Preview

Comparing Rome's Republic And Punic Wars

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
459 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Comparing Rome's Republic And Punic Wars
According to Morey, W. C. (1901), Carthage had a greater power, prestige, and influential navy, but Rome had a more efficient army. He also stated that Carthage had more extremely intelligent leaders, while Rome had a more immovable body of citizens. The main strength of Carthage had sufficiently rested in her wealth and commercial resources. On the other hand, Rome rely upon the character of her people and her well-organized political system. The notably large in size of the Carthaginians was shown in their successes, while the great multitudes of the Romans were most fully displayed in the dark hours of destruction and trial. However, their societies were officially controlled by two very different models. The Roman Republic was a form of representative government that was derived from an intellectual ancestor from the Greeks' experiments in democracy. Carthage, on the other hand, while technically a republic, is better described as a mercantile oligarchy. In structure, it is probably best compared …show more content…
Prior to the Punic Wars, Rome was almost an exclusively land-based military. Their army was also made up of mostly citizen who enters into military service voluntarily who were well-trained to fight closely united. Carthage's military system was more well-balanced to such extent as its navy was the greatest of its time. In some respects, given that Carthage was a business of buying and selling products to earn money power, having a powerful navy was a requirement. But Carthaginian ships were also the standard of the world at the time. In contrast to the volunteer-based armies of Rome, Carthage's army was almost entirely comprised of mercenaries. Being a commercial empire, Carthage could draw its troops from across the Mediterranean, including Iberia (Spain) and North Africa. Although, as evidenced by the campaigns of Hannibal, Carthage's army was a more than capable force, it had its

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Many Libyan, Numidian, Spaniard, and Celt mercenaries, joined the Carthaginians Army and greatly assisted in the victory. In the beginning, the Romans created a massive push forward, which succeeded in pushing Carthage back. After that, the Carthaginians attacked the flanks of the Roman Army. The Carthaginians are now so close to surrounding the Roman Army. During this time, the Carthaginian Cavalry, with help from the elite Numidian Cavalry, was able to drive the Roman Cavalry off the field.…

    • 920 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    From a snapshot of the Second Punic War, the Carthaginians defeated the Romans while under the consul of Gaius Flaminius. The battle is considered one of the largest and most successful ambushes in military history. The battle consisted of around 50,000 Carthaginian soldiers versus about 30,000 Roman soldiers. The aftermath of the battle produced well over 15,000+ lost soldiers for the Roman army while Hannibal only lost approximately 2,500 of his own. Despite the overview of the battle, much more can be examined when looking at the events leading up to the brilliant ambush set by…

    • 1242 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    By 246 BCE, the Carthaginians controlled the trade routes and maritime trade in the Mediterranean. The Rome Republic was founded in 509 BCE as a result of an overthrow of Tarquinius Superbus, King of Rome. By 246 BCE, Rome, a small city, was unable to trade in the Mediterranean, only the Tiber River, but it dominated the Italian Peninsula, and only had access to the Italian Peninsula. However, Rome was growing stronger. The Punic Wars were fought to determine who controlled the trade in the…

    • 4407 Words
    • 18 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    While the Carthaginian government make some valid points in their explanation of the blame for the Second Punic War Hannibal. Both they and Hannibal can be seen to share the responsibility for Carthage’s defeat in the Second Punic War. Hannibal’s quixotic plot to attack Rome without a veritable intention to destroy her left Carthage stranded in a war that would ultimately turn against her. However, the circumstances and misfortunes faced in a war on foreign soil against the might of Rome can at times be seen as beyond Hannibal’s control.…

    • 647 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Rome rule its people in a very organize and civil manner, which draws loyalty among its citizens. Rome has an effective and distinct way in managing people, particularly to the inhabitants of their newly acquired lands and territories. One of the best example was the Latins in Latium, whose devotion and loyalty were exceedingly commendable, especially during the Second Punic War, where they fought valiantly--along with the Romans --against the forces of Hannibal. On other hand, Carthage "great advantage" was they have a "permanent able leader," that command its military forces. Unlike Rome, the order of its military resides in the hands of its civil magistrates, who were constantly replaced…

    • 594 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The stability of the law, the military, and financial standing of Rom kept it powerful. Rome successfully battled the Carthaginians, the Celtics(British), the Etruscans, and the…

    • 418 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    They also used mercenaries to fight their wars. Unlike in Rome where military service was prioritised and they used citizen soldiers. As the Carthaginian empire expanded into the regions of Sicily with the Greco-Punic Wars, war with Rome became inevitable. In 264 BC Rome had become dominant power throughout the Italian peninsula, while Carthage had established itself as the leading maritime power in the world. This date marks the…

    • 1559 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Rome was losing many of their soldiers and without soldiers you wont have an army than you…

    • 639 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Republican period of Roman history began in 509 BCE after the last Etruscan kings was dropped. The Republic was controlled by the Senate, which was an assembly by dominated upper-class families. This dominance by the aristocracy led to tensions between the social classes, especially among the lower classes who fought for equality in both the economy and the government. Despite these inner struggles, Rome's military power strengthened throughout the 5th and 4th centuries BCE and by 270 BCE they commanded the entire peninsula. 264 BCE brought the beginning of the three Punic Wars fought against Carthage over control of the western Mediterranean. These resulted in victories for Rome which granted them access to the wealth of Greece, Egypt,…

    • 803 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Comparing and contrasting the final turbulent between the Roman republic and U.S. politics were both controlling land outside of their borders, had the three branches of government, system of checks and balance with no branch of government being the strongest. Some of the differences were that Rome conquered control by subjection and the U.S. tires to include people into the nation. Every citizen that was born in the U.S. had natural rights, but in Rome you were just subjects and not citizens.…

    • 82 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Roman Republic and the Roman Empire highly differ in their political structures. The republic: created in 509 BCE. was a form of representative democracy. It consisted of 2 consuls of which were appointed by the senate and then voted on. These consuls were the head officers and the were appointed for one year. The senate was one of two legislative bodies comprised of 300 senators and 10 tribunes who were all patricians. The other body was knows as the tribal assembly and was made up of plebeians who met in a forum to vote on things such as consuls. When Julius Caesar was assassinated a civil war broke out in Rome. The senate was no longer trusted to rule Rome bringing the republic to an end and the empire to a beginning in 27 BCE. An empire is a form of government in which one person -the emperor- had all the real power. Emperors took power through force or inheritance and ruled for life, though many were assassinated. Some emperors embodied peaceful, prosperous, philosophical and basically just "great" praises. Where as others were vicious, mentally disturbed doctoral murders. The reason for the difference between the roman republic and empire is that in the republic the goal was to avoid having one person with too much power where as in the empire it was basically that due to the corruption with in the senate.…

    • 899 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In addition to the governmental aspects of Rome and the United States, both civilizations have a strong military. Being superpower of their time, the Roman, and American had military advantages. The Romans had the best training, biggest budget, and finest equipment that the world had ever seen in their time. On the other hand the United States also is just as remarkable in its military budgets, which are longer than nine other countries put together.…

    • 542 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    A Description of Carthage

    • 831 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The geography of Carthage has very mountainous terrain in the north while the south has more of a dessert appeal. Carthage is centered off the shore of the Gulf of Tunis on a triangular peninsula. Most of the terrain is covered in low hills through the town and other parts. Where the city was laid out on the bank of the peninsula made it easy to protect the people living in the towns. It also had a safe anchorage for ships near the waters plus, an abundant supply of fish from the golf. The city was connected to the mainland by a narrow piece of land close to the edge of the peninsula. Also, Carthage was a favorite city to be in for emperors, even though none of them resided there, they had enjoyed visiting the city.…

    • 831 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Democracy is a system controlled by people in which they rule their own government. Democracy most of the time is seen as fair by the people. There are also requirements to being truly identified as democratic. The Roman Republic was only democratic to a certain extent. It’s government consisted only of men. This isn’t fair to the women and slaves when making decisions for the government. It isn’t fair to women because they were also citizens.…

    • 204 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Roman Successor Empires

    • 3500 Words
    • 14 Pages

    The barbarian forces were able to effectively invade the roman empire and the military fighting was used to show the power of the ruler. Traditionally the Roman forces were paid in fee regularly whilst the Barbarians were not due to the lack of a tax system. The men enlisted to fight were often men from the aristocrats’ army and the king’s men (a small proportion of the total population). If a war leader was successful they are able to set up a post- roman regime like Clovis. In this period there…

    • 3500 Words
    • 14 Pages
    Powerful Essays