims to have met her husband. He describes Odysseus in such perfect detail that Penelope begins to cry. Penelope offers Odysseus, who is still disguised as a beggar, a place to stay and a bed to sleep in. He turns down the bed and sleeps on the floor like he is used to. Eurycleia, a servant of Penelope, washes Odysseus’ feet where she discovers a scar on his one foot. She recognizes the scar and throws her arms around Odysseus. Odysseus had received the scar from when he had gone boar hunting with Autolycus, his grandfather. Eurycleia keeps what she has found out away from Penelope. Before going to bed, Penelope shares a dream she had had…

    • 426 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Penelope instructs suitors that whoever could shoot through all 12 axe handles at once they could marry her. Odysseus, still disguised as a beggar shoots and makes all the 12 handles. Once he completes that he reveals himself to the suitors as Odysseus. Odysseus and his squad, Telemachus, Eumaeus, Philoetius and Athena slayed all the suitors and unloyal people. Odysseus kills top two suitors Antinous and Eurymachus. Antinous gets shot in his throat. As…

    • 384 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Many people have noticed the similarities between The Odyssey by Homer, and O’ Brother, Where Art Thou? by the Coen Brothers. Both characters exhibit perseverance at great lengths and many other things throughout their journeys. There are many things in common between the two main characters. Both are away from their homes for a long time and are leaving loved ones behind. Their journeys were very similar but different at the same time. Two things may be very similar but things are bound to be different.…

    • 584 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Upon his return home Odysseus is tested by his wife Penelope- she tests him in order to determine the reality of his being. Odysseus had been gone for years and Penelope could not be so easily persuaded that he had alas returned. Penelope orders Eurycleia to move her bridal bed, in doing so Odysseus grows uneasy. He begins to describe the bed and how he built it, thus proving his identity.…

    • 723 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    With Odysseus’s departure twenty years prior, Ithaca has descended into chaos, by a swarm of suitors, who plague the palace, and pursue Odysseus’s wife and queen, Penelope. Odysseus father, Laertes, and Penelope, his wife and queen, are the two individuals who truly test him— he returns the favour—, as personifications of Ithaca, they act as stepping stones in his reinstitution as head of his household and kingdom.…

    • 427 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    He tells Penelope that he was born on the island of Krete. He also tell her that he saw Odysseus in a coastal city and says that he was his caretaker for a short amount of time. After hearing this story, Penelope begins to cry. Nevertheless, Penelope is still skeptical so she decides to ask the beggar Odysseus what her husband was wearing. The beggar Odysseus says that Odysseus was wearing a double thick purple cloak, a gold pin that resembled a hunting dog, and a fine white tunic. Penelope cries again and says that those were the clothes she had dressed him in on the morning of his departure. Despite these two stories from Odysseus, Penelope still believes that her husband is dead. Trying to rid her of these thoughts, Odysseus begins to tell his story from the point of a spectator. He describes the majority of his journey and then mentions how Odysseus is on the island of the Phaikians and therefore, will be returning very shortly. But, Penelope is still in denial and does not believe that her husband will…

    • 713 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Cold Mountain Odyssey

    • 1159 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Cold Mountain and The Odyssey share many aspects of their plot. Both novels dominantly contain the theme of “The Journey.” The adventure contained in the theme “The Journey,” represents the journey of life and all that happens on life’s voyage metaphorically. Cold Mountain and The Odyssey both exemplify said metaphor. Many characters in both Cold Mountain and The Odyssey share many traits with characters in Alice Walker’s The Color Purple.…

    • 1159 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Odysseus’ wife, Penélopȇ, weeps every single day. When Penélopȇ expresses, “If he returned, if he were here to care for me, / I might be happily renowned! / But grief instead heaven sent me – years of pain” (19.151-3), she is conveying that she is in disorder because Odysseus is missing. Without Odysseus, his entire oikos crumbles merely because of the fact that he is the head of his household. He should be keeping it organized. This includes being with Penélopȇ to keep her content. Instead, he is absent from his duties as the head of the house. Odysseus’ household is in ruins without him. The suitors that exploit the fact that Odysseus is missing merely make the situation worse. They are able to live contently, especially when they take advantage of Odysseus’ servants in his absence. His servants become, “the suitors’ harlots” (22.483). The servants essentially betray him when they have sex with the suitors in his absence. The servants’ loyalty is required for an oikos to be considered organized. With their betrayal, the oikos is further ruined and put in disarray. Chaos for Odysseus and his household is only resolved when he kills the suitors as well as his treacherous servants. These events signify that chaos is no longer present for Odysseus. Only calm and peace remain for him. Vice-versa is also true in reference to the suitors. The tranquility in their lives disappears because chaos symbolized by their deaths replaces it. Since Odysseus is the Homeric hero, it is only right for him to end up as the party that lives…

    • 1007 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Charles Frazier 's novel Cold Mountain opens with an intelligent and reserved confederate soldier named Inman lying in a Virginia hospital bed recovering from war wounds. Shattered by the violence he has witnessed while fighting in the Confederate army, Inman escapes from the Confederate hospital and journeys to his home on Cold Mountain so that he may reunite with his lover, Ada. Throughout his journey, Inman is chased by the Home Guard, drugged, shot, and dragged out of a grave by wild hogs. Just as Inman from Cold Mountain faces many troubles and setbacks on his journey home to Ada, Odysseus from Homer 's epic The Odyssey faces many hardships on his journey to Ithaka. However, unlike Inman, Odysseus survives his hardships. He escapes from his duress on Kalypso 's island and ventures to return to his lover, Penelope, in Ithaka, despite being warned that he was to "undergo [hardships] before getting back to [his] country" (5.12.206). Throughout his quest, Odysseus courageously and audaciously faces Helios, Zeus, the ferocious Polyphemos, and the Earth Shaker, Poseidon. In instances where Odysseus provokes the gods, Homer illustrates the inevitability of hardship on a journey.…

    • 1204 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Penelope, Odysseus’ wife, tests him to assure herself of his identity. As he listens, she asks Eurycleia to move the bedside out of the couple’s chamber and spread it with blankets. The king himself had carved the bed as a young man, shaping it out of a living olive tree that grew in the courtyard of the palace. He built the bedroom around the tree and would know that the bed cannot be moved. When Odysseus becomes upset that the original bed may have been destroyed, Penelope is relieved and accepts him as her long absent husband. For the first time in twenty years they spent a blissful night together. In relation to a soldier some have trouble stepping back into relationships with family and friends after an experience that sent home a different person.…

    • 508 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The Lord of the Rings and Odyssey are two very weird stories in my opinion. The two stories include several similarities. The most noteworthy similarity of the two that were in common was the use of themes. Both included similar themes such as, life, death,power, brotherly love, myth, temptation, and journey.…

    • 1538 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Penelope is shown to be contsently in emotional termilol over odyessus throughout the Odyssey. For much of the book she is seen to be crying until a god take pity on her and allows her to fall asleep. But while Penelope is seen to be very leaky, she is also shown to be very rational, and very bounded to many things. One of this things is the funeral shroud that she uses to trick the suitors for three years by unraveling it at night. This was a very interseting part, because in some way it reence backs to Zues putting a viel on chaos and giving it form. Rather in this intsence the viel is a shroud, Penople is Zeus, and the chaos she is bounding is her solution to keep her husbands home without remarrying, or having to give it up, and to move back in with her parents. Penelope is and intersecting character because she mirrors Zeus first wife in many ways, such as tricking her suitors for three years, and by rational finding out that is Odysseus was the true Odysseus, and not and…

    • 604 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays