Preview

Compare and Contrast: 'Always a Motive' and 'Gentlemen, Your Verdict'

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
625 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Compare and Contrast: 'Always a Motive' and 'Gentlemen, Your Verdict'
Compare and Contrast: Always a Motive and Gentlemen, Your Verdict

Recently I’ve read two very good short stories: Always a Motive (by Dan Ross) and Gentlemen, Your Verdict (by Michael Bruce). Always a Motive is about a young man, named Joe Manetti, who is accused of kidnapping. Gentlemen, Your Verdict is about five men who are questioned about the murder of sixteen crewmembers. While both Always a Motive and Gentlemen, Your Verdict are written in third person and pull at the readers emotions, Always a Motives theme is how people tend to see things only from one perspective and things can change in an instant while Gentlemen, Your Verdicts theme focuses on the justification of murder in certain circumstances.
Gentlemen, Your Verdict is a story that teaches us that sometimes in life we have to kill, or let someone die to ensure the survival of others. In this story Lieutenant-Commander Oram (who’s in charge of the submarine) is forced to play god when his submarine goes down. There is only enough air for two days and rescue won’t come until five days after their oxygen supply will run out. Lieutenant-Commander Oram would rather let some of his crew survive than have them all die. But he has a hard choice to make: who will be the ones to survive, which I believe is also a part of the theme. He makes a solemn choice to kill sixteen men, including himself, to save the lives of the five married men on-board; because they have a wife and possibly even children that would live sorrowfully if their father was gone. This statement is turned around in Always a Motive, where a father loses his son and wife and is forced to live a miserable life alone.
Joe Manetti was a father to a little boy and a happy husband, but tragedy struck when his son was ran over and killed by a truck. After that Joe’s life fell apart; his wife left him, he doesn’t work anymore, he barely eats, and he runs away from his problems by driving , driving for however long until he feels okay. One

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    In Gentlemen Your Verdict (GYV) and Always A Motive (AAM) the main character takes on te role of a hero. Joe from (AAM) returns the little miller boy to his family and Commander Oram (GYV) saves 5 family men from an underwater submarine disaster.…

    • 279 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Over the years short stories have become popular for readers to be able to read and connect with the story that isn’t drawn out. “Where Are You Going, Where Have You Been” (Oates, 1966) and “Hills Like White Elephants, (Hemingway, 1927)”. Both of these short stories tell about decisions that have to be made through different conflicts and really just making decisions for what is best for oneself.…

    • 894 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The setting of this short story is on the freeway of Los Angeles. Jake is a self-absorbed, lazy, irresponsible, protagonist, who is driving along the freeway. He begins daydreaming about a car better than his 58’ Buick, with crushed velvet interior and an FM radio. His daydreaming causes him to hit the car in front of him. The driver of the other car is a naïve, innocent women, named Mariana. Mariana is on her way to work, driving a car given to her by her father. Jake approaches Mariana with confidence and tries to smooth things over by flattering her and asking her for her phone number. Jake is a very dishonest person looking to keep his freedom and willing to do whatever it takes to do so. He gives Mariana a fake phone number, address, and insurance information. Mariana is gullible in believing Jake’s lies. Jakes intentions are to walk away from his destruction with no consequences.…

    • 996 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Sniper Short Story

    • 755 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Both stories show the heartache of men who had gun with an occasional of killing something different and are written in the third person limited point of view. While the similarities are strong, they are different in the characters actions to the situations and in how they act and how they feel. There are both great storied by great authors, which touched the hearts of people who read them because of the great personnel struggles that go n in everybody. Perhaps they will all make us look deeper into ourselves and then take a look at the bidder pictures of…

    • 755 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Gentlemen, Your Verdict

    • 324 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In this story Gentlemen your verdict, the captain of a submarine, L-C Oram, is put in a difficult situation which results in him sacrificing 14 of his men including himself, to save 5 men with families waiting for them back home. Of course killing people is wrong, but if I, or anyone else, was put into a situation like L-C Oram was, then I think it would be okay to…..as bad as that sounds. In situations like these, I think there are some exceptions to killing people. He wasn’t trying to murder his crew for fun, he had good intentions! He did it so that 5 men could go home to their families. He even sacrificed himself! He was being generous and thinking about the wives and children on those 5 men. L-C Oram had no choice! He was the captain, it was his duty to do the right thing….whatever that may be. He had no time to think, and there was no way he could save all the men in the submarine. He was even kind enough to make sure the crew died somewhat peacefully with the poison. But, this short story doesn’t make any sense at the end when the jury is asked “So gentlemen, guilty or not guilty?” Obviously he is guilty since he killed 14 other men and himself on top of that. I don’t see why he is on trial in the first place, he is dead! You can’t send a dead body to jail. Oram acted in the moment, anyone else would do the same thing. At least he saved the men that he did. In my opinion, he was a true captain. Everyone makes mistakes, even if this was a big one. I’m sure many others would agree with me that the only thing he is guilty of is being a true captain. A…

    • 324 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    ponyboy curtis

    • 681 Words
    • 2 Pages

    He’s world has been turned upside down after his parents were killed in an automobile…

    • 681 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    always a motive

    • 264 Words
    • 2 Pages

    2. Joe Manetti, a confused young man, has lost his son in a tragic accident and is dealing with the loss of his wife who has left him. Joe Manetti has experienced a great depth of emotional suffering and severe anguish, which has become unbearable. Joe is no longer a father or a husband. The only peace that Joe seems to find is when he is out driving. After Joe is arrested for the kidnapping of the Miller child, the Inspector asks Joe where he was the day the Miller child went missing.…

    • 264 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Joe Davis was not the greatest child growing up, but what ever he did he stuck with it no matter what the consequences. He thought everything he did made him cool. Joe was very committed, committed to smoking, committed to his drugs and even committed to breaking the rules at school, which he had to finally drop out of. Even though his actions were not the best he still showed his commitment to those actions. Joe’s commitment to his wrong doings led him into a downward spiral of loneliness and pain. His actions finally led him to the hospital and a bullet in his back that left him paralyzed.…

    • 718 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    12 Angry Men

    • 379 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Twelve Angry Men is a play about a young boy on trial for murdering his father. If the boy is found guilty, he will be sentenced to death. The jury men are very aware of this fact, most are perfectly fine with sending this boy to die as one man searches for the empathy of his jury peers. One by one the jury begins to sway toward the not guilty plea, as every fact thrown into conversation gets disproved. Now, one lone juror faces not the pressure of his peers but the pressure of his emotional attachment to the case to see that the boy be punished. This finally leads to Juror #3’s inevitable surrender of not guilty.…

    • 379 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Compare and Contrast

    • 1210 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The most interesting short stories that caught my undivided attention were: “The Yellow Wallpaper” by Charlotte Perkins Gilman, and “Jealous Husband Returns in Form of Parrot” by Robert Olen Butler. These stories were both fascinating and intriguing in the sense that they made me feel like if I was the actual character. You could feel the pain and anguish the characters felt, even the desperation. It got to a point that I felt pity for the protagonist whom in both stories where narrating. Here we can see how someone can feel so desperate that they think the only way out is by taking their lives. Both Charlotte Perkins Gilman and Robert Olen Butler created an incredible form of fiction that makes you question if the scenes in the stories can truly happen in reality.…

    • 1210 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    My Forbidden Face

    • 825 Words
    • 4 Pages

    We have read many fictional short stories during this course. In O’Conner’s, “First Confession,” fear was the motivation that made the young boy not want to participate in his first confession. Different people in his own family had made him believe that it was a scary task and he felt that it should be avoided at all cost. In “The Jilting of Granny Weatherall,” by Katherine Porter, the end of the grandmother’s life was the source of her reminiscing over all of the things that she felt had been incomplete over her life. As she remembers the bad times that she had, the reader could always see the good things that had come out of each of those “bad times.” Minnie, I am sure you have read Poe’s “The Tell-Tale Heart.” The one that motivated the main character to murder the old man was complete insanity. All of these stories and others show various ways to motivate the characters.…

    • 825 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Moral Dilemma

    • 685 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Lieutenant-Commander Oram’s decision shows the compassionate side of him. His actions after the accident illustrate how he prioritized his moral values in order to resolve a moral dilemma: he chose “the lesser of two evils". Even though he was still hoping that there was another way out of this fatal situation, after much cogitation, “He told us he had special duty for four of us, what could only be done by married men with families, and as far as he knew, there wasn’t nothing to choose between us” (23). This was the only available option------kill others in order to save some. In addition, the president turned, “Gentlemen, it is for you to decide, guilty or not guilty” (25). When does a murderer start to sound like a hero? Is this really a murder? The difference between a decision that is moral and one that is lawful is often far too separate for some people’s comfort. Moreover, in “The Firing Squad”, Adam seems full of pressure and…

    • 685 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Hiding Place will be the first story I talk about. This story is important because it tells about how a house of Christians became a secret hiding place for over 10 underground Jews. What happened was an older Christian woman and her husband felt the pain of the Jews and then let them hide out in their house along with the woman’s sister and child. Then the Green Police came to their house and arrested them with only a large amount of rations cards as proof. Then once the police had taken them away the Jews escaped and made their way out of town where most of them escaped to freedom. Years later a fault in the Nazis system gave one of the women taken away the chance to live.…

    • 631 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Joe woke up in a state of confusion he was in the hospital. He had just come out of a coma. The reason for this coma was Joe went on a green light like he was supposed to, but then he looked over to his right and a driver had ran the red light, the driver sped through the light not even seeing Joe. It was too late for Joe to react to the other car. His car flipped over 3 times and landed in a ditch on the side of the road. Due to the other driver making a drastic driving error, Joe woke up in the hospital paralyzed from the waist down. Driving had always been Joe’s favorite hobby,this was a horrible turn of events for him he needed the ability to drive for his job as an uber driver. Joe was torn, he was paralyzed and in jeopardy of losing…

    • 1612 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The short story genre is characterized with a short length, few people and a short story line. Short stories often begins in media res. Short stories are fiction and has a composition. This novel is a crime story because it contains a murder. This short story is not a typical kind of crime story because the reader doesn’t know there’s the murder until the end.…

    • 900 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays